Wii U: A Hard Sell?

There is a misguided consensus amongst quite a few that Nintendo are directly competing with Sony and Microsoft...

There is a misguided consensus amongst quite a few that Nintendo are directly competing with Sony and Microsoft, which I personally believe they stopped attempting to do quite a few years ago: even if Nintendo themselves seem to forget this on occasion. This blinkered thought-process is not aided by Nintendo€™s almost reconciliatory gesture in making the Wii U capable of outputting HD graphics (I jest slightly with this particular statement), and also its pandering to third-party development. This last point is apparent from Nintendo€™s E3 (Electronic Entertainment Expo) conference in L.A. wherein they spent a large part of their presentation introducing Wii U ports of Batman: Arkham City, Mass Effect 3 and Ninja Gaiden 3 to name just a few. The presentation was also disappointing in that we only saw two Nintendo-developed games that are likely to be with us come launch: Pikmin 3 and New Super Mario Bros. U. Pikmin 3 looks fantastic in HD and New Super Mario Bros. U seemed a bit too familiar for its own good. This is especially true when you factor in New Super Mario Bros. 2 having only just recently hit the shelves, and in overpriced form on the eShop (which doesn€™t bode well for Nintendo€™s future plans on digital pricing for their big-budget titles). They also neglected to even hint at any other future Nintendo franchises on Wii U. Obviously they€™ll arrive at some point, but it would have been nice for some acknowledgement to drum up excitement. Maybe they€™ll announce something exciting on Thursday 13th September at their €œNintendo Wii U Preview Event€ in New York City (Wii U release date and launch title line-up announcements are a cert, surely?).

Hardcore Or Casual?

I€™m not saying that Nintendo should ban third-party development on the Wii U (because that would be absurd; or that they should have stuck to standard definition), rather that emphasising it over Wii-U exclusives such as the Platinum Games developed Project P-100 (which failed to make an appearance during the presentation) only highlights a feeling of desperation on Nintendo€™s side in trying to convince us that they can offer the same videogame playing experience as Sony and Microsoft. Surely most of us buy a Nintendo console/handheld because of Nintendo€™s exclusive intellectual property and hardware innovations: Mario, Zelda, Metroid, the N64€™s analogue stick and Wii€™s motion-controlled Wii-mote? It seems likely that these days€™ people buy a Nintendo console for the exclusives and PS3 or XBOX 360 for third-party games. Nintendo€™s Wii U seems unlikely to change that. In fact I don€™t think I€™m wrong in saying that most people who solely owned a Wii console were €˜casual€™ gamers. I don€™t mean that in derogatively geeky way (though that does come across€). I€™m just not convinced that the majority of third-party developers are going to develop titles with the Wii U specifically in mind. Maybe at first to test the consumer response, but I fear they€™ll get bored with trying to be innovative and go back to €˜traditional€™ gaming on the PS4 and whatever-it€™s-called next-gen XBOX. There is a distinct irony in the knowledge that motion-gaming via Microsoft€™s Kinect and PlayStation€™s Move was €˜inspired€™ (blatantly nicked) from Nintendo€™s innovation with the Wii. And that this motion-gaming function is now a mainstream component of gaming culture, presumably to play a huge part in Sony and Microsoft€™s next-gen plans. Nintendo innovate with the peripheral aspects of hardware, and this is evident from Microsoft€™s recent unveiling of SmartGlass, which is suspiciously similar in the functions it allegedly shares with Wii U€™s GamePad. Nintendo hold a lot of clout that the regular gamer probably doesn€™t appreciate, but the other hardware manufacturer€™s secretly do.

What Does That Do?

The challenge Nintendo have with Wii U is in trying to explain its unique functions to the average consumer. Wii was easily explained: you wag the remote and your movements are replicated onscreen. The Wii U is a harder sell: you have a controller (which is called a GamePad), and it has a built-in screen. That€™s the easy part: the Wii U is a very exciting console and its controller has many potential uses. You could play a game of co-op in which one person sees in first-person through the GamePad screen and somebody else can play via the TV. The person playing on the TV won€™t be able to see what the GamePad player is up to. This is a great idea for a stealthy game like Splinter Cell and brings some of the unique qualities of online gaming to an offline environment, which is also a boon for those annoyed at the lack of offline split-screen multiplayer in most modern videogames. And not to forget Nintendo€™s renewed efforts to embrace online gaming with their new online architecture the Nintendo Network. As for another example of how the GamePad could work: in a survival horror videogame the gamepad player could be the monster à la Slenderman and the TV player would be the potential victim that has to escape. It€™s clear that family-oriented multiplayer gaming is Wii U€™s strongest selling point, and it therefore ties into the family-friendly philosophy that Nintendo has long tried to promote (survival horror concept notwithstanding!).

Remote Play: Nintendo Style

Another exciting use that I€™ve yet to see concretely confirmed by Nintendo is the ability to play Wii U games solely on the controller's screen without needing a TV. Obviously this diminishes the unique €˜asymmetric€™ (as Nintendo call it) gameplay opportunities available when using the GamePad€™s screen and the TV in tandem, but it€™s still a great additional perk to owning a Wii U, and a unique selling point. Especially compared to Sony€™s poor support of the Remote Play (streaming PS3 games to PS Vita) functionality they had originally touted before PS Vita€™s release, and subsequently failed to provide in any convincing fashion. Though Sony has redeemed itself slightly with PlayStation 1 Classics support added to Vita and a patch to allow streaming of God Of War and Ico & Shadow Of the Colossus HD to the handheld. I'm also hoping that Wii U will not have to deal with the latency issues that PS Vita and presumably Microsoft€™s SmartGlass will suffer from when trying to stream content from one device to another. The reason why I'm optimistic isn't just because the controller can be directly linked by cable to the Wii U, but also due to Nintendo's time and effort in trying to maximise its functionality as Wii U€™s main selling point. It€™s not merely an app, but potentially the crux of the hardware.

Mainstream Appeal

Then there€™s the graphics: Nintendo follow at a slower pace in this respect, and it€™s an easy blow to strike with when dismissing Wii U. It is a moot point in most respects except that third-party multiplatform support will be compromised once the PS4 and next-gen XBOX arrive. This is why we need to forget the emphasis on third-party development, at least when it comes to multi-platform releases: Wii U most likely won€™t be the victor when it comes to those. Wii U is scheduled for a Japan, US and European release late 2012, and they must be hoping that Sony and Microsoft aren€™t planning their next-gen console announcements near that time in an attempt to derail Nintendo€™s marketing train. Nintendo€™s follow-up to Wii Fit, predictably called Wii Fit U, is presumably their silver bullet for the casual audience they successfully hooked as consumers of the Wii. Whether that will be enough to persuade people to upgrade from Wii to Wii U is hard to predict, but if Nintendo wheel out the advertising juggernaut near its launch I wouldn€™t bet against its chances. Wii was a massive success for Nintendo (currently close to 100m units sold worldwide), and it€™s no surprise they kept the Wii brand name for the new console.

Contributor

Darren Millard is an aspiring journalist and music devotee. Needs someone to help him understand Ableton. Also, life.