WWE 2K15: 10 Superstars That Are Criminally Over-Rated

3. Sheamus - 93

If we were talking about 2010's WWE Champion than maybe a rating of 93 would be about right. However, The Celtic Warrior's character has gone pretty stale since losing the World Heavyweight Championship to The Big Show a couple of years ago. After making such a hefty impact as a heel, the move to make him a good guy was necessary to test the waters but WWE has cast him in the role for too long, and even a prolonged period as the United States champion couldn't re-engage the WWE Universe with the Irishman. 93 sees the former champion rated higher than the likes of Brock Lesnar, Roman Reigns and the same as The Undertaker which any regular viewer of WWE programming would see as unthinkable. Now, Sheamus is set to return to action very soon after two months out following surgery. Surely he needs the heel turn to get himself back into the upper echelons of the WWE roster.