10 Buffy The Vampire Slayer Episodes That Are Almost Perfect

These episodes of Buffy the Vampire Slayer were so close to being flawless.

Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

Buffy the Vampire Slayer is a classic television show with a dedicated fanbase who love to talk about their favourite episodes. As you might expect, opinions vary on the matter, but there are certain episodes that are universally acclaimed by almost everyone.

‘Hush’, ‘The Body’, and ‘Once More, With Feeling’ are the ones that get mentioned the most. Though many consider this famous trio to be the apex of the show, there are plenty of other outstanding episodes, and some of them just fall short of being perfect.

Whilst some of these imperfections take the shape of an egregious and outdated special effect, most of them stem from an issue with the script. Sometimes, this involves a redundant character or a blatant plot convenience, but there are also some strange moments that simply feel out of place within the context of the story.

Thankfully, these imperfections don’t ruin the episodes they’re featured in. Yet they’re still frustrating to watch when you consider how good the rest of the story is. With just a few small tweaks, the following episodes could have been perfect.

10. Spiral (Season 5, Episode 20)

Buffy the Vampire Slayer The Knights Of Byzantium
The WB

‘Spiral’ is an action-packed episode that follows our heroes as they flee Sunnydale in a caravan to protect Dawn from Glory. The gang are soon set upon by the Knights of Byzantium (who are also after Dawn), and they are forced to take shelter in an abandoned gas station.

Everything about this episode is terrific apart from the opening scene. Having discovered that Dawn is the Key she so desperately craves, Glory chases after the Slayer and her sister. It doesn’t take long for her to catch up with them, but Buffy and Dawn manage to escape when Glory is taken out by a passing truck. Glory then transforms back into Ben, and we’re immediately into the opening titles.

Aside from being an obvious plot convenience, the tone and the pacing are just awkward. Usually, the opening sequence gets us excited for what is about to happen. But in this scene, it feels like the writers were trying to wrap up the previous episode as quickly as possible.


9. The Prom (Season 3, Episode 20)

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Buffy Angel
Mutant Enemy

‘The Prom’ is a classic Buffy episode with many iconic scenes. The senior students come together to celebrate the end of their high-school years, and they even find time to honour Buffy with the Class Protector Award. But despite the terrific final act, this episode is hindered by the Hellhounds.

Before Buffy gets to the Prom, she has to take out these frightening beasts, while the others enjoy the festivities without her. But really, the story would have been much better if the supernatural element had been removed. All of the best moments in this episode are focused on the characters – whenever the Hellhounds show up, it just feels like an unnecessary deviation.

It's almost as if the writers were afraid to deviate from the monster-of-the-week formula. But if they had, this terrific episode would have been even better. Situated directly before the two-part finale, it was the perfect opportunity to slow down the pace and give us an all-out, character-focused episode.


8. Nightmares (Season 1, Episode 10)

buffy the vampire slayer nightmares clown
20th Century Fox Television

‘Nightmares’ is one of the best episodes from the first season. In this episode, the characters’ worst nightmares start coming true, and the Scooby Gang have to put a stop to this frightening supernatural event.

Buffy and Giles soon realise that a boy named Billy is behind it all. After being beaten up by his baseball coach, Billy fell into a coma, and – with a little help from the Hellmouth – his astral body came out of the coma, and the nightmares came with him.

Billy’s baseball coach also has a nightmarish makeover, taking on the appearance of a large, demonic figure known as the Ugly Man. The thing is, this villain doesn’t really have a purpose beyond giving Buffy something to fight. Most of the other nightmares are grounded in common fears – there's no supernatural element – so the Ugly Man feels completely out of place.

Whilst it’s cool to see the vampire version of Buffy take down the Ugly Man at the end, this isn’t enough to justify the inclusion of a redundant character.


7. Restless (Season 4, Episode 22)

Buffy Cheese Man
Mutant Enemy Productions

The finale of Season 4 is such a fun episode. Rather than featuring an action-packed battle to the death – like the other season finales – the story explores the minds of Willow, Xander, Giles, and Buffy with four fascinating dream sequences.

All the dreams analyse the desires and fears of the main characters in a unique way, and every scene is crammed with meaning. But there’s one thing in this episode that’s totally unnecessary: the man with the cheese slices.

There’s no real substance to this character – he simply symbolises the random thing in every dream that has no meaning. Whilst this does make some sense, the Cheese Man feels like a gimmick compared with the rest of the episode. He’s nothing more than a meaningless distraction from the interesting things going on around him.

Thankfully, his brief appearances only last a couple of seconds, but this episode would have been perfect if he wasn’t in it.


6. Conversations With Dead People (Season 7, Episode 7)

Cassie Buffy
Mutant Enemy

‘Conversations with Dead People’ is a standout episode in the final season. Buffy enjoys a midnight conversation with an ex-classmate who’s become a vampire. Dawn is terrorised by a series of supernatural events. And Willow talks to the ghost of Cassie, a young high-schooler who died earlier on in the season.

The dialogue is top-notch, and the actors don’t put a foot wrong throughout this fascinating episode. Right at the very end, Willow starts to suspect something sinister is happening when Cassie encourages her to take her own life. Cassie (who’s actually the First Evil) also talks about her intentions for the Scooby Gang, claiming that she will devour them.

Then, Cassie gives Willow a weird, CGI-infused grin before she turns inside out and vanishes into thin air. It’s an awkward exit that’s dated horribly thanks to the rudimentary special effects. It would have been much better if the First Evil had just walked away at the end of the scene.


5. Lover’s Walk (Season 3, Episode 8)

Buffy Lovers Walk Spike
Mutant Enemy

Heartbroken by Drusilla’s betrayal, Spike returns to Sunnydale in ‘Lover’s Walk’ and tries to fix his relationship by kidnapping Willow and forcing her to perform a love spell. Xander also gets roped into the proceedings, and Spike imprisons the two of them in the abandoned factory.

Oz and Cordelia – who are in relationships with Willow and Xander respectively – start searching around Sunnydale, and Oz suddenly reveals that he can smell Willow nearby.

This ability is an offshoot of Oz’s werewolf condition, but it’s never established beforehand, so it feels like a massive plot convenience, allowing Oz and Cordelia to find their friends quickly. And strangely enough, Oz’s overpowered nose doesn’t really come up again. (The only exception is when he smells Willow’s scent on Tara’s clothing in Season 4.)

It's a small issue, but it still snaps you out of the episode. If the writers had just mentioned Oz’s ability in an earlier episode, this problem would have been avoided.


4. Passion (Season 2, Episode 17)

Giles Buffy Passion Anthony Stewart Head
Mutant Enemy

‘Passion’ is an important episode in the show’s history because it’s the first episode to feature a tragic death. Determined to stop her from returning his soul, Angelus hunts down Jenny and snaps her neck.

But despite how great the second half of the episode is, Giles and Jenny’s final conversation doesn’t quite land. It’s meant to be a romantic scene in which Jenny reveals her true feelings for Giles, but the moment she declares her love just feels off.

In a scene like this, sometimes less is more. It would have been better if Jenny had teetered on the edge of vocalising her feelings. This would have made the conversation less cheesy and her death more tragic, as Giles would have never known Jenny’s true feelings about him.

It’s still a great episode, but this romantic exchange definitely needed a few more revisions. With a couple of tweaks here and there, Giles and Jenny’s final conversation would have been brilliant.


3. Graduation Day, Part 2 (Season 3, Episode 22)

Mayor Snake - Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

It’s hard not to love the finale of Season 3. The gang’s high-school years come to a close with an epic battle sequence between the students of Sunnydale and the Mayor’s crew of vampires.

But the final battle will always be tarnished by the horrific CGI. There’s just no getting away from the fact that Olvikan looks like something from a PS1 game – the textures and the lighting are both awful. So, far from being an intimidating sight, the Mayor’s transformation is laughably bad.

It’s a shame because the general lack of CGI is one of the reasons why the show has aged so well. Most of the time, the monsters are 100% practical, but on this occasion, someone made the wrong decision.

Thankfully, we don’t have to witness this poor spectacle for very long. After provoking the Mayor into chasing her, Buffy leads him into a room full of explosives, Giles triggers the detonation, and this terrible CGI villain is blown to bits.


2. Angel (Season 1, Episode 7)

Buffy Angel
Mutant Enemy Productions

With the possible exception of ‘Prophecy Girl’, ‘Angel’ is the best episode from Season 1. The story focuses on Angel’s true identity and Darla’s attempts to kill Buffy and her mother.

Unfortunately, the final fight is ruined by one thing: guns. Rather than having a brutal fistfight, Darla arrives on the scene with a pair of pistols and starts shooting away at the Slayer. This continues for about a minute or so, and Buffy is forced to duck and cover as bullets fly across the room.

The problem with this scene is that it feels completely out of place. Guns are a rarity in the Buffyverse, and this is the only moment in the show where a vampire tries to kill their target with firearms, so it’s totally unnatural for Darla to do something like this.

It’s a shame because this is Darla’s final scene (not including flashbacks), and she deserved a much better send-off than the one she got. Whoever came up with the idea to give Darla a set of pistols made a very poor decision.


1. Chosen (Season 7, Episode 22)

Lucifer A Devil of My Word
Fox

The final episode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer is fantastic. Fun fight sequences are balanced with some great character moments, and it’s great to see the relief on Buffy’s face during the closing scene.

But despite how great this finale is, it isn’t quite perfect. For one thing, the ubervamps – who were so frightening at the start of the season – are much weaker during the final fight, which is a clear plot convenience designed to give the Potential Slayers more of a chance.

Yet the biggest disappointment is definitely Anya’s death. For the last four seasons, Anya has been a major part of the Scooby Gang, but – for whatever reason – she gets a rushed death that lacks any emotional punch. Amongst the chaos of the final battle, we briefly see Anya getting stabbed from behind, and that’s it – the next time she appears, she’s just a corpse on the ground.

Whilst ‘Chosen’ is still a great way to end the show, it would have been much better if Anya’s death was given the time it deserved.


Harry Potter Or Buffy The Vampire Slayer Quiz: Who Said It – Ron Weasley Or Xander Harris?

Ron Weasley Smile Harry Potter And The Philosophers Stone
Warner Bros.

1. “I Wasn't Looking At Its Feet. I Was A Bit Preoccupied With Its Heads."

Contributor

Love to read and write. Have an unhealthy obsession with Harry Potter. Enjoy running up hills.