Doctor Who: 10 Most Heart-Breaking Moments

doctor In 2005, the BBC rejuvenated the Doctor Who franchise for the first time in nine years. The Doctor, a 900-year old alien from the planet Gallifrey, sidled alongside new companions to fight against classic foes from the 60s and 70s like the Daleks and Cybermen. New arch villains were introduced like the Weeping Angels, statuesque creatures who kill you buy sending you to the past and feeding off the energy of your unused life, and the Silence, memorably forgettable creatures who have made Sharpie marks on your arms more terrifying than waking up with a scrotum drawn on your forehead. Tom Baker's multi-colored scarf has been traded out for leather jackets, then converses, and now bow-ties, fezzes and cowboy hats. Though legendary adventures and terror abound in Doctor Who, one aspect of the show that remains steadfast throughout is heartache. The isolation of the Doctor, the last surviving member of his species who perished in the great Time War, should be enough to lead any man to claim "no, I just have something in both of my eyes at the same time," but throw in some companions with their own troubles and you have a recipe for one hell of a Fez-wearing tear-gas bomb. So grab your handkerchiefs and TARDIS-shaped mugs and let's find out the saddest moments of the new Who.

10. Kylie Minogue

As one of WhatCulture's American writers, I've never been all too familiar with Kylie Minogue. She had that song that I couldn't get out of my head, and apparently she's been on soap operas in Australia in the past. What I actually remember most about her was that when she performed on Saturday Night Live, Sir Ian McKellen sat at the front corner of the stage and watched her sing from two feet away. She also seems adorably tiny; in fact, there's a decent chance she's actually hiding in my coat pocket right now. Seriously, she's like three apples tall. I've never been a huge fan of the Doctor Who Christmas specials. In comparison to the serial episodes, they tend to miss out on the bond the Doctor has with his companions that make the show so compelling. And then there was Astrid Peth. In the Christmas special Voyage of the Damned, Minogue plays the waitress the Doctor befriends. They travel from the spaceship to earth, and Astrid alludes to wanting to travel the universe. And, having serendipitously befriended the Doctor on his travels, it would seem that her wishes might be fulfilled. But, as always, crap goes awry when Max Capricorn and his Angel Hosts stage a terrorist attack on the ship, the aptly named Titanic. Before the Doctor can be harmed, Astrid pulls an Ellen Ripley-esque move and uses a forklift to kill Capricorn, sacrificing her own life in the process. We find that she has a teleport bracelet on, but cannot be regenerated in a physical form. The Doctor shares a kiss with her shimmering silhouette before she dissipates into stardust, free to float around the universe and loco-mote back to the top of the pop charts.

9. The Girl in the Fireplace

the girl in the fire place I know there's a Series Six episode called The Girl Who Waited, but Reinette, the 18th Century Frenchwoman will always be the girl who waited to me. Reinette first meets the Tenth Doctor as a child when the Doctor and companions investigate an abandoned spaceship. The Doctor steps away from Reinette seconds for what seems like only seconds, but he returns to find her now months older. He is forced to take leave of her again to protect her from the clown-android living under her bed. When he returns a second time, he's surprised but pleased to find Reinette now looks strikingly similar to Sophia Myles. Reinette is now Madame de Pompadour, the mistress of King Louis XV, a man who took the throne at age of five and became famous for... well, I'm not a scholar but I think his greatest achievement was Madame de Pompadour. Of course in the Doctor Who universe, things go awry as the mandroids try to use Reinette's brainpower to re-power their ship. The Doctor saves Reinette by horseback and leaves, promising to return. When he arrives for his final visit with Reinette, he learns she had passed away many years prior. He pockets a letter she wrote him, where she states that against all reason she believes her lonely angel will visit her once more before passing. (Spoilers: he doesn't).

8. Peter Tyler

petertyler In the Series One episode Father's Day, the Ninth Doctor and Rose go back to the 1980s to the day Rose's father was killed by a car. Rose, still an infant at the time of the accident, never knew her father. The first time she sees him on the side of the road as he lays dying, Rose is frozen, unable to approach him in his final moments. They try another time, only now Rose pushes her father out of the way, saving his life but creating a paradox. The other time traveling copy of the Doctor and Rose disappear, and large dragon-like creatures called Reapers descend and begin devouring the townsfolk. reaper The paradox gets doubly bad as, inside the save haven of a church, Peter throws infant Rose into adult Rose's arms. His wife also assumes adult Rose is a hussy that Peter is having an affair with, for a little Greek mythology flair. In order to undo the time paradox, Peter realizes that the linchpin of the universe is his death. He runs out into the street, getting run over by a car, righting the universe again and ruining some poor innocent driver's day.

7. Oswin

Doctor Who - Series 7 In the Series 7 premier Asylum of the Daleks, The Doctor and his companions are lured into the Parliament of the Daleks. They inform him of the asylum they send their post-traumatic stressed compatriots to, as even the Daleks fear these mad machines. Instead of trying to exterminate the doctor, they have now acquired him for assistance in de-activating the force field protecting the planet so that they can destroy it before the insane Daleks escape. While on his journey, the Doctor intercepts a message consisting of portions of the opera Carmen. He ultimately discovers that the message is from a foxy young lady named Oswin Oswald, a sharp-tongued crash survivor who has been stranded on the planet for a year, successfully avoiding being morphed into a Dalek like other visitors of the planet and biding her time by cooking souffles. Oswin, played by the current companion Jenna-Louise Coleman, is charming and demonstrates a quick-witted back and forth rapport with the Doctor instantly. A brilliant mind, Oswin is also the key to unlocking the force field which will successfully conclude the Doctor's mission. When the Doctor, with the aid of Oswin, manages to evade the onslaught of Daleks and reach Oswin's chamber, he's devastated to find that she is not who she believes she is. The Oswin she once was had since been transformed into a Dalek; it was only through her sheer will to live that she maintained her last shreds of humanity. The end is bittersweet, as Oswin's demise is a tragic one. But as the audience, we know that the success of this character is a good omen for future episodes with Number 11 and his new companion. And good god, those dimples.

6. Van Gogh's Legacy

doctor who pait I'm not exactly an art aficionado, but I know enough about it to know that Vincent Van Gogh was not what you might call a happy dude. The man cut off his own ear and give it to a hooker (though history is uncertain if this was in the form of a gift or payment for goods or services rendered). He also shot himself in the chest, only to survive and walk himself into town. He died the next day, with his last words supposedly being "The sadness will last forever." Just some heavy, heavy s**t. The Vincent in the Series 5 episode Vincent and the Doctor is portrayed by Tony Curran as an unexpectedly somber and depressed individual. He is also being associated with a string of murders that, given the Doctor's presence, are more likely to have been committed by some alien creature. Vincent's keen eye and attention to detail help save the Doctor and Amy Pond. Prior to their departure, he makes another characteristically socially awkward move by proposing to Pond. She shoots him down of course, but before they leave him, the Doctor takes Van Gogh into the future to see that his life's work is not forgotten. Van Gogh's tearful reaction is a heart-breakingly sweet moment in the life of a man who's felt so much pain. Of course, the real tragedy of the story is that in real life it is highly unlikely that a two-hearted alien took Vincent Van Gogh time traveling to an art museum of the future.

5. The Doctor and Wilf

doctor who wilf I think if you happen to run into a wide-eyed older man who sells newspapers on the corner and seems to perennially wear a winter cap with antlers budding from it, you might think he's a little off. And when he begins ranting about his times star-gazing and alien lifeforms on earth, you might be convinced of it. But Wilf, Donna Noble's grandfather, manages to avoid all the normal traps seen with conspiracy theorist whackos. He's sweet and (like his daughter's married name) noble, and after Donna's memory is erased Wilf is perhaps the one person who understands the Doctor the best. In the End of Time Part II, The Tenth Doctor and Wilfred find themselves in traps set by both The Master and the Time Lord President played by Dalton, Timothy Dalton. Wilfred, locked in an isolation chamber awaiting a lethal dose of radiation, can only be saved by the sacrifice of another. The Doctor and Wilfred have a Mexican stand-off of self-sacrifice, each believing their life worth to be inferior to their companion. The Doctor ultimately receives the fatal blast of radiation, stating this sacrifice would be his honor. Wilf shouldn't have felt so bad since humans die and Doctors just regenerate. Anything else by Number Ten would've just been plain rude. Wilfred's encounter with the Doctor leads right into #4...

4. Number 10 Doesn't Want To Go

doctor The final moments of the aforementioned episode show the Tenth Doctor trudging along the world a dying Time Lord. He saves Sarah Jane Smith's son from dying, protects Martha Jones and Mickey from being shot, visits Rose Tyler before she's met the Ninth Doctor, and gets Captain Jack laid. Like he needed any help. That is a beautiful, beautiful man. The Ninth Doctor's exit was full of brash exuberance, claiming that while Rose was "absolutely fantastic", so was he. The Tenth Doctor, portrayed by David Tennant, is less upbeat about his impending demise. As he watches his injured body begin to regenerate, the Doctor reflects on his recent past with his three companions and says to himself "I don't want to go" before exploding into a ball of energy. Number Ten is reincarnated as Matt Smith. He's instantly appalled at his chin size but quickly becomes comfortable with a wardrobe of bow-ties and a brand new sassy redhead to follow him around. And speaking of sassy redheads, let's check out number #3...

3. Donna's Loss

tate 2 The final episode of Series 4 Journey's End pulls out all the big stars to fight Davros, the creator of the Daleks. We again bump into Mickey, Martha Jones, Rose and the parallel universe Doctor. There's also the Tenth Doctor's severed hand, which interacts with Donna Noble in a manner fit for a Stan Lee serial from the '50s. Donna, through electrocution by Davros, has her own genetic makeup combined with the Doctor's to form DoctorDonna (which incidentally some people absurdly refer to as "the REAL Eleventh Doctor"). But having a Time Lord inside your head isn't all it's cracked up to be. Donna's mind short-circuits, like someone who was just forced to sit through a couple Zack Snyder movies with toothpicks holding their eyelids open. But unlike people who were tricked into seeing that garbage film 300 in the theater, Donna's mind is fortuitously wiped clean; of course, her real tragedy is not that she also saw Sucker Punch, but that all of her memories of travels with the Doctor are gone forever.

2. Amy's Goodbye

Arthur Darvill put it best on his Twitter account the evening the final episode featuring The Ponds aired, saying only "Best of luck cry babies." rory Any audience member who'd paid attention at all knew that this was the final Amy-and-Rory episode. And for the less observant, it's spelled out quite blatantly in the book chapter titled Amy's Last Farewell. The episode follows Rory as he is cast back into the early 20th century Manhattan by the notorious foes the Weeping Angels. The Doctor, Rory, Amy and a broken-wristed River Song elude the Angels and trek to an apartment building, entering a room labeled with Rory's name. In a flashback to the earlier episode Blink, we watch as the aged version of Rory dies in his bed. Amy is crushed, but adamantly refuses to accept this version of reality. Amy and Rory jump together off of the rooftop, committing to either create a paradox to erase this version of history or die, albeit together. The end of the episode sees the group walking through a graveyard in the modern day. The Doctor and River clean the TARDIS and joke around. A happy ending. Then another angel comes from behind Rory, again sending him to the past. The nearby tombstone has Rory's name etched on it. Amy, crying, steps in front of the angel to again be sent back to Rory. The Doctor screams at Amy as she turns away from the angel to be sent back in time to be with Rory forever, as she's supposed to be. S***, is it dusty in this office or is it just me?

1. Number Ten Tells Rose That He...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JvkjthzlyV8 I think everyone saw this one coming. The Tenth Doctor is forced to abandon our beloved Rose Tyler in an alternate universe and we watch as they try to communicate one last time by a holographic version of Skype. Unfortunately, the connection isn't the best and it cuts out at a somewhat inopportune time. I don't even have anything clever or witty to say about this one. If Shakespeare were alive, and I have it on good authority that he may be, he would take Romeo and Juliet and re-title it Rose and the Doctor. Are there any heart-wrenching moments from the Doctor that I've missed? There's no need to sonic-screwdriver the article, just comment below or shoot me a message @BeastDuels on Twitter

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Nick Fulton hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.