20 Greatest TV Villains Ever

Evil will always triumph, because good is dumb.

Without villains, the medium of television would be comprised of nothing more than a bunch of nice people sitting around playing Monopoly. Even if you hate the bad guys, you can't deny that their existence is completely necessary to create engaging story lines that continually challenge not only the characters, but the viewers themselves. That said, writing a good villain is easier said than done. That's why there are so many power-hungry cardboard Snidely Whiplashes running around out there. Harder still is the task of finding an actor who can bring a truly evil character to life while resisting the urge to chew on all the scenery they can find. It's a difficult equation to get right, because it depends on the mood of the piece. Sometimes less is more, sometimes more is more. But in the end, you just know it when you see it. And when a great antagonist is born, they captivate viewers and make a show into something special. Because the audience doesn't have to like a villain, they are allowed a great deal more emotional latitude, and can be complicated, conflicted, and morally ambiguous.

20. Joe Carroll - The Following

So...Joe Carroll is a serial killer with a body count in the double digits, who then went on to become a dangerously manipulative cult leader. That means that technically he's worse than Charlie Manson who, when you think about it, never actually killed anyone himself. But what makes him a cut above a lot of other naughty characters on television is his level of intelligence. He's a college professor who went rogue and used his considerable intellect to further his sociopathy and need for control. Carroll is basically a criminal mastermind who is just as dangerous behind bars as he is out on the street, and somehow manages to stay about four and a half steps ahead of the police. That's pretty scary...but at the same time oh so charming. Do you see why he's such a conflicting character for audiences? While everyone can pretty much agree that he's a thoroughly despicable character, you can sort of see why he has, well, a following.

19. The McPoyles - It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia

The McPoyles are pretty much the comedy version of that crazy family from Texas Chainsaw Massacre. They're weird, incestuous, and spend altogether too much time sitting around in bathrobes drinking milk. Human adults are not even really supposed to drink milk, but that's the least of that family's problems. They are the mortal enemies of the Paddy's gang, and both groups exist in the same heightened reality where it's totally OK for each of them to basically take turns committing atrocities against one another. Are the McPoyles the only ones at fault? No, of course not. But there's something so indescribably creepy and unsettling about them that just catching a glimpse of one of them (or, god forbid, the entire family) is enough to make your skin crawl.

18. Councilman Jamm - Parks and Recreation

Part of the reason why Parks and Recreation is such a great show is that it's relatable, and it feels almost like real life. Just with funnier, more attractive, slightly better versions of the people that you know. And just as Leslie Knope reminds you of a friend you wish you had, Jamm is your real life enemy. No, he's not blowing up buildings or taking over Metropolis, but all of his little attempts to undermine the Parks gang are made so much infuriating because they smack of the shenanigans your most hated office co-worker is pulling all the time. He's not out and out evil, but there's something that really gets under your skin about a bureaucrat who is sneaky and underhanded while at the same time being shockingly incompetent.

17. Sideshow Bob - The Simpsons

The obvious choice here is to go with Monty Burns, but Mr. Burns is evil in the same way that your great uncle who still refers to Vietnam as French Indochina is racist and politically incorrect. Yeah, technically, but he's just a harmless old guy so you have to cut him a little bit of slack. Sideshow Bob, on the other hand, is straight up psychotic. His attempts to capture and kill Bart are ridiculously menacing, especially for the likes of a cartoon that has a large following among children, and while Monty Burns is driven by greed, Sideshow Bob is driven by who the hell knows what. Which is significantly scarier. Is there are more malevolent, frightening character that has ever been featured on the show? Unlikely. And if The Simpsons' recent desperate play to lure in viewers is any indication, he might be getting the thing that he's longed for since his first appearance on the show.

16. Cartman - South Park

Cartman is a ruthless, conniving, manipulative jerk who has zero redeeming qualities. And if he's that bad whilst in elementary school, imagine what an adult Cartman with full use of his powers would be like? Throughout the long and illustrious run of South Park, he has proven remarkably willing to abandon and betray his closest friends with nary a second thought. He's a racist, cruel momma's boy who, on a consistent basis, has shown a complete lack of a conscience. But what makes Cartman a great villain is not that he's a brat (because really, that's hardly a rare commodity in the nine year old boy population), but how successful his nefarious efforts are. For a little kid, he can do a shocking amount of damage. Without his best friends to rein him in, he is a loose cannon and a force to be reckoned with. And God forbid you ever mention his weight to him.

15. Newman - Seinfeld

Sometimes there are people in your life who you've hated for so long that you can't even remember what actually happened between the two of you to make the relationship deteriorate. And you don't really care, either. All you know is that the very sight of your nemesis is enough to make your stomach turn. That's what Newman is for Seinfeld. He's the perfect representation of that guy you just can't stand. Newman abuses his lofty position of power as a postal worker almost exclusively to make life difficult for Jerry and his friends, and he does it all with an irritatingly smug look on his face. We've all been there, though. Who hasn't had what feels like an eternal feud with some random person who they're forced to interact with interact with on a semi-regular basis through a mundane curse of the gods?

14. Frank Underwood - House of Cards

Sometimes it's hard to think of a Kevin Spacey who doesn't have at least a little bit of the super-intelligent villain in him. Do you think he had that dry, sardonic voice even when he was in primary school? He's put his unique skill set to good use as Frank Underwood on House of Cards, one of the shows that launched Netflix as a legitimate provider of original content. Spacey plays a dastardly politician (is there any other?) in a way that few others can. He's ruthlessly manipulative, willing to do anything to further his own agenda, with no regard to who he is hurting or the damage he causes along the way. It might feel like a easy target. After all, Frank Underwood isn't the first corrupt politician character that has ever been written. But then you watch the show, and realize what an engaging and multi-faceted person Frank Underwood is. He may be the main character of House of Cards, but it's hard to argue that he's the hero of it.

13. The Smoking Man - The X-Files

In a show as episodic and alien-of-the-week as The X-Files was, The Smoking Man was the closest thing it had to a proper, consistent villain. He's a living representation of Machiavelli's writings that the ends justify the means, as he is just as devoted to concealing the truth as Mulder is to exposing it. And he's willing to go to some dark places to accomplish his goals, committing monstrous acts to protect the secrecy of the Syndicate. Although his effectiveness as a character waned in later years, he was at his best when he maintained a mysterious, lurksome presence with no clear motivations. Say what you will about the Smoking Man, it's a testament to the show's commitment to his shadowy anonymity that he was on The X-Files for six and a half years before his name was actually revealed. To this day, he proves that the less you know about a villain, the scarier it can be.

12. Fiona Goode - American Horror Story: Coven

There aren't a ton of characters in any of the American Horror Story shows that one could classify as being particularly good, so when you come out and call someone out for being eviler than usual, that's really saying something. Fiona Good goes above and beyond the average morally ambiguous and becomes actively malevolent. She's the Supreme of the coven featured in the show, and she is utterly committed to the goal of eternal life, willing to do pretty much anything to achieve it. Upon being convinced that she needs to kill the new Supreme, she makes it pretty clear that she's not too concerned about racking up a body count as she murders everyone unluckily enough to get in her way with extreme prejudice. While Jessica Lange played some other nasty characters during her time on American Horror Story, Fiona is the jewel in her demented little tiara.

In this post: 
South Park
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.