WWE 2K24 Superstar Ratings: 10 Biggest Surprises & Snubs
4. Surprise/Snub - Becky Lynch (94)/Becky Lynch '19 (90)
Becky Lynch had a good 2023 - her feud-ending match with Trish Stratus was a bonafide classic, and her run as NXT Women's Champion made the belt mean more than it has in years - but she was nowhere close to the heights she was at during her 2018-2019 peak. Heck, Becky Lynch's storyline going into WrestleMania this year is that she feels threatened by Rhea Ripley's ascent, and needs to prove to herself that she's still got what it takes to be the best in the business.
As such, it's hugely surprising that the current incarnation of the Irish superstar gets a 94, while the Becky Lynch who bestrode the narrow world like a colossus in 2019 only gets 90. Becky may arguably be better in the ring now than she was back then - not many wrestlers could have given Trish the 5* sendoff Becky did - but her star has definitely fallen since her 2019 heyday.