10 Reasons Why Data Was A Dangerous Threat To The Enterprise

He has unmatched strength, an unbeatable intellect, and an evil twin. What could go wrong?

Data Star Trek
Paramount

Data is one of the most invaluable members of the USS Enterprise 1701-D. That is an indisputable fact. Without this amazing android, any number of calamities would have befallen the crew of the Enterprise.

Not only that, but a lot of civilian populations would also have died horrible deaths at the hands of frightening aliens or bizarre space anomalies. Data’s a peach. There’s no getting around it, and we all love him for it.

But, he’s also incredibly dangerous. Like, dangerous enough that it really doesn’t make sense to have him aboard a Federation starship. And it’s insane for Starfleet to have granted Data the position of the second officer. Even more absurd to place him aboard one of their most important ships. Data, himself, proves this point time and time again throughout the series.

There are countless examples of Data going rogue. He’s taken over the ship, he’s lied to his commanding officers, and he’s been subject to manipulation.

It’s a terrible truth, but Data shouldn’t have ever been allowed to set foot on the Enterprise. He’s too much of a risk...

10. He Can Beat The Hell Out Of Worf

Star Trek Worf Gun
CBS

Ok, so there are plenty of Youtube montages out there of Worf getting his ass kick over and over. They’re pretty funny actually. The poor guy got tossed around like a rag doll by just about everyone aboard the ship at some point.

But, normally, Worf’s opponents were overpowering aliens. Or, sometimes fellow crew members possessed by overpowering aliens. The one guy aboard the ship who could consistently rough Worf up was Data, though.

In fact, Data could probably take down any warrior in the Klingon Empire. We’ve seen him wreck powerful foes numerous times on the show.

Getting in a fight with Data really isn’t a fight, it’s just humiliation. Data doesn’t bother to engage in any fighting style. And you know he’s programmed for, like, jiu-jitsu or something.

Most of the time it’s far more efficient for Data to grab you by the shoulder and toss you across the bridge like a sack of potatoes. Why is this important, though?

Well, Worf is the Chief of Security aboard the Enterprise. He’s the first line of defense against any threat on the ship. And, he’s a Klingon which makes him physically imposing. But, if Worf or any of his mustard-shirt wearing toadies try to take on Data.

We all know how that fight will go.


9. He Has The Mind Of A Child

Data Star Trek Nemesis
Paramount Pictures

So, we’ve established that Data is, without a doubt, the strongest member of the Enterprise crew. Beyond that, he’s also probably the smartest. That’s if we’re speaking in terms of how much, well, data Data can hold.

By the way, don’t bother googling, “how much data could Data hold.” It will get you nowhere. But, according to most sources, Data’s maximum storage capacity was eight hundred quadrillion bits. That’s about 100,000 terabytes or 100 petabytes.

Now, that’s just storage capacity. Data’s computational speed is described as “near-instantaneous.” So, when Picard asks him, “Data how long will it take to get to Vegra III at warp 8.9?” He’ll know the answer before the captain has even finished asking his question.

With all that said, Data’s intellect was lacking in one important, hard to define, aspect. Call it wisdom, call it life-experience. Whatever you want to call it, Data didn’t have it. That’s why friends were constantly explaining to Data the nuances of human behavior.

Take, for instance, a simple argument between a couple. In the Episode, “Data’s Day,” Keiko and Miles O’Brien are getting married. The day before their nuptials, Keiko calls off the wedding and she and Miles get into a huge argument.

Data assumes that the couple is done for good. Geordi has to explain the concept of wedding-day jitters, and that the couple was not doomed.

Data takes things at face value. If you tell him something is true he’ll believe you unless he knows for a fact that thing isn’t true. There’s a term for this, and it’s called naivety. So, while Data was definitely the smartest crew member aboard the ship he was also the most gullible.

Not an ideal trait for a Starfleet officer.

By the way, did you know that gullible doesn’t actually appear in the dictionary? Weird right?


8. His Creator Was Unhinged

Noonian Soong
Paramount

By the time Doctor Noonian Soong showed up in an episode of TNG he looked like a rotted, old jack-o-lantern. Seriously, can we take a minute and question what was up with the make-up department when it comes to Soong?

They only needed to make Brent Spiner look a few decades older. Instead, they made him look like a potato with a droopy face, bald head, and ghost-white mullet. It’s disturbing.

Back to Soong as a character, though. He’s a genius, for one, the first person to build an android as advanced as Data. His techniques were so groundbreaking that Data, and others like him, are called Soong-type androids.

While Soong was a respected scientist, and definitely a genius, some of his decisions were questionable. Chief among these was his failure to destroy Lore, one of his early creations.

Lore was an android with much of the capabilities of Data, but one slight difference. Because Lore was kind of a homicidal maniac.

Lore once lured the Crystalline Entity to the colony where he and Soong lived. The Entity arrived it destroyed the colony, killing almost all its inhabitants. This wasn’t a mistake. Lore knew what would happen. It was his goal, in fact.

But, when Soong fled with other colonists, he disassembled and left Lore, trusting the dangerous android would never be reactivated. Lore was activated and went on doing his homicidal thing.

Also, Soong’s wife, Juliana was killed in the Crystalline attack. Instead of mourning her, Soong built a perfect android replica of Juliana. He also never told Juliana she was an android. Then, he neglected her for his work leading to the couple’s divorce.

Juliana later remarried, never realizing she was a robot. So, the wife he literally brought back from the dead, left him for another man.


7. He Once Raged-Out On a Borg Drone And Beat Him To Death

Descent Star Trek The Next Generation
CBS Media Ventures

This happened in an episode called “Descent,” and it’s not the only troubling action Data took during the episode. Descent starts like so many other TNG installments- with a distress call.

The Enterprise arrives in orbit of a planet and to find a hostile and unknown vessel. Riker takes Data and others on an away mission to the other ship. Once there, the away team is swarmed by, oddly emotional, Borg drones.

Data engages in hand-to-hand combat with one of these drones. During the fight, he experiences anger for the first time. Then he snaps the drone’s neck.

Needless to say, this is a cause for worry among the crew. Riker confronts Data about the incident, but Data is like, “Yeah, I’m confused too. idk, man,” to paraphrase.

Turns out, Data’s brother Lore discovered a way to beam emotions into Data’s brain. At this point, Lore brainwashes Data. The two Soong-type androids are set to go on a murderous rampage.

Lore even goads Data into almost lobotomizing his best friend, Geordi. Data almost does it, but the crew reboots his “moral subroutines” just in time.

Take a second to consider the ramifications of a crew member who can have his morality switched off like a light bulb.

Actually, you don’t need to think about it. Just watch Descent. He starts carving into his buddy’s frontal lobes almost immediately!


6. He Once Lied To The Entire Crew Of The Enterprise

Data The Schizoid Man
CBS

This happens in an episode called “Clues.” On the way to investigate an M Class planet, the Enterprise encounters a wormhole. Everyone, but Data, is knocked out. When the crew wakes up Data tells them they’ve only been unconscious for a few minutes.

The problem is that a bunch of clues around the ship tell a different story. After some investigation, the crew discovers they’ve lost an entire day’s worth of time. If that wasn’t disturbing enough, Picard begins to suspect Data of lying to the crew.

This is strange since Data is almost incapable of lying. Straying from the truth is a violation of Data’s “moral subroutines.” Now, as it turns out, Data is only lying because Picard ordered him to then Picard’s memory was wiped.

This does reveal Data’s capacity for guile and subterfuge. These talents were previously unknown by the crew. Fortunately, he’s not very good at either.


5. He's Constantly Making Notes On The Entire Crew

Data Star Trek Riker
CBS

In an episode called “Data’s Day,” we get a rare glimpse into Data’s inner thoughts. In fact, the entire episode is narrated by Data’s inner monologue. So, what do we learn?

That Data is secretly resentful of and disgusted by, his meat-bound counterparts. Just kidding, Data harbors no ill-will towards the crew. He’s maybe too interested in them, though.

During the episode, we hear Data make observations about his colleagues. For example, Data makes the following note about Commander Riker:

“The tone of Commander Riker’s voice makes me suspect that he is not serious about finding Ambassador T’Pel charming. My experience suggests that in fact; he may mean the exact opposite of what he says.”

Sure, this is a harmless observation. But, Data has an infallible memory. This is little note, along with countless others, will be filed away somewhere in those hundred petabytes of Data’s memory.

Consider how you would feel if you found a file on your coworker’s desktop. And, in that file, were thousands of inane tidbits about you, and everyone in the office. Things like how you’re kind of a sarcastic prick who talks behind peoples’ back.

That’d be more than a little creepy.


4. He Created Another Android Without Telling Anyone

Star Trek TNG Lal The Offspring
CBS Media Ventures

Fans of TNG know that Data had a daughter long before the two daughters from Star Trek: Picard. Her name was Lal, and like Data, she was a Soong-type android. Data assembled Lal in secret, not revealing her existence until she was fully conscious.

Captain Picard, and Starfleet Command, were pretty unhappy about this. And they were right to be. We know from Lore that Soong-type androids have a 50/50 chance of being complete psychopaths. Luckily, Lal took after her father, but it was a real risk creating her.

Picard even states that had Data told him of the project he would have ordered it stopped. Perhaps that’s why Data kept the information to himself? We’ll never know.


3. He Doesn't Really Have Control Over Himself

Star Trek The Next Generation Data Sneeze
CBS

Going back to Noonian Soong for a moment, he built Data as a sort of mystery box. There are tons of hidden subroutines that popup throughout the show. Even Data is unaware of them until they are activated.

A benign example of this is Data’s ability to dream. Data can’t dream. That is, he doesn’t until the episode “Birthright.” When Data suddenly has a dream about his father, Noonian.

It turns out that Data’s dream subroutine laid dormant for years. It wasn’t meant to be activated until Data reached a certain level of sophistication.

Not all these “hidden” subroutines are as harmless as Data’s ability to dream, though. Some of them put the Enterprise, and her crew, in considerable danger.


2. There Was That Time That Data Commandeered The Ship And No One Could Stop Him

Data Picard
CBS

In the episode “Brothers,” the Enterprise is on the way to a starbase. A young boy aboard the ship is in desperate need of an emergency medical procedure that isn’t possible aboard the ship.

That’s when Data intervenes. Out of nowhere, he sets a new course for the ship and cuts off life support to the bridge. The bridge crew escapes to Engineering while Data stays behind. Lucky for him he doesn’t need pesky things like air to breathe.

Data then locks the crew out of the computer so they can’t change course. The Enterprise arrives at a planet inhabited by Noonian Soong. From there Data beams down, leaving the crew with the computer locked out. His encryption is so complex no one can break it.

Turns out, Data didn’t do any of this willingly. Apparently, Soong had activated a homing beacon that called Data to the planet. The beacon did the same for Data’s brother Lore.

The reason Soong wanted Data was so he could install an emotion chip in Data’s brain. Lore, who happens to look exactly like Data tricks Soong into giving him the emotion chip instead.

For good measure Lore murders Dr. Soong.

After that the crew of the Enterprise welcomes Data back aboard as if nothing happened. Like he didn’t just pirate the ship and almost kill a young boy. As for Data’s excuse, he said he didn’t remember doing any of it.

That’s awfully convenient, Data.

This gets us to the final, and most serious, security risk when it comes to having Data on board the Enterprise.


1. Lore Exists

Star Trek The Next Generation Lore
CBS

If there’s one point we’ve really hammered today, it’s that Lore is irrevocably evil. The in-universe explanation for this is that Lore’s ethical subroutines are malfunctioning. Whatever the reason for it, Lore just likes to be a prick.

He also looks like Data. He sounds like Data. He possesses both Data’s unmatched strength and impressive computational speed. He’s been known to impersonate Data. And, even Data’s and Lore’s creator couldn’t tell the two androids apart.

Lore represents a clear and present danger to the entire crew of the Enterprise. That is an undeniable truth that is crazy to ignore.

The fact that Lore never sneaked aboard, deactivated Data, stole his uniform, commandeered the ship, and flew it straight into Borg space is pure, dumb luck really.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

John is a teacher and writer living in Texas. He spends far too much time watching Star Trek. Check out more if his work at artofnarrative.com