WWE 2K23: 18 Best Legends CAWs You Must Download

Seriously, these created WWE 2K23 legends are good enough to be official!

WWE 2K23 Mankind
2K Games

2K furnished fans with a brilliant twist on the established Showcase formula, a revamped MyGM suite, some swish new stories in MyRise, several key gameplay improvements and even the mighty WarGames match type, but Community Creations is still arguably the best reason to pick a copy of WWE 2K23 up.

It's the gift that keeps on giving.

Creators like WhatsTheStatus, ATTITUDECREATIONZ, KELSCREATIONS, IconicCAWs and more continue to pump out character models that must make those at 2K towers blush. Spend enough time browsing through the download tabs, and you'll be able to nab hundreds of painstakingly-brilliant creations that are just as good as anything officially on-disc.

The legends wing has been a big selling point for 2K's series over the years. Playing as greats from yesteryear is a real thrill some some gamers, but grumbles could be heard from many when they realised a fair few heroes wouldn't be on the roster this year.

Not to worry, because Community Creations has your back. 2K clearly knows their willing army of creation suite-hungry uploaders will fill in any gaps they leave anyway.

You need to download all of these now. Seriously!

18. Dusty Rhodes

WWE 2K23 Dusty Rhodes
2K Games

Creator: TokyoTaco

Downloads: 15,326

'American Dream', baby.

Over 15,000 folks have grabbed TokyoTaco's sterling work to date, and no wonder - there's something for every era of Dusty Rhodes fan to enjoy here. If you're partial to some polka dots, go wild. If not, and you prefer the classic NWA era, then that's here too.

There's even a nod towards Dusty's late stab at ECW life if that's more your thing. In the name of Rhodes, TokyoTaco thought of everything! This is one of the biggest 'must haves' on the entire Community Creations hub.

Then, you can set Dusty as Cody's manager and have him there when his boy wins the WWE Title. Glorious.


17. Hawk

WWE 2K23 Hawk
2K Games

Creator: dedewils

Downloads: 23,135

Or, you can download The Road Warriors/Legion Of Doom and have them try to gouge Dusty's eyes out with the spikes on their entrance attire. OK, so maybe that option isn't included in WWE 2K23. It's just a little too violent (and a little too niche) for the modern-day audience.

Definitely get Hawk anyway though.

Perhaps the greatest thing about this package is that it comes with the traditional red and black gear or some fancy blue and black attire. That's one for the true old-schoolers out there, and it's something every CAW should have. Multiple attire slots are essential, and that's just the way it is.


16. Animal

WWE 2K23 Animal
2K Games

Creator: dedewils

Downloads: 23,712

More people have downloaded Animal than Hawk, which hardly makes any sense. Who in the name of spiky shoulder pads wants one Road Warrior without the other?! That'd be like plumping for one eye over two, but best leave that old NWA angle alone now.

Seriously, go and nab both of these guys.

If you're in a nitpicking mood, you might point out that Animal's head is a little on the small side. Yes, the dude was jacked in his prime, but his head didn't shrink. To be fair, that's something you can easily sort out by diving into the creation suite after downloading.


15. Goldust

WWE 2K23 Goldust
2K Games

Creator: bhangraman

Downloads: 2,376

Dustin Rhodes' current AEW status rules him out of a WWE Hall Of Fame induction for now, but you have to believe it's coming someday when he eventually hangs up the boots. He deserves it for playing the Goldust character alone, so why not honour Goldie in 2K23?

The bold bhangraman included a classic 1995-1996 version of the character to play as in the first attire slot. As if that wasn't enough, you can play as his final WWE incarnation before he left to become #AllElite. There's so much to like here, and the shine on that costume is really spot on.

Get after it.


14. Luna Vachon

WWE 2K23 Luna Vachon
2K Games

Creator: ScheiBeCreations

Downloads: 462

Yes, Luna Vachon is a wrestling legend and your writer won't hear any different. She can be considered one of WWE's original pioneers for the female game, because nobody was really like Luna back in the day. She was 'anti-Diva' before that was even really a thing.

Respect the mullet too.

Vachon's wild child approach is a must have if you're looking to bolster the women's division in WWE 2K23. Maybe you've got a Universe Mode save that's exclusively female, or perhaps you're going for a retro theme but need more women to pad things out. Either way, Luna is ready.


13. Sable

WWE 2K23 Sable
2K Games

Creator: LeeValentineXo

Downloads: 3,656

Granted, this isn't the Sable model most would want. It isn't from her late-1990s classic era, but it's still a stunning piece of work from one LeeValentineXo. They've captured Sable's face perfectly, and also get bonus points for including multiple attires that really bring the overall package to life.

Brock Lesnar would be proud. So, mind you, would Marc Mero.

This CAW is based on Sable's most recent WWE run before she called it a day in the biz. It's really, really good, and acts as a reminder that creators out there focus on every available era from pro wrestling's past. Who else is thankful for that?


12. Mickie James

WWE 2K23 Mickie James
2K Games

Creator: WhatsTheStatus

Downloads: 7,008

"Acts as a reminder that creators out there focus on every available era from pro wrestling's past". Case in point: Mickie James. Quiet at the back too, 'cause Mickie has entered the legends wing in WWE lore now. She's still wrestling, but that changes nothing as far as this guy is concerned.

She's one of the best female stars WWE's product has ever seen.

This is also one of the best CAWs you're ever likely to see too. Facially, it's spot on, and the attention to detail on her ring gear is second to none. Download this one and go 'Hardcore Country' on everyone in sight.


11. DDP

WWE 2K23 DDP
2K Games

Creator: ATTITUDECREATIONZ

Downloads: 14,838

Yo, it's he, it's he, it's D...D...P.

Traditional WCW lovers playing WWE 2K23 will adore what ATTITUDECREATIONZ has done with this Diamond Dallas Page model. His hair is massive (backcomb that bitch!) the tattoo work resplendent, and Page even has his discounted "dad jeans" on for maximum effect in the second attire slot.

That everyman look helped endear DDP to a whole generation of wrestling fans, and it turned him into one of WCW's most unlikely success stories in the 90s. Relive the glory days of knocking back the nWo and hitting Diamond Cutters aplenty by joining the near-15,000 strong who have already downloaded this CAW.


10. Lex Luger

WWE 2K23 Lex Luger
2K Games

Creator: DrGorillaNuts

Downloads: 1,079

Initially, there was a different 'Sexy Lexy' in this spot. Then, yours truly stumbled across what DrGorillaNuts has done with Luger. This is one of the newer models on the download tabs, but that doesn't mean you should skip it if you're in the hunt for some Lex goodness.

His standard WCW look is there, and so is the nWo Wolfpac variation of his run (complete with hair scraped back for maximum Wolfpac cool points). It's going to be difficult for anybody to top this Luger character, to be honest. It really is the total package.

Oh man, sorry about that.


9. Chris Jericho

WWE 2K23 Chris Jericho
2K Games

Creator: ATTITUDECREATIONZ

Downloads: 2,864

Break the walls DOWN.

It's shocking that so few gamers thumbing through Community Creations have downloaded ATTITUDECREATIONZ' very own Chris Jericho. There's something to be said for fans preferring his WWF days or modern AEW look, but it's still a bloody travesty of justice if you ask older fans.

Jericho should've been more in WCW, but they never appreciated his talents properly. Put that right by turning Monday Nitro in your Universe saves into 'Monday Night Jericho'. Jericho is WCW, and he'll slap those who criticise his poodle-like hairdo as well.

All jokes aside, this is a tremendous piece of work.


8. Kane

WWE 2K23 Kane
2K Games

Creator: WhatsTheStatus

Downloads: 518

There is a masked Kane in WWE 2K23, but it's not the one people want. No, true 'Kanenites' (that will always suck) want to play as their chargrilled monster hero from the 2000-2001 days. That original costume and the mesh-style see-through one that showed off the gym gains are both here.

Rest easy, everyone. Not in peace though, because you'll want to raise hell as retro Kane thanks to WhatsTheStatus. Of course, they've slapped Kane's in-game move set, mannerisms and entrance onto the 'Big Red Machine' so this CAW is pretty much ready to go as soon as you hit download.

He's alive! Kane is alive!


7. The Rock

WWE 2K23 The Rock
2K Games

Creator: WhatsTheStatus

Downloads: 9,242

Attention, 2K decision-makers: Having The Rock and The Rock from 2012 in your game isn't enough, and it'll never be enough. 'Attitude Era' fans playing your games demand a version of Rocky from the glory days before he was Hollywood's leading man. They demand it.

WhatsTheStatus has come through, at least.

They've uploaded a version of The Rock from 2000, but included an alt model that could either pass for 2003 or 2013 (depending on what you're looking for). It's superb quality too, so you won't be missing out on anything by giving 2K's officially-produced character the ol' heave ho in favour of this one.


6. Mankind

WWE 2K23 Mankind
2K Games

Creator: WhatsTheStatus

Downloads: 10,870

Time to reunite the 'Rock N' Sock Connection', brothers and sisters.

Or, if you're more into Mankind circa 1996, that's here as well. It's just a pity 2K didn't include his stunning, serene piano exit piece in the entrance music options. That's a little too much to ask when Mankind isn't officially in the game, to be totally fair.

This is the best Mankind on Community Creations by a mile. The mask (for a start) really pops without looking awkward on the model's face, and it's obvious WhatsTheStatus spent some serious time poring over every minor detail on the attire too.


5. Ric Flair

WWE 2K23 Ric Flair
2K Games

Creator: KELSCREATIONS

Downloads: 10,787

Anyone hoping to win championships as both Ric and Charlotte Flair in 2K23 would've been left disappointed...until now. KELSCREATIONS has crafted a great replica of Ric's glory days (y'know, before he was p*ssing everyone off weekly via his podcast) or having "one more match" too many inside the ring.

This CAW is so 1980s, and that's a good thing.

It's NWA Flair at his finest, but could also work if you've got a 1992 WWF save going on. Other creators have been bringing Ric's WWE career to life, and even mirroring his recent "retirement" look. Bin those and get this instead.


4. Sting

WWE 2K23 Sting
2K Games

Creator: ATTITUDECREATIONZ

Downloads: 87,839

As Tony Schiavone might bellow on AEW programming: "It's Sting!".

The Stinger's best look depends on your age, usually. Those who favour the late-80s/early-90s like 'Surfer' Sting the best. Those who are wrong like TNA's 'Joker' Sting. Those who know what's what always go for 'Crow' Sting, and that's what ATTITUDECREATIONZ did.

Let's be clear about something. This is just as good as any official model 2K's games have produced in the past. In fact, it's arguably even better than some of those. Everything about the thing is flawless from head to toe, and you'd be doing yourself a favour by downloading it.

Stick that payment in the post, ATTITUDECREATIONZ! Only joking.


3. Shawn Michaels

WWE 2K23 Shawn Michaels
2K Games

Creator: CERASTES

Downloads: 772

Want something that's flown a bit under the radar compared to Sting's 87,000+ downloads? Well, then here's a character model based on Shawn Michaels' 1992-1993 look, and it's awesome. CERASTES has crafted both a red and white attire and the slick black and white version of Shawn's gear.

He thinks he's cute, he thinks he's sexy. He's right.

Playing as modern-day Shawn Michaels gives one acid reflux when they think of Crown Jewel 2018, and the 2005 character just doesn't cut it quite the same as retro either. Thankfully, CERASTES knows the score and uploaded this gem onto the suite.


2. Mr. Perfect

WWE 2K23 Mr Perfect Curt Hennig
2K Games

Creator: KINGofdaRING

Downloads: 6,022

It's a bit rubbish that technical wizard and big bump machine Curt Hennig wasn't included on the roster in WWE 2K23. You can't have everybody, sure, but he's a firm favourite with fans young and old. The good news is that KINGofdaRING went to town on an old-school Mr. Perfect that's erm...perfect for your needs.

Forget the fact that image above makes him look like a giant Refreshers bar (Google it).

Tag-teaming this download with a SummerSlam 1991 arena means you'll be able to recreate Perfect's timeless Intercontinental Title battle vs. Bret Hart. Or, if you're into fantasy warfare, why not put on a clinic opposite GUNTHER?


1. Randy Savage

WWE 2K23 Randy Savage
2K Games

Creator: KINGofdaRING

Downloads: 939

'Macho Man' Randy Savage is on the books in WWE 2K23, but the lack of attire choices for him is slightly alarming. After all, bold outfits were a huge part of Randy's appeal, so it makes sense to have as many as possible. That's why you should grab KINGofdaRING's creation as soon as possible.

It incorporates classic outfits from some of Savage's biggest WrestleMania matches, and they're even better than the default one 2K offers. Alternatively, the same creator also has a 1992-1994 version of 'Macho' if you'd like to put the WWF's wrongs right by sticking him back in the ring.

Why not go for both?

For more content like this, check out WWE 2K23: 15 Best WCW CAWs You Need To Download and 10 Problems WWE Must Solve In The 2023 Draft!


In this post: 
WWE 2K23
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.