The Best Video Game Plot Twist We Never Got To Play

Why oh why was this game cancelled?!

Prey 2
Bethesda

Prey 2 is one of those cancelled video games fans will likely never get over.

The series as a whole has never had it easy, with the original sci-fi shooter starting development all the way back in 1995 but not releasing on PC and the Xbox 360 until 2006. It proved only a modest hit, but its tale of one man's trip to space to rescue his family resonated enough that developers Human Head Studios quickly put a sequel into production.

Unfortunately, that sequel was never to be. The first signs of trouble came when publisher 3D Realms sold the rights to the series to Bethesda in 2009, causing a re-shuffle of development. Still, two years later the sequel was re-announced with the same developers, and the official line was that production was going smoothly.

Even better, fans got their first look at the game, and did it look tantalising...

[Continued on Page 2]


Prey 2
Bethesda

Swapping out the setting, main character and tone of the original, this sequel was set to be a total reinvention; a grittier, nastier version of itself with more unique ideas to boot. To wheel out a tired old comparison, it was supposed to be the Empire Strikes Back of this new series.

Set to the tune of Johnny Cash's cover of Rusty Cage, the reveal trailer highlighted a day in the life of amnesiac player character Killian Samuels, a bounty hunter with a wicked name living on a grotty alien world called Exodus. And this grotty world was absolutely packed full of your regular scum and villainy. The trailer was dripping with personality, and players couldn't wait to explore this open world for themselves and uncover its secrets.

Unfortunately for them, they would never be able to, as the game was officially cancelled in 2014 in favour of a (pretty damn great) reboot from new developers Arkane.

Still, that trailer made an impression, and even if you check the comments on it today you'll still see people pining over what could have been.

What makes it even better, is that the best and most intriguing part of Prey 2 wasn't even in the trailer. In fact, it was being saved as the sequel's biggest surprise, a late-game series of plot twists that would have turned the entire narrative on its head...

[Continued on Page 3]


Prey 2
Human Head Studios

But let me go back at bit so it makes sense. The core of the original Prey's plot surrounded the Sphere. Though it may look like a planet, it's actually a massive sentient alien space station that abducts alien races kinda as a food source. In the first game it gets blown to all hell by protagonist Tommy, but the story of this mysterious alien phenomenon wasn't going to end there.

Though it initially seemed to be a total departure, Prey 2 was set to feature yet another Sphere, though this one markedly different from the original. It’s not entirely clear how, but the Sphere in Prey 2 would have had some kind of connection to the game's open world. With the plan to eventually connect it directly to the plot of the first game, the sequel was set to explore the unknowable and reality-bending properties of the Sphere's power.

In a great deep dive into the game's development and story over on Eurogamer a few years ago (which you should also check out), more was revealed about what specifically would have happened to player character Killian Samuels. The video revealed that Samuels and Tommy would eventually team up in the hopes of destroying yet another Sphere in order to save the species it hoovered up.

Along the way, you'd realise why Samuels couldn't remember anything about his past. Up until the start of the game, his time on Exodus had essentially been a constant state of purgatory, with the bounty hunter completing jobs and living day by day for years at a time. The sense he was reliving the same day, though, wouldn't just be a thematic beat, but would actually be woven into the story...

[Continued on Page 4]


Prey 2
Human Head Studios

The Eurogamer video revealed that one of the late game twists would reveal that Samuels is actually a clone - well, multiple clones. As you're probably aware, in most games the player getting the main character killed in combat isn't considered canon. It's just a fail state, and you'll respawn at a previous point until you finish the level as intended. The failure isn't recognised by the story.

In Prey 2 though, the game was actually going to make those player deaths mean something to the story. It would reveal that every time the player got Samuels killed, they'd actually respawn as one of his clones. Each death was a real death, though the amnesia would mean you wouldn't realise. Every time you died you'd wake back up at his apartment, and in the context of the plot that was a new clone being activated.

This revelation was even supposed to be revealed in a super cool way to the player. While attacking the Sphere, Samuels would stumble into a room made up of nothing but the corpses of his clones. It's a tantalising image to consider, and an amazing way to present this reveal so far into the game, turning your whole play experience on its head. Even if the whole game wasn't all that fun, this would be one of those twists we'd be talking about for years.

Hell, we still are regardless, but there's still one final wrinkle to this story as well, and that's Prey 2's final, final twist...

[Continued on Page 5]


Prey 2
Bethesda

After saving the day, Samuels was going to be given a happy ending back on Earth, with the player seeing him enjoying a bit of quiet away from his bounty hunting days. While he'd get to live out these years and die from natural causes at a ripe old age though, death would only bring more pain. A final stinger would show him waking up after this, once again a younger man, and back on Exodus. A new clone. Far away from Earth. Ready to repeat the cycle all over again.

Like, goddamn, why was this game cancelled? And this is from someone who loves the reboot.

So many games focus on the act of dying and respawning, but few make it actually something you're supposed to care about on a story level. While there have been some titles since that have incorporated it directly, for instance last year's Deathloop (interestingly developed by Arkane, who took over Prey) centred its entire story around dying and respawning.

Back when Prey 2 was in development though, this was incredibly rare, and would have marked it out as something truly special.

[Concluded on Page 6]


Returnal PS5
Sony

Now, it wouldn't be a video about a video game twist if I didn't have one final twist in the tale for you though, would it? Well, I do. First you need to know that I'm about to heavily spoil Returnal, and that’s because in a way, the title of this article is actually a bit of a lie. While Prey 2 was cancelled and the twist died with it, this recent PS5 exclusive featured a remarkably similar rug-pull. Let me explain...

Returnal is a third-person game where you play as Selene, who finds herself trapped in a time loop after crashing on an Alien planet. Like Samuels, her history is drenched in mystery. And, after a few hours spent blasting your way through the planet's constantly-shifting structure, you start to realise that this isn't Selene's first attempt to get home. Strewn around the environments are dead bodies that look just like Selene, often clutching an audio recording or artefact.

Like in the proposed Prey 2, each time the player died the implication was that you were adding to these corpses - which would actually show up in the worlds of other players' games online - and starting with a new, fresh Selene for each run.

While that's already similar, it's Returnal's mid-game twist that links it close with Prey 2. Here, after a slog through three full biomes, Selene and the player finally manage to escape the planet. Back on Earth you watch the rest of her life play out as she starts a family, grows old in a lovely little house and then ultimately dies a peaceful death. Sound familiar? The final scene sees her lowered into a coffin when the game suddenly cuts back to the Alien planet, with Selene waking up once again. She might have escaped, but she didn't sever whatever formed the time loop in the first place.

So, while it doesn't quite have the same surprise as Prey 2's reveal, at least fans got another awesome game that played around with the same twisty concepts that Bethesda's cancelled sequel was being built around. And whatever happens in the future, let's hope we haven't heard the end of Prey.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Prey 2
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.