Doctor Who Regenerations: Ranked From Worst To Best

The times they are a-changin'.

For Doctor Who fans, nothing is quite so bittersweet as a regeneration. Not only do you have to say goodbye to one Doctor, a man you've come to know and love over the course of his adventures, but you also have to say hello to a strange new face that you're somehow not quite sure of. The Doctor's habit of changing is one of the reasons fans love the show - a regeneration can often give the story a much needed shot in the arm and make for some interesting onscreen conflict. While this may be the case, fans are often worried that the change will be a negative one and that the new Doctor will never be your Doctor. However, one thing that can ease this transition for fans is if the outbound Doctor leaves in a scene which is in someway moving or memorable. The regeneration scene is a Doctor Who staple and is a key component of the wonderful eccentricities which make up the show fans love. This is why it's so important that those making the show get it absolutely right. The tenth Doctor's first regeneration won't be counted on this list, simply because it didn't involve a change of lead actor. So without further ado, click forward to take a look at some of the best (and worst) regenerations in Who history (so far)...


12. The Sixth Doctor To The Seventh Doctor

One of the worst regenerations to ever grace our screens, the Sixth Doctor's regeneration into his seventh incarnation was less than impressive. Having been unceremoniously replaced, Colin Baker (quite rightly) refused to shoot a regeneration scene and so helpful old Sylvester McCoy offered to don a blonde wig and play both the Sixth and newly regenerated Seventh Doctors. While fans only have a brief glimpse of the newly deceased Sixth Doctor, it's quite clearly not Colin Baker and thus, completely ruins the moment. Furthermore, the less than heroic final moments given to the Sixth Doctor just don't do him justice. In life, the Sixth Doctor had been dramatic and bombastic, heroic and brave (if a little difficult at times). Unfortunately, his death is glossed over and he was swept from our screens and under the rug. A truly shameful regeneration indeed, Doctor. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4_OT2obe710

11. The War Doctor To The Ninth Doctor

While the 50th Anniversary special gave fans so many wonderful moments over which to, ahem, 'squee', there were a few moments which could've gone just a step further in order to give fans the ultimate experience. Admittedly, The Day of the Doctor was a wonderful story and showcased some truly stellar performances with enough fan-service to keep even the most ardent of fanboys happy and, while it was like Christmas come early, it's difficult not to feel cheated by the War Doctor's regeneration. If this had been omitted and left to the imagination, fans would probably have thought no more of it, however it's inclusion meant that for a brief moment on 23rd November 2013, thousands and thousands of viewers thought - if only for a split second - that Christopher Eccleston had actually shot a scene for the special and was going to appear at any moment after all. Suffice to say, when the scene cuts away shortly after the Ninth Doctor's eyes appear, hopes were certainly dashed. Damn. A cool moment, definitely, but just a little bit disappointing in hindsight. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yDYSiERa50s

10. The Second Doctor To The Third Doctor

Perhaps one of the most trippy regenerations seen on screen, the Second Doctor's final bow came at the hands of the Time Lords. Standing trial for his meddling in time, the Second Doctor is forced to regenerate and begin exile on Earth. During the course of the trial, fans see the Doctor being offered several new faces to choose from - none of which particularly please him. After the Doctor bemoans his options, the Time Lords make the choice for him. What happens next is a bizarre visual feast of Patrick Troughton's head being multiplied, spinning round, and gurning as the screen eventually fades to black. Simply one of the most alienating regenerations due to the lack of actual transition, this is perhaps one of the weirdest exits taken by a lead actor in Doctor Who. That said, Troughton's performance leading up to his regeneration is brilliant to say the least. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XjIZPl3ABXo

9. The Fifth Doctor To The Sixth Doctor

Another slightly trippy regeneration now. The Fifth Doctor's swansong The Caves of Androzani is often touted one of the all time greatest Doctor Who stories, and rightly so. In the final moments of the story, the Fifth Doctor and Peri have succumbed to spectrox poisoning and barely make it back to the TARDIS in time for the Doctor to bravely sacrifice himself and save Peri's life by giving her the last of the bat's milk antidote. A sudden transition, this scene serves as a reminder that regeneration can be a particularly troubling and uncomfortable experience for a Time Lord and Colin Baker's frenetic, prickly introduction reminds viewers of how such a traumatic change can seriously affect a Time Lord's mind and personality. The quick regeneration and the abrasive nature of the Sixth Doctor makes for a jarring transition which, unfortunately, alienated many viewers. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qvAenK95PfQ

8. The First Doctor To The Second Doctor

One of the most defining moments of Doctor Who history was when Doctor regenerated for the very first time. Perhaps the most peaceful regeneration seen on screen, the First Doctor simply faded away and in his place was the newly regenerated Second Doctor. While the sheer audacity of recasting your lead actor and explaining it as part of his alien biology is utterly inspired and did, indeed, give us much of the show fans know and love today, it's also a little anti-climactic when it gets down to it. Modern fans may well be used to explosive and dramatic regenerations and thus, this first tentative transition seems a little dull in comparison. It was the 60s. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pmXoHKzp4Lc

7. The Seventh Doctor To The Eighth Doctor

Events were made 100% canon in the 1996 Doctor Who TV movie by showing the on screen regeneration from the Seventh Doctor to the Eighth. While this was terribly sporting of McCoy to come onboard for what is, essentially, a short cameo, it's a real shame that his Doctor had to go in such an anticlimactic way. Gunned down in his apparent prime, the Seventh Doctor is killed either by the gunshots or by the confusion of the surgeons trying to save his life. Either way, this is a death unbefitting of a Time Lord and the regeneration that follows is often as maligned as the Seventh Doctor's exit. In a manner not dissimilar to the Second Doctor's regeneration, this transition seems to be based around McCoy's elastic face and his ability to gurn 'til the cows come home. The Frankenstein imagery, though interesting, seems a little misplaced and so the thunder and lightning gives an odd juxtaposition to who fans know the Doctor to be. Furthermore, the transition, essentially, is fairly swift and happens while the Doctor is technically dead. A slightly... disturbing regeneration, certainly... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cKRa06hP6vc

6. The Third Doctor To The Fourth Doctor

Another swift yet peaceful regeneration, the Third Doctor shares a few tender words with Sarah Jane before lapsing into unconsciousness after he absorbed 10 years of radiation poisoning after getting lost in the time vortex. The Brigadier utters the famous words "Here we go again..." as Jon Pertwee's "old grey model" fades away to reveal the bonkers bonce that is Tom Baker. While the regeneration is subtle, it is perhaps one of the most memorable of classic Doctor Who. The lack of drama and tension makes for a scene which allows fans to experience the sadness in losing such a wonderful Doctor in Jon Pertwee and then rejoice in gaining one of the most definitive actors to have ever taken on the role. The effects, aged though they may be, manage to hold to up to today's standards due to their inherent simplicity and so the scene is just as enjoyable today as it was back in 1974. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=snl6LqFrr1A

5. The Tenth Doctor To The Eleventh Doctor

The Tenth Doctor's final moments not only made a number of fans cry but he also ended up blabbing himself. The Doctor's teary regeneration in this divisive scene is a topic which causes hot debate to this day amongst die hard fans. While the Doctor's apparent upset at having to regenerate seems out of place, given that it's been established that throughout each regeneration the Doctor still is, at heart(s), the same man, it was, perhaps Russell T Davies' tendency to make the Tenth Doctor into a messianic figure which inspired his infamous final words "I don't want to go...". In addition to this, the regeneration itself is literally explosive and leads to the Eleventh Doctor spending his first moments crash landing the TARDIS into Amelia Pond's garden. The transition, though not particularly soothing for fans, is a swift and punchy change which lends a great deal of drama to the occasion. Whether you loathe or love Tennant's final scene at the helm of the show, it's certainly memorable. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sVEY5AL5zzk

4. The Eighth Doctor To The War Doctor

Since Doctor Who was revived in 2005, fans had been crying to see a regeneration from the Eighth Doctor to the newly cast ninth... While 2013's The Night Of The Doctor didn't give Whovians quite what they'd been craving, they did get a wonderful minisode crammed full of fan service which ramped up the hype for the 50th anniversary even more. Having crash landed during the Time War, the Eighth Doctor finds himself on Karn. The resident Sisterhood manage to bring him back to life temporarily and allow the Doctor to choose what he needs to be in his next incarnation.As a result of this, fans were treated to a regeneration which introduced the wonderful John Hurt as the War Doctor. This regeneration not only gave desperate fans a sense of continuity between classic and modern Doctor Who but it also allowed for a great deal of fan service in the process. The regeneration itself isn't actually seen on screen but viewers were just happy to see Paul McGann as the Doctor again. It had been far too long. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ylI5ZrmkkOM

3. The Eleventh Doctor To The Twelfth Doctor

Perhaps one of the most shocking regenerations to have graced our screens, the Eleventh Doctor went out in a suitably epic style. Having been gifted a new regeneration cycle by the Time Lords, the severely aged Eleventh Doctor takes down the enemies of Christmas and makes his way back to the TARDIS. When Clara finds him again, fans see the Doctor is back to his youthful good looks thanks to his body 'resetting' prior to the regeneration. The fact that the Eleventh Doctor died of old age is beautiful, poetic, and generally fitting of Matt Smith's tenure aboard the TARDIS. His run started as a fairytale and it certainly ended as one, too. Perhaps even more poignant is the speech delivered by the Eleventh Doctor prior to the transition. This regeneration succeeds in being sentimental without being too cloying which is where some fans believe David Tennant and Russell T Davies fell down. The transition itself is a wonderfully jarring snap change which suddenly, and shockingly, introduced audiences to the quintessentially different Peter Capaldi. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4F84WapAH7M

2. The Ninth Doctor To The Tenth Doctor

The regeneration which introduced the concept to a whole new generation of fans, the Ninth Doctor breathed his last in the finale of the first series of NuWho. Both witty and moving, the Ninth Doctor's final moments gave audiences a real insight into how confusing the process can be for companions and just how alienated one might feel if your best friend suddenly changed everything about them before your very eyes. Eccleston, Piper and Tennant all provide stellar performances during this scene which makes for one of the most impressive regeneration scenes in the show's history. Eccleston's last moments in the show give him some truly memorable lines and gave young fans a very bittersweet experience in losing their first Doctor, but gaining a whole new one that would go on to become a firm fan favourite. This scene also introduced the style of regeneration which would be used pretty consistently since. The explosive light effects make for a more dramatic image than previous incarnations had experienced and finally lent the process a real dramatic punch, making it a much more visceral and violent act. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qa3NM9Jhkn0

1. The Fourth Doctor To The Fifth Doctor

One of the all time greatest Doctors, Tom Baker's incarnation of the Time Lord met his end foiling the Master's plans once again. Having fallen from a great height, the Doctor learns that the suspicious and ghostly Watcher was his future self all along. While the regeneration itself is a little odd, with the Watcher melding with the Doctor, fading away and revealing Peter Davison underneath, it makes for some truly entertaining (if surreal) viewing. Marking the end of the fourth Doctor's era, this regeneration is a fitting conclusion to Tom Baker's run and left viewers with a lasting memory of a truly unique regeneration. "It's the end," says the Doctor. "But the moment has been prepared for." Perhaps one of the most memorable and oft quoted lines about regeneration, Baker delivers the line with his trademark grin and wild-eyed enthusiasm. This Doctor was quintessentially himself right through to his very last moments. Viewers may still be a little confused over the presence of the Watcher but it certainly makes for a fun topic of discussion and speculation - and if there's one thing fans love, it's to speculate! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l3w-BHsXt4I What did you think of this list? Let us know if you agree with the countdown in the comments section below.

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Christie D. Inman-Hall hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.