Star Trek: 10 Things You Didn't Know About Beverly Crusher
Remember me? A lot has changed since 2364.
She's the doctor without (space) borders with two sons who also like to travel, former CMO of the flagship, now head of Starfleet Medical. There might have been a running gag about how many patients died on her table in season one of Star Trek: The Next Generation, but Doctor Crusher was and is a skilled and compassionate physician to whom many owe their lives. Going above and beyond in her duty of care, Doctor Crusher also provided a much needed moral counterweight on matters such as the all-too-stringently applied Prime Directive.
Until very recently, it is true, Doctor Crusher wasn't really given the chance to shine in her own right. Whilst there are plenty of brilliant Beverly moments in The Next Generation (Descent, Remember Me, and Suspicions come to mind), the character was still often weighed down by writing that veered into sexist trope (especially in season one), or, in the films, simply not written for much at all. Then, of course, there's what happened with season two. Her turn in Star Trek: Picard was a triumph, however — opening, and effectively closing, the show with a command performance throughout.
So, never mind the 'boogers' (we'll pretend that never happened). Get the hyposprays out and the tap shoes on! It's time we found out a bit more about Starfleet's most famous 'dancing doctor'.
10. If You CAN Do, Teach; If You CAN Teach, Do
Gates McFadden and her Star Trek counterpart are two of the finest reasons to dismiss that old George Bernard Shaw binarism — "Those who can, do; those who can't, teach" — as the bunch of bull it is. McFadden has forged a supremely successful career out of doing both supremely well, and Beverly Crusher is doctor, surgeon, teacher, mother, researcher, head of Starfleet Medical, take your pick!
At the very beginning of the creation process for Star Trek: The Next Generation, Beverly Crusher was, in fact, the ship's schoolteacher. As cited in The Fifty Year Mission: The Next 25 Years: From the Next Generation to J.J. Abrams, it was story editor/creative consultant David Gerrold who suggested otherwise: "We don't have a ship's doctor yet, why don't we have Beverly Crusher be the ship's doctor?" Others were hesitant, "And then Gene started discussing it. By lunch, Beverly Crusher was the ship's doctor".
Doctor Crusher herself taught acting and was a playwright and producer, but before becoming Beverly, Gates McFadden had already spent several years as a theatre teacher in higher education at George Washington University, the University of Pittsburgh, and Harvard! She also continued to teach at several different universities (including her alma mater Brandeis) after The Next Generation had finished. McFadden is an accomplished theatre director and was artistic director of Ensemble Studio Theatre in Los Angeles for five years.
9. Third Time's A Star Trek
It would be impossible to imagine anyone else in the role of Doctor Crusher, but as Gates McFadden tells it in her self-narrated and exec-produced documentary series The Center Seat: 55 Years of Star Trek, she almost didn't even make it to her own audition.
McFadden was already in Los Angeles for "something else" at the time and was on her way back to the airport. It was only a last-minute call from her agent — who was a huge Star Trek fan — that got her to go to Paramount for the Next Gen audition, although her agent didn't specify the part. When McFadden arrived, she was told she could read for "any of the [three] women's roles," and picked what she thought was the 'funny character,' Beverly Crusher, but apparently that was just a scene from The Naked Now.
Having been offered the job, it seems McFadden still needed a little more convincing. She would, in fact, say no to Trek twice and went to do a play in New York instead. If McFadden said yes the third time then it was, as she said in The Center Seat, because she thought "it was a big step forward for women in command positions".
Unfortunately, that sense of optimism for the character was not set to last long.
8. A Season Two Short
Star Trek: The Next Generation got off to a very rocky start. Its debut season was hit and miss, but mostly miss. Behind the scenes, cast and crew were dealing with the Maurice Hurley-burly and being lawyered by Leonard Maizlish. Denise Crosby went the way of the angry Armus, and Gates McFadden was 'fired,' 'let go,' or 'not asked back,' depending on the phraseology.
The backstage turmoil was hardly a secret to the outside world at the time. In 1989, Cinefantastique (vol. 19, no. 3) ran a piece detailing in no uncertain terms the "sturm und drang on the final frontier" that had led to "a creative exodus of writers and producers". Even legendary Original Series writer D.C. Fontana had left TNG by October 1987. Nonetheless, McFadden appeared remarkably stoic about her departure. As she said in the Cinefantastique article: "I had a good year, made wonderful friends, did good work and made some money."
Behind such stoicism was the reality of the 1980s version of the 24th century, however. McFadden had expressed concerns about Beverly's (disappointing) interactions with Wesley, and about certain sexist tropes she felt were present in scripts such as Angel One, to writer/producer Maurice Hurley. As McFadden told Inside of You with Michael Rosenbaum, that "really pissed him [Hurley] off." It was Hurley who was then reportedly responsible for her dismissal.
Thankfully, fans began a year-long letter writing campaign to bring Doctor Crusher back, and Patrick Stewart later rang McFadden to ask her to return for season three.
7. Wesley's Mom
Doctor Crusher's live-aboard, decidedly precocious 'genius' son was a character particularly dear to Gene Roddenberry's heart. Wesley was Roddenberry's middle name. In the Star Trek: The Next Generation Companion, Roddenberry is quoted as saying, "I identify probably more so with Wesley because he is me at seventeen".
During the development of Next Gen, this affiliation meant that Beverly barely got a look-in, only mentioned when in reference to Wesley until the final edition of the writers' guide where Beverly finally got her own page of notes. Doctor Crusher's entry in the first casting call for TNG from 10 December 1986 also began with the line "leslie's [sic] 35 year old mother". Producer Robert Justman had argued for the child genius to be daughter 'Leslie,' but Roddenberry changed the character (back) to Wesley.
On Inside of You with Michael Rosenbaum, Gates McFadden pointed out that Doctor Crusher was a brilliant scientist in her own right and had raised the 'child genius'. Clearly, she had had something to do with his success, yet throughout season one, Beverly was reduced to the mothering role of "Oh, Wesley… why did you do that?" All of the serious discussions with Wesley went to the male characters. McFadden wasn't "buying it".
It really took until Star Trek: Picard for all this to change. In that, Beverly wasn't an addendum to son Jack: she had her own agency. As for Wesley, his Mum quite literally had the last word (chronologically speaking).
6. 'Le Docteur Danseur'
"Voulez-vous m'apprendre à danser ? [Would you teach me to dance?]" Data famously asked Doctor Crusher in the French (dubbed) version of Data's Day (Une journée de Data). The scene on the holodeck that eventually followed the question is now the stuff of Star Trek legend, and if Brent Spiner didn't quite do all of the tap dancing (claquettes), Gates McFadden did.
What you probably know by now is that the chaotic comedy, or at least the semblance of chaos, of that scene was choreographed by Gates McFadden. What you perhaps didn't know is that McFadden learnt the art, in part, by studying with renowned French actor/choreographer/mime, movement, and mask artist Jacques Lecoq in Paris (on a scholarship, no less) for over two years, and also returned to the States as Lecoq's assistant at Harvard University.
McFadden speaks French and has given interviews (about Star Trek) in the language. In 2018, she was guest star, for example, at 'Planet Fiction Convention [sic]' in Marseille alongside Battlestar Galactica's equally francophone Jamie Bamber. She could probably teach Jean-Luc a thing or two!
Before the dancing didactics with Data, McFadden was already pulling the strings as Director of choreography and Puppet Movement for Jim Henson on the film Labyrinth starring David Bowie. Before that, she had acted in the film The Muppets Take Manhattan and choreographed all the scenes that used Henson's Creature Shop creatures in the film Dreamchild. Fittingly, Doctor Crusher then appeared in parodic puppet form in Sesame Street's Spaceship Surprise: The Next Generation in 1994.
5. Beneath 'Beneath The Rose'
If you're looking for notorious episodes of Star Trek, nothing holds a candle to Sub Rosa quite like the one it holds to itself. It's Ronin the unfriendly sex ghost! To quote Seán on the episode: "Everybody gets a thought orgasm."
Gates McFadden has gone through quite the journey with "The Beverly Crusher sex episode". As she commented to Kate Mulgrew on her podcast Gates McFadden Investigates: Who do you think you are?,
This is the seventh season, and I thought [upon seeing the script] 'are you f**king kidding me?' You're telling me this woman, who is so smart, has come from a family where they've all been having sex with a lamp ghost? […] Now, I am so happy I did this episode because it's become a cult with younger people, and everyone laughs at it […]. It's funny! You have to just laugh.
Where family is concerned, the Howard surname — first seen on Beverly's personnel file in Conundrum — was a nod to Next Generation line producer Merri Howard, and Felisa was the first name of Sub Rosa teleplay writer Brannon Braga's grandmother. 'Felisa' without the Howard was first mentioned in The Arsenal of Freedom, an episode which, according to The Star Trek: The Next Generation Companion, was initially meant to be its own love story between Picard and Doctor Crusher (more than the hint at it we got, anyway).
Now, as Mulgrew said at the end of the podcast, "We really must have that martini and talk about that lamp. Long may it shine!"
4. The Genesis Device
As he flies with Riker to the Eleos aboard the more-than-just-borrowed shuttle from the Titan-A, Admiral (retired) Picard pulls up Beverly Crusher's last known Starfleet medical profile. For the first entry under 'Medical History,' the stardate is a little hard to make out, but it's 47653.2 either way. The text reads: "Near paralysis from unidentified venom. Placed in stasis to prevent paralysis. Reconstructive surgery required."
"Unidentified" was perhaps a subtle clue to a still then undercover agent of Star Trek: Picard's season three, for we know exactly what, or rather whose, venom it was in Star Trek: The Next Generation's Genesis. 'Twas Worf, dangerously de-evolving Worf. Doctor Crusher's screams as she writhed around on the floor in agony in that episode will no doubt haunt us forever, but there was a logical and altogether more off-screen reason for Worf's vicious venom attack.
Stasis for Crusher was in the script to give Gates McFadden more time behind the camera for her Star Trek directorial debut. In doing so, McFadden also became the first female cast member to direct an episode — preceded by Gabrielle Beaumont as the first woman full stop to direct Star Trek (on Booby Trap and six more episodes of The Next Generation, then one of Deep Space Nine, and one of Voyager). The next female cast member to take to the director's chair would be Roxann Dawson for the Voyager episode Riddles.
3. Cheeseburger Liquor Party
Okay, so this one is extremely left-of-field, but then again, there could be no greater bit of maybe unknown miscellany, nor ode to a character, than Star Trek meets acid punk/rock. This inspired fusion of genres is exactly the case for Seattle-based music group 'Beverly Crusher'. If you've come for the Starfleet Medical conference, you'll be getting a gig instead. Oh, and 'Cheeseburger Liquor Party' is the title of Beverly Crusher's (the band's) first album, followed up by the perhaps more apt 'Pills Pills Pills'.
The eponymous homage came rather naturally as well. Lead vocalist/guitarist Cozell Wilson had locked himself away one summer to watch Star Trek (as all of us quite literally have too) and decided that 'Beverly Crusher' would probably make a good band name… and it did. The name does mean that Wilson's fellow band members get to introduce themselves in rather comedic (and good natured) fashion: "Hey! I'm Sam Stiles. I cook and play drums for Beverly Crusher" and "My name is Max Stiles. I play bass in Beverly Crusher."
The 'real' Beverly Crusher was more used to string quartets and piano recitals aboard the Enterprise, but we get the feeling she was more hardcore than that. As Gates McFadden told The Shuttlepod Show, she has always wanted to learn how to play the drums. Perhaps a collab with her on-screen's off-screen namesake?
2. Crusher-Two-Two-Beta-Charlie
Throughout the run of The Next Generation movies in particular (and arguably during the series as well), Doctor Crusher wasn't given an awful lot to do. In Star Trek: Generations, the character was essentially just a punchline for Data's emotional development. In Star Trek: First Contact, she activated the EMH, gave her command code (the title of this entry), and not much more. In Star Trek: Insurrection, Crusher had a couple of lines, and then there was that bit about boobs. In Star Trek: Nemesis, well, blink and you'll miss her.
It's also telling that in amongst the deleted scenes in Nemesis (although there are quite a few) lies the one that would have explained what Crusher did next, i.e. go (back) to work at Starfleet Medical. That could never be canon now anyway, as in Star Trek: Picard, Beverly remained on the Enterprise-E until 2381, not long after coitus and call-back on Casperia Prime.
"Wait, so I was in those films?" Gates McFadden remarked, tongue-in-cheek, during a 92nd Street Y panel alongside Patrick Stewart, Michael Dorn, and Jonathan Frakes ahead of season three of Picard. In fact, expressly disappointed by how Doctor Crusher was portrayed, McFadden went on to say, "So I'm thrilled with what's going on now."
1. The Butterfly Effect
For season three of Star Trek: Picard, Beverly Crusher was back, and she was bloody badass from beginning to end. From the pump-action phaser rifle to the volleys of photon torpedoes, via the DNA and nebula gravity-well detective work, practical (and caring) parenting, and general doctoring, this was a fully-rounded Crusher at her very best. Well, that said, it was all probably a tap dance in the park for someone with her abilities.
Gates McFadden has spoken openly about the fact that she didn't want to return to Star Trek unless the role was different. Fortunately (for all of us), the way of doing things on Picard was diametrically opposed to the Next Gen season one approach. As McFadden told TrekMovie.com, showrunner Terry Matalas called her well in advance of filming to explain his story idea and ask for her input. The pair then communicated for several months because, as McFadden noted, "I just wanted to make sure that it was really going to be a story in which Crusher was really used".
The effects of Picard's third season are still being measured. For Doctor Crusher, what began with a move back to Earth and to London to protect her son, as well as joining the Mariposas (the medical group started in the past by Rios and Teresa Ramirez), ended in battle with rogue changelings and the Borg Queen, their defeat, and a joyful return to Starfleet. Even the smallest of actions in life can make a legacy, so, for the character that finally got to change the most, let's hope that butterfly continues to flap its wings!