Xbox Scarlett: 5 Burning Questions Microsoft Must Answer

Microsoft's comeback will be with... an all-streaming console?!

Xbox Scarlett
Microsoft

At E3 2018, a mere two months ago, Phil Spencer concluded Microsoft's impressive showcase by nonchalantly adding that his team was hard at work on the next generation of Xbox systems, codenamed Scarlett.

While this wasn't shocking news in and of itself - companies like Sony and Microsoft tinker at new consoles as soon as the previous ones launch - Spencer being so open and honest on stage was surprising from an industry so often unnecessarily tight-lipped.

What was truly interesting about his statement however, was the word "consoles". Plural. This raised a few eyebrows, but most industry pundits chalked it up to multiple SKUs, like when the PS3 launched with two of the same systems having differing storage capacity.

A recent report from Thurrot has stated that Microsoft is indeed working on more than one system, but they are far from mere storage SKUs.

According to the report, Microsoft is working on two different consoles.

The first is said to be a traditional Xbox console, while the second is a more interesting, cloud-based streaming system. The alleged streaming console will be built around a service akin to PlayStation Now.

Suffice to say, the news was controversial amongst gamers, and raised more questions than answers. Will gamers be receptive to such a system? Will it even be usable by the majority of consumers? Only time will tell.

5. How Will Subscriptions Work?

Xbox Live
Microsoft

A fairly basic question that should be easily answered come Xbox's first reveal; how will subscriptions work?

Will Xbox Gold and Xbox Game Pass work seamlessly with Scarlett? Will you be able to download the games or just stream them?

These are a few of the most fundamental questions surrounding Scarlett Cloud.

As of now, the only way to play games purchased through Xbox Live Gold or Game Pass, is to download them to your system. It seems as though that won't be an option with Xbox's Cloud system, so will we simply be able to stream the games via the console library?

That seems the most likely option, and a fairly straightforward one.


4. How Good Does Your Internet Connection Need To Be?

Xbox One streaming PC
Microsoft

This is the mac-daddy of questions, the one everyone jumps to when they hear terms like "cloud" or "streaming". When Microsoft attempted an always-online Xbox One, fans were outraged, largely because internet connections in most parts of the world are shoddy at best.

It'll be seven years since then when Scarlett is said to launch, and things aren't much better. If the system is to be always-online as we suspect, it needs to work perfectly with varying internet speeds for people to believe in it.

PlayStation Now is the perfect reference point for how cloud-based technology can be unreliable. For context, this writer's internet connection speed (just outside of Toronto) is 20.5 MBPS, and PlayStation Now is a 5 frames-per-second mess.

So Xbox Scarlett will need to seamlessly function on speeds even lower than that for it to work in countries across the world. This will be a huge make-or-break for the console; if a guy in a village in Scotland buys the system and it doesn't work because his internet speed is only 5 MBPS, he won't be happy.


3. Will The Average Consumer Understand?

Xbox One Console
AP Photo/Nam Y. Huh

A video game console that operates entirely through cloud-based programming with no internal storage or disc-drive might fly right over the head of the average consumer.

Sure, that may sound insulting, but would your mum know what it is? Would she be able to work it?

These are accessibility issues that needs to be explained as plainly as possible - the Wii sold so incredibly well because even grandmother's could turn it on and go bowling. How many parents will buy it for Christmas, along with some physical games, only to realise on Xmas morning that the system doesn't work that way?

They're very real problems, and Microsoft will have to address these issues when marketing a cloud-based system.


2. How Big Is The Internal Memory?

Xbox One Game Download
Microsoft

Microsoft could solve a lot of concerns with internet speeds, if the Scarlett Cloud launched with some internal memory.

Perhaps not a lot, maybe even just 200 GB, that way gamers could download 2-4 titles and keep them on the system for rainy days. Or for those with poor internet speeds who would rather have the cheaper system. If there isn't sufficient internal memory, the system will need to run spectacularly well on meandering internet connections.

It's unlikely this will be the case, it seems this is Microsoft's attempt at diving headfirst into the streaming world. After the failed reveal of the original Xbox One, Microsoft reverted back to a traditional games console. Now it seems the company's idea for averting such a disaster, is to launch two consoles to appease both types of gamer.

Additionally, word has it that Scarlett Cloud will be significantly cheaper than a traditional console, and therefore it's unlikely to feature any internal memory.

That would be a mistake.


1. What Happens If The Cloud Crashes?

Lenticular Cloud Over Harold's Cross Dublin Ireland 30 6 15
Wikipedia

The most obvious question surrounding Xbox Scarlett is also a simple one: what happens if the cloud crashes? The entire system will seemingly run on cloud-based technology and storage, so if that gets hacked, crashes, or some such disaster, what happens to our games? Our progress? Our sanity?

The reason many gamers are reluctant to go all-in on digital market-fronts, i.e. PSN and Xbox Live, is because they believe them to be unreliable. It's not an unreasonable notion, especially given the many PSN outages since 2011. So, when such outages occur, gamers would be unable to access their vast library of games. This is obviously a problem, but it's not as though things are ever going to go backwards.

Having an all-digital games library certainly is easier, less clutter, and more manageable; simply put, it's the future. Things are only going to get easier and such digital outages are less common on Xbox, so this is one that is a little terrifying but not as apocalyptic as many believe.

Hopefully the brains at Microsoft have come up with a fail-proof cloud-streaming console.


In this post: 
Xbox
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Curtis is from Ireland and lives in Canada now.