Why Animal Crossing Is The Loneliest Game I've Ever Played

After MANY hours of game time, there is a lot to say.

Animal Crossing New Horizons
Nintendo

I remember the first time I bought a chair and table combo in Animal Crossing: New Horizons, elegantly placing them in between the museum and town centre thinking "That'll be a cool place for things to happen!"

I sat on the chair, and it hit me: No one cares. The A.I. aren't programmed in any way to say "Hey, cool chair!", and as I sat there, emote-waving to an invisible camera in the sky so I could share this image with the world, I felt a profound sense of loneliness.

It's this sensation that's stuck with me - in differing degrees - whilst playing Animal Crossing: New Horizons for another 70 hours, and it's something I need to dissect, because everything about this game is fascinating. I just can't tell whether it's for better or worse.

Now, I'm not this guy, and I have plenty of great memories to mull over, but after living on my "island paradise" for almost two months - alongside being a pernickety sort who makes his living thinking and talking about video games - I have a TON to say.

Animal Crossing New Horizons
Nintendo

First off, New Horizons is certainly a solid game; a peaceful one, and in the current climate of all Hell breaking loose, it's been a welcome reprieve from the omnipresent doom and gloom.

With so many deliberate systems and an immaculate sense of polish, the biggest defenders will say you can't chastise it for something it doesn't do. That clearly its mechanics are designed in a way to give you the purest sense of relaxation and zen-like calm, and to get annoyed that you can't "craft multiple things" or use the mountain bike you just bought, is folly.

I'm totally with that in theory: Animal Crossing is as Animal Crossing does, and what it does, is provide a freeing, customisable space to exist in.

That side of things is - again, in theory - exemplary, but I'd contend that breakable tools, being ludicrously in debt and relentlessly mining or crafting things to advance are far from tranquil. To me, nothing here feels like a genuine interaction that endears a character to me, in a way that millions of other titles do.

There's always something missing - something buried amidst distractions like constantly flimsy equipment, the consumerist capitalist grind that is goal-setting overall, and the fact that for as much as Nintendo TRY to set up an intricate matrix of conversation, causality and remembrance, Animal Crossing: New Horizons is not an idyllic utopia of endless possibilities, dreams coming true and friends giving gifts left, right and centre.

It's The Truman Show.

truman show
Paramount Pictures

By manufacturing this sense of "eternal goodness" where you're the centre of attention, juxtaposed with the reality of what you're doing to deserve or maintain that spotlight, robs this life sim of the one thing needed to be truly worthwhile: Honesty.

And if we're being honest, there are things in here that don't add up.

Gameplay systems that are the barest minimum of interaction, and the constant fallback that no matter who you talk to; no matter how much you build, you're still left living alone on an island governed by repeatable systems designed to keep you in a specific lane.

Thankfully I'm not the only one when it comes to suggesting gameplay improvements, but let's break this down.


The Only Real Feedback System Is Social Media

Animal Crossing New Horizons
Nintendo

This is hard to articulate, but I'm always left with a feeling of having to self-motivate in Animal Crossing, versus anything close to real, acknowledged reward.

Where - and I get these aren't perfect comparisons, but bear with me - Minecraft's gameplay becomes its own reward or Stardew Valley has an intricate clockwork of timers governing seasons, produce and cashback, Animal Crossing forces you to "make your own fun", because there is very little else.

I can set myself custom "projects" like make an orchard of fruit, a peaceful Japanese tea room or terraform part of the island into a small city... but why? For who?

"Because I can" works in the short term, but what comes next?

There aren't any A.I. interactions or comments for combining pieces of furniture together, the game can't "recognise" these groupings of items in any capacity, and after a while, you're left like I was with that very first chair: Looking to the invisible camera in the sky, taking a picture for social media, hoping it provides the gratification I need from the time invested.

Now, if this was the intended effect, why isn't there an inbuilt points system centring on photos uploaded to an in-game "NookPhone" server, where we can give Bells or get recommendations from everyone's best snaps?

When the villagers I'm supposed to be bonding with don't reply properly, their conversations don't go anywhere, their memories are limited to "Hey, how about that [thing that happened weeks ago], right?" and interactions with other players are fleeting, what is there other than isolation?


Gameplay Repetition

Animal Crossing New Horizons rocks
Nintendo

Let's talk gameplay and pacing, because holy hot damn does Animal Crossing like to play its hand one fragment of a card at a time.

You're literally waiting until the next working day (or past 5am) for items to be delivered, construction to advance or many of the high-rewarding Nook Miles goals to reset.

It's gotten so bad that half the player base - and this was a bigger deal at launch - have become time-travellers, tweaking their Switch's system clocks to zip ahead by a few months, so they can actually play something other than Animal Crossing: Pocket Camp Version 2.0.

Now, by proxy of time invested and the mundanity of chopping wood, mining ore and crafting tools, it does feel rewarding to get out of that first couple of weeks stint, obtain a house, move some villagers in and building a community.

Only, 1. As I said before, the community aspect doesn't really set in, and I've seen ONE pair of villagers talk to each other in 70 hours, and 2. Those base grinding mechanics don't evolve or change. At all.

Every day you're hitting rocks with a shovel to get iron, chopping trees for a Nook goal or gathering up a few weeds to keep things clean.

Various characters talk about how you should "take pleasure!" in the latter as it's a nice way to "wind down", but if video games at their base function are a form of escapism, I certainly don't want to "escape" to a world where weeds always need pulling.

Yes, all of this "gives you something to do", but to me, it reinforces the creeping notion that ultimately, I'm wasting my time.


Only YOU Have Any Agency - Everyone Else Is A Robot

Animal Crossing Stalk Market
Nintendo

You ever catch the other villagers doing things on the island? If you're lucky you might see one creeping after a bug. Never catching it, but looking like they're doing something.

And hey I'll admit, the first time two villagers lined up and sang what was playing on a nearby boombox, my heart melted AND grew three sizes simultaneously.

But if we're talking about the things that reinforce that only you have any real agency or sentience in this place, the A.I. is a major component.

Inane, random responses or conversation options are one thing, but you never see them doing anything that would line up with the reality of your living space.

Get told "the whole town" is pitching in for an incline or bridge? Nope, that's actually all on you. You never see anybody plant flowers outside their house, give donations to things that would benefit everybody - or do anything other than leech of your goodwill, all day, every day.

Unless you make a second player account and summon that person in, you're literally the only person living by any set of rules, despite the game being very much governed by strict adherence to overlapping formulae.

The commerce of the land and advancing the island overall is ENTIRELY on you, and while you can argue that's what the game is, to me it only reinforces the notion of being the only person doing anything.

Again, this isn't a community or wholesome village of well-meaning animals, it's lonely and off-putting.

Just let me see another villager drop something off in the item box, just one.


The Nook Destinations Are SEVERELY Lacking

Animal Crossing New Horizons
Nintendo

What the hell is up with the Nook Miles destinations?

Aiming to be this "delightful getaway" from your island where you can see and experience who knows what, besides the tarantula and scorpion islands, they all feel identical.

Maybe there's a different shaped river or lake in the centre, but you can very much tell we're playing something generated from the same tileset and world biome.

If you're extra lucky there'll be another villager, but they're always located at the top-right of the map, wandering about like they were waiting for just you.

Oh, and how to get there in the first place? More of the same rock tapping, flower planting, balloon-popping tedium that you've been doing since moment one. If you convinced yourself that saving up for a plane ticket would be a way to experience something more than the same ol' same old, that goes out the window when the island you're given is the same as yours, without anything to take away other than more tulips, ore and pieces of fruit.

Back to your island, and back to the grind.

The grind you're experiencing by yourself.


Even Multiplayer Is An Anxiety Fest

Animal Crossing New Horizons multiplayer
Nintendo

Every time I've had people over to my island, my brain snaps into a place of "Is everybody happy? Are they doing enough? Is this even fun?" to the point where I'm just glad it's over.

"Multiplayer" in Animal Crossing is like playing that energy that comes from someone's point in a conversation wrapping up, and not having anything ready to say next.

There is N O T H I N G to do, other than be imminently aware that you're killing time together.

You could sit and talk, which would be lovely, but an on-screen keyboard isn't very intuitive, and certainly can't replicate a flowing conversation. There's a childlike innocence to whacking each other with bug nets or sprinting around the museum, but is anyone else there to interact or play with? Is there anything other than duplicating your own solo experience?

Hell no.

You can even save up and buy goal posts and a ball, but you can't kick it. Make an entire diner or outdoor area for everyone to sit at, but you can't sit or eat. Get basketball hoops and mountain bikes, but you can't interact with them.

Everything is in this stale, ornamental state where you're acquiring it for the sake of having it. It's modern day materialism at its finest, and you KNOW there's an endless amount of fun to be had if you could actually touch anything, but instead you're trapped like an unwitting mime, aware of the invisible prison walls that confine you, but unable to do anything about them.

Even if you reach the highs of giggling over simultaneously presenting an Oar Fish to camera, back you go to your island of robots, unable to sleep, but awaiting whichever infinite goals the game has in store for the next day.

In so many ways, it's an on-the-nose grindfest with no reward other than what you make. Honestly, that might make it the most accurate life sim of all time, but at least in real life I can drink my morning coffee.


Watch Next


The Ultimate Nintendo Gamecube Quiz

Nintendo NX zelda
Nintendo

1. What Was The Gamecube's Development Codename?

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.