BoJack Horseman: 10 Worst Things Mr Peanutbutter Has Ever Done

If this list has proven anything, it’s that Mr Peanutbutter doesn’t deserve much benefit of the doubt. He tends to get a lot of it, both in the show’s universe and - to a lesser extent - from the fanbase. However, while this does rank as the second worst thing he’s ever done, he couldn’t have foresaw the consequences.

First off, losing the Oscar nominations and making them up was a daft thing to do. He would so obviously be found out, most of his choices were ridiculous, and it would always end in disaster. If that was all he’d done though, it’d place near the bottom here, if at all.

Once he drags BoJack in however, he’s just setting his friend up for an even bigger fall. Typical Mr Peanutbutter, making people happy in the short term with no thought to the consequences.

And those consequences - that word again - are huge. Lying that BoJack was nominated for an Oscar directly sets off a chain of events leading to Sarah Lynn’s death.

Obviously, BoJack and Sarah Lynn herself hold more of the blame. Still, if Mr PB had just done his job, who knows what would’ve happened...