Casting Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Reboot

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine may be sacred, but what if...?

Star Trek Deep Space Nine Reboot
CBS

Nothing at all is sacred in Hollywood but sometimes that isn't the end of the world at all. Star Trek was successfully rebooted in 2009 with JJ Abrams' films, and though Leonard Nimoy, William Shatner, and Deforest Kelly all seemed irreplaceable, the cast in those films was actually spot on. So much so in fact that with the sad passing of Anton Yelchin, there have been many calls to retire the character of Chekov altogether.

While there are many (including this writer) who would take the news of a reboot of Deep Space Nine with... hesitation... that doesn't mean it isn't fun speculating about who could step into those roles if the situation arose!

Now this entire post is entirely a bit of fun speculation - budgeting for these players plays no part in this dream!

For the past several years, television has been enjoying a golden age of high production values and output. Star Trek: Discovery and Star Trek: Picard both look superb, and the animation on Star Trek: Lower Decks is glorious. What is certain is that, if Deep Space Nine were to be rebooted, there would be stunning new depictions of the station, of Bajor, and even the Wormhole itself.

So, take a leap of faith, and let's see who could be manning that lonely station on the edge of the final frontier.

19. General Martok - Brian Blessed

Brian Blessed Flash Gordon
Universal

Yes, this is a slightly older photo.

No, we don't care. If Patrick Stewart can lead a show while in his '80s, then so can Blessed, dammit!

Brian Blessed was made to be a Klingon! He would be the most believable leader of a troupe of Klingon soldiers, single-handedly charging into battle if the need arose. It takes very little imagination to think of him in Klingon gear, with a ridged forehead and an eye patch.

In the attached picture (again proving he is no stranger to science fiction) that smile alone would turn even the bravest Jem'hadar warrior on their heel and send them scurrying back through the Wormhole.

There might not have been a war at all if Blessed had been there.

Food for thought!


18. Vic Fontaine - Michael Buble

Michael Buble The X Files
Fox

Michael Buble would be the perfect choice to take on the role of the crooning lounge singer in Quark's holosuites. His voice is like melted butter and he has acting experience already. The picture above is a still from The X Files - so it wouldn't even be a huge jump for him to arrive in science fiction!

He suits the style of the lounge easily, it is not a stretch to imagine him decked out in a tux and singing to the crew as they toast with a champagne flute. Also, some of the best moments of Deep Space Nine's final season took place in the casino - and Buble would easily slot into that Ocean's Eleven mould.

There is another reason for casting him. It has become something of a running joke that Michael Buble is only let out of his cage when it gets close to Christmas. Wouldn't it be nice to let him sing at other times of the year?


17. Kai Winn - Sarah Paulson

Ratched Sarah Paulson
Netflix

One might see this entry and think 'are they just basing this off the fact that she played Louise Fletcher's most famous role?'

And to that we reply - partly!

Sarah Paulson is just phenomenal in everything she appears in. She dominated Ratched and has been a powerhouse in her various roles in American Horror Story. She can do funny, she can do horror, she can do authority, she can do vulnerability.

Kai Winn is one of the most hateable characters in Deep Space Nine, though she unquestionably believes that she is doing the right thing whenever she does it. Paulson is an actor who can absolutely sell belief in her actions. This would be a fantastic casting win on the part of this fantasy show.


16. Damar - Burn Gorman

The Expanse Season 4 Burn Gorman
Amazon

Glinn/Gul/Legate Damar was fantastically realised by Casey Biggs. The growth that the character goes through is immense throughout the four seasons that he appears in, so taking on that role has to come with a big slice of talent.

Burn Gorman made a splash with his arrival in Torchwood, as the untrustworthy Eoin. While he wasn't a bad guy through and through and there, he certainly knew how to portray an anti-hero. Later, with his roles in Game of Thrones, The Dark Knight Rises and The Expanse, he has showed that he can deliver range.

Damar rises from a sycophant to a resistance leader and portraying that needs to be done carefully. If this fantasy reboot exists in a world of unlimited budgets but presumably shorter series, he will have less time to develop and selling that change needs to be done by an actor who can deliver the goods.

Burn Gorman is certainly that actor!


15. Mads Mikkelsen - Gul Dukat

Rogue One Mads Mikkelsen
LucasFilm

Gul Dukat is probably the most evil single character in all of Star Trek, so getting his casting right needs to be of the highest priority. For you see, Dukat is not simply an evil meglomaniac - he is also, in his own twisted way, a caring father figure for the Bajoran people and a guided leader of the Cardassians.

To display this level of derrangement, one needs look no further than the fantastic - and frightening - Mads Mikkelsen. Anyone who has watched Hannibal need not worry as to whether he can play evil or not.

He can be warm and caring when the situation calls for it, something that Dukat needs to be seen as as well. But having him take on the mantel of the galaxy's greatest despot is an easy choice for this reboot.

Please, CBS!


14. Garak - Christoph Waltz

Inglourious Basterds Hans Landa Christoph Waltz
TWC

While no one would ever dream that Andrew Robinson is not the perfect fit for the Cardassian 'tailor', there is also a very loud contingent of people who will think immediately of Christoph Waltz when searching for an intensely likeable villain.

For Garak is a villain, even if he is playing on the side of the Angels.

Waltz's performances speak for themselves here. He can play both a smaller, cagier role or an out and out, over the top madman. Frankly, both suit the role of Garak perfectly. He needs to be both menacing and coy, engaging and secretive and at all times mysterious. With that smile on display, it is not hard to imagine the person on the receiving end vanishing from the station in the moments that follow!


13. Kassidy Yates - Zoe Kravitz

Zoe Kravitz Divergent
Lionsgate

Zoe Kravitz has been an absolute find in Hollywood recently, not least in her performance in Big Little Lies. She shows cool under pressure, while also displaying a fun and carefree attitude - something that Kassidy should be able to bring to the station.

She will need to work as a counter-balance for Ben Sisko, which Kravitz could certainly achieve. Also, if the idea of switching Jake's character to a female part were to go ahead, Kravitz has already shown that she can be both sisterly and motherly when the situation arises.

There is also a tough streak to her, something that a potential Maquis supplier - but certainly a freighter captain - would need in spades. Penny Johnson may still have our hearts, but Kravitz would most certainly win them over eventually!


12. Weyoun/Brunt - Jeffrey Combs

Star Trek Weyoun
CBS

Sometimes, you just have to accept things as they are. Jeffrey Combs is Weyoun (and Brunt!) and if we can only keep one actor from the original Deep Space Nine (in these arbitrary rules that we have set up....by ourselves) then there is no question at all about who is it that needs to return.

His sinister cool, his suave delivery of lines and along with that - he's just truly bloody evil when he wants to be. Jeffrey Combs knows exactly what frightens you, and he'll smile his way into your nightmares.

Jeffrey Combs, your Star Trek family awaits you!


11. Rom - Stephen Graham

Greyhound Stephen Graham
AppleTV+

Now, this is a very different choice from Max Grodenchik's Rom - but isn't that half the fun of this reboot? There is the feeling that this Rom may not be such an easy push-over, but he could certainly be a much stronger Grand Nagus!

Stephen Graham has been around for quite a while in Hollywood but he's really emerging in recent years for his roles. He can be brutal when he needs to be, something we haven't seen in Rom's character before - but he is also a tender and loving father, something we most certainly have seen and would love to see again with Rom!

His pairing with Toby Jones and Harry Melling would be a great trifecta - pure British talent taking over the promenade!


10. Jake Sisko - Caleb McLaughlin

Stranger Things Lucas
Netflix

Jake Sisko, as played by Cirroc Lofton, was often the core of Ben Sisko's emotional journey - at least in the early years of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine for sure. Both Avery Brooks and Cirroc Lofton have credited the relationship that developed between them as one of their fondest, warmest take-aways from the entire series.

Caleb McLoughlin rose to prominence with his role of Lucas in Netflix's Stranger Things. Along with the rest of the young cast in that show, McLoughlin displayed incredible acting talent from an early age - standing out among his fellow stars as the supremely likable Lucas. His role grew with succeeding seasons.

He has Broadway experience as well (playing Young Simba in The Lion King) so he has already shown a fair amount of versatility. While he is nearly 20 (he was born October 13, 2001), in this age of Riverdale - where all school children look like they have mortgages and three kids - this is hardly a barrier!


9. Nog - Harry Melling

Harry Melling
BBC

Harry Melling has come a very long way since playing Dudley Dursley in the Harry Potter movies. He has shown time and time again that with the right material, he can deliver strong and stand out performances.

He recently offered a supporting role in The Queen's Gambit, the Netflix limited series starring Anna Taylor-Joy. This is another example of his understated, yet multi-faceted, ability to mold, chameleon-like, to any role.

Aron Eisenberg made the role of the first Ferengi in Starfleet his own and he is very lovingly remembered by all Star Trek fans. There will never be another man like him. He is dearly missed and should most definitely be remembered in the performance of any player who takes on the role.


8. Worf - Idris Elba

The Mountain Between Us Idris Elba
Fox

In this reboot, we can change actors. Djimon Hounsou was our choice for The Next Generation reboot, yet for this entry we're going with something a little different.

Yes, we know he has already been in Star Trek! But it doesn't matter, that's half the fun. Several actors have returned to play different roles, and it's been a hoot! Idris Elba is simply one of the coolest people alive on the planet - who wouldn't like to see him in full Klingon make-up?

He has the gravitas, he has the suave. He looks like a man with whom messing should be bloody low on anyone's list.

He's also shown that he can do comedy when the need comes in. Worf was, for a time on Star Trek: The Next Generation, arguably too stuffy and inflexible. Many compilation videos of him being shut down by Picard circulate online - Elba looks like a man who wouldn't find himself in these situations!

It may never happen, but wouldn't it be fun all the same?


7. Quark - Toby Jones

Toby Jones Hunger Games
Fox

To play Quark, an actor needs to be able to express under heavy make-up. Armin Shimerman was the perfect choice for the character as he managed to make the nefarious con artist into a lovable rogue - something that it would be a crying shame to lose as an aspect of the character.

Toby Jones has been knocking it out of the park in his roles throughout his career. While many audiences would have known his voice before his face - he voiced Dobby in the Harry Potter movies - this British actor has certainly got the presence to take charge of a scene.

He knows how to play meek and turn it around. Think of his turn in The Mist, where his mild-mannered shop clerk ends up snapping. He was able to command in Dad's Army and his villainous role of Arnim Zola should be enough to convince people that he can pull off devious when needed.

Bagging him would be a win!


6. Dax - Tessa Thompson

Tessa Thompson Creed
Warner Bros.

Tessa Thompson has been impressing with almost every role that she has delivered to date (let us agree not to speak of Men In Black: International). While she achieved the most widespread acclaim for her role as Valkyrie, she has shown in her other roles that she is flexible in what she can do.

This is essential in playing a Trill character. Not only does the actor have to embody the named character they are playing, but like playing the Doctor in Doctor Who, there must be something of the previous hosts on board as well.

Blu del Barrio is facing that current struggle at the moment in Star Trek: Discovery. Tessa Thompson has shown that she is more than capable of switching it up when the situation calls for it, and it is easy to believe that behind those eyes are several generations of memories and experience.

She could play either Jadzia or Ezri - as long as there is a Dax in the name, it would be great to see!


5. Dr. Bashir - Riz Ahmed

Riz Ahmed Rogue One
LucasFilm

Dr. Julian Bashir is a character combining both English and Middle-Eastern heritage. Alexander Siddig was a fantastic actor in Deep Space Nine, who's Bashir was an example of a man just doing his job and getting along without his race ever being an issue.

That is exactly what the character needs, yet it would also be exciting to explore something of this heritage as well. As the future has shown that, thankfully, the human race has managed to unify itself (for the most part), there have still been many examples of traditional aspects of culture shown throughout the franchise - although this was never truly explored with Bashir.

Riz Ahmed has shown in Rogue One, Venom and Nightcrawler that he has the range to play with already. That is not to say these are his only (nor even his best) roles - but here is an actor with star quality who would be a fantastic addition to the franchise week to week.

Although there is a definite age gap between the choice for O'Brien and Ahmed....does it really matter??


4. Chief O'Brien - Brendan Gleeson

Brendan Gleeson The Guard
Optimum Releasing

Brendan Gleeson can do no wrong. Once again - Brendan Gleeson can do no wrong.

While he would certainly be an older choice to play the Chief than Colm Meaney was back in '87, Brendan Gleeson has the appropriate world-weary presence to more than perfectly play the main engineer on board the station.

How easy is it to imagine him grumbling as the turbolifts break down again and again, or having to fix a computer screen after another fight with the Cardassians? It isn't a stretch to imagine him jumping in a Runabout and chasing a Galor class warship down to make sure they don't cause any more hassle.

Any one of his roles to this point would make for a strong audition reel for Deep Space Nine. He is versatile and highly talented. He would make a fantastic chief!


3. Odo - Peter Capaldi

Doctor Who Hell Bent Peter Capaldi
BBC

Some reading this may be aware that this could not be the first time that Peter Capaldi's name is associated with Star Trek. It is not, in fact, the first time it has been associated with Star Trek: Deep Space Nine!

In 1992, Peter Capaldi auditioned for the role of Commander Sisko, the role which of course went to Avery Brooks instead. Capaldi has done so much in the intervening years that a turn as the stern-but-lovable chief of security would be an exciting move for all concerned.

Think of this: lose the attack eyebrows, but that glare coming from the face of the Changeling? Sold.

While no one could ever replace the great and sadly missed René Auberjonois, Peter Capaldi has both the gravity and the warmth to make the role both his own, and a wonderful tribute.


2. Colonel Kira - Emily Blunt

Emily Blunt Sicario
Lionsgate

Emily Blunt is one of the best actors working in Hollywood today. She has shown a huge range in the roles that she has chosen, proving that she can carry both an emotional lead with an action hero strength as well.

Her turn in Sicario is almost proof enough that the role of a hard-boiled fighter would be second nature to her. Yet Kira is more than just a freedom fighter learning to adapt to the new normal of the Federation alliance. She is also a Bajoran who wants what is best for her people.

It is crucial that Kira be a sympathetic character to the audience. Where some shows fall is that they pigeonhole their characters into a small box, effectively having them be one thing rather than all of the things.

Give this woman a decent script and watch gold unfurl on-screen.


1. Captain Sisko - Sterling K. Brown

This Is Us Sterling K Brown
NBC

Sterling K. Brown is one of the most impressive actors to grace screens in the past few years. He was excellent as the lawyer Christopher Darden in Ryan Murphy's The People vs. OJ Simpson, and of course he is in Emmy award winning form in NBC's This Is Us.

With his gravitas, but good humour, he would be well placed as the leader of the last space station before the wilderness. He has shown on many occasions that he is more than capable of controlling the scene around him. Think of some of those confrontations with the Dominion - Brown would be excellent in a stand-off against the Cardassians.

But he also displays a vulnerability that is key to humanizing Sisko. One of Deep Space Nine's most successful themes was that of family and having Jake Sisko (or another character - Jake need not be a son) is crucial. Again, Brown has shown he can go straight for the heartstrings of an audience time and again. One needs only to watch an episode of This Is Us to see that!


Watch Next


How Well Do You Know Star Trek Deep Space Nine Season 1?

Star Trek Dax And Bashir
CBS Media Ventures

1. What Class Of Federation Starship Delivers Dax And Bashir To Deep Space Nine?

Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"