Uncharted 4: 9 Annoying Things That Stop It Being Perfect

Someone has to say it...

Uncharted 4
Naughty Dog

Look, I love Uncharted 4. I love Drake, Victor "!*$%" Sullivan and all the high-octane thrills n' spills that come from all four adventures. A Thief's End is not only the finest of the four games - right up there with Uncharted 2 - but it contains a story that completely reframes all three previous entries, giving depth and relatability to Nathan Drake in a way that's never been touched on before.

I say all this, because the shinier and more perfected the product, the more you'll notice even the smallest of scratches or blemishes. Uncharted 4 is by all means the 'landmark achievement' in game design you've been hearing about, but in playing through its campaign and drinking in what should be Drake's final adventure, I've gotta say, there were a few things that were still pretty jarring.

A crucial part of games criticism and being a fan of something overall is acknowledging flaws no matter what, so while I'm still going to include this as one of the site's 'Games of the Year (So Far)' next month, I have to address the aforementioned annoyances, as they're still worth talking about.

Don't invoke the curse of El Dorado just yet. Hear me out...

Note: Spoilers throughout.

--

9. The Story's Structure Is Incredibly Repetitive

Uncharted 4 Nate Clock Tower
Naughty Dog

You can totally argue that a key staple of every 'let's unearth the past and find the treasure' movies is beholden to fall back on 'find this, uncover the clue, go somewhere else, find another clue, rinse repeat', but by the time it's happened four consecutivetimes, it'll wear on you.

Even Sully notes that it's starting to feel like a wild goose chase, and I'll give writers Neil Druckmann and Bruce Straley the benefit of the doubt: Devoting this much time and effort to such a line of work should feel slightly aimless at times, it should feel like you're going out of your way and neglecting your 'real life' for a flight of fancy - but that doesn't make the game's structure any smoother on paper.

If you take a step back and look at the narrative, remove the introspective character moments (which yes, are integral overall) and you've got a story that places its characters in one given location, has them explore it, solve some puzzles and then leave to do the exact same thing again and again.

By contrast, Uncharted 2 had its train chase, Uncharted 3 the overturned ship escape - yes the overarching progression was still the pursuit of riches, but the masking of that gave those games a feeling of variety that Uncharted 4 simply lacks.


8. Crates, Crates Everywhere

uncharted 4 crates
Naughty Dog

This is the kind of thing you realised upon a second playthrough of The Last of Us - that game's liberal use of wooden boards as a means to get Ellie across any expanse of water. Thankfully they always made sense contextually (a piece of debris would always be somewhere nearby during the post-apocalypse), whereas in Uncharted, the abundance of crates starts to feel hilariously forced by game's end.

Two particular times I laughed at just how convenient these were. Firstly during At Sea, where you and brother Sam explore the Madagascan coast, finding ruined temples and disused cave systems. You hoist Sam up a ledge and he remarks that he'll "find something to help you up", only for a whopping great industrial crate - complete with wheels - to come tumbling down.

Like, who put it there? And why is it the only modernised piece of environment design to remain?

The exact same thing happens later on with Elena, where the same scenario plays out in the middle of a humid jungle - a perfectly-sized crate just happens to be lying around, waiting for you to use it.

Yes, it's a video game and yes, 'box puzzles' have been a part of the genre since Lara's chest-melons were triangles, but could Naughty Dog really not have included some other way of getting around these areas? It's a stilted reminder that you're playing a video game, amid an experience that's otherwise succeeding at being so much more.


7. Massive Set-Piece And Certain Death? Look For The Rope Icon

uncharted 4
Naughty Dog

This is a lingering annoyance that comes with how Naughty Dog have always handled set-pieces in all the Uncharted games. Most of the time they work out fine, and you'll emerge from any collapsed building or explosion-filled sprint through a city square unscathed - but for those times you don't, ALL the game's charm and appeal goes right out the window.

To remedy this, Uncharted 4 introduces the ability to rope-swing your way out of danger in basic gameplay - yet extends it into a huge amount of the scripted 'near death' instances you'll encounter. Sliding down a ledge to certain doom? There'll be a rope icon to grab. Broken ledge gave way and you're now face-down into the abyss? Rope icon. Gunfight getting a bit hairy and the game needs to push you forwar- ROPE ICON.

It works very well, the physics behind Nate are exquisite, but it doesn't save the fact that a whopping great prompt pops up every time you're near certain death, becoming your own personal Star of Bethlehem, guiding you out with the deftness of a button-push.


6. How Does Elena Find Nate?

uncharted 4 elena
Naughty Dog

Not the second time, as we know that happens through Sully providing a helping hand. No, the first time - Nate, Sam and Sully get back from that phenomenal crane-chase sequence, come bumbling in through the door and Elena is just... there.

Obviously the confrontational setup highlights the clashing of Nate's two lifestyles and the suddenness is essential to that reveal, but the whole time during, I was sat thinking "How the hell did you find us?!"

Elena herself notes that Drake is a "a hair off course" from 'the Malaysia trip' he's been lying about, and although Fisher is a great journalist, there's not a single line devoted to how she figured out the truth, tracked him to a different continent and then found the specific hotel room the trio were staying in.

Being her other appearance is addressed later on - and head-on - I'd of liked a little something to flesh this particular twist out.


5. Elena Is A Trained Killer Now?!

uncharted 4
Naughty Dog

Speaking of Elena, once she's back in the story for good, her presence is intended to evoke a feeling of "Why the hell didn't I clue her in from the start?". It's a valid thought process, and Nate even mentions to himself after seeing her jump between a sizeable ravine, "A girl like that, and you p*ssed her off".

However, come another stealth/fight scene as you enter Libertalia, Elena's A.I. will start snapping necks and shooting goons like nobody's business. Seriously, I had a beat where I was pinned down by one guy and an assault rifle, only for Elena to spring up and wring his neck like she's cracking a glow-stick.

It's just something of a conceit for this series that wanton violence is forever at odds with the cheery and charming nature of the protagonists, but where in this character's history did she start learning to dispatch villains like Rambo?!


4. You're ALWAYS The First On The Scene

uncharted 4
Naughty Dog

Another one for the "but that's just the genre!" pile.

Yes, you're uncovering ruins and pathways that haven't been walked on or even thought of for hundreds of years, but only for the most part - occasionally you'll happen across places that are integral to your adventure, but that contain clues and items someone else would surely have stumbled across.

Obviously it's in favour of telling the story and linking Nate's thieving ways with that of Henry Avery's crew, but the abundance of notes and artefacts you find some hundred years later, are just a little bit too conveniently placed for the sake of that correlation.


3. Nate Can't Take Enough Damage

uncharted 4 drake
Naughty Dog

From day one, Naughty Dog have struggled perfecting Uncharted's combat. Initially more of a cover shooter in the vein of Gears of War, Uncharted 2 and 3 injected way more verticality to proceedings, encouraging you to stay on the move, gain the high ground, leaping around enemies to get the drop on them.

However, for the sake of encouraging this speedy and pacy gameplay, Nate can take only a handful of bullets before going down. Enemies will pop off shots from across the map no matter what too, meaning if you happen to roll or jump into the wrong area, you're gunned down in seconds.

Part of the appeal of Uncharted comes in fulfilling this escapist fantasy dream of being an athletic, bullet-dodging explorer, pulling off all sorts of superheroic feats and returning with the bruises and marks to show for it, and because Naughty Dog set this feeling up so !*$% well, it's only eminently more soul-destroying when things don't come together.

A particular late-game stage wants you to leap to the rescue and save Sam from an onslaught of pirates, but you'll do most of the fight in black and white, as laser-focussed enemies sear you to ribbons whenever you step out of cover.

There's a big disconnect between the Nathan Drake we talk about and the Nathan Drake we play, as the latter is nowhere near as dependable as his own legend would have you believe.


2. The Villains Are Underused

uncharted 4 nadine rafe
Naughty Dog

Rafe and Nadine? Brilliant characters, just brilliant - for the hour or so they're on screen.

Rafe in particular is a really conniving and snivelling brat of a human being - one you're glad to skewer with a sword at the close of the game, but it takes until that point for his motivations to become anything close to clear. Nadine on the other hand is by far the strongest female character the series has ever had (in a literal, physical sense) and her fight against both Nate and Sam is one for the history books.

However, it's precisely because these interactions are so fantastic, that it sucks they're not in the campaign more. Near the early-goings when you're darting from place to place, both Rafe and Nadine show up in the auction house and across Madagascar. The pressure is most definitely on, and you feel like you're going up against these two furiously dogged individuals, with drives that match your own.

Following this though, right around the time of At Sea and especially after Elena comes back into the picture, they all but disappear. It could be a comment on how they seem more imposing because Nate's attention is on them and away from his home life, but as both antagonists factor into the final scenario with some very key lines of dialogue, it's a shame they spend the better part of the second half waiting to deliver it.


1. The Trailers Showed Every Major Level

Uncharted 4 Nate Marooned
Naughty Dog

When did it become the 'in thing' to give away all your major set-pieces and plot-points in the trailer? Batman V Superman suffered most, but after Naughty Dog revealed the HD collection of The Last of Us by opening with Joel holding his dying daughter in his hands, the trailers for Uncharted 4 yet again spoiled far too much.

Take the fact that the very first footage we saw of A Thief's End showed Nate meeting up with Sam on an island. In the game, this could've been a very pivotal moment: the story opens with a boat crash after all, leading to the fact that Nate doesn't know if his brother is alive. This level comes right at the end of the story, too, and the game plays it out with a lengthy expanse of climbing before the two meet up. However, we as the audience already know exactly where Sam is, having seen the reunion in the trailers, so any semblance of "Is he alive/What condition is he in?" is lost.

This happens throughout, where it dawns on you that every major set-piece has been included in the pre-release footage, many of which involving specific characters. When the race was on to get across Madagascar and see if Sam was alive in a specific tower, I knew from the trailer we'd happen upon him riding a motorcycle. Even the repercussion of Nate hiding his exploits from Elena was shown, as her saddened face from discovering the deception was all over the marketing materials.

There's an inherent joy in looking up at a rollercoaster and then riding it for yourself, but for Uncharted 4, almost every location and major part of the story was already out there for all to see.

Do you agree, disagree? Let us know in the comments what you think of Uncharted 4!


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.