If Ernest Hemingway could tell a compelling story in 6 words, why can't a musician craft a great song in 60 seconds? Short answer: They can and they have. But unlike Hemingway's super succinct masterpiece, most of these songs won't go on to obtain legendary status. And I'll never really understand why. It seems that we're craving shorter and shorter pieces of entertainment as our attention spans turn to mush, but for some reason we're not quite willing to accept anything less than the typical three-minute pop song. Which is a real shame, because some of the greatest songs pack more substance into one minute than some musicians put into an entire album. Now, to be fair, oftentimes a running time this short means the track is just an interlude or a skit or an uber-experimental bit of nonsense. But occasionally, it's just a really brief, extraordinary little song. The good news is that if you don't like any of those listed, you've only wasted, at most, a minute of your life on it. So play the odds and click on the videos embedded within. You've got nothing to lose...
20. Paul McCartney - "The Lovely Linda"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mn-wqFI9YcE "Awwww, that Paul. He's so sweet." If anyone doesn't think that was the reaction McCartney was hoping to hear most often in his post-Beatles career, they obviously haven't heard his schmaltzy solo debut. That album is almost defiantly adorable. "The Lovely Linda" is the opening track from that debut, and the shortest song Paul's ever recorded. It's a simple love song dedicated to his first wife that was meant as a subtle jab to his former bandmates declarations of love to Yoko Ono.
19. Band Of Horses - "Lamb On The Lam"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eh5cg4tl4n8 This Cure-inspired instrumental was primarily used to separate the old-timey, foot-stomping, folk song that came before it and the frenzied bounce of indie rock that came after it, "Lamb on the Lam" works in its own right, largely because the riff is so damn entrancing. Sure, it would be great if Band of Horses had stretched it out into a "proper" song, but this short track was destined to be put on loop at a planetarium while stoned kids try to figure out the meaning of life And isn't that its own gift?
18. Madvillain - "Supervillain Theme"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qx2zU1c2LFM Try to find a song in modern hip-hop that sounds anything like the off-kilter experimentation of MF Doom and Madlib on their only full-length, non-remix album. Madvillainy is a singular adventure, a dark carnival of meticulous beats and sophisticated rhymes that grips you by the throat while it spits hot fire into your ear. There wasn't a bad moment on the album, and the duo even slipped in a few brief instrumental tracks that actually added to the album, rather than stop the listener in their tracks or pad the thing out. "Supervillain Theme" is chamber music explored through the lens of someone with a serious bone to pick and a penchant for creeping everyone out in the process.
17. Sam Phillips - "Love & Kisses"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y6Xa07s_Z18 Speaking of chamber music, is there a better way to kick off a critically acclaimed, Grammy nominated alternative album than with this Revolver-era, Beatles-esque track? (That wasn't a real question and the answer is "no," by the way.) Unlike some of the songs on this list, Phillips' contribution doesn't sound the least bit unfinished. It really does sound like it was written to be this specific length. Of course, I wouldn't argue with the release of a Director's Cut that extends to four minutes, if such a thing exists.
16. Modest Mouse - "Path Of Least Resistance"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uEEXIwpduJ0 Although some of the best of Modest Mouse's output has come to us in sprawling, long-form allegories and extended jams (hello, Lonesome Crowded West), they also have a knack for cutting through the fat when they feel like they need to. Their first collection of recordings as a band, Sad Sappy Sucker contains a ton of musical morsels, some of which are clearly the beginning stages of a brainstorming session that the band would never finish. Others feel like inside jokes that were never intended to be released. And then there's "Path of Least Resistance," a conceptual song about giving in when things get too hard. It shows a glimmer of the creative genius that Modest Mouse would eventually blossom into.
15. Green Day - "The Ballad Of Wilhelm Fink"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C6bCWMdarZI This sounds like the beginning to one of the best Green Day songs never released, cutting off right before it would normally launch into the bombastic, full band section. Only, "The Ballad of Wilhelm Fink" never quite gets there, making this an exercise in tantric music listening. Despite that, it's actually the most fully realized song on the collection, Short Music For Short People, which features 101 punk bands performing 30-second pieces. And it's still a thousand times better than most of Green Day's post-American Idiot output.
14. Animal Collective - "College"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8VX93QbzF2c "You don't have to go to college." Seven simple words that could have saved me so much heartbreak in the student loan department if I'd only heard this before I embarked on that fabled mission of lifelong debt. Unlike most Animal Collective albums, which are brimming with complex arrangements and every instrument Willy Wonka could imagine, Sung Tongs is a stripped-down affair. And "College" is a welcome, Beach Boys mocking reprieve from the group's otherwise constant barrage of freak folk.
13. Minor Threat - "Straight Edge"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0OSnAPxyMzo Perhaps no other song on this list has had such a lasting effect on the world as the one by hardcore punk outfit Minor Threat. Despite clocking in at a brisk 46 seconds, "Straight Edge" was responsible for creating an entire lifestyle in the punk culture that's still prominent today. Being straight edge means living a drug-free lifestyle while also abstaining from caffeine, non-vegetarian foods, and promiscuity. The lyric "I've got better things to do than sit around and f*ck with my head" began a revolution in the punk world, one that directly countered the excesses surrounding the culture at the time.
12. Sum 41 - "Never Wake Up"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ATsI8zE-W8 Sum 41 were out to prove that the title of their album All Killer, No Filler wasn't just a BS tagline used to move copies. They reinforced the truthfulness of it with a collection of energetic, no-fuss pop-punk songs that were determined not to go on for a second longer than they needed to. Enter "Never Wake Up," a Bad Religion-inspired skate punk opus that is over before your Hot Pocket even finishes cooking in the microwave.
11. Tenacious D - "Classico"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z5VhszQ4Srw Expanding on the classical guitar merits Kyle Gas showcased on their first album with "Rock Your Socks" (while simultaneously cutting down on the overall runtime), Tenacious repurpose a bit of Johann Sebastian Bach's "Bouree in E Minor" to great effect on the succinct "Classico." It's a beautiful reminder that not only are these guys very talented musicians, but they know not to wear out a simple joke by stretching it out.
10. Van Halen - "Spanish Fly"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDsa4uDM3zU Eddie Van Halen's guitar solos are as much a part of the band's identity as anything else, and yes that includes Diamond Dave's often karate-related stage antics. The fact that "Eruption"--a nary two minute guitar solo--is one of the band's most enduring songs shouldn't be a surprise. Because it kicks ass. And that's all Van Halen really wanted to do in its earliest days. And sure, instrumentals like "Eruption" and its acoustic variation, "Spanish Fly" (off Van Halen II), are pure showboating. But that's literally what every song from those first two albums are. And isn't that part of the reason we still love them?
9. The Magnetic Fields - "Boa Constrictor"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KuD8bTyKYjM The entire 69 Love Songs album is chockfull of these little ditties. (That title isn't taking the piss, there really are 69 different songs stretched out across three volumes.) It's a sprawling anthology of wildly different genres and song topics that was conceived as a piece of musical theater that would be performed by drag queens. "Boa Constrictor" is one of the shortest in the collection, but it might just be the most hauntingly beautiful. Although lyrics like "My mother should have murdered me" don't paint the rosiest picture, the sprightly guitar plucking provides a fascinating contrast. It's like a Shel Silverstein poem come to life.
8. The Killers - "Enterlude"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oC3bb4bZ79I Far from your typical musical interlude, "Enterlude" is a joyful welcoming to the Killers' hometown of Las Vegas. Sam's Town is their version of a concept album, a musical love letter to the parts of the city that most tourists will never take the time to see. And "Enterlude" sets the listener on the right track, wrapping them in a warm hug and offering to buy them a beer. "We hope you enjoy your stay," Brandon Flowers sing over a twinkling piano. "It's good to have you with us, even if it's just for a day." You don't get a better salutation than that.
7. Violent Femmes - "Dahmer Is Dead"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Kj1uphTN68 Those who are only aware of the band's alt-rock classic "Blister in the Sun" might be a little thrown off by the band's full-on punk assault on songs like "Dahmer Is Dead," but that's a big part of the Milwaukee-based band's sound. Well, maybe not a big part (this song is over by the time you've finished Googling the name of the band that sings this weird tune), but it's certainly one of the many facets of their sound that makes them such a noteworthy contributor to the 80s alt-rock canon.
6. The Mamas & The Papas - "Once Was A Time I Thought"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6KmZOwSmTc Just listen to those rapid fire harmonies! What are they saying? I have no idea! And I don't even care because this is so utterly delightful! "Once Was a Time I Thought" is the final track on The Mamas & the Papas self-titled album, but it's not a throwaway track. On the contrary, this was a pitch-perfect reminder that no one could hold up to the vocal stylings of this group at the time. And it's nice for an album like this, that had its production marred with so much infighting, to end on such a harmonious note.
5. De La Soul - "A Little Bit Of Soap"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NJEArOnEbcE De La Soul were pioneers in the alternative hip hop scene of the late 80s and early 90s. Their incorporation of jazz elements and other, unusual stylistic choices had many critics lauding their debut album, 3 Feet High and Rising, as an all-time classic. And while the album is a postmodern masterpiece that's as sonically inventive as it is socially conscious, there's at least one track on the album that keeps it from sounding as pretentious as my description just did. "A Little Bit of Soap" is a flat-out silly track that samples one-hit wonder The Jarmels (a doo wop group from the 60s) while slinging lyrics about body odor. It proved they could be charming...and just a little stupid. Which only endeared them more to the public.
4. The White Stripes - "Little Room"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UJe9msZaGB8 In what could arguably considered The White Stripes greatest album, White Blood Cells, Jack white comes storming through the speakers carrying nothing but a fuzzy guitar and a garage rock attitude. Except for on this nugget of a song, where the guitar is conspicuously absent. "Little Room" is the most basic of blues songs, using just a drum and a voice to tell the story. Jack is able to cram quite the nifty story into 50 seconds, though, a virtual onomatopoeia of a tale that would do Edgar Allen Poe proud.
3. The Descendents - "M-16"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p4EVmwX1tC8 It turns out you can have a fast, loud, concise, AND tuneful punk song. Who knew? The Descendents did a lot for the hardcore punk movement, but they're greatest achievement was proving to a generation of kids obsessed with screaming vocals and loud guitars that punk music can also be melodic. Of course, the band had nothing against playing fast or playing brief, which they proved time and time again on their influential debut album. (All but one of the tracks stays under the 2 minute mark.)
2. Coldplay - "Parachutes"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYZYqkAM9uI Coldplay have since become well known for their bombastic, anthemic arena rock, but when Parachutes was released, Chris Martin and company were just a group of brooding young fellas from London who favored acoustic ditties over soaring dance pop. And the title track from that album is as arresting as anything the band has done in the 15 years since. It's truly one of the only times that Coldplay was capable of leaving their audience wanting more. That's not a knock against them, it's just that the structure of most radio rock lends itself to being overly repetitive. And while most fans of this album would have loved for "Parachutes" to go on for five-plus minutes, there's a bigger beauty in its smallness.
1. The Beatles - "Her Majesty"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YMuLi7BC_wc The Beatles ended up being, among so many other things, the undisputed kings of the very short song. They had quite a few over the course of their career, none as lovely or as concise as "Her Majesty," a song about Queen Elizabeth II. Not only was this one of the first examples of an album containing a hidden track (it wasn't listed on the sleeve of Abbey Road), but it wasn't supposed to appear on the album at all. According to Paul McCartney, this was one of those "happy accidents" that the Beatles always seemed to luck into. But that delightful fingerpicking was no accident. It's a friendly reminder that George Harrison wasn't the only talented guitarist in the group.