20 Problems Only Whovians Will Understand

Doctor Who fans are living in a golden age... But that doesn't mean we can't find anything to complain about.

Since Doctor Who returned to screens large and small in 2005 it has stepped out of the subculture and truly become a global phenomenon. Now, nearly a decade of Nu-Who on, fans of the show are truly living in a golden age. This is an age where wearing your Doctor Who T-shirt to school actually makes you cool. An age where Target Novelizations are valuable collectibles and not items that must be hidden at all cost lest they get you beaten up after gym class. An age where you might actually wear your Doctor Who T-shirts out in public and get something other than confused stares. Time has rolled on and proved that we were right all along, Doctor Who IS the coolest show ever. Now everyone knows it. So why aren't we happier? It may well be that while paradise is nice and all, it doesn't mean that there aren't still some irritations out there. Some issues that only we are aware of. In short - some problems that only Whovians will understand.

20. Constantly Resisting The Urge To Say, 'I Told You So.'

How many times have those same relatives shaken their heads in the past, wondering why you could possibly be interested in some children's show that even the BBC had the good sense to stop making ages ago. How often do those same relatives now happily watch the newest episode with you while telling you knowingly how enjoyable it is, as if you were ever the one to have claimed that it wasn't. It ruins Christmas if you punch them, so try to restrain the impulse. Just sit quietly and enjoy the knowledge that time has proved you correct.

19. Having To Learn To Love The Main Character All Over Again And Again

This probably doesn't count as a spoiler, but on a fairly regular basis the character of The Doctor dies, regenerates, and is played by a different actor with a different take on the character. This has been happening since 1966, so you might be forgiven for thinking that we'd all made peace with it by now. In practice however, this means that after three or so years of falling in love with, say, David Tennant's version of The Doctor, suddenly we're confronted with a shockingly young stranger with ridiculous hair who says a few lines and then disappears for 6 months or so before they start making new episodes again. During which time you're left with no idea how you feel about this new Doctor and very little to base a new opinion on. It's amazing Whovian Fandom isn't more rife with abandonment issues than it is, honestly. This process of course leads directly to...

18. The Rookie New Doctor Reaction

As previously noted - The change of Doctors has been going on for most of the last 50 years. What has not yet been noted here is that there is a fairly large chunk of Fandom that got on board with the series after it was brought back in 2005, which means that they didn't have the emotional prep time to really be ready for it when David Tennant left the show and they had to decide whether or not they liked Matt Smith. One positive thing about Christopher Eccleston leaving after just one season is that his Doctor wasn't so entrenched as to do significant emotional damage to the new viewership. It was sad, of course, but he came and went so quickly that it felt very much like that had been the point of his story all along - which made it much easier to accept and roll with. After four years and forty-odd stories with David Tennant things were very different. Particularly for a section of Fandom who saw the Tenth Doctor as much as a pinup as a mysterious wanderer through time and space. To them the replacement of David Tennant with Matt Smith was nothing short of emotional betrayal and they took to the internet to announce it as such. The current manifestation of this same trend has caused outpouring of moral outrage at Peter Capaldi's performance, solely on the basis of his not being young and dreamy. Rookies.

17. Learning To Suppress That Vague Resentment Of Newer Fans

Obviously since the series came back on our screens it has enjoyed a huge influx of new fans around the world. This is clearly a wonderful thing, and thinking about it rationally everyone would agree that the increased popularity is nothing but positive for everyone involved. But that doesn't mean that a significant percentage of Fandom isn't constantly resisting the urge to suddenly snap and shout, 'YOU! You with your Fez and your unbridled joy! You weren't there in 1989, man... You never lived through the JNT years... You weren't there to have your heart briefly given hope again before being brutally ripped from your body and stomped on in 1996! You don't know, man! You don't KNOW...!'

16. Learning To Suppress That Vague Resentment Of Older Fans

It can be difficult, getting out there and interacting with the rest of the Whovian world as a brand new fan of the series. Particularly with the seemingly endless number of fans from the classic series who are only too eager to constantly remind you that they had to wait almost a year to find out what Peter Davison's Doctor was going to be like before happily telling you where they were at the exact moment that they heard the news about the great suspension of 1986. Which seems to inevitably lead to...

15. Being Compulsively Driven To Explain The Old Series References

In detail. At great length. It's as much about getting carried away with the joy of being able to discuss the minutia of Doctor Who's history as it is about sub-textually asserting 'fan-dominance' through the implication that you're somehow 'more' of a fan by virtue of knowing who The Macra are. To be fair, this sort of thing is nothing new and all sorts of other groups of Fandom are guilty of it to a greater or lesser degree; it's the same force that drives sports fans to memorize football statistics. That said, it's still probably better if we stress the 'joy of sharing' aspect and try to keep a lid on the 'showing off' part. That way leads to...

14. Proprietarialism

More of a factor for long-time fans than it is for those who found the show after 2005, there's a definite urge to feel possessive about Doctor Who. This is perfectly natural when you take into consideration the fact that Doctor Who was, from sometime around 1985 to 2005, looked on by the not-we as something of an embarrassment. Fandom spent the better part of two decades not really talking much about the show except among those they knew to be in the circle. Then Christopher Eccleston came along and it seemed like the rest of the world finally realized what the fans had known all along - That Doctor Who was the coolest thing out there. So not unlike when your favorite little bar gets discovered and suddenly everybody is there, it's hard not to feel just a little bit of resentment for having been there first.

13. Explaining Why Cliffhangers Matter

It's difficult to explain to newer fans why the older fans got so excited by the end of Aliens of London. It must have seemed bewildering to them to see so much excitement over the fact that the story was going to be interrupted halfway through. To long term fans however, this was the final confirmation that Doctor Who was really back It's a sad truth that one of the few things about Doctor Who that didn't make it back from the dead in 2005 was the traditional cliffhanger. Fans of the new series, most of whom have been raised on a completely different style of television, can't possibly understand how important the cliffhangers were to the rhythm of the show. At their worst the cliffhangers devolved into just a closeup of Colin Baker's face saying, 'Oh no, Peri!', but at their best they turned everything you thought you knew about a story on its head. Before 2005 no one in Fandom could have imagined the show without them. Now we're left having to try to explain why.

12. The 'I Hate (Insert Current Show Runner Here)' Syndrome

There is absolutely nothing new about this. For every fan currently swearing that Steven Moffat is the worst thing to ever happen to show, there was one five years ago saying the same thing about Russell T. Davies. And before him Philip Segal (although there's a case to be made...) And before him John Nathan Turner, and so on. If Twitter had existed in 1965 it would have been full of declarations that John Wiles was the 'Worst Thing to Ever Happen to Doctor Who.' That's just the nature of Fandom, irritating though it may be to read. It's somewhat comforting though to remember that as soon as a producer leaves they instantly become 'So much better than (insert new producer's name) and the cycle begins anew.

11. The 'Rose Factor'

There has never, in the history of Doctor Who, been another companion who was so divisive that people were still arguing their pros and cons years after they had left the show. Not even Mel comes close to the level of excitability you'll encounter is you're brave enough to post 'Rose Tyler was the best/worst companion ever!' on any of the available internet comment board threads. It's hard to see why Billie Piper inspires such a high level of adoration/blinding fury. Partially it may be due to the fact that she was the first companion that the new audience got to meet. More likely it has to do with the way she became a personification of the possibility of a Doctor/Companion love match (a topic that large portions of Fandom appear ready to kill one another over.) Whatever the reason, it might be hoped that one day passions might cool on the subject and it might be possible to remember her fondly without having to make a big deal out of it. That day, however, has not yet come.

10. Feeling The Need To Defend Colin Baker

The Sixth Doctor's era, much like Rose Tyler, tends to bring out strong feelings from Fandom. A combination of weak scripting and production decisions that border on the inept side of complete lunacy did not do Mr. Baker any favors. The decision to portray his Doctor onscreen as deliberately unlikeable finished the job. By the time he was fired from the show the majority of Fandom had a shared view that, while it was unfair to him, we weren't really sorry to see him go. Time and Big Finish have proved that sentiment wrong. Getting to know what Colin Baker is actually like through interviews and appearances (and finding out that he's one of the most gracious and humble people to have ever been involved with the show), alongside his performance in many of the better audio adventures put out by Big Finish show us just how wonderful his time as The Doctor could have been.

9. People Who Still Think It's All About The Scarf

In a way Fandom only has itself to blame for this one. Even as recently as Peter Capaldi's debut the iconic Tom Baker scarf was given a mention. Admittedly that was just to make fun of it, but it still brought 'The Scarf' back into the conversation. It's slightly less prevalent than it was before 2005, but there are still people out there who, upon hearing that you're a fan of Doctor Who, will immediately make some sort of joke about 'The Scarf'. Usually followed by something about Daleks not being able to go up stairs. Part of being a Whovian is learning to accept the fact that there's nothing you can do about this. Those people will continue to be out there, and for the most part don't mean any harm by it. They just don't know any better. Console yourself that in 30 years we'll all be facing an identical fez problem.

8. The Ongoing Twitterfeed Trainwreck

Naming no names, but it can hardly have escaped the notice of most Whovians that there's a general kerfuffle going on in the Twittersphere regarding certain lost episodes. The discussion is primarily focused between two fairly well known fans of the show with various other people chiming in at regular intervals in support of one or the other. The whole thing regularly descends into unseemly territory, and quite honestly doesn't do any section of Fandom any credit. Yet it's impossible to not follow it, which means that on some level you're contributing to the whole thing continuing.

7. Deciding What 'Counts'

Mentioned above, the company Big Finish have been producing new audio adventures featuring the 4th-8th Doctors since 2000. Before the revival in 2005 everyone was more or less happy to consider these as 'Canon' (i.e., just as 'real' as The Doctor's televised adventures.) Once they started making the show again things got a little more complicated. If the Big Finish audios were 'canon', did that mean that the books published by Virgin and the BBC between 1993 and 2005 were also 'real'? If so, what about the fact that Human Nature happens to The Doctor twice, once to the 7th Doctor and once to the 10th? What about the comic strip? Frobisher the shape-shifting penguin (yes you read that correctly) appears both there and in the Big Finish audios, so does that make him 'count'? It all gets incredibly complicated, incredibly quickly. Ultimately the best advice is simply to enjoy the stories that you enjoy and ignore the ones you don't.

6. There's Just Too Much To Keep Up With

As mentioned above, in addition to the television series, there is also a range of audio adventures being produced. There is also a range of tie-in books from the BBC. Also out there is the range of New Adventures from the 90s, the Missing Adventure, the BBC Eight Doctor Books, The Telos Novellas, etc. For a new fan coming to the series this is just overwhelming. Twenty-Six seasons of the classic show on their own are a tremendous amount of backstory to try to catch up on without even starting on the rest of it.

5. The New Series' Scheduling

For the first few years of the new series things were fairly dependable. The new season would premiere in the spring, run for twelve weeks, then would be done until Christmas Day. While the gap between the end of the series and Christmas was a little on the long side, at least you knew where you were. Then we had the year of five specials instead of a new season due to a combination of David Tennant's schedule and the collapse of the global economy, and for most of that year the BBC couldn't even tell us when the third special was going to be on until a few weeks before it aired. Since then the production team appears to just throw a dart at a calendar and start to air the new series then with only a few weeks warning. Fortunately this past year Fandom had something else to obsess about to pass the time...

4. Omnirumour Fatigue

It's now been well over a year since the first whispers started to hit the internet. No one could really believe it, but more and more sources were starting to say that most if not all of the missing episodes from the programme's first six years had been recovered. This was such good news that it was practically inconceivable. At that time there were a total of 106 episodes from those early years that were lost, most believed forever. But the whispers continued and then in October of 2013 it was announced that two complete(ish) Second Doctor stories had indeed been recovered. This seemed to give some credence to the rumors that everything had been found, and since that moment Fandom has doggishly followed every scrap of a whisper of a hint of a rumor, vaguely expecting that at any moment the BBC would be announcing the entire find. And then time passed. By this point Fandom as a whole is so entirely sick of scouring the web for news of the so-called 'omnirumour' that an announcement either way would be a relief if only to finally have the whole thing settled.

3. The Classic Series Stars Are Beginning To Die

In the last couple of years we've lost Nicholas Courtney, Liz Sladen, Mary Tamm and Caroline John, just to name a few. In a very short time there will be fewer actors from the classic series alive than there are who have passed away, to say nothing of the production staff. This has the strange effect of making the DVD commentary tracks both touching and important, as they increasingly become our only way to hear the voices and thoughts of those that are no longer with us. Tom Baker is 80 years old. Think about that.

2. The Nagging Fear That They'll Stop Making It Again

It took a long time for Fandom to learn to trust again. They'd been hurt before. Were they really ready to get their hopes up for the 2005 series reboot, remembering the pain of 1996? Fortunately the answer was yes, and as Fandom embraced Nu-Who the rest of the world did likewise. But that doesn't stop that nagging little worry. They've stopped making it before. Three times. As good as the current series is and as much global love as the show is receiving, one day this will all end. In a way this is a positive thing. Having been through it all before, Fandom is remembering to enjoy it while it's here Because it's also important to remember...

1. There's Over 40 Hours Of Doctor Who That We Will Never Get To See

It's a sobering number to think about, but it's true. There are 97 episodes of early Doctor Who that are simply gone. Watched back to back non-stop it would take nearly two entire days to get through them all. But unless you happened to have been a fan in the 60s and caught them on their original broadcast, you're never going to see them. Perhaps it's time to check on Twitter for word about the Omnirumour again... Whovians - Agree? Disagree? Others that we've missed?

Contributor
Contributor

Mikey is, in no particular order, a freelance writer, improvisational comedian, volunteer firefighter, playwright, Bon Vivant, and Jane Espenson enthusiast. Born in the small mining town of Eden Prairie, MN, he has some 40 years later successfully moved about 20 miles north of there to the City of Brooklyn Center, MN where he lives with an unreasonable number of dogs. If you'd like to hear him discuss something other than Doctor Who while pretending to be a dog, check out www.the42ndvizsla.blogspot.com or follow him on twitter at @the42ndVizlsa