XBox One Vs PS4: 5 Simple Tips To Welcome In A Real Next Generation

Xbox One Ps4 The new generation of gaming has arrived, but to be perfectly honest, it doesn't feel much different from what we're used to. It seems that without a big leap in display resolutions, disc formats, or crazy input methods (Kinect had a predecessor already), we're still left watching the horizon for something exciting - something to really herald a new era of engagement. If it won't come from the hardware, and it won't come from system features, we may have to resort to the craziest idea of all: designing better games. Game design seems to be at extreme opposites these days, but not much stands out as revolutionary or "next-gen". Indie developers are throwing wacky, minimalistic concepts on the wall to see what will stick, while big publishers are trying to perfect their safest and most lucrative formulas. Honestly, it's like most people don't even know what a next-gen idea would look like. Here to help everyone realize there's still at least five design ideas that could instantly give new games a sense of being "next-gen," and by way of a handbook for XBox One and PS4 game developers looking to make something really innovative, I offer the following list. You may have seen glimpses of these in other places, that only means those games were ahead of their time. R emember this isn't about dreaming up impossible visions of the future, driven by cutting edge technology €“- on the contrary, they're all long overdue, and have particular significance today.

5. Life Is Precious

Ryse "Artificial intelligence" has always been a nice fancy term that didn't live up to its name, but by now we've forgotten its meaning completely. Nobody tries to create artificial intelligence in the true sense of the word anymore. The old fantasy of interacting with sophisticated virtual beings who would not only be cleverly designed in order to challenge our intellect, but eventually become smarter than us and surprise us with their decisions, has been replaced with a half-hearted acceptance of literally mowing down thousands of unthinking zombies, who have no sense of self-preservation and can only groan as they're ground into sludge. At this rate we can expect to be playing the world's most photorealistic looking fish-in-barrel massacre sim by 2024, and we'll still be obligated to refer to it as "next-gen". I'm not asking Nintendo to put a Watson computer behind every Koopa, but most game characters could use a baby step toward common sense. For example, when a character's "health points" are low, they should behave differently than when they're at full health. It's not hard to implement that, but it goes a long way in creating the sense of "artificial intelligence" and "next-gen." If your game is all about shooting people, maybe you could program characters to act like they got shot when you, y'know, shoot them. I watched a demo of Ryse: Son of Rome and was stunned by the uncanny valley effect of watching masterfully modeled warriors run up like idiots and ignore thirty stab wounds from the hero, fighting as vigorously and confident as before. They even have superficial cuts on their bodies, but it makes no practical difference to their actions or reactions. The more real people look, the more disappointing their unrealistic behavior feels. We're actually moving backwards. The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion was scripted so that its bad guys tend to boast and rally together when they have a clear advantage, but scatter and beg for mercy when their posse gets devastated. The original X-COM: UFO Defense included a "morale" system, wherein enemies and squadmates would psychologically weaken as their team was attacked and killed. Eventually they'd snap, shooting randomly at things or throwing their weapon on the ground and standing still, panicked. That was 1994.

4. Finite Ammo

Kill Zone If you told a game designer that they could only allocate a total of 100,000 bullets to all the armed forces in a game, which could never be magically replenished under any conditions, and if you told them each entity could only carry a realistic amount at any given moment, how do you think it would change the way that game was designed? The idea here is to design around self-imposed limitations, instead of becoming lazy with the excessive wastefulness of the digital realm. This is a next-gen idea because keeping track of many things accurately is harder than simply generating things that disappear and are forgotten, but also because it pushes game design forward. Enemies would no longer be able to use the "stand and shoot endlessly in the general direction of the player" strategy, which designers seem to think is still acceptable even in big budget "next-gen" games of today. It's not. With finite ammo, suddenly every shot would become valuable, including those of your generic soldier units, whether friend or foe. And while it's true that armies tend to have huge caches of ammunition (with warehouses and crates full of the stuff) they are still finite, and lots of logistical work goes into transporting it to where it's needed, when it's needed. With an idea like this, capturing and protecting supplies would become a natural priority in your mission, and so would hoarding and protecting your own stash. Things like that. Realism isn't the best reason, of course. A better reason is that game designers don't realize the importance of tension and anticipation in a conflict. Fear of being shot is more intense than actually being shot at. All you need to do is watch a battle in Killzone: Shadowfall to see how boring next-gen combat is when everybody is spraying death at each other constantly. You acclimate to it, and it starts to become background noise. As a game designer, shouldn't that be embarrassing? The next generation of games could fix this, and they should. Enemies would have to be scripted to have a Plan B in case they run out of ammo, or rather, they'd have to have a smarter Plan A to begin with. Ambushes, traps, and creativity might become better solutions than blasting a waist-high piece of cover indefinitely. The Last of Us did a wonderful job demonstrating how precious weapons feel when you're scavenging for ammo, but it also made two glaring errors: 1) people react to bullets like they were mosquito bites, and 2) against all logic, every enemy has unlimited ammo right until the moment you search their dead bodies, at which point their guns are usually empty. It gave us a taste of a world where ammunition mattered, but then copped out.

3. Weather Should Matter

Loco Again, this is about taking something extremely familiar and giving it a new significance. Games love to place our characters in fantastical scenarios, from blazing volcanos to bug-ridden swamps, but it almost never matters in terms of how we play. Both practically and psychologically, environment should be a constant concern, with its own rewards and risks. If next-gen games could start giving us this, it would feel revolutionary indeed. For example, water. In real life, being wet in instantly changes a person's game plan. Water absorbs body heat 25 times faster than air does; it ruins dry goods, destroys electronics, rusts metal, adds weight, and takes a long time to go away. In games, water is a little dripping effect that happens on your character for a few seconds as you climb out of it. It would take a bit of proper game design to account for all the consequences of various weathers and environmental conditions, but the end result would be a game that demands respect. I remember the first time I saw rain in Grand Theft Auto III. Watching the sky randomly get cloudy and start raining was crazy -- but when I got in a car and realized that it actually changed the car's handling, I felt like I had stepped into the future. Now that I'm in the future, I'm disappointed by the game industry's assumption that environments are the sole domain of art departments, not programmers. Commandos 2: Men of Courage also had a moment of environmental enlightenment in the "White Death" mission, where the player have to sneak around an arctic Nazi encampment searching for winter clothes, ducking into warm (but risky) spots to keep from being frozen. It made me realize there's something more terrifying than being unarmed and naked in a Nazi encampment, and it's wind.

2. Choose Your Own Goals

Minecraft Dragon Different than sandbox games or linear paths, the idea is that developers should allow us to choose and customize our own objectives from the start of the game, which would then dictate the scope of that particular playthrough. Imagine playing a classic RPG, but instead of 20 minutes of dialogue and exposition designed to make you care and burden you with instructions, you are sitting with your best friend on a bench outside. The friend asks you what you want to do with your life, and you can choose from a list of goals, including everything from becoming the ruler of the kingdom, to exploring the mysteries of the Far East. You check the boxes that interest you, and just like that, the game knows what you want to do, and can start guiding you along those paths. For the sake of feasability there needs to be limits, but you can opt in or out of what matters to YOU. Once you've completed all the things on your list, the game congratulates you, and the credits roll. You didn't want to save the princess this time, so it didn't pretend it was important. This would fix many problems that sandbox games have; particularly that of internal contradictions. Sandbox games feel obligated to create an "ending", but they never seem to know how to get there, or why we should bother. They encourage us to get distracted with everything available, but they need us to stay interested in a plot that is never allowed to pose a real threat. This results in a game about a crazy person with a tremendous ego, because any attempt at emotional depth and impending doom would feel like a joke as we spend three in-game weeks bullying strangers we meet and collecting trinkets for our collection. The Player Dictated Narrative idea finds a perfect balance, letting players consider what they want to do, and then commit to it earnestly. It's time to stop spending so much time, effort, and money on distracting us from the limitations linear games create, and start handing us the keys. If there's one thing we've learned from the massive success of "Achievements" or "Trophies" in gaming, it's that people don't need fancy cutscenes and exposition to get motivated, they just need a goal and a pat on the head when they reach it. So why not create worlds and game structures that work hand-in-hand to harness such natural impulses? Minecraft is the biggest grassroots phenomenon in gaming, and it simply plops the player down in a random spot and let's them explore, or not. Minecraft technically has an ending, but it only highlights the awkwardness of the Creator Dictated Narrative. Who cares about killing the dragon? Nobody. Why put all the effort into making one? Because we have to roll credits somewhere, and we want to end on a high note. But it's not a high note, because we didn't really care about that. If we could custom design our own "Final Achievement" in Minecraft, we would celebrate every step closer to it, and have an ending that means something to every individual player, in each playthrough.

1. Make-A-Mode

Noclip Lastly, an idea to get more mileage out of games by simply letting us create our own "modes" before we start, almost like a user-friendly "debug" mode. Debug modes are used by developers to quickly jump around to specific locations, try specific things, tweak some numbers, and see what happens. Plenty of old PC games featured a commands such as "godmode," which made the player invincible, or "noclip," which let them pass through walls. Debug isn't usually meant for players to use because it breaks the illusion of a seamless world with unquestionable rules, but there are a few great reasons why it's time to let us under the hood. For one, we no longer have cheat codes. Chris DeLeon from HobbyGameDev.com discussed the merits of cheat codes and game tinkering in a recent video, and he's right: game designers don't always know best. The games we loved as children often had secret codes which let us bypass what the designer intended. Before the Internet revolution, these codes were so precious that they sold gaming magazines by the thousands. Today, the "modding community" has done something even better, by creating and sharing their own versions of existing games. But too few games support this, and nobody makes it very easy, despite Steam's Workshop functionality. You're basically re-engineering a game the hard way. What we really need is an easy, no-brainer method of just customizing our playthrough. And what's the downside of letting us have it? Those who don't want it can ignore it, while most people would be delighted to play with the gravity settings, projectile speed, health and damage amounts, or the starting items and abilities. It mulitplies the entertainment value of the game and it takes practically zero work. Just include a little disclaimer that it may cause unintended effects and break the game, and we'd laugh when it happens. Realistically, it would also relieve a lot of pressure from game designers to make things "perfect", saving work balancing every aspect when players are guaranteed to think could be improved with a few tweaks anyway. It takes an old idea and evolves it for the next generation. What do you think? How should the real new generation really be heralded in? Share your own thoughts in the comments section.

In this post: 
PS4 XBox One
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Humble philosopher and Metal Gear enthusiast. I prefer not to tread lightly. I believe that to write something interesting you can't just answer the question better, you have to find better questions to begin with. I could write a bunch more of those, because I'm full of wisdom and conviction like that. Just say no to college, kids!