Altered Carbon Review: 7 Ups & 3 Downs

Blade Runner: The Series. More or less.

Altered Carbon
Netflix

Netflix's much-anticipated new sci-fi TV show, Altered Carbon, is finally available to watch, and while being generally met with mixed-to-positive reviews so far, it's fair to say that it's one of the most impressively ambitious undertakings the streaming giant has tackled to date.

Adapted from Richard K. Morgan's 2002 acclaimed, award-winning cyberpunk novel, Altered Carbon delves deep into heady themes of identity and existence, while cleverly relating this far-flung future to our own present-day Earth.

Though not always broaching its ideas as well as you might hope, the end result is nevertheless an intoxicating trip like nothing else on TV right now, and a totally singular experience.

With an evidently huge budget, admirably adult tone and plenty of potential to become one of Netflix's most intriguing cult hits moving forward, this is a must-see for sci-fi fans starved of compelling new content.

Free of spoilers, here's everything Altered Carbon got right, and what it could improve upon for the inevitable second season...


Downs...

3. The Protagonists Are Pretty Dull

Altered Carbon Ortega
Netflix

Perhaps the most disappointing aspect of the entire show is just how uninteresting the two lead characters are.

Joel Kinnaman's Takeshi Kovacs has an intriguing back story and sounds like a fitting protagonist on paper, but Kinnaman's fairly flat performance sucks the air out of the show at times. He's clearly trying to be stoic but it comes off more lethargic and boring than anything.

Then there's the female lead, Martha Higareda's Kristin Ortega. Though Higareda gives a decent enough performance, her character rarely moves beyond being a generic hot-headed Latina cop cliche, complete with cheesy one-liners and a few eye-rolling subplots.

As is so often the case with high-concept TV shows and movies, the figures at the center are essentially the least interesting pieces of the puzzle.


2. There's Way Too Much Exposition

Altered Carbon James Purefoy
Netflix

It becomes apparent very quickly that Altered Carbon isn't the most delicately written of shows, with practically every single episode featuring at least one scene where a character lazily reels off a lengthy monologue force-feeding the audience the plot or what a character's motivations are.

Characters speak in awkward, mannered tones that no actual person would in order to reel off information for the viewer's benefit, and it's frequently distracting.

It doesn't help that many of these dialogues unfold via uninspired shot-reverse-shot conversations, and though the show occasionally slowing down to recount the oft-confusing narrative isn't a totally bad idea, it's done with an almost comical level of blatancy here.


1. It's Bloated & Convoluted At Times

Altered Carbon Joel Kinnaman
Netflix

In the show's defense, it is full of complex and heady concepts, and to a point it wants to intentionally confuse the audience, because this suits the show's themes of ambiguous identity and distrust.

However, there are definitely times where the layout of scenes, ideas and information feels sloppier than it really needs to be. Keeping track of everything isn't easy because there's an excess of subplots, many of which appear and disappear on a whim and ultimately don't have satisfactory payoffs.

There's also a lot of breadcrumb-following detective work once the central premise is established, and with its 10-episode running order, it probably could've lost two-or-so episodes to make it feel a little less distended, as is a common criticism of Netflix Original shows.

Altered Carbon is good enough to stick it out regardless, but the messy writing often thinks it's being clever and complex when it's more convoluted and willfully obtuse than anything.

With these cons in mind, here's everything the show got right...


Ups...

7. The Production Values Are Totally Insane

Altered Carbon
Netflix

The first thing everyone will notice about Altered Carbon is how utterly, jaw-droppingly visually stunning it is.

Generally, sci-fi TV shows have to take a huge hit in the budget department compared to movies, but Netflix has clearly spared no expense creating a glossy, gorgeous future, with eye-wateringly slick cinematography and some of the best CGI the TV medium has ever seen.

It wouldn't be a stretch at all to call Altered Carbon the best-looking sci-fi TV show ever made: it really does feel like Blade Runner 2049 brought on the small screen (albeit with less visual discipline), and there's not a moment where it ever feels like corners have been cut or money saved.

If Netflix can produce other big-budget shows of this absurdly high production quality, then the future's looking even brighter for streaming than we ever imagined.


6. It's Surprisingly Funny

Altered Carbon Edgar Allen Poe
Netflix

The biggest difference between this show and something like Blade Runner is that Altered Carbon doesn't dare to take itself all that seriously.

Sure, there are dark, adult themes and a lot of unpleasant things, but it's never more than a few minutes away from a pithy one-liner or a quirky character.

In that sense Altered Carbon feels like it's filling the Blade Runner niche for those who find Blade Runner too severe or self-serious.

Especially note-worthy is Chris Conner's riotous performance as Poe, an Edgar Allan Poe-themed AI who runs a hotel - called The Raven, of course - that Kinnaman's Kovacs resides at. He serves as terrific comic relief throughout the show, especially during his interplay with the more serious-minded Kovacs.

There's also some wry social commentary, especially regarding the state of modern America, which helps prevent things ever getting too dark or serious for their own good. That it pulls all this off without causing any tonal whiplash is impressive.


5. The Gritty, Mature Tone

Altered Carbon Joel Kinnaman
Netflix

It wouldn't have surprised anyone if, in order to achieve its gorgeous visual style, Altered Carbon's more mature content had to be toned down, but this being Netflix rather than a conventional TV network, that thankfully wasn't the case at all.

This show is not for kids, let's just say that. It is jam-packed not just with brutal violence and blood-letting, but plentiful graphic nudity - of both the male and female kind, which is refreshing - to the point that it's almost comical.

Seriously, if you thought Game of Thrones was gratuitous in the sex department, it's got nothing on Altered Carbon. You can argue it makes the show feel "trashy", but considering the inherent sleaze of the world created here, it doesn't harm the series' integrity at all.

Sure, you might not want to watch it with your parents, but for those craving a sci-fi show that's both big-budget and lets it all hang out - literally - this is a major breath of fresh air.


4. It's Clever & Ambitious

Altered Carbon Joel Kinnaman
Netflix

Sure, the writing isn't always as water-tight or as logical as it could be, but it's easy enough to mostly forgive considering the ludicrous ambition of the show on practically every level.

The central concept - of people's consciousness residing within a poker chip-like object called a "stack", which can be transported into different empty bodies, aka "sleeves", at will - is both horrifying and fascinating, especially in terms of the effect this has on society, from religion, to the government and even the nature of human relationships.

It is a show overflowing with ideas, more than it knows what to do with perhaps, but the depth of the mythology and the consistently intriguing, slippery riffs on the shifting meaning of identity, as well as the perils of immortality, make it never less than transfixing to watch at almost all times.


3. The Spectacular Action Sequences

Altered Carbon
Netflix

Those aforementioned incredible production values are put to fantastic use during the show's litany of intense, beautifully brutal action sequences.

Most episodes feature at least a set-piece or two, making the most of the excellent sets, costumes and visual effects to generate action that would feel just as at home in the cinema as on your TV screen.

While most TV shows settle into generic patterns with their action sequences, recycling the same camera set-ups over and over again in order to save time and cut costs, it always feels dynamic and diverse here, aided by some fantastic sound work in particular, especially for the punchy gunshot effects.


2. It's Full Of Sneaky Twists & Turns

Altered Carbon Joel Kinnaman
Netflix

No spoilers here, of course, but above all else Altered Carbon is a show that will keep you guessing all the way to the end.

The series' tricky premise, where people can slip in and out of bodies at will and assume new ones, creates an air of distrust from the outset, such that until the big finale, you can never be quite sure who is who, and who is on whose side.

The show steadily doles out the surprises in a way that makes it compulsive, binge-worthy viewing, constantly upending what the audience thinks they know while leaving plenty up in the air as the final credits roll. Bring on season two.


1. The Excellent World Building

Altered Carbon
Netflix

And finally, Altered Carbon's first-rate world-building is what will ultimately keep viewers hooked throughout.

Aided by the fantastic visuals, there's a fascinating depiction here of a hypnotic future Earth, which while initially seeming to ape Blade Runner's familiar aesthetic, takes it in a wholly different direction as it explores future society, both in terms of the wealthy elite and those making a living in the gutters.

It manages to feel both otherworldly and familiar at once, with its heightened style but constant callbacks to how society functions in the present.

The future created here is incredibly convincing in every sense, and considering how difficult it is to pull this off without making concessions somewhere along the line - usually budgetary - Altered Carbon stands as a truly staggering achievement, flaws and all.

What did you think of Altered Carbon's first season? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.