WWE 2K17: 10 Most Underrated Wrestlers

The Man 2K Sports Forgot.

WWE 2K17 Neville
2K Sports

WWE 2K17 is here, and as usual, fans have been passionately debating the dubious accuracy of the game's overall ratings for each wrestler.

Likely driven by a desire to sell more copies of their Accelerator DLC, 2K have skewed countless superstars to play as conspicuously weaker than their real-life counterparts, and given some of the wrestlers who are also massively overrated in the game, it's resulted in some infuriating inconsistencies.

These numbers, being in kayfabe as they are, may reflect what the WWE thinks of certain wrestlers, but fans know better than anyone when something isn't right, and so it's clear that these superstars are all in desperate need of a significant stat-boost to match their real-life in-ring skill.

From world champions through to under-appreciated mid-carders, here are the 10 most underrated wrestlers from WWE 2K17...

10. Enzo Amore

WWE 2K17 Enzo Amore
2K Sports

Rating: 74

More shocking than how grossly WWE 2K17 has low-balled Enzo's overall is the fact that he comes in at a whole 10 points lower than his tag team partner Big Cass.

For context, this rating puts him on par with Erick Rowan (74) and below Titus O'Neil (75), The Dudleyz (Bubba and D-Von are 78 and 76 respectively), and even someone who isn't really a wrestler, in Shane McMahon (77).

Even ignoring Enzo's immense mic skills and sheer entertainment value, his terrific athleticism ensures he deserves a far higher ranking than this.

New Rating: Sure, he should probably still be at least a few points behind Big Cass, so we'll go for a respectable 80.


9. Goldust

WWE 2K17 Goldust
2K Sports

Rating: 70

Goldust's score gets positively nuked from the (admittedly ridiculous) 86 he was rocking in last year's game, but considering the incredible shape he's in these days, and has arguably put on some of the best wrestling of his career in recent times, it seems absurd to rate him so low.

Somehow, he's rated a point lower than both of The Bushwhackers, not to mention Heath Slater (72) and, most embarrassingly of all, Stephanie freaking McMahon (73).

Goldie was never going to be a top-tier superstar in the game, but he deserves a score that recognises how much of a talent he continues to be.

New Rating: Age works against him, but he's still basically killing it. 77 feels fair.


8. Becky Lynch

WWE 2K17 Becky Lynch
2K Sports

Rating: 83

Despite being the Smackdown Women's Champion, Becky Lynch remains the runt of the Four Horsewomen, at least as far as this game is concerned. Her score is somewhat lagging behind Charlotte, Sasha Banks and Bayley, all of whom boast an impressive 86.

It's tough to see the reasoning for this other than the stats simply not being updated to reflect Becky's more recent in-ring work, but even so, on her prevailing merits she's just as skilled (if a little scrappier perhaps) than her three contemporaries.

New Rating: This one's easy: let's give her the same rating as her pals. A nice and sturdy 86.


7. American Alpha

WWE 2K17 American Alpha
2K Sports

Rating: Gable and Jordan have 79 and 80 respectively.

Despite being easily one of the very best tag teams in the WWE, American Alpha are ranked below Earthquake and Typhoon (81 each), The New Age Outlaws (82 each), Xavier Woods (83), Rikishi (83) and most criminally, the wildly overrated The Usos (84).

Alpha's mixture of Gable's athleticism and technical ability and Jordan's smash-mouth strength make them an incredible force to be reckoned with, which sadly isn't at all reflected in 2K17.

New Rating: Firstly, drop The Usos down a fair few points because they're way too high, and then shove Alpha up to 84 and 85 a-piece.


6. British Bulldog

WWE 2K17 British Bulldog
2K Sports

Rating: 83

Even though he never managed to win the WWE Title, the British Bulldog is easily one of the best WWE superstars to never capture the strap, and in his prime was the epitome of incredible strength and conditioning.

83 is by no means a bad score, but it essentially says that he's on the same level as Sheamus (83) and Rikishi (83), and a lesser superstar than The Usos (84), The Miz (85), Cactus Jack (87) and JBL (87), all of which are just laughable.

New Rating: Bulldog was a world-class athlete even though he never got the plaudits to back it up. A strong 87.


5. Kevin Owens

WWE 2K17 Kevin Owens
2K Sports

Rating: 86

On the face of it, 86 is not a rating to be sniffed at: it places Kevin Owens in the top pantheon of WWE superstars, though not the very, very top, despite him being the WWE Universal Champ.

K.O. is ranked below a litany of wrestlers whose superiority are questionable at best: Booker T (87), Samoa Joe (87), Sami Zayn (87), Vader (87), Bray Wyatt (87), Lex Luger (88), and Diesel (88).

That's right. The Universal Champ is a lesser wrestler than Bray Wyatt, who routinely loses on PPV and has been thoroughly wasted over the last few years.

New Rating: Owens probably shouldn't be up there with the John Cenas and Brock Lesnars, but a slight boost to 89 would suit the champ just fine.


4. Neville

WWE 2K17 Neville
2K Sports

Rating: 78

Though he's not really been used to his potential yet during his WWE tenure, Neville is an immense wrestler and by far one of the most athletically gifted high-flyers on the roster.

Why, then, is he rated below Luke Harper (79), Baron Corbin (80), Road Dogg (82) and...Jim Neidhart (82)? That last one in particular stings something fierce. The Anvil, really?

A high-risk grappler but not a flat-out cruiserweight either, Neville is one of the most versatile wrestlers on the roster and has considerable breakout potential as Rey Mysterio-like figure if WWE just gives him the right spot.

New Rating: The guy's awesome but is still likely to grow as a performer over the years. An admirable 84.


3. Asuka

WWE 2K17 Asuka
2K Sports

Rating: 85

Asuka is, of course, the NXT Women's Champion, but more to the point, she has remained undefeated for over a year, which really should place her above Sasha Banks, Charlotte and Bayley (all 86), the latter of whom she defeated for the title.

Then there are the legends: Trish Stratus, Lita and Alundra Blayze are all rated 87 in the game, but given Asuka's virtually unrivaled dominance, shouldn't she really be the highest-rated female in the entire game?

New Rating: Going by this logic, Asuka edges the lead on the three legends with a cool 88. Asuka, herself a gamer, would no doubt approve.


2. AJ Styles

WWE 2K17 AJ Styles
2K Games

Rating: 89

89 is no mean score, but it does mean arguably the best wrestler in the world is considered on-par with Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, the Ultimate Warrior and Roman Reigns, while incredulously falling below Mankind (90) and John Cena (93).

Nobody who calls themselves a wrestling fan would dare try to argue that Mankind deserves a higher score than AJ, even when factoring in his physicality and hardcore wrestling style. On any and every conceivable level, Styles thoroughly outclasses him.

New Rating: If AJ were to receive 93, that would put him on par with Cena, Seth Rollins and The Undertaker, while still keeping him away from the God-tier Brock Lesnar and Stone Cold Steve Austin, who hold 95 each.


1. The Revival

The Revival WWE 2K17
2K Sports

Rating: Dash and Dawson get 75 and 77 each.

And finally, we come to the most under-appreciated two wrestlers in the entire game, possibly best all-around tag team in the WWE right now and as such worthy of a rating reflecting that.

Instead, Dash is bested by Vince McMahon (76), while neither he nor Dawson can't stand up to The Dudleyz (78 and 76), Luke Harper (79), Jim Neidhart (82) and The New Age Outlaws (82).

When you consider that they're the only team to hold the NXT Tag Titles twice, their ridiculously low rating seems all the more outrageous,

New Rating: It's tough to score one over the other here (and we promise it's not because we can't tell them apart), but 84 each seems more indicative of their abilities and accomplishments.

Which WWE superstars most deserve a stat-boost? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.