9 Most Fan-Pleasing Moments In Television

What the fans want, the fans get. Just, sometimes... be careful what you wish for.

Sherlock Rooftop
BBC

Television has always had a fanbase peculiar to it. While cinema has an air of exoticism to it and the theatre has that aura of respectable aloofness, the television squats in the corner of our living rooms, watching us go about our lives, its programming a constant presence, the men and women appearing in it almost a part of the family. Their theme tunes become the hummed soundtracks of our lives.

For decades the home audience has had a close, personal relationship to the television shows it takes to its heart… almost too close. We campaigned for the reinstatement of cancelled shows like Star Trek, Community and Firefly. We fell in love with weird, awkward hybrid creations like reality television and professional wrestling and turned these peculiar niche products into mainstream sensations.

Fans became fandom, oddly obsessive over the minutiae of specific television shows… and our fandom began to attempt to influence the way those shows were put together, to steer the narrative and the characters in the direction that we wanted them to go. These days, a call to arms can go viral, a petition reach thousands in a matter of hours, a Twitter campaign trend worldwide.

The age of the Internet makes all of us backseat drivers, but at least we’re going where we want to go. These are the moments when being a fan paid off: when we got just what we wanted, for better or worse.

OBVIOUSLY there are spoilers within. Wouldn't be much use without them...

9. Supernatural Transforms Into Glee For One Night Only

Jensen Ackles Supernatural Thats Cute Gif Gif
Warner Bros. Television

Two hundred episodes is a monumental achievement, especially for a genre show about bickering brothers fighting and skewering paranormal and mystical nasties: Buffy The Vampire Slayer with a bro code. How did the producers of The CW’s veteran genre action/horror show elect to celebrate such a significant milestone?

With an episode titled ‘Fan Fiction’ that celebrated the (mostly female) fanbase of the show, that’s how. Heroes Sam and Dean Winchester arrive at a high school to find that they’re staging a musical version of the Winchesters’ lives… based on the prophetic books of Carver Edlund, aka Chuck Shurley, a man they’ve previously encountered who may (or may not) be God, messing with them.

The all female cast of the musical are essentially stand-ins for the Supernatural fandom, with references to slash pairings – including one for Dean and Sam, prompting Dean to insist that the main characters stand further apart onstage (“You do know they’re brothers?”). There are also a fair few nods to the people with problems with the show: basically, the writers have made notes on the fandom, and have incorporated them into the text of the show, good or bad.

Unlike previous metatextual attempts to make fun of the fandom within the course of Supernatural storylines, this love letter to the fandom is sweet and perfectly constructed – a lovely idea, brilliantly executed. Oh, let’s not forget that Chuck turns up at the end to give the production a ringing endorsement… which pretty much means that the fandom-inspired show just got the thumbs up from God.


8. Nikki And Paulo Are Horribly Killed To Death

Lost expose nikki paulo dead
ABC

Come season three of Lost, the show was haemorrhaging goodwill in pints: a lacklustre, even dull season two had segued into a worse season three, and fans were up in arms. And then Nikki and Paulo were introduced. Who were Nikki and Paulo? That’s a very good question. Survivors of the plane crash that propelled the narrative, they weren’t in the tail section of the plane, crashed on another part of the island. No, Nikki and Paulo had been with the other main survivors of the crash all along… it’s just that they’d not been part of the plot until now.

To say fans hated the new cast members would be a massive understatement. It wasn’t the first time show-runners Carlton Cuse and Damon Lindelof had addressed why the dozens of crash survivors who were played by extras didn’t ever have anything exciting happen to them: in the first season, the unfortunate Leslie Arzt was constantly moaning about the lead characters’ ‘little clique’, at least before he exploded. But coming at a point when the mythology of the show was broadening out and a definitive end point had been given to fans, to waste screen time on two annoying newcomers was considered unforgivable.

When the show returned from the mid-season break, Cuse and Lindelof acknowledged the fact that Nikki and Paulo had been a massive misstep. Season three’s fourteenth episode, Exposé, gave us back-story for the pair of conniving lovers, and told us where they’d been and what they’d been doing for the previous eighty days… and then killed them, really rather horribly, as a nod of gratitude to the fans for sticking with the show during its rocky period. 

Femme fatale Nikki poisoned poor, stupid, unsuspecting Paulo, temporarily paralysing him, and then fell victim to the same spider bite… and the rest of the survivors, thinking that the two were dead, proceeded to bury them alive.


7. We Were Always Rooting For You Crazy Kids To Get Together, Part 1

889564

You can’t have an article like this without discussing relationships between characters that would never have happened without fan involvement. The X-Files was one of the first television shows to benefit from an online following, who would pore over episodes, storylines and characters with a fine-toothed comb. As usual, the fans were split on many of the things they appreciated most about their show, but one thing almost all of them agreed on was that it was only a matter of time before FBI agents Dana Scully and Fox Mulder admitted that they were totally in love with each other, damn it.

However, that ‘almost all of them’ definitely doesn’t include series showrunner Chris Carter, who’s gone on record as saying that their partnership was never intended to become a romantic entanglement of any kind. He was interested in the fact that they were best friends, perfect partners, that Scully may even have been Mulder’s only friend.

Resisting that urge to get the two of them together until the very end could have been what kept the spark between the two alight… after all, it’s a storytelling truism (referred to as ‘the Moonlighting curse’) that once you answer the ‘will they, won’t they’ question, interest in the characters inevitably dies off. There’s a reason that romantic comedies tend to finish with the characters getting together… no one wants to see what happens afterwards…


6. We Were Always Rooting For You Crazy Kids To Get Together, Part 2

Niles Daphne Fraiser
NBC

…except in the case of Daphne and Niles from the hit sitcom Frasier, of course.

In the original drafts of the show, Frasier didn’t have a brother and Daphne was a fiery Latina. That all changed when the producers were given a head shot of David Hyde Pierce, and they discovered how much he looked like a young Kelsey Grammer. Once Jane Leeves had been cast as their father Martin’s live-in physical therapist, the core of the show, the four of them, was set in stone.

The relationship between Niles and Daphne wasn’t intended from the beginning either: it was purely a throwaway joke that Niles had an intense crush on Daphne from the word go, when the writers were spitballing what Niles’ reaction to meeting her would be. As time went on and Hyde Pierce’ nuanced, sly performance allowed Niles to become the show’s breakout character, fans began to clamour for a genuine consummation of his feelings towards her, yelling at the screen to tell her how he felt.

Over seven years, the fans waited: through the hilarious, then painful break-up of Niles’ marriage, through his time spent single and patching himself up. It’s unfortunate that the moment they’d been waiting so long for occurred during the downturn in Frasier’s creative fortunes – by the time Niles and Daphne got together, the show simply wasn’t as funny as it had been.

But the fans got what they wanted. Patiently, carefully set up to be the perfect couple, despite their vastly different personalities and interests, Niles and Daphne are pure, perfect fan service.


5. We Were Always Rooting For You Crazy Kids To Get Together, Part 3

Arrow Olicity
The CW

And then there’s the flip side to that: when television producers cave to fan demands, and the much longed-for romance between ‘shipped’ characters simply doesn’t work. Step forward, Arrow and the terrible story of Olicity: Oliver Queen and Felicity Smoak.

Felicity was only ever intended to be a small part for Emily Bett Rickards, an Easter Egg for comics fans (originally, Felicity Smoak was a supporting character in The Fury Of Firestorm) – but the producers loved her interpretation of the geeky, awkward computer genius, and Felicity gradually became an integral part of Team Arrow. That’s where the fans come in.

Convinced that Felicity was supposed to be with the show’s protagonist Oliver, aka the Hood, aka the Arrow (aka Green Arrow, by the time the show’s fourth season rolls up in October this year), fans seized on every scene between the two, every long take, every flustered instance of dialogue, as evidence that there was a spark between them. By season two, those moments weren’t delusion on the part of the more romantic of the show’s fans: they were being written into the show itself, culminating in a finale that seemed to pay off the relationship.

But fans would have to wait until season three to see ‘Olicity’ proper… and what a damp squib it’s been so far. Felicity’s feelings for Oliver led to tension of an entirely different sort between the two, and it’s become clear that Rickards’ gift for comedy doesn’t extend to a talent for more heavyweight acting: her ‘pent-up emotion voice’ was used as a one-stop-shop to convey sadness, anger, grief, and denial, making her scenes difficult to watch. 

Added to that, in her new role as the person who tries to talk Oliver out of every decision that might place him in danger, Felicity becomes a downer in nearly every scene the two share, the bitter pill that poisons the mood. This is an action/adventure superhero show, after all – the show’s love story can’t act as a spoiler for that without curdling.

Here’s hoping that season four has the two of them having learned to work together more harmoniously, and that the Arrow crew have figured out how to write to Rickard’s strengths without revealing her weaknesses. If not, ‘Olicity’ may become a cautionary tale, a case of ‘be careful what you wish for’.


4. Bobby Ewing And The Dream Season

Dallas Bobby
CBS

Actor Patrick Duffy’s decision to leave primetime soap sensation Dallas at the height of his success in the part of dashing young oil tycoon Bobby Ewing caused a whole heap of problems. While Duffy wanted to pursue other avenues in his career while he was still able to take advantage of them, fans were horrified at his character’s death at the climax of season eight, run over by his obsessed sister-in-law.

With significant outcry, the fans voted with their feet. Ratings for the subsequent season weren’t the greatest, and neither was Patrick Duffy’s much-vaunted career once he’d become a free agent. It wasn’t long before both Dallas and Duffy were looking to reconcile… but how, given that Bobby had been dead a year and that everyone had moved on?

The decision was made to retcon the entirety of season nine as a dream, Bobby’s wife Pam waking to find him in the shower as though nothing had ever happened. To keep it a secret, Bobby’s appearance in the shower was filmed entirely separately to Pam’s own scene, and in the context of a faked shower cream commercial for Patrick Duffy: no one aside from the show’s producers and Duffy himself knew that this was how Bobby would return to the show. That even extended to Victoria Principal, playing Pam – ironically, she was under the impression that Pam’s shocked reaction was to finding a dead body in the shower.

Hilariously, Dallas spin-off Knots Landing had crossover ties with many of the events of the dream season nine, and that show’s producers felt that altering their own continuity was a step too far. Essentially, that means that the final few seasons of Knots Landing diverge from mainstream Dallas continuity – they’re more or less a continuation of that alternate universe that Pam Ewing dreamed up. 


3. Yes! Yes! Yes! Etc.

933147

Monday Night RAW is the flagship television show in World Wrestling Entertainment’s continuing Stalinesque ruthless dominance of the western professional wrestling market, and a huge number of wrestling fans have been watching it, on and off, for over two decades. The ‘off’ part of that is down to the fact that, although wrestling fans want WWE to be great, far too much of the time it is godawful.

It’s like the Simpsons: it used to be great, it still shows flashes of greatness, and it could be great again. But WWE fans are nothing if not determined: they have a lot invested in RAW not being a three-hour bore. In 2013, when WWE fans decided that they wanted superbly talented mid-level wrestler Daniel Bryan to move up to the main event (the equivalent of a supporting character becoming one of the protagonists), they gave WWE very little choice in the matter, hijacking TV tapings with shouts and cheers for their hero, centred around his irritating catchphrase "Yes!"

WWE tried as hard as they could to offer fans other alternatives that they were more comfortable with. Bryan wasn’t their first – or even third – choice for a top-level guy (wrestling not being a meritocracy), so they paraded the few wrestlers they had in the top spot, cycling them around and hoping that the audience would connect with someone else.

It didn’t happen: if anything, the company’s attitude galvanised the fans still further, and through sheer pigheadedness they forced WWE to change the main storyline leading into Wrestlemania (the biggest event on the pro wrestling calendar, a show which can change a city’s financial fortunes simply by taking place there). Daniel Bryan was inserted into the main event match for the WWE world heavyweight championship, making it a three-way fight. Even better than that, to give the crowd the ultimate pro wrestling feelgood moment, Daniel Bryan, perennial underdog, was actually booked to win. 


2. Beth Returns From The (Walking) Dead

daryl beth walking dead
AMC

Season five of The Walking Dead saw fan favourite, singer Beth Greene killed, shot in the head in a moment of sudden, random violence. The fan outcry was unprecedented for the show, which had made its name in sudden, random violence and the dramatic effects this violence would have upon the main cast.

Beth’s death was considered to be for shock value only, to give the mid-season finale a horrible ‘water cooler moment’ for people to discuss the next day. An online petition was circulated, citing the loss of the character to the show and describing the scene in particular as “disgusting and unsatisfying”. Series creator Robert Kirkman, meanwhile, responded to the surprising backlash by telling fans that he was working on a way to persuade the powers that be to bring Beth back, or to find closure for her character that would satisfy the audience.

Eventually, that closure came about. During the protracted death of Tyreese, another major character, Beth would appear as a hallucination along with several of his other dead friends, the children Lizzie and Mika and Bob Stookey. Initially appearing as corpses rather like the walkers themselves, the wounds sustained in death still with them, by the end Beth and the others have returned to a more peaceful countenance, and as Tyreese dies, she sings him to his rest.

The implication, however cheesy, was that Tyreese has come to terms with his losses and with his own impending demise, and is at peace: similarly, the audience is invited to believe that Beth, Bob and the children are also at peace, perhaps even gone to a better place.


1. How The Hell Did He Get Out Of That, Then?

Sherlock Jump
BBC

Sherlock’s second season climaxed with the apparent suicide of the main character, Benedict Cumberbatch’s abrasive genius Sherlock Holmes. As part of a monumentally silly plot by his nemesis Jim Moriarty, Sherlock would be forced to kill himself to prevent the deaths of his friends, by jumping from the roof of a building. To seal the trap, and prevent himself being used as leverage for Sherlock to escape it, Moriarty actually shot himself in the head.

Viewers saw Sherlock fall, saw his heterosexual life partner John Watson rush to his side, saw him pronounced dead at the scene, witnessed his funeral and sat through John’s agonised, distraught one-way conversation with Sherlock at his graveside… only to see, just before the credits rolled, Sherlock himself witness the same conversation as he spies on John from a distance, completely and utterly alive and unhurt.

It was two years before season three would hit the BBC television screens, and the Internet went a little peculiar in the downtime between season two’s finale and season three’s premiere. Sherlock fans had one topic of conversation: how did Sherlock survive? Theories ran rampant, ranging from the scientifically plausible and logically constructed to the utterly ridiculous and facile.

Upon Sherlock’s return, we never quite received a definitive answer as to how it was done… at least, not one that satisfied the fanbase. Instead, show-runner and writer Steven Moffat would incorporate a few of the most popular fan theories into the episode, rewriting the character of Anderson, the forensic scientist, as one of many iterations of Sherlock fandom within the show itself, the creator of a fanclub-within-the-show called The Empty Hearse, which doubled as the title of the episode.

Fans weren’t particularly amused by Moffat’s irreverent mockery of their fevered speculation. The funniest version of Sherlock’s survival had the whole thing restaged as an implausible practical joke on Watson by both Sherlock and Moriarty, followed by a passionate kiss between the archenemies: a tongue-in-cheek reference to the thousands of Sherlock slash fiction stories that had been written about the two since season two had ended.

Funnily enough, the climax of season three seemed to suggest that Moriarty himself had returned, presumably having faked his own suicide on the rooftop. Given the likely three year gap between season three and season four, fans will have even longer to heatedly speculate on just how that came about, and whether Moffat will take the mickey out of them come the season four premiere, too…

What’s your favourite moment of fan service on television? Tell us all about it in the comments!


In this post: 
Sherlock
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.