BoJack Horseman: 10 Worst Things Mr Peanutbutter Has Ever Done

A lot of Mr Peanutbutter’s interactions with his romantic interests can paint him in a bad light, but also offer some absolution. Neither Katrina, Jessica Biel nor Diane are that likeable, and Mr PB always plays the nice guy.

Cheating on someone though definitely places him in the wrong. Young, vapid and shallow Pickles isn’t necessarily the most popular character in the fanbase, but cheating is cut and dried: wrong. Mr Peanutbutter is a bad dog.

This list has largely strayed clear of the fan theory that everything Mr Peanutbutter does is an elaborate act designed to manipulate people, in favour of actual terrible things the loveable labrador has done. However, there is one example which is a pretty fitting addendum to this entry.

To break the ice, Pickles suggests they just blurt out secrets on their first date. After a few silly ones, Mr PB admits he still has feelings for ex-wife Diane. A pretty bad thing to say on your first date, especially to someone much younger and probably more vulnerable.

Is he just a bit of a birdbrained goofball, or does he like putting Pickles in her place? Jury’s out...