10 Most Controversial Series Finales In TV History
Part of the journey is the end, but it’s not always the most popular part of it.
TV finales tend to have the pressure cranked up, especially for massive shows with a huge following. A certain HBO show recently found that out in the worst way, as the once great series utterly crumbled in its final season, leading to one of TV’s most controversial endings ever.
It’s not just the poorly received send offs which are controversial though. David Benioff and D.B. Weiss famously (and in hindsight, rather foolishly) said they hoped Game Of Thrones’ ending would be like Breaking Bad, where people are debating whether it’s an A or an A+.
While that ‘debate’ isn’t enough controversy to land it a spot here, some critically revered finales generated huge discussion and plenty of disagreement amongst the fan base.
It’s hard to let go of something, especially when it’s been part of your life for so long. It leads to expectations which shows sometimes fail to deliver on. That’s often what drives these controversies: wanting to hold onto the show’s magic as long as possible fuels debates which can rage on for days, weeks and months.
Some these finales were great, others were terrible, but all of them got their fans talking.
10. Game Of Thrones
Game Of Thrones is the most recent example of a controversial finale, with the entire six-episode run of Season 8 a rushed mess that fumbled many character arcs and abandoned the intelligent dialogue the show had previously been known for.
The events of the season weren’t the problem, it was how fast they were thrown at the viewer. The Night King’s death, Daenerys’ descent into madness, and Bran becoming King could all have worked if given room to breathe.
That’s not even mentioning that the finale includes only 17 minutes of dialogue, despite its increased runtime. The whole season was poor, but the finale was the low point.
From around episode 3 onwards, the final season was generating huge amounts of backlash online. A petition was launched to redo the season entirely, though this was mainly a symbolic gesture.
Other fans have claimed the discontent is only down to fans not getting what they wanted. While some are disappointed in how Jon & Daenerys were treated by the final season, the backlash reaches way beyond this.
One good thing to come out of it though is the same fans who launched the petition have turned their attention to fundraising for Emilia Clarke’s charity.
9. How I Met Your Mother
How I Met Your Mother, or, to give it its full title, How I Met Your Mother But Then She Died So I Married Aunt Robin Which Is Why She’s Been The Focus Of The Story For Nine Seasons.
Realistically, with the throwback sort of sitcom HIMYM was, Ted getting with Robin was the natural conclusion; just like Ross and Rachel in Friends. However, HIMYM was restricted from the start by its title and concept.
That was the fatal flaw with HIMYM’s finale. It needed to commit to its gimmick, but Ted & Robin seemed destined for each other.
Fans were pretty much in two camps on this one: they liked it as an episode or hated it as a finale. Most fans are in agreement that on its own it’s pretty funny, but that the ending, which undid Robin & Barney’s marriage, subverted the key theme of Ted getting over Robin, and almost instantly killed off the mother they’d spent nine seasons building up to, didn't work.
Fan forums and message boards were lit up after the finale, with arguments ensuing even as everyone agreed. The question was did it matter that the conclusion wasn’t satisfying as long as it was funny?
8. Gossip Girl
The Gossip Girl finale is a weird one to rank. Some fans point to the fact that Blair ended up with Chuck and deem that enough to shower it with praise.
It’s reasonable for some viewers to want a little more, but then it’s equally reasonable to point out that they’ve been watching Gossip Girl for the past five years; this is a show more concerned with the Teen Choice Awards than they are the Emmy’s. That’s not a criticism either, by the way. Gossip Girl knew exactly what it was and it delivered.
However, it’s still a fairly controversial episode, not only because of the slapdash happy ending (can’t please everyone every time), but also because of Gossip Girl herself. Or rather, himself.
In the moment, it’s a gasp-worthy twist for Dan Humphrey to be Gossip Girl, but when you start to think about it, it falls apart.
Gossip Girl frequently acted against Dan’s interest, even harassing his sister Little Jay out of NYC; something the finale tries and fails to waffle away.
The finale ultimately proved satisfactory to the typical Gossip Girl audience, even if you can poke a lot of holes in it.
7. Mad Men
Most things in television are subjective, but you’ll struggle to find too many people willing to defend the finales of How I Met Your Mother or Game Of Thrones.
Mad Men’s finale though is a very different creature. It boasts a 9.3 on IMDb, and is typically thought of as one of the best episodes the show ever put out (and make no mistake, there were a lot of good ones).
The final season focuses on Don changing, with him heading out to a hippy retreat to gain perspective.
Meanwhile, Peggy’s career finally takes off. In the finale, he calls her to tell her about his quest for inner peace, before a take of him meditating turns into the famous ‘I’d like to buy the world a Coke’ advert.
It’s deliberately unclear whether Peggy spins Don’s enthusiasm into the Coca-Cola advert, or if Don was sucked back into the capitalist world and wasted his personal growth to sell fizzy drinks. Therein lies the genius, though leaving Don’s arc unresolved certainly ruffled feathers.
The show always asked questions, but some viewers were unhappy that the finale left things so open, citing Don’s lack of closure as a big sticking point.
6. The Sopranos
Ahead even of Mad Men, The Sopranos stands tall as one of the best finales ever, alongside the likes of Breaking Bad, Six Feet Under and M*A*S*H.
Despite being critically revered and generally praised by the fans though, that hasn’t stopped it being one of the most controversial and debated finales in television. It’s the good kind of controversial, where everyone loved it for different reasons, but the ambiguous nature of the ending certainly got people talking.
The majority of the episode focuses on what you might expect The Sopranos finale to have focussed on; wrapping up the loose ends of the mob storylines. These had been winding down running into the finale, and it was a smart decision to do the basics right.
It certainly gets ambiguous after that, and just like Mad Men, anything open to interpretation will cause division in the fanbase.
Several (hundred) fans took to YouTube and blogs to give definitive explanations of the ending, often contradicting each other. To make matters worse, showrunner David Chase has tried to explain it himself; he too though has contradicted his own explanation multiple times.
Seriously though, whose idea was it to end on a-
5. Pretty Little Liars
Pretty Little Liars: like Gossip Girl, only worse.
That’s a fairly accurate summary of Pretty Little Liars overall, but it counts double for the finale. While Dan being Gossip Girl was clearly stitched on at the last minute with no planning, it at least made some sense.
You can poke holes in it, sure, but it’s not like they said Gossip Girl was Blair’s evil British twin...
Pretty Little Liars though did exactly that. After having pretty much every non-Liar feature as A at some point (before turning out to just be a minion of the big bad), they were struggling to find anyone to be the overarching villain.
Fan theories were abound that it was one of the main cast themselves (Aria Montgomery was the leading candidate) who was the ultimate villain. The theories weren’t prefect, but they at least didn’t need to invent a new character at the last second to work out.
The show had already jumped the shark by this point, but to go so telenovela at the end was just ridiculous. While Gossip Girl fans at least got a satisfying (if threadbare) popcorn finale, Pretty Little Liars fans were left in the lurch, with huge negativity spilling over online.
4. Lost
It seemed like Lost was only going on and on as the writers struggled to come up with a way to wrap it all up. In the end, they only made it more convoluted and complicated, switching the focus, storylines, and central themes several times.
Lost really felt like three different TV shows stitched together; each of them would’ve been decent on their own, but together they make it hard to sum up exactly what Lost even was.
It never seemed to fully understand itself, so clearly the audience was never going to either. Not terrible by any stretch, Lost was simply too ambitious. By constantly expanding outwards, ending it with any degree of satisfaction became nigh on impossible.
The show was confusing at the best of times, but fans were willing to roll with it in the hopes it would all wrap up cleanly. When it demonstrably didn’t, they weren’t shy about airing their grievances online.
The finale had some controversy before it even aired, with Mr. Eko (Adwele Akinnuoye-Agbaje) refusing to return at all. Once it had aired though, all that was forgotten as several major newspapers ran columns defending, attacking, and mostly explaining whatever was going on with the ending.
3. Dexter
Had Dexter been just a bit more popular, the finale would have undoubtedly have generated just as many headlines as Game Of Thrones’ The Iron Throne. While it’s not as well known in pop culture, the weird events of the finale are still a very sore spot for fans all these years later.
Killing Dexter off would’ve been a satisfying and fitting end to his arc, but the show went another way.
The final season tries to offer him some redemption, and that too would’ve been a safe ending. A little cheap, perhaps, and not exactly fitting with Dexter’s amoral tone, but nothing to write home about.
Instead, Dexter rejects his chance at happiness, as well as an end of any value whatsoever. Instead, he sails away to become a lumberjack. An anticlimax to say the least.
Clyde Phillips, who was showrunner for the first 4 seasons of Dexter (typically considered the better seasons), admitted his distaste for the final season overall in a Reddit AMA for his then-new show, Nurse Jackie. He did, however, steer away from criticising the finale itself, which was more charitable than most of the fans felt it deserved.
2. Girls
Girls never strayed too far from controversy at the best of times, with Lena Dunham polarising opinion everywhere she goes. However, even amongst her staunchest defenders, Girls’ series finale split the fanbase.
The main story throughout Girls was the lives of four young New Yorkers and their circle of weirdos. It was deeply pretentious in places, strangely nonsensical in others and incredibly self righteous throughout. In order words, it was the perfect epitome of modern day New York.
The last episode ditches the tone, New York and two of the four major cast members to focus on Hannah’s new life with the baby. As a lead in to the next season it might have worked, but as the ultimate end, it’s way off kilter.
Dunham claims the episode is more of an epilogue, with penultimate episode Goodbye Tour a more traditional finale. It’s fitting for both Girls and Dunham to be so grandiose, but it still falls flat.
Girls often had to fight off criticism from outsiders, but the fans thenstended to stick together.
This fell apart though after the finale, with many popping up online to criticise Dunham’s self-indulgence, while others praised the imperfect ending as fitting for the thoroughly unlikeable cast.
1. Seinfeld
Seinfeld was massively ahead of its time. The debate in the ‘90s raged on between Friends and Seinfeld, but apart from their New York setting they weren’t all that similar.
The characters were deeply unlikeable, in a way mainstream TV characters would not be for another decade. As George Constanza famously said, it’s a show ‘about nothing’, and in lots of ways Seinfeld opened the door for shows which came after it.
Like a few other episodes here, The Finale is not bad by any stretch. However, the decision to spend the second half of the episode focussed entirely on minor characters like the Soup Nazi was a poor one in hindsight, and having the central cast end the series in jail was asking a little too much of audiences in 1998.
Like the show itself, the ending has gotten better with time. Though many felt it was deflating at the time, fans views on it tend to have softened over the years. US Today famously gave it a measly one and a half stars, while 20 years later many view it with fondness. TV shows were supposed to have happy endings, especially sitcoms. Seinfeld bucked that trend, and it had everyone talking.