10 Most Unjust Cancellations In TV History

dollhouse Where would we be today without television? Yes, the human race seemed to do just fine without it years ago but they also did fine without any form of technology which - sadly - most people today would never be able to accomplish. Television has been a permanent fixture in the lives of many for so long and what we've seen onscreen has evolved tremendously each decade. Some television shows have become so popular they've branched out into multimedia franchises while others have stayed under the radar. But not every single series that flops is deserving of being forgotten. In fact, there have been a great number of television shows that were among the best yet couldn't seem to find an audience leading to their ultimate downfall. I previously wrote an article about ten current shows that are in heavy need of cancellation. Many of you agreed on some but still had wildly differing opinions on other entries. Here, I present to you ten television shows that fall on the opposite end of the spectrum. These shows never even had a chance to jump the shark as each was canceled far before it even had a chance to tie up loose ends some during or right after their first season. This doesn't mean they were bad; not at all. Instead these are the ten best shows to ever face a cancellation that can only be described as unjust. Click next to begin...

10. Firefly

Rsz 1rsz Firefly1 Beginning the list with one of the biggest disappointments is Firefly which was canceled before it could even finish airing its first season! Nathan Fillion led this space western which took place in a new star system in the year 2517. Firefly was far more than just a sci-fi show, however. The series was a drama that blended themes of multiculturalism, political turmoil, expansion, and the savagery of the human race. Firefly was - in the simplest of terms - damn good. No surprise there as it was created by none other than television God Joss Whedon. So why was the show given the axe in the first place? It was all because of poor ratings; isn't it always? Then president of the Fox network Gail Berman stated that though she loved the series it was quite expensive to produce and, unfortunately, the expenses outweighed the ratings at the time. Despite the low ratings the series managed to maintain an incredibly strong fanbase. A fanbase that was - of course - outraged upon cancellation after the eleventh episode. We had a reason to rejoice, however, as Whedon continued the story in his hit film Serenity which tied up loose ends and gave some much needed closure. The likelihood of Firefly returning to television is quite low. Having already been wrapped up on the big screen and with its biggest actor currently starring in another well-loved series there really is no way it could happen. We're content with this; however, it doesn't justify that the cancellation was incredibly unfair to the numerous fans or to those who helped make the show so great.

9. Veronica Mars

Veronicamars Kristen Bell headlining a neo-noir murder mystery? Yes, please! To some Veronica Mars sounded like just another teen drama but to anyone who managed to actually tune in it was one of the best shows on the air. It followed title character Veronica Mars as she loses her best friend to murder and subsequently her popular student status as her father - the sheriff - is revoked of his status after making wild accusations. He then opens a private detective agency and Veronica joins him as an apprentice. The first season follows her investigations into the murder of her best friend and when that case is cracked she continues to become involved in intriguing tales of mystery. Unfortunately, the series was put on a hiatus during its third season and then abandoned altogether. While it managed to last longer than some other entries on this list three seasons surely wasn't satisfactory. So why the sudden decision to pull Veronica Mars from its time slot? Well, all signs once again point to ratings. Each season only managed to bring in around 2.5 million viewers a night leaving it at the bottom in the ratings pool. The show didn't receive the recognition it deserved and many argued that the Emmy's unfairly overlooked Kristen Bell's outstanding performances. Though the big mystery of the first season was solved the abrupt cancellation still left many fans dissatisfied. Rumours of a Veronica Mars film circulated since the cancellation but no fruit was ever borne. Fortunately, a Kickstarter for the project was both created and completely funded earlier this year meaning fans will get some closure come 2014.

8. Freaks And Geeks

Freaks and Geeks James Franco, Seth Rogen, Jason Segel, and more in an all-star ensemble cast about a group of misfits in the eighties, Freaks and Geeks was pure comedy gold. Unfortunately, it never found its audience during its short time on the air. The series followed Linda Cardellini as Lindsey Weir - a brainiac who becomes involved with a group of "cool" kids - and her younger brother and his two nerdy best friends. Lindsey struggles to be accepted amongst her peers while younger brother Sam and his friends have trouble being accepted at all. Being a comedy, Freaks and Geeks certainly delivered the laughs but was written far better than your typical sitcom charades. Each character had a distinctive personalty and feel, their own persona and emotion that they brought onscreen. The troubles they found themselves facing weren't just whacky shenanigans thought up by hired help, but real struggles that teenagers have dealt with in every decade. Everything about the show felt entirely organic and this was reflected by both writing and acting. In fact, the series was nominated for two Emmy's during its run for outstanding writing for a comedy series and snagged a win for outstanding casting. This wasn't enough to keep the series alive, unfortunately, and after only eighteen episodes the show was given the boot. While the series was never entirely wrapped up many associated people did go on to prove their talents elsewhere. The aforementioned actors and actress as well as occasional writer and director Judd Apatow have all found their niche and carry on the legacy of what was once one of the best shows to focus on what it meant to be a teenager trying to find their place.

7. Twin Peaks

Twin Peaks Like Special Agent Dale Cooper's coffee, Twin Peaks was damn good! Many obviously agreed as during its first season Twin Peaks was one of the most watched television shows on the air, and one of the most critically-acclaimed as well. It seemed as if everyone was asking the same question: who killed Laura Palmer? As the series went on and more of the eccentric townsfolk's secrets were revealed viewers found themselves with even more questions surrounding this mysterious dead girl. Being the creation of David Lynch, Twin Peaks was nothing short of strange yet wonderful. It took home two Golden Globes and secured eighteen Emmy nominations taking home two for costume design and editing. With an original concept taking flight due to incredible direction, ensemble acting, and superb writing while being well-reviewed by just about anyone watching what possibly could have gone wrong? This one can be chalked up to executive meddling. As the second season began production ABC couldn't help but meddle. They pushed Lynch and crew into prematurely revealing Laura Palmer's killer's identity subsequently throwing off the anticipatory build-up. Many storylines were changed including Cooper's budding romance with the sexy, mischievous schoolgirl turned sleuth Audrey Horne. Due to this many fans were noticeably unhappy as ratings dropped considerably during the mid-season. ABC thereafter put the show on hiatus but Twin Peaks retained a strong enough fanbase to persuade them to finish the season. Unfortunately, it ended on a cliffhanger that was never entirely resolved. Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me - a prequel to the series - was released which tied up some loose ends regarding Laura Palmer's dealings with the evil in the town of Twin Peaks. The cliffhanger ending, however, wasn't quite resolved and never really will be. David Lynch has stated that Fire Walk With Me would be the last Twin Peaks project leaving the series dormant. It still remains its cult status after all these years and still remains one of the greatest productions to ever hit television sets.

6. Carnivale

Carnivale1 If Twin Peaks proved anything it's that weird can be amazingly awesome, and Carnivale only further helped cement that notion. A five time Emmy winner alongside ten other nominations as well as a record-setting premiere back in 2003 prove that Carnivale was one of the best original series' to be featured on HBO. It centered on a young man with newly awakened healing abilities and his joining a traveling carnival with each episode taking place in a new setting. The show put focus on the acts and their likeness to previous depictions of "circus freaks" such as in the 1932 film Freaks. However, there was a much deeper theme of good vs evil culminating just below the surface. Carnivale was originally meant to be a six-year run, but HBO pulled the plug after the second season stating that the costs were greater than the rewards as ratings dropped drastically. While the original good vs evil plot was brought to fruition many cliffhangers occurred as major character fates were left in the air. Plans to further the series on other networks or tie up loose ends in a film were left untouched and only in 2007 was a pitch document revealed detailing the intended fates of characters and story alike. With an incredible cast of characters and interwoven plots set upon a wall of superb cinematography and art design Carnivale was a better version of American Horror Story years before AHS had even been a passing thought. It's a shame the series was never continued, and even more so that the reason for this being HBO's reluctance to allow another network to possess the series despite refusing to continue it themselves.

5. My So-Called Life

my so called life It's quite sad that today's world offers teenagers so little in the world of television. While shows like Degrassi and Gossip Girl exist they are but weak examples of what it truly means to be a young adult in the world. They offer only cheesy melodrama, unbelievable plots, and groups of young people you just want to smack. While some in the 90's were watching Beverly Hills 90210 - another example of the aforementioned shi**y series - others were tuning in to a little gem called My So-Called Life. Starring a young Claire Danes and co-star Jared Leto, the series focused on the life of fifteen year old Angela Chase as she embraces adolescence and seeks her identity. While many sitcoms and dramas of the 90's focused on important yet controversial themes - such as violence, censorship, homophobia, homelessness, and alcoholism - they tended to use them as a one-time "very special episode" in which the theme would be addressed and then forgotten altogether. My So-Called Life depicted a true sense of realism as these issues were congruent with the overall story. They weren't one-time plots that would pop up and disappear; they were very real problems the characters dealt with in their day-to-day lives. So why was the one young adult drama that finally got it right canceled after only one season? Well, lead actress Claire Danes didn't want to return for a second season. In fact, many of the young cast members were having trouble juggling their roles on the show with their schoolwork and personal lives. Danes, being only as old as her character at the time, was excused and the series wasn't continued. Though it was a true shame that My So-Called Life wasn't able to continue it really can't be denied that doing so without Angela would have been a bad move.

4. Dead Like Me

Dead Like Me I was only twelve when Dead Like Me first premiered on Showtime in 2003. Between its overuse of foul language, clever depictions of death, and more than overt talk of sex and drugs my young mind was hooked. Of course, my father highly disapproved of his preteen son watching such filth but it certainly didn't stop me. This filth was nothing short of brilliant and even as a walking display of puberty I was able to understand its greatness. The series follows Georgina "George" Lass - a young, unfocused woman who quit college and moved back in with her parents; eventually she is forced to take an intern job and then dies. Yeah, you read that right. She dies! Fortunately - or unfortunately depending on how you look at it - she is recruited by a group of grim reapers. She now has to learn to deal with life after death as well as her new non-paying job as a taker of souls for the soon-to-be departed. The series boasts an outstanding supporting cast including the always wonderful Mandy Patinkin and features some of the best dialogue to ever grace premium television. So what happened? Bryan Fuller - the mastermind behind it all - had a lot of difficulty with broadcaster Showtime over cuts to what he deemed significant to the overall plot of the show. Eventually, because of these conflicts, he departed from the series after season one leaving much to be desired as MGM Television continued to butcher the series. Following the second season in which a decrease in ratings occurred the series was officially canceled. A direct-to-DVD film titled Dead Like Me: Life After Death was released five years later in order to wrap things up. During its first season Dead Like Me was nominated for two Emmy's. The series showed true potential and it's unfortunate Fuller had to leave.

3. Spartacus

Spartacus The first original series to be produced by premium broadcaster Starz, Spartacus is based on the Thracian gladiator of the same name as he escapes execution and is subsequently sold into slavery. Filled to the brim with explicit violence and sexuality coupled with a good story and incredible acting Spartacus could have easily become anyone's guilty pleasure. Unfortunately, however, the series was canceled after three seasons. Being good enough to be compared to Game of Thrones one must wonder why such a decision was ever made. To be entirely honest Spartacus wasn't truly canceled but was instead finished and decided upon that it would not return for a fourth season. Each season is presented as a separate miniseries which come together to form an entire series. Still, the show was certainly excellent enough to continue beyond three seasons and had both the ratings and critical acclaim to back it up. It truly is a disappointment that something as carnal - and that's meant in the best way possible - as Spartacus has reached its end. Spartacus has spun-off into many other media including comic books, video games, and novels. It would be nice to see the series continue as a comic book similar to what Joss Whedon has done with Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Speaking of Mr. Whedon...

2. Dollhouse

Joss Whedon hasn't had the best of luck in television following the end of hit series Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Spin-off Angel was axed shortly after Buffy ended and his following series Firefly has already featured on the list. Before finding success with current hit Marvel: Agents of Shield Whedon created a unique drama called Dollhouse starring Eliza Dushku. The series follows Dushku's character - known only as Echo - a "doll" for the Los Angeles "dollhouse" branch. These dolls are volunteers who have had their memories and personality wiped and saved on an external hard drive. The dollhouse hires the dolls out to wealthy clients for a large variety of reasons and following their "missions" the dolls once again have their memories wiped. Over time, however, Echo begins to retain small fragments of the memories that should have been erased which leads to self-awareness - something that could be dangerous for the dollhouse. Meanwhile, FBI agent Ballard hears rumors of the dollhouse and sets out to expose its existence. What made the series so great was once again the wonderful mind of Whedon as he tackled the concepts of identity and personality. Through his direction we come to relate to characters that don't even truly have personalities of their own. The idea was fresh and unique and was like nothing else that was on television at the time. Dollhouse, like Firefly, didn't receive strong enough ratings to be carried on beyond its second season having only been saved from cancellation after the first by the massive support of Whedon's fans. There has been no follow-up to the series so chances that Whedon may continue the story in a film are somewhat likely. It's something that would definitely be worth investing his time in.

1. Star Trek

star_trek_csg_014 Surprised by this? How can Star Trek - one of the most influential, most popular, and most spun-off television shows of all time - be featured on a list of shows that were unfairly dismissed? Well, because Star Trek was canceled after only three seasons. In fact, excluding the short-lived animated series the original Star Trek is the shortest running series of them all. So how could such a beloved series be given such ill treatment? Star Trek had actually performed rather poorly in the ratings races during its first season. Most shows would have been canceled right away but Star Trek managed to acquire a young demographic that saved it from being axed. Ratings continued to decline during the second season most notably due to a time slot change in which many younger viewers would be unavailable to watch. The show was renewed once more for a third season and once more was saved by its demographic. This time, however, the audience was deemed to be of "quality" mainly consisting of educated males. The third season was the last the series would see as questionable decisions on the network's part caused the few watching to turn away as the show was once more placed in an undesirable time slot. Despite the many protests of its hardcore fans, Star Trek was unjustly canceled. As years went by, however, many noticed just how amazing the show actually was and the cult following - and subsequent spin-0ffs - began. Are there any television shows you were sorry to see go? Let us know in the comment section below. Live long and prosper, readers!

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.