Casting Star Trek: Voyager Reboot

What might Star Trek: Voyager look like today?

Voyager Julianne Moore Seven of Nine
Paramount

Following on from our Star Trek: The Next Generation and Star Trek: Deep Space Nine fantasy castings, we here have decided that the next Star Trek series we'd like to have a bit of fun with is Star Trek: Voyager! Voyager was a pioneering iteration of Star Trek, with Kate Mulgrew in the lead as the fearless Captain Janeway. There was a great variety in the rest of the crew, leading to one of the most diverse casts in Star Trek history.

That is a spirit that we very much want to retain. Now, this is obviously simply a fun 'what if?' type of scenario. Although we won't be casting anyone who has shuffled off this mortal coil, we will also not be hindering ourselves with such silly considerations as, you know, budgets!

We have scoured the casting pages for those who we think would actually bring something fresh and exciting to these roles, while also keeping the spirit of the original in place. With that, here is our list of the perfect actors for a modern day Star Trek: Voyager reboot.

12. Seska - Noomi Rapace

Voyager Seska Rapace
Paramount/FOX

Seska is of course the turncoat Cardassian infiltrator, assigned to spy on Chakotay's Maquis cell. Once she finds herself flung across the galaxy, she quickly reveals herself and escapes to work with Voyager's enemies.

Knowing that she is a spy does nothing to affect the rewatch, and Martha Hackett did a fantastic job of bringing the shady character to life. To capture this fully, the new actor needs to be able to switch from deeply trustworthy to out and out villain on a whim.

Noomi Rapace of course burst onto screens in the Swedish versions of The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo series. Since then, she has appeared in many other roles, with Prometheus being one of her biggest to date.

She is able to play both vulnerable and terrifying, displaying a power that suggests one should absolutely not mess with her.

She would be a fantastic addition to this fantasy reboot!


11. Icheb - Noah Schnapp

Voyager Icheb Noah Schnapp
Paramount/Netflix

Icheb was originally played by Manu Intirayami, who revealed recently that the character was the polar opposite to how he identified at the time. He was delighted to be allowed to expand the role as he was continually brought back, as there is something very interesting in how a Borg child adapts to life again.

Noah Schnapp is of course best known as Will Byers in Stranger Things. From the first season, he has had to do a lot of the heavy lifting when it comes to the male cast, battling the demigorgon and Mindflayer as he has. He has continually risen to the challenge and continues to impress.

To see him adjusting to life again, guided by our pick for Seven of Nine, would be a fantastic opportunity to again delve into the psychology of being torn from the Collective, through the eyes of a child.

We can only hope that this Icheb has a slightly happier fate.


10. Kes - Lili Reinhart

Voyager Kes Lili Reinhart
Paramount/The CW

One of two Riverdale cast members to feature here, Lili Reinhart would make an excellent choice for a rebooted (and hopefully FAR better written) version of Kes. The Ocampan character was poorly written from the beginning in Star Trek: Voyager, with the show not really knowing what to do with her. Unfortunately, Jennifer Lien who played her was fired after three seasons.

Kes is a fascinating idea of a character. Living for only nine years, every element of life must be lived to the fullest as she quite literally doesn't have the time to spare. This could lead, not only to great comedy, but great tragedy as well. How does one find their calling in life, when these things often take years to master?

Reinhart has starred in Riverdale since the beginning of the show. As Betty Cooper, she has been everything from a reporter, to a dancer, a gang member and very nearly a murder victim. While Riverdale is absolutely bonkers, it has delivered again and again on the concept. If Kes were treated as suggested above, Reinhart has shown that she is maleable enough to jump through the hoops that would be set down in front of her.


9. Neelix - Eric Stonestreet

VOYAGER NEELIX ERIC STONESTREET
Paramount/ABC

The character of Neelix, as played by Ethan Phillips, has been a slightly polarizing one with fans. As written, his infectious optimism has often been criticized. He has been called annoying on more than one occasion! However, he is arguably one of the most essential characters on the show.

Neelix is both a guide and the morale officer aboard the USS Voyager. To truly capture that, an actor needs to display both a wisdom, yet a playful energy in the part. Eric Stonestreet is perhaps best known for portraying Cameron Tucker on Modern Family, one half of the same-sex married couple alongside Jesse Tyler-Ferguson.

His upbeat optimism and hilarious line delivery have shown that he can absolutely deliver when it comes to the comedic side of Neelix, yet he has also shown that he can play both sweet and serious as well. He has appeared in several movies, along with other roles in television series.

While he may disappear beneath the Talaxian make-up, there is no question that Stonestreet would bring a wonderful joy to the show!


8. Harry Kim - Charles Melton

VOYAGER HARRY KIM JAMES MELTON
Paramount/The CW

Charles Melton is an American-Korean actor who has risen to prominence thanks to his role in Riverdale, where he plays Reggie Mantel. He took over the role from Ross Butler, when the latter had to leave the show due to his commitments to 13 Reasons Why. Since then, Melton has quickly established himself as one of the most intriguing actors on the show.

His star is just beginning to rise. He has starred in his first film (The Sun Is Also A Star). To play Harry Kim, he brings not only the confidence that he has displayed in his other roles, but also his youth.

Harry Kim, dubbed the forever Ensign due to his absolutely inability to get a promotion, is an essential member of the crew on Star Trek: Voyager. He is often the one to save the day, even if he never truly believes in himself. While the rest of the crew come to depend on him, he still finds himself the butt of many of their jokes.

Knowing now how popular the character was, it would make sense to give him more screentime this time around. Last time, the character was nearly written out at the end of the third season. Charles Melton, with his screen presence and popularity, is more likely to bring more and more (and younger!) fans to the show.


7. Tom Paris - Miles Teller

Voyager Tom Parris Miles Teller
Paramount/20th Century Fox

Miles Teller is one of the best actors of the last ten years of cinema. He seriously impressed with his turn in Whiplash, while also standing out in War Dogs. The critical and commerical flop that was Fantastic Four wasn't down to his performance - he was actually quite good in the part!

Tom Paris has to walk the line between both likable and questionable. He's not quite the bad boy of the ship, but he does need to show rebellious tendencies. To capture the spirit, he needs to have almost failed his way up the ladder. When Janeway recruits him, it is because he is a great pilot - not because of his service record.

Teller has shown the right level of snark in his roles to be able to be a bit of an annoyance, while not truly crossing over into the land of truly unlikable. He has also shown that he can play buddy roles well - something that will be essential when doing his scenes with Harry Kim.

Plus - anyone who saw the determination with which he played those drums in Whiplash will never question whether or not this man could get the ship up and away from a fleet of Borg Cubes!


6. The Doctor - Stanley Tucci

Voyager The Doctor Stanley Tucci
Paramount/Marvel

The Doctor, as activated in Caretaker, is an irrasicble character who takes some time to warm to the rest of the crew. As he was only meant for short term use, there was no particular need to give him a personality. However, over the seven seasons of the show, it was clear that there was a lot for the holographic character to add, so casting a charismatic actor makes the most sense.

Stanley Tucci is one of those actors who is simply brilliant in everything he is in. That is not to say he hasn't appeared in a few stinkers (The Silence) but he can generally raise the class of any piece he is in, simply by showing up.

Were he to appear in the blue uniform, one only needs to think of some of his cutting remarks from The Devil Wears Prada to imagine his bedside manner. But he has shown so many warm and caring performances as well throughout his career, it is very simple to imagine The Doctor's softer moments with Tucci in the role as well.

One hopes that in this fantasy reboot, he receives his mobile emitter sooner rather than later, as confining this man to one set only would be a crying shame!


5. B'Elanna Torres - Ana De Armas

Voyager B Elanna Torres Ana De Armas
Paramount/Warner Bros.

Ana De Armas rose to prominence with her turn as Joi in Denis Villeneuve's Blade Runner 2049. She beautifully captured the hologram, presenting a warm and loving partner for Ryan Gosling's K. She is of Cuban-American descent, is fluent in Spanish (she acted in several Spanish language productions) and is continuing to impress with wonderful starring roles - not least being her appearance in Knives Out.

She would be perfect for the fiery half-Klingon chief engineer. B'Elanna Torres is a character who is ripe for a deeper exploration of where she comes from and what drives her. In Star Trek: Voyager, though her lineage is often spoken-about, it is predominantly her Klingon side that is favoured over her human side.

The episode Lineage is a notable exception, though does not go far enough to truly display the dichotomy of her. In this new-era of Klingons, ala Star Trek: Discovery, it would be extremely interesting to see how this split is represented in the character. While the producers of this fantasy series may not opt for full Disco-Klingon make up, having Torres be both more alien yet more curious about her humanity is something that we would be delighted to see.

Ana De Armas would be, in our opinion, absolutely perfect for this role.


4. Tuvok - Charlie Barnett

Voyager Seven Of Nine Anja Taylor Joy
Paramount/20th Century Studios

Tuvok is one of the most interesting characters in Star Trek: Voyager. He was the first Vulcan that we had truly seen in a starring role since the days of Spock, and Tim Russ played the part perfectly. He was able to balance the curt nature of the security chief with the caring soul that lay just underneath the logic.

Charlie Barnett has been rising to fame over the past decade in a variety of roles. He appeared in the fantastic Netflix series Russian Doll, along with You and, most prominently, Chicago Fire.

Although he is quite a bit younger than our choice for Captain Janeway, the ageless nature of Vulcans means that this shouldn't make any difference. Tuvok and Janeway have a bond that goes beyond service, something that Barnett would be more than capable of delivering on.

He is also no stranger to fantasy and science fiction, as he was cast in the final season of Arrow as well. He is certainly one of Hollywood's up and coming actors working today and would be a great choice for the cast.


3. Seven Of Nine - Anya Taylor-Joy

Voyager Seven Of Nine Anja Taylor Joy
Paramount/20th Century Studios

Anya Taylor-Joy burst onto the scene with Robert Egger's The Witch, a dark and atmospheric period horror that showed her as more than capable of carrying a film as the star. Since then, she has continued to impress in Split and its sequel, Glass, Thoroughbreds, The Secret of Marrowbone and most recently in Netflix's The Queen's Gambit.

Seven of Nine, originated by Jeri Ryan, is of course back in Star Trek, appearing in Star Trek: Picard. Therefore, this recasting falls completely into the realm of fantasy. But, if this was to happen, Taylor-Joy has quickly emerged as one of the most fascinating actors of recent times.

She has the ability to make the audience care deeply for her, while being able to show the less savoury side of her characters as well. Seven of Nine, recovering from her time with the Borg, has made highly questionable choices in how she deals with others. There is an element of stand-offishness that anyone needs to bring to the role.

Taylor-Joy has talent in spades, showing time and time again how much she can bring to a project. She would make an excellent drone and a stellar Seven.


2. Chakotay - Gil Birmingham

Voyager Chakotay Gil Birmingham
Paramount

Robert Beltran has gone on record several times to voice his dissatisfaction with how Chakotay was handled in Star Trek: Voyager. To be fair, he has a point. From the beginning, the writers attempted to use his Native American character to show a spiritualism in Star Trek still exists, but this was used less and less until it seemed to fizzle out altogether.

Gil Birmingham may be best known to audiences for his role in all five of the Twilight films. Don't let that put you off though - he is an incredibly talented actor. His turn in Wind River would banish any doubt about this.

Chakotay need not be defined by his Native ancestry, yet if it is to be addressed, then it needs to be done in such a way that isn't pandering, nor exploitative. In Voyager, there are episodes which feature the 'spirits' that his people worshipped, who are shown to be aliens. This mixing of alien and human natures is something that deserved deeper exploration.

While Chakotay was relegated somewhat to the odd anecdote about his heritage, there is ample amounts of material to bring forward for him to not only be an essential member of the crew, but have Native American history and experiences on full show, rather than simply teased.


1. Captain Janeway - Julianne Moore

Voyager Janeway Julianne Moore
Paramount/FOX

Few who have seen Julianne Moore act could doubt that she would easily, and convincingly, step into the role of captain of a Starship. She is capable of both high drama and intense comedy, with all of the range in between to bring something truly special to the part.

When Kate Mulgrew was cast as Kathryn Janeway, she did a phenomenal job with absolutely no notice whatsoever. She replaced Genevieve Bujold, who had left the role after a mere two days. Therefore, she certainly made the role her own, rather than having the writers work with her (initially) to craft the perfect part for her.

Janeway, in the early episodes, was a very ill-defined character - other than a strong leader. She is leading a ship, many thousands of light years from home - she needs to be in charge, but she needs to be vulnerable. One thing that Star Trek: Discovery has done well in season three is to show the trauma that the crew are experiencing, lost in time as they are.

Julianne Moore has many examples of powerful performances. She was a leader in Children of Men, a despairing mother and wife in The Hours and a highly-strung celebrity in Maps to the Stars. She was a fantastic replacement for Jodie Foster, taking over the role of Clarice Starling in Hannibal as well.

She could easily lead the team, though it is very easy to imagine her relaxing around her trusted lieutenants and allowing the audience to see what lies beneath.


Watch Next


Star Trek Quiz: What Colour Uniform Did They Wear?

Captain Kirk TOS Star Trek
CBS

1. What Color Did Captain James T. Kirk Wear In The Original Series, As Seen In "The Trouble With Tribbles"

Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"