WWE 2K18 Early Reviews: 10 Things We Learned
Those entrances, those beautiful entrances...
It's no secret that WWE video games have needed a total overhaul for years now. Despite the evolution of gaming as a medium over the past 20 years, there are still elements of WWE 2K17 which remind long time gamers of the very first WWF SmackDown title from 2000.
2K18 is the latest to try and set this right, but early reviews suggest the game continues the mixed bag trend of recent releases. Are we set for more of the same here?
The WWE 2K18 review code that's out there right now is limited, and it's important to state that this isn't the finished product. Come the October 17 release date, it's expected that 2K will iron out any kinks and make 2K18 the biggest WWE video game yet.
Better get working then...
10. Commentary Is Still Disconnected
Early reviews disappointedly suggest WWE 2K18's commentary (at least in the preview build) isn't a major improvement over prior titles. Those disconnected, ill-fitting and downright wrong comments from Michael Cole? They're still prevalent, only this time they're joined by similar nonsense from Byron Saxton and Corey Graves.
Hearing fresh voices behind the announce desk was only ever going to be a good thing, but it's deflating that 2K didn't spend more time making the commentary tie in with what players are doing inside the ring. There's no excuse for this when other sports titles like FIFA and 2K's own NBA franchise continue to improve with each year.
9. The Improved Lighting Really Works
On the plus side, that new lighting engine shines down on superstars and brings them to life in new and exciting ways. Gone are the 'waxy' models of before, aside from a few exceptions. Names like Seth Rollins, Randy Orton and John Cena all look eerily reminiscent of their real-life counterparts, and this is all down to the brand spanking new lighting rig. Who would've thought that some changes to shading and how light kisses a model's frame would cause such drastic improvements?
On occasion, 2K18 already looks beautiful, and that's before the developers have tweaked things a little more pre-release. The fact characters look better in motion and in still images proves how much this new system has been a success for the series.
8. Entrances Are Immaculate
Squint your eyes during several entrance sequences in 2K18 and you may just be fooled into believing you're watching an episode of Raw or SmackDown. Again, that lighting is sublime, but characters appear to have more of an 'earthy' look facially. Wrinkles and blemishes go a long way to making these guys look like real people.
Yes, the entrance routines are a little on the long side, but they're entirely skippable. Although it would be nice to have the option of shorter clips, that's nit-picking to the extreme. For a game dedicated to appearing as a WWE simulation, 2K18 gets things spot on when it comes to entrances.
Character models no longer look like they've been pasted on to pre-rendered backgrounds, which has been a problem for years. Now, everything feels like a real-life set, and the wrestlers themselves are a big part of that. 2K deserve a pat on the back for getting entrances so right.
7. It's Now Harder To Kick Out
Whether you prefer 2K's mini-game approach to pin falls or you just want to mash the buttons in a frantic bid to escape, it seems like pinning situations will be harder to get out of this year. Kicking out of finishing moves in particular feels like an achievement, because those seem to end matches quickly this time around.
If your character has soaked up even a modicum of abuse over a short period and your opponent hits his/her finisher, forget about it. Maybe this is 2K's way of steeping things further in simulation, but it'll irk a fair few players who yearn for the arcade feel of past titles like Here Comes The Pain.
We know what the developers are going for here. This is supposed to make winning matches feel like more of a victory than a yawn-worthy series of one-sided beatings followed by a gauntlet of finishers and reversals. It remains to be seen how popular this addition will be.
6. There Are New Selling Animations
Selling is such a huge part of pro wrestling. If that seems obvious, then consider just how little of it the cast of WWE 2K17 did. Sure, there were those short outbursts of motion following a major move or strike, but for the most part characters just lay on the ground motionless. That always needed to change.
New selling animations bring matches to life in a subtle way. Some gamers may not even have noticed the lack of selling in previous WWE games, but they will notice when 2K18's stars writhe and roll around the mat in agony following big moves. Why hasn't this happened before now?
For the first time in years, it's possible to watch a match play out in-game and feel the crunching impact of signature moves or heavy strikes. Characters fall to the canvas in much more convincing fashion, and this is aided by the wrestler dishing out the damage reacting to the pain too.
5. New Royal Rumble Eliminations Work Well
To go along with the new selling mechanics and facial expressions they've included, 2K decided to freshen up a popular multi-player match type by adding new eliminations to the Royal Rumble. In 2K17, the 30-man match was hard to win from the #1 spot, which is exactly how it should be. 2K18 is very much the same.
The Rumble is a grind. Attack every wrestler who enters the ring and it won't be long until you're hurled over the top rope and forced to pick another character to play as. New eliminations still follow the mini-game/quick time event formula, but it's cool to see 2K thinking outside the box when it comes to the Rumble.
In addition, it'll be interesting to experiment with a new 'carry' mechanic. Now, you can hoist opponents up onto your shoulders, and that should make eliminating them from the Rumble a little easier. We should be able to throw fresh entrants out of the ring and use the element of surprise occasionally.
4. Visual Quality Drops In Multi-Man Matches
In the screenshots showing Cesaro and Sheamus, both characters look like CAW jobs from WWE 2K15. In particular, Sheamus just doesn't look realistic at all. Is that beard painted on? This isn't good, and it's a little poor from 2K to treat one of WWE's best tag-teams this year like an afterthought.
When matches are one-on-one, they look fantastic. Pick a tag-team (or worse, a 6-man tag) match though and you'll see a drop in visual quality inside the ring. Things begin to look a little grainy compared to the slick lighting and high-quality feel to singles matches. To make matters worse, the frame rate gets choppy.
The more wrestlers involved, the lower the frame rate. This doesn't bode well for the Royal Rumble, Elimination Chamber matches or even a basic 6-man tag. An awful lot of people are going to want to play 2K18 with friends, so it's a shame they may have to stomach crappier graphics to do so.
3. Glitchy Environmental Interaction Remains A Problem
Speaking of the Elimination Chamber, the popular match type could be hampered by those niggling glitches that make it hard for players to suspend their disbelief. When John Cena clips through the chamber glass or Randy Orton's hand goes through the ropes, it kinda' shatters the illusion.
Weapons look much higher-res this year, but what good is that when the same clipping issues from years ago are still weighing things down? When we Irish Whip someone into the steel steps at ringside, we don't want them to run in the same spot for a few seconds before connecting. That just doesn't look real, and it hits home during these moments that you're playing a video game.
2K need to start sorting out these glitches when it comes to environmental interaction. WWE matches should be a sandbox of fun for gamers, not a buggy mess that glitches up when they try to do something cool and deviate from the ring.
2. One-On-One Matches Feature A Zoomed In Camera
'Camera Cuts' have been part of WWE video games for years. You know the ones, those flashy angles that zoom in on the action to catch a big Neckbreaker or finishing move. In 2K18, singles matches take you deeper inside the ring than ever before, and it's quite a noticeable change during the first few matches.
It's only in one-on-one matches that this happens, for obvious reasons. 2K enjoy showing everybody on screen at once, which is why tag matches and other multi-person affairs retain the old hard cam view point. This only makes singles bouts more enjoyable though, because it at times feels like there's a camera man perched up on the ring apron.
Being able to choose your own camera angle is the next logical step for the series. Remember that unique angle from the first few SmackDown titles which showed the entrance set during matches? That was awesome. Although not true-to-life, it's the kind of customisation fans of the series would enjoy.
This zoomed in angle is a start.
1. The Series Hasn't Taken A Huge Leap
Overall, WWE 2K18 isn't a huge leap up from 2K17. Maybe it's unrealistic to expect that in 12 months, but we were really hoping for some true innovation this time around. Yes, the new lighting and selling animations are a nice touch. Yes, entrances look good. No, these additions don't change the core experience.
This is still the same old WWE 2K series with a few new bells and whistles. It's going to take a few years off (which will never happen, because the 2K series is a money-maker) before the developers have a chance to build anything from the ground up again. We can but hope for something new in the next couple of years.
For now, 2K18 looks like another run-of-the-mill WWE video game. If you like the simulation feel and slow pace, then you'll still enjoy this one. If you're crying out for Here Comes The Pain in 2017, then it's going to be hard to suppress some disappointment.
Who knows, perhaps 2K will surprise us all when the full game is released on October 17.
Are you looking forward to WWE 2K18? Do you think it'll be a massive improvement over 2K17? Let us know down in the comments section below!