10 Actors Who Turned Down The Decade's Biggest TV Shows

Dominic West... you silly, silly man.

We always hear about actors turning down parts and later regretting it, such as Sean Connery passing on Gandalf in Lord of the Rings, but what about in the world of TV? Deciding to take a juicy TV role is typically a much more difficult decision than agreeing to star in a film, because a movie will never take up more of an actor's time than around 4-6 months, whereas a TV series can lock an actor in for 6 months a year for up to a decade, depending on the contract offered and whether the part is adapted from previous material. Still, these actors all turned down roles in huge shows that surely would've given each of them a small-screen boost, especially as at the time many of them could certainly have used the exposure. We're not going to stop there, though: we're also going to consider whether these actors would have been able to fill the shoes of the actor who eventually won the part, or whether it really was for the best. Also, is there any chance any of these actors may have been truly better-suited for the part had they not refused it?

10. Jennifer Love Hewitt - Robin Scherbatsky (How I Met Your Mother)

In a Reddit AMA earlier this year, How I Met Your Mother co-creators Craig Thomas and Carter Bays were asked which well-known actress was originally touted to play Robin Scherbatsky, the plucky Canadian newscaster eventually played by Cobie Smulders. The duo replied with, "Jennifer Love Hewitt did The Ghost Whisperer instead of HIMYM!", and though Ghost Whisperer ended up running for five seasons before its cancellation, one has to wonder whether Hewitt regrets not taking the Robin part, considering the show's absurd popularity and the fact it ran for more than 200 episodes split over 9 seasons. Would It Have Worked? We can't help but think that Hewitt would have simply been too well known for the part, for though Jason Segel and Alyson Hannigan were also famous before the show began, they were pretty much just playing variations on their best-known movie characters anyway. It's hard to imagine Hewitt having the down-to-Earth appeal of Smulders' Robin, and we're just not that fussed about her acting abilities either...

9. Dominic West - Mance Rayder (Game Of Thrones)

In a 2012 interview with the Huffington Post, The Wire's Dominic West confirmed that he had been offered a part on HBO's hit show Game of Thrones, and though he didn't specify the role due to being unable to remember the name, online sleuths have been able to deduce pretty safely that it would have been Mance Rayder, the so-called King Beyond the Wall eventually played by Ciaran Hinds, though having appeared for just four episodes so far. Why did West turn it down? Because shooting would apparently have required him to be "in Reykjavik for six months", a claim that's difficult to believe given how minor Rayder's role has been so far, though when we consider West's elaboration that he needed to be in London for the sake of his young children, his turning the part down at least makes sense. Would It Have Worked? Absolutely. West is a world-class actor and would have nailed the part. That said, Hinds is also a snug fit for the part, so we have no regrets.

8. Dana Delany - Bree Van De Kamp (Desperate Housewives)

Dana Delany was so sought-after for the role of Desperate Housewives' prickly Bree Van de Kamp that after auditioning, she was offered the part three times, and each time turned it down, claiming that she thought the role was just too similar to her character on the 2001 TV series Pasadena. The role eventually went to Marcia Cross, and Delany later admitted regretting not taking the part. However, she ended up appearing on the show for a lengthy run as icy domestic goddess Katherine Mayfair, and somewhat aptly spent much of her screen time feuding with Bree. Would It Have Worked? Delany's performance was one of the most-praised aspects of the mid-section of Desperate Housewives, and with good reason. Series creator Marc Cherry credited her with delivering "a fantastic audition" for the original Bree role, and as such there's little doubt that she would've absolute run away with the part. Still, it's hard to imagine anyone but Cross playing the part because it's so closely identified with her as a performer.

7. Scott Foley - Ted Mosby (How I Met Your Mother)

Scott Foley is best known for his TV work on shows such as Felicity, Scrubs, The Unit, Grey's Anatomy, True Blood and most recently, Scandal. The guy clearly does not want for work at all, so perhaps that's why he didn't feel pressured to accept the part of schlub Ted Mosby on How I Met Your Mother, which eventually went to relatively unknown actor Josh Radnor when Foley did not respond, and it shot Radnor straight to overnight fame. Would It Have Worked? Probably. Foley is a handsome yet down-to-Earth actor who could probably have penetrated the same sort of neurotic sweetness that made Radnor's Mosby such a hit with audiences, though Radnor just about edges it because he's slightly more normal looking, and as a result is a tad more believable as the sort of everyman the show is trying to appeal to. Still, it certainly wouldn't have been a bad fit by any means.

6. Rob Lowe - Dr. Derek Shepherd (Grey's Anatomy)

Rob Lowe's latest memoir revealed that he was originally offered the part of Grey's Anatomy's Dr. Derek Shepherd, aka McDreamy, which eventually went to Patrick Dempsey. Lowe turned it down as his deal had already been made for the short-lived series Dr. Vegas, though did agree to meet with the show's producers, stating, "I got an urgent call from the producers of a potential new show for ABC called Grey's Anatomy...I had read it and loved it...Grey's was a much better script; in fact, there was no comparison." Though Lowe has enjoyed subsequent success on the likes of Brothers and Sisters and Parks and Recreation, one can't help but wonder if he regrets not accepting the lucrative Grey's Anatomy deal, given that it's just been renewed for an 11th season. Would It Have Worked? Totally. Lowe is an extremely handsome middle-aged man, and pretty much any role he takes ends up alluding to his ridiculous good looks in one way or another, so the McDreamy label would still apply no problem. After over 200 episodes in the role, it may be difficult to imagine anyone but Dempsey playing the part, but Lowe would have been about as good a substitute as we could imagine. Still, we're glad he ended up playing Chris Traeger instead...

5. Jessica Chastain - Season 2 Protagonist (True Detective)

chastain6001 Last month, the rumour mill exploded that Jessica Chastain had been offered a part in the second season of HBO's superb drama True Detective. Though this was never actually confirmed by either HBO or Chastain, she was quick to deny that she would have any presence in the show, claiming, €œIt's such an awkward thing...That news broke yesterday and it went crazy on the internet. There was so much of an explosion. Also it's an awkward thing because when all that attention happens, it takes away from whoever plays the role. I love Woody Harrelson, and I'm gonna watch the second season just like I watched every episode of the first. But I won't be on it.€ Many have taken Chastain's definitive statement as proof that she was offered a part and quietly passed on it, though we may never know for sure. But if HBO were as smart as we think they are, hopefully they did lobby hard for the talented actress to take the part. Would It Have Worked? Without a shadow of a doubt. With Chastain's track record playing strong women, most memorably in Zero Dark Thirty, she would have effortlessly filled Woody Harrelson and Matthew McConaughey's shoes. If the show truly will feature a female protagonist next season, they'll struggle to find an actress as tough and emotionally resourceful as Chastain.

4. Katee Sackhoff - Debbie Pelt (True Blood)

Battlestar Galactica's Katee Sackhoff was approached to play the crazy on-off girlfriend of Alcide Herveaux, Debbie Pelt, for the third season of HBO's True Blood, though turned it down in favour of cop drama Boston's Finest, which ultimately wasn't even picked up by ABC. Why did Sackhoff turn the True Blood part down? In her own words, "I am a huge fan of True Blood...But I wanted more security than one season of something, so I rolled the dice with . This entire business is about rolling the dice and hoping you made the right decision." It's an ironic twist of fate for the actress, and to heap this on even more, Pelt, who ended up being played by Brit Morgan, ultimately lasted two seasons in the show, racking up a 14-episode tenure by the end of season four. Would It Have Worked? While we think Morgan was a better fit, Sackhoff proved during her run on 24 as Dana Walsh that she can play crazy-annoying just fine, and had Sackhoff accepted, the show certainly would not have suffered.

3. Thomas Jane - Don Draper (Mad Men)

On a 2011 podcast interview, Mad Men's Don Draper himself, Jon Hamm, admitted that he was far from the first choice for the part of the super-suave advertising executive (€œI started, literally, on the very, very bottom...I couldn't have had less heat on me....The casting directors didn€™t know who I was. I wasn€™t on anybody€™s lists€"). Rather, AMC were lobbying for Thomas Jane, but were told that at the time he " not do television", and so the role opened up to Hamm, who made his career on the part and became an overnight sex symbol. Would It Have Worked? Though Hamm has made the role so categorically his own, Jane is a rather handsome man in his own right, and with a nice clean shave, a slick hairdo and a tight-fitting suit, it's easy to imagine him sucking down scotch and smoking his insides raisin dry. He may not have ended up playing the Don Draper we know and love in this universe, but in addition to his looks, Jane is also a talented performer in his own right and would've no doubt brought something very interesting to the table.

2. Gillian Anderson - Cora Crawley (Downton Abbey)

In 2012, gorgeous X-Files star Gillian Anderson confirmed that she had initially been offered a lead part in Downton Abbey, playing Cora Crawley, the role that eventually went to Elizabeth McGovern. Though Anderson was relatively circumspect about explaining why she turned it down, she did state that, "€˜My 18-year-old cannot believe that I would turn down Game Of Thrones or Downton €” things she loves to watch...But if I am going to be spending that amount of time working on something I would rather be working with a director like Martin Scorsese." A tad snobbish, perhaps, but you can't fault her honesty. Would It Have Worked? Probably, but with a caveat. Anderson has plenty of experience working in period fare (Bleak House, Great Expectations), and certainly has the acting chops to boot, but casting the older, more normal-looking McGovern was certainly a savvy choice, as we can't help but think that Anderson's comparative youth and movie star beauty would just distract us from everything else going on around her.

1. Matthew Broderick - Walter White (Breaking Bad)

For years, word has spread around the Internet that John Cusack turned down the role of teacher-turned-drug-dealer Walter White on AMC's hit show Breaking Bad. However, Cusack took to Twitter last year to categorically shoot this widely-believed rumour down, casually declaring to a fan "Didn€™t turn it down u crazy". The belief that Matthew Broderick was handed the show's script continues to hold strong, however, and given the Ferris Bueller actor's rather meager prospects these days, we're pretty surprised he didn't take it. Would It Have Worked? This is a tough one. Broderick is an actor who rarely stretches himself by playing bad guys: he's just too fresh-faced and likeable for that, so would we ever have been able to buy him saying things like "I am the one who knocks"? More to the point, would Broderick be willing to throw his vanity aside and shave his head for the part? We could imagine the show being cancelled during its first season simply because Broderick wouldn't have fit the part, but then the same could easily have been said of Bryan Cranston prior to the show airing, and look how that turned out. Whether it would have worked or not, it's virtually impossible to imagine anyone but Cranston as Walter White. End of story. How do you think these original casting choices would have fared? Let us know in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.