The Sinking City Review - The Year's Best Horror Game?

Cosmic horror meets Sherlock Holmes.

The Sinking City
Frogwares

Rating: 3.5/5

The premise alone of The Sinking City is enough to make it one of the most interesting releases of the year. Boasting a narrative that combines an open world, Lovecraftian horror, and mystery-solving shenanigans, it's something between L.A. Noir and Call of Cthulhu, featuring a flooded city that immediately hooks you in with its tentacles and drags you deep into its swirling mythos.

In 1920s Massachusetts, there lies the city of Oakmont. Here, a supernatural flood has cut the population off from the outside world and brought eldritch monsters from the deep that now terrorise the locals.

Many are plagued with horrific hallucinations that have drawn them to Oakmont's treacherous landscape, including ex-Navy diver and Private Investigator Charles W. Reed - a man who will stop at nothing to figure out the grisly events that have befallen the near-submerged city. If you like a healthy dose of existential, gloomy, cosmic horror in with your mysteries, then this really is the game for you.

Reed is on the hunt for truth, and that takes him to plenty of places that many would rather avoid...


5. Elementary Detective Work

Frogwares

Where The Sinking City excels against similar titles is that it seems to want to do everything just a little bit differently. Investigating crime scenes is a search for clues that you write down in your casebook, but you also have the ability to see with your 'mind's eye', opening up flashback images of the crimes as well as ghostly reenactments you can piece together to find out what really went down.

There's hidden walls, ritual chambers, and creepy rune-laden omens that will guide you in your searches, but look too closely into the dark and the dark will look back - dropping your sanity meter into peril, causing blindness and terrifying visions to materialise and attack. These features are all wonderfully implemented throughout the main storyline, making the pacing consistently immersive and proving for some surprising finds in Oakmont's secretive underbelly.

The culmination of all this investigation work ultimately comes together in a tab titled 'The Mind Palace', where you link all the clues you find in different ways to come up with final deductions of how to solve the case. Sometimes you'll want to lie in your results to protect a victim, and sometimes you'll be going off pure educated guesswork, but it all feels satisfyingly solid in terms of playing an actual detective doing actual detective work, and gives branching choices with different consequences.


4. A Unique Open World

The Sinking City
Frogwares

And through all this, the game really doesn't hold your hand. It provides a tutorial tab you can access any point, but otherwise allows you to figure things out on your own. New locations and prompts don't crop up automatically, with you instead having to decide what you'll do and where you'll go by sorting through the casebook notes and pinning locations to your map.

It's liberating to be able to look at your own notes and your own map and curate exactly how you're going to approach the world around you through your own measures, lightyears away from the open world markers of games like Assassin's Creed that are oversaturated to the point of ridiculousness.

The strange paranormal elements combined with hard-boiled noir create a truly unique worldview, which is then littered with pulsating half-formed bodies and creatures made of far too many hands.

The Sinking City doesn't just revolve around investigation either though, allowing you to walk the ocean floor on deep dives, become embroiled in shootouts, and research archives for information as you go about your way in the world.


3. A Story That Tackles Difficult Themes

The Sinking City
Frogwares

The game definitely thrives on its atmosphere, which is its biggest strength - offering a forebodingly large map that is rife with the weird and wonderful. Houses poke out of the water covered in strange growths and boarded up windows, and the streets themselves often are so waterlogged you have to take a short boat trip to the other side. The sky is oppressing and bleak, it's almost constantly raining, and the locals are all sorts of strange - if they're not battering each other for a fish, they're on soapboxes wielding driftwood staffs and pointing to the ocean. Developer Frogwares has perfectly captured the essence of a Lovecraft story and distilled it into The Sinking City's very sense of being, and it's a real treat to run around the streets of Oakmont soaking it all up.

Of course, that also means that some less than savoury aspects of Lovecraft's world building have had to be incorporated too. The game opens up with a warning about the game's content representing prejudice, which feels somewhat alarming given we're inhabiting a dark, fantastical, and wholly fictional world - but it soon becomes clear that this isn't reflective of what you'd expect. Frogwares have made the effort to sift Lovecraft's hateful approach to race into cross-species humans that are warring against each other, giving us the wealthy Throgmorton family who are proudly 'gifted' with Ape genes, and the snubbed, fish-faced Innsmouthers seeking refuge from their destroyed home nearby.

The developers have taken the time and care to represent this divide between the various inhabitants of Oakmont in a tasteful way as you work between them to quell tensions, and crafted some memorable faces in the process, too, which is relieving to see in the place of what could have been in a Lovecraftian work.


2. Its Ambitions Escape Its Reach

The Sinking City
Frogwares

However, as wonderful as all the things that The Sinking City gets right are, there's a few glaring problems that rear their head as the gameplay progresses. The open world is an excellent concept for this Lovecraftian nightmare, but it's also one that's incredibly hard to live up to with the tools that this indie title possesses.

It's sometimes a bit too vast, repeating house models and NPCs to a noticeable point that then takes an incredibly long time to run between in the sprawling streets. The game feels like it's been stretched, copied and pasted to create scale rather than honed into one incredibly tight vision, which perhaps could have been possible if its districts were squashed down somewhat, or NPCs made more interactive. There's a few times that the detective work can get a little overly familiar, too, with repetitive beats to hit at each scene you experience.

The construction of the monsters is another high point, but the way they interact with the environment can be troublesome. Playing through the early stages of the game saw plenty of moments where limbs were poking through solid walls or creatures sinking through floors where they shouldn't, and on one frustrating occasion I personally fell into a staircase with no way out other than by loading an old save point. This is something that will likely be tightened up post-launch, but I can only go from my own experience - which was fine for the most part, but occasionally immersion-breaking when seeing a disembodied lump of flesh poking through a doorframe every now and then.

Combat is not particularly inspiring either, though sneaking and running is obviously the intended (and far better) option for facing up against enemies. One exploitation that I discovered is that if you get too close, you can smack crawling creatures with your shovel without their attacks landing as intended - which again will need patching in the time to come. Other than that, load times are long and common, but expected in a piece this large.


1. Conclusion

The Sinking City
Frogwares

The negatives are there, but The Sinking City has such a fantastically bizarre world and so many intricate, weird stories that they're forgivable in the grand scheme of things, and noticed far more keenly in the side quests than through the main cases. Overall, the game is a real treat to explore, and relishes in its creepy, atmospheric, and dark subject matter to excellent effect, bringing to life H. P. Lovecraft's otherworldly sense of horror in a tangible and engaging way. The Sinking City is a game that draws you deeper and deeper into its mysteries, no matter how repulsive they might be, and more than makes up for any shortcomings through narrative compulsion alone. There's some serious lore, and love, that has gone into crafting this world.

The strength of Lovecraft is in his ability to tell a story after all, and that's evident with Frogwares achievement with this title. The Sinking City is sometimes over-ambitious, but for a game that equates to what can only be described as an AAA indie title - it still manages to deliver in horrifying abundance. If you want a game that will disgust you, fascinate you, and scare you in equal measure as you dig into the core of it, then The Sinking City is a very exciting title to get your hands on. At the very least - you won't be looking at the ocean in the same way any time soon.

Kay be with you, newcomers.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Horror film junkie, burrito connoisseur, and serial cat stroker. WhatCulture's least favourite ginger.