10 Most Messed Up Deaths In Star Trek: Enterprise

A bright, optimistic view of the future? Here's Star Trek: Enterprise with a body count and a grin

Star Trek Enterprise Sim and Archer
CBS Media Ventures

In what has become something of a grim tradition, TrekCulture has listed the most messed up deaths from The Original Series, The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine, and Voyager. Star Trek: Enterprise has at times been accused of being a copy of those older shows. This list certainly holds its own when it comes to unpleasant and weird ways to die.

For a show that lacked much of the technological advancements of its predecessors (ironically), it sure did find inventive ways to bump off its crew. It also teased the audience, only killing its first crewmember in the third season - but wow did it make up for lost time. Jonathan Archer has the dubious honour of, statistically, having the most deaths under his command out of all of the main captains. 

Congratulations?

Though this list has only ten entries, the grim truth about Enterprise is that it could probably fill a few lists - with eighteen entries for the Battle Of Azati Prime alone. 

Get your Will in order, strap in, and let's count the dead. 

10. First Past The Struts - Anomaly

Star Trek Enterprise Anomaly Fuller Death
CBS Media Ventures

Sometimes, it really is ok not to be first in the class. At least, Fuller must have been thinking that in the infinitesimal moments before he hit the deck in Anomaly. Credited as Enterprise's first fatality, Fuller had the dubious honour of being forever remembered as the first person in something. We assume, however, this is hardly the honour it sounds like. 

When Enterprise was boarded by Osaarian pirates in Anomaly, Fuller was killed after being shot at point-blank range in Engineering. He was most likely dead before he hit the hull plating, which is the one mercy in this sad tale. Reed, in dialogue that was omitted from the episode, would go on to lay the melodrama on thick.

Fuller, apparently, had been hand-picked by Reed to serve on the ship. He had gone through the same training programs as him, he had learned more about photon torpedo technology than anyone else, and he had a young daughter as well. This daughter sent a letter to Reed, asking the latter to keep her daddy out of danger. 

We'll assume he didn't read it in time.

Poor Fuller. File this unfortunately soul as yet another crewman just trying to do their job in a galaxy that seems hell-bent on wiping out all humans. 


9. Killed To Shock The Audience - These Are The Voyages

Star Trek Enterprise These Are The Voyages Trip Tucker Death
CBS Media Ventures

We now move to a death that was so pointless and ill-conceived that even the writers agreed it was a bad call. Trip was killed to shock the audience. As this was the final episode of Star Trek: Enterprise (with no foreseeable continuations) everyone was fair game, with poor Charles Tucker III getting the short straw. 

While some pirates boarded the ship, he distracted them by blowing up a power conduit, resulting in his own death. Sure, he went out in a heroic fashion, but at what cost? Star Trek has a habit of fumbling the ball when it comes to shock deaths (see: #PrayersForJadzia, #YeetTasha) - this, alas, was no improvement on that sad trend. What's more, with the show's ending, there was no chance to properly revisit the character ala Yesterday's Enterprise or Ezri Dax's arc.

While Trip survived in Beta canon, for Alpha canon he is unfortunately brown bread. It was a silly move in the episode, it remains a silly move now. In a phrase this writer genuinely never expected to type - thank the Prophets for the Very Short Treks!


8. Mountain Climbing Accident In The Space Age - First Flight

Star Trek Enterprise First Flight A.G. Robinson
CBS Media Ventures

In the 22nd Century, mountaineering is still a dangerous sport. By the 23rd Century, anti-gravity boots had become standard issue, allowing Spock to hover beside Captain Kirk at El Capitan, yet there was no such gear available to poor A.G. Robinson in the episode First Flight.

He was posthumously introduced as a Starfleet rival of Captain Archer's, vying with the latter for command of the Warp 5 ship. However, when Archer won Enterprise, he remained on Earth, little knowing this was spelling his doom.

Robinson was killed in a mountaineering accident. This, sad to say, feels like an unlucky fate in a time where warp flight is now commonplace. Perhaps the man's own hubris played a part - were there no safety nets to be found? Perhaps there were but, like a certain captain almost one hundred years after him, he may have elected not to bother with them. 

Though it was only Enterprise's second season at the time, this felt like an odd way to kill a man who, it was revealed, was such an important 'almost ran' in Starfleet history. We will remember you, Robinson - if not for your climbing prowess, then certainly for your inspiring actions toward Jonathan Archer.


7. Death By Decompression (Right Outside Her Front Door) - Azati Prime

Star Trek Enterprise The Forgotten Jane Taylor
CBS Media Ventures
Just remember me. Is that asking so much?

Taylor was one of Trip's team who was killed by the Xindi as a result of the battle of Azati Prime. The section she was in decompressed, blasting the unfortunate occupants out into space. She died within inches of her quarters, expelled into a vacuum, but that wasn't the end. 

Trip, wracked with guilt over her passing, was visited in his dreams by her apparition. This trauma refused to lift as, in her, he saw not just the wasted potential of a dead officer, but the faces of everyone else who had perished under his command. Taylor became the avatar for how commanding officers dealt with or failed to deal with, the loss of people under them.

Trip's dream is stark, depicted in hues of cold blue. Though the man understands he is asleep, Taylor refuses to let up. She doesn't blame him in any way but she does chastise him for forgetting details about her. He headhunted her, he used to say she would make a fine engineer - all of these are true, yet they were all far from his mind when she confronted him. 

Taylor may not have had the biggest role on Enterprise, but in her small scene, she managed to offer the audience a face to the nameless officers who perished during the mission. The manner of her death was cruel, yet the impact of her death was nothing short of crucial.


6. Assimilation Before It Was Cool - Regeneration

Star Trek Enterprise Regeneration Borg
CBS Media Ventures

How messed up must it be to be assimilated - before the Borg had even been invented? That's just damned unlucky if you ask us! 

While assimilation isn't exactly death (see: Locutus, Seven Of Nine, Hugh) it is often a hopeless existence. To be connected to the hive mind, all traces of individuality are erased, though one remains aware of what is happening around them. Could assimilation be the death of the soul? 

When the Borg were reawakened in the Arctic Circle (time travel, just go with it) they quickly overpowered and assimilated the research team. This led to them taking a ship, assimilating Tarkalian traders, and very nearly assimilating Dr. Phlox. Enterprise is tasked with hunting the Borg down - something it was badly underprepared for in the 22nd Century.

Though the drones are destroyed, there is little more horrific than existing as a Drone, depending on which version of the Collective we're speaking about. By the early 25th Century, it seems to be a blissful place that's just...just great. But in the 22nd Century, it was stark, it was horrible, it was the death of freedom. 

Regeneration, and we've said it before, truly made the Borg - and what they do - terrifying again. 


5. Massive Cellular Disruption - Burrows

Star Trek Enterprise Deadalus Burrows Death
CBS Media Ventures

When one is killed in the line of duty, there's rarely a good way to go. Sure, there are those methods that might scream honour or glory, but when you get right down to the nitty-gritty of it, the poor soul is still dead at the end of the day. One could maybe hope that their death contributes to a greater good. You have to wonder if Burrows even had time to hope for that.

When Emory Erickson came aboard Enterprise in Deadalus, he was heralded as a genius. He was the human inventor of the transporter, a visionary and someone who had a direct impact on space travel. He was also harbouring a secret, one that sadly saw the end of this young officer.

Burrows was killed by a manifestation of Quinn Erickson's transporter signal. Erickson, son of the inventor, had been lost in a sub-atomic transport, though his pattern continued to exist in the form of physical disturbances in space. His father concocted a ruse to bring the ship out to the Barrens, the area of space in which the accident occurred. 

Rather than saving his son, Emory was indirectly responsible for the horrific death of Burrows. His cells, melted as they were, resulted in a grusome tableau for Reed to discover. It was a sad addition to the tragedy of Erickson's legacy. 


4. Daniels Gets Melted - Storm Front, pt 1

Star Trek Enterprise Storm Front Melted Daniels
CBS Media Ventures

Agent Daniels, or crewman if you prefer, had a varied career. Long before he was shaking hands with Captain Burnham in the 32nd Century, he was rubbing elbows with Captain Archer in the 22nd. He also popped back to the 20th, although that trip warped his body, melted his face, and killed him. 

Whoops.

Daniels' body was torn into different time periods as a direct result of the Temporal Cold War. Temporal agents had been sent back with orders to disrupt the flow of time, spurred on by the Na'kuhl and their attack (with a little help from the Nazis). He burst into sickbay on Enterprise, stunning Dr. Phlox, who was unable to save him.

It was a quick, awful death. It was painful, it was degrading, and it was a sad end to Daniels' legacy. Thankfully, with a bit of temporal jiggery-pokery, Daniels 2.0 was back and laughing by the of Storm Front Pt. 2, confidently telling Archer that, thanks to Enterprise's help, the Temporal Cold War was coming to an end. 

All's well that ends with a smiling Kovich. 


3. Death By Faith - Terra Prime

Star Trek Enterprise Terra Prime Masaro Death
CBS Media Ventures

Masaro was a member of the extremist group Terra Prime. Though his actions led to a lot of tragedy, he was in many ways just a poor, disillusioned kid, swept up in all the wrong things. He provided the genetic material to Paxton that led to the creation of Elizabeth and also sabotaged a Shuttlepod, almost resulting in a crash. 

Masaro had been a member of the crew for some time, having been injured at the Battle of Azati Prime, though he survived. Whether his survival was a benefit to history is for others to judge. He may have been a capable crewman, but he was a spy at the same time. 

Masaro takes his own life when he is discovered. Though it would be easy to judge this as an easy escape, it is in fact a desperate act by a cornered man, consumed with shame, and unable to see any other option. That it happens directly in front of Archer's eyes can be nothing but traumatizing for the captain. When added to the sad outcome of Terra Prime's actions, this is simply another wasted life, thrown away for believing the worst in the galaxy.


2. Killed To Harvest Their Organs - Similitude

Star Trek Enterprise Similitude Sim Death
CBS Media Ventures

Similitude works so well because we the audience truly care about Trip Tucker. One might then question why we should feel so strongly about the manner of another character's exit - but that, of course, is the brilliance of Conner Trinneer's performance as the character in question. 

Sim is a clone of the Floridian engineer, created for a single purpose: they're going to Never Let Me Go him, saving their engineer, but killing the clone in the process. It's a stark reality of the third season of Star Trek: Enterprise. No one is expendable - provided they have a critical role to play. Sim certainly had a critical role - it was just a finite one.

Hearing the man plead for his life evokes memories of Tuvix, which may in fact have been the writers' intentions, but his acceptance is just as crushing. There is no hope for Sim - he is doomed, if not by Phlox's hand, then by Phlox's design. Without a treatment to stop the rapid ageing, he will age and die in a manner of weeks - resulting in both his, and Trip's, deaths. 

With this and Velton Ray Bunch's haunting score, Similitude is a difficult watch. We understand why this has to happen, but it feels so brutal to sit through. Sim may want to live, but the cost outweighs the will. 


1. Killed by Dialogue - The Forge

Star Trek Enterprise The Forge Admiral Forrest Death
CBS Media Ventures

We come to another shock death (take a shot) and here we discuss the fate of poor Admiral Maxwell Forrest, the only main character from Enterprise to have the ignominy of an off-screen death. Yes technically we see the explosion that kills him, but it is only in dialogue that we learn he's gone to meet his maker.

Vaughan Armstrong has died several times in Star Trek's screen history, yet here was the first time that a long-serving character went out. Forrest had easily shown himself to be a dependable, capable officer. He was loyal to Archer, though had no issue in calling him out. He defended the Warp 5 program, even against Starfleet itself. Without his support, it would have died in its infancy, almost certainly dooming the human race from the Xindi.

To discover that he had been killed after the fact felt like a let-down. Though he truly went out as a hero, protecting Soval from the blast, dying to save the representative of the very people who had stonewalled Starfleet for so long, it was a damp squib of an ending. Forrest deserved better. 


Watch Next


In this post: 
Star Trek
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"