Game Of Thrones: 15 Theories Better Than What We Got
The things Aegon Targaryen could have done with his claim to the throne.
For the first six seasons of its existence, Game of Thrones sat alone atop the list of greatest TV shows of all time. The characters, the narrative, and the performances of a stunning cast, among other things, brought George R. R. Martin's world to life in a way few novel adaptations can boast.
Season seven saw a noticeable drop in the show's quality, and though not enough to rob the series of its legacy, the same cannot be said about season eight. Never has a show seen such a backlash from its loyal fan base, and in the case of Game of Thrones, it was deserved.
After almost a decade of precise, deliberate story telling, just about every narrative was either cut short or rushed to the finish line, robbing the show of the payoff it had worked so hard and so long for.
Game of Thrones took the entire planet by storm, and with that came unprecedented amounts of speculation, predictions, and theories about the ending of the Song of Ice and Fire, and out of this came some truly incredible ideas. Some were even better than the show itself.
15. The Night Queen
For seven seasons, since the very first scene of the show, the battle between the living and the dead had been teased, and the fans had some incredible ideas on how it would play out.
One such theory revolved around the Night King and one potential Queen of Westeros, Cersei Lannister, taking some inspiration from the 13th Lord Commander of the Night's Watch from George R. R. Martin's novels. The man dubbed the Night's King formed an alliance with the white walkers, by way of marrying one of them.
Applied to the show, this theory suggested that Cersei would come to some accord with the Night King, and rule over the cold and desolate Westeros together. It was said that she would see King's Landing burn if she could be Queen of the ashes, so surely she would see it freeze to be Queen of the ice.
Taking into account the Night King's ability to fly over Winterfell and head straight to King's Landing, and Qyburn's ability to bring the dead part way back to life, Cersei could have been killed by the leader of the white walkers, only to be brought back into an alliance with him.
A bit far fetched, certainly, but a shocking, surprising twist in the final stretch of the story as well.
14. Lady Stoneheart
Ever since Catelyn Stark's death during the Red Wedding in season three, fans of the books had patiently waited for her return as the zombie Lady Stoneheart.
In the source material, the body of Lady Stark is found several days after her death by Beric Dondarrion and Thoros of Myr. She is brought back as a shell of her former self, going by the name of Lady Stoneheart and leading the Brotherhood without Banners.
Though she hasn't featured in the books a huge amount, the fact that she exists at all is a game-changer, and she will certainly come into play during either the Winds of Winter, a Dream of Spring, or both.
This led to the theory that Michelle Fairley's character would return to lead Beric and Thoros' company, taking revenge on the Freys and anyone else who had a hand in the death of her eldest son, but no such luck. Instead, the Brotherhood found themselves disbanded somewhat, with Beric and Thoros ultimately heading North of the Wall with Jon Snow.
There was also an interesting theory that suggested Arya would take on the mantle after she travelled back to Westeros to take revenge on the Freys, but instead, the character was left out of the show entirely. Perhaps Gregor Clegane was enough part-resurrected zombie for the show, but there's no denying Lady Stoneheart would have been incredible to see on screen.
13. Ned Stark's True Identity
Over the years, Game of Thrones became known for its shocking moments and major character deaths. Even to this day however, the death of Ned Stark in season one remains one of the most shocking scenes in the history of the show.
Such was the Game of Thrones fan base, and their loyalty to the Lord of Winterfell, there were many that simply wouldn't accept that the most honourable man in Westeros was actually dead. Despite George R. R. Martin never holding back from killing major characters, there was a wonderful denial of Sean Bean's head being removed from his body.
From this blind faith came a theory that could have actually potentially made a lot of sense. What if Ned was replaced with a Faceless Man before his execution, who gave his life for the Warden of the North to keep his own? The still-breathing Ned then lived out the rest of his days as the mysterious Jaqen H'ghar.
This would certainly go a long way to explaining the relationship between Jaqen and Arya, and why they were almost destined to each other for much of the remainder of the series, and would have added yet another layer to Arya's time in the House of Black and White.
12. Bran The Dragon
When the Three-Eyed Raven told Bran that, though he would never walk again, he would fly, you would be forgiven for thinking further down the line about the possibility of the young Stark warging into a dragon. We all thought it, and the theory behind it made a lot of sense.
It's well documented that one of the few characters George R. R. Martin had a full story arc in mind for from the start was Bran Stark. His story may have been quite slow and steady to begin with, and he even skipped out on season five entirely, but fans knew that it was building to something big.
Yet what was much theorised never came to pass. Taking into account Bran's arc, his history with the Night King, and his ability to potentially warg into any creature alive, it seemed very likely that the future King of Westeros would at some stage take control of Viserion's body, and thus the Night King's flight path.
Instead however, Bran used his powers more for the time traveling, all-seeing aspect than the physical, mind controlling aspect. It would seem either the Three-Eyed Raven was speaking metaphorically, or was simply referring to the ravens Bran used to scout the Night King. Technically he did use them to fly, it just would have been better to see him as a dragon.
11. Bran The Night King
As said before, everyone knew that Bran would play a huge part in the conclusion of Game of Thrones, however thanks to the supernatural aspect, and the years of journeying to learning such skills, we all thought he would be involved more than he ultimately was.
Thanks to Bran's timeline traveling North of the Wall, he was one of the few characters to physically come into contact with the Night King. Ever since then, the Stark child had a special connection with the leader of the white walkers, and the Battle of Winterfell suddenly revolved entirely around him.
Bran had also shown previously that he was capable of reaching into the past, and interacting with others, when his own father heard him whisper, and when he possessed Wylis, inadvertently turning the stable boy into Hodor. These were shocking moments, and it seemed that they could be leading to something bigger.
One theory suggested that the reason Bran and the Night King shared such a connection, was that they were the same person. If Bran could go back in time and warg into Hodor, then it was entirely plausible that he did the same to the human that would become the Night King.
The time traveller would have taken over the body of the future leader of the dead, in a futile attempt to prevent his transformation. However, this would have gone very wrong, trapping Bran in the body as the dragonglass pierced the heart of the would be ice zombie, bonding him and Bran forever.
10. Bran's Multiple Personalities
Completing the hat-trick of theories based around the eventual King of Westeros, in the same vein of Bran taking the place of someone in the past, there was a theory suggesting he went back in time and lived as every Brandon Stark throughout history.
The Stark lineage is full of namesakes of Bran's, from Bran the Builder to Bran the Breaker, Bran the Shipwright, and Ned's older brother, among many, many others. Some thought that Brandon was more than a family name, with a deeper meaning running through it.
This would have given Bran, who had so much potential going into the final season, much more significance to the story, and his coronation at the conclusion of episode six would have felt a lot more earned if he had built the Wall, been murdered by the Mad King, and helped establish one of the greatest Houses in the history of Westeros.
Though it would have been slightly strange for Bran to have been betrothed to Catelyn during his time as Ned's brother, this is Game of Thrones, and it would have been no stranger than Jon's relationship with aunt and girlfriend, Daenerys.
9. The Prince That Was Promised
Religion played a big part in the Game of Thrones story, and with it came several important prophecies. One of the biggest came from those who worshiped the God, R'hllor, and revolved around the Prince that was Promised.
The prophecy told of the mighty warrior, Azor Ahai, being reborn into the world, with his flaming sword, Lightbringer, to lead the living in the war against the dead. Melisandre preached this more than anyone in the show, but could never seem to put her faith in the right character.
After being ultimately let down by Stannis, the Red Woman put her faith in Jon Snow, even then hinting that the Prince that was Promised could have been a Princess that was Promised. What was to stop the reincarnated warrior taking the form of a woman?
The theories of who Azor Ahai would be revealed to be ranged across many characters, most frequently Jon Snow and Daenerys Targaryen, but the strongest theory revolved around the former. Thanks to Jon's connection to death, with the Red God seemingly choosing to bring him back to life, the King in the North would have made the perfect incarnation of the Prince that was Promised. Why else would R'hllor have acted as he did, bringing Aegon Targaryen, a true Prince of Westeros, back to life?
8. Reanimated Starks
As the Night King breached the Wall and marched on Westeros, the dead slowly made their way toward Winterfell. With the living fighting against the odds, the protection of the castle walls and the people within was paramount.
However, the leader of the dead had the amazing gift of being able to bring the dead back to life, something he used to devastating effect at the Battle of Hardhome, and many more times throughout history.
When the Battle of Winterfell was on the brink, it seemed likely that, with the Night King being kept outside of the castle, he could raise the dozens of dead Starks laid to rest in the crypts below and expand his army from within. This would have been nothing those inside the castle could have prepared for, and would have added another, terrifying level to the fight.
This theory gained traction even during the battle itself, as the army of the living had the idea of putting the women and children down with the dead for their own protection. Just imagine seeing Jon Snow having to cross swords with the reanimated bones of Ned Stark, the bones they had to fight so hard to bring back home. This could have been the last in a string of mistakes Tyrion seemed to make over the course of his time as Hand of the Queen.
7. Cersei's Fake Pregnancy
She may have been one of the most evil characters the show had, but Cersei's one redeeming factor was the love she had for her family. Everything she did, she did for the good of the Lannister name, and the legacy of her house. As the show was coming to its conclusion however, all three of her children were dead, leaving no one to take the throne after she was gone.
In season seven, she revealed almost out of the blue that she was with child, but it happened so suddenly and at such a convenient time for her, that fans believed there must be another angle to it. Just as Jaime was pulling himself further away from her, she had the exact news that would keep him loyal to his sister.
With Cersei Lannister certainly not being above lying about a pregnancy, there was a theory that she simply fabricated the story, using the lie to manipulate Jaime into staying with her. Since there was never any true evidence of her pregnancy, with it going unconfirmed by any maester, fans were certain her lie would be uncovered, ultimately driving Jaime away from Cersei, and possibly into the arms of Brienne.
Though Cersei died before beginning to show signs of carrying a child, it would seem that this was one of the few times she was simply being honest, telling Jaime she was pregnant because she was actually pregnant.
6. Jon Snow's Coronation
There is a reason the show was called Game of Thrones. Throughout everything, though the white walkers were hinted at being the real battle, the most important thread was ultimately about who sat atop the Iron Throne when the series ended.
For years, the most popular fan theory was the R+L=J theory, which correctly predicted the true heritage of Jon Snow. Instead of coming from Ned Stark and a random woman, the one time Lord Commander of the Night's Watch was actually the product of Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark's secret love.
This reveal confirmed that Jon Snow, or Aegon Targaryen's claim to the Iron Throne was actually stronger than that of Deanerys. The theories began revolving around what Aegon would do about being the rightful King, with one of the strongest being that he would challenge his aunt, and ultimately end the series atop the Iron Throne, as befit his claim.
Why else would such a bomb be dropped if not to cause another split in the Targaryen house?
Instead however, the writers took Jon's story in a different direction, having him stand loyally by the woman he viewed as Queen. It would seem that there was more Stark in Jon than Targaryen after all.
5. Tyrion's Deal With Cersei
From the moment Tyrion Lannister was born, he had always been hated by his sister. But by season eight, after the deaths of both Joffrey and Tywin, and Tyrion's defection to the Targaryen side of the war, Cersei wanted him dead like never before.
Season seven ended with the meeting between all parties to discuss putting the war for Westeros on hold while they came together to fight the army of the dead, but Dany and Cersei failed to come to an agreement. Before heading out of King's Landing however, Tyrion managed to get himself a one on one talk with Cersei.
He left with the word of his sister that the fight against the Night King would take precedence over the battle for the throne, but how had he done this? What could he have possibly said to his sister, or offered her in return for her promise?
However, Cersei later revealed her true intentions to Jaime, that she had no plans to put a stop to her side of the fighting, and Tyrion sailed away with a concerned, almost guilty look on his face.
This gave life to the theory that the Imp had betrayed his new Queen in favour of his true family, striking a deal with his sister while rediscovering his loyalty to the lion of Lannister, rather than to the Usurper from across the Narrow Sea.
4. Jon And Daenerys Sharing The Iron Throne
As said previously, going into season eight, everyone watching was fascinated by how Jon Snow's claim to the throne would affect things. It was one of the biggest question marks hanging over the entire series, and could have completely changed the final outcome of the show.
While some theorised that Jon would use his stronger claim to remove Daenerys from the picture, others believed that Jon and his aunt/girlfriend would continue the tradition of keeping the Targaryen lineage pure, join forces, and rule Westeros together.
There could have been no greater poetic depiction of the Song of Ice and Fire than a Targaryen and a Snow, the mother of dragons and the King in the North coming together to rule the country. This would have made sense for both the character arcs of Jon and Daenerys.
Not only would this have made the Aegon Targaryen reveal worth revealing, it would have completed Daenerys' dream of breaking the wheel, ruling equally with her husband, and righting the wrongs of the Lannisters, Baratheons, and Targaryens before them. This particular theory simply made too much sense to be ignored by fans going into season eight, but the writers instead chose the Mad Queen path, likely the character's end game in the books themselves.
3. Tyrion Targaryen
Family is a very strong theme throughout Game of Thrones, and there were constantly theories that certain characters were either related, or not who they claimed to be. By the time it was eventually revealed, just about everyone knew that Jon Snow wasn't really Jon Snow, but this raised more questions than it answered.
The prophecy told of a three headed dragon, matching the creature on the Targaryen sigil. With Daenerys flying Drogon, and Jon taking Rhaegal, this left one riderless dragon, and one head of the dragon unaccounted for.
Thoughts turned to who this potential mysterious Targaryen could be, with one theory suggesting that it would be none other than Tyrion. When Tywin Lannister served as Hand of the King to Aerys II, it was well documented that the Mad King enjoyed the company of Tywin's wife, Joanna.
It was entirely plausible that it was Aerys that fathered the child that killed his mother in labour, making Tyrion Daenerys' half-sister, and the third head of the dragon. This would have certainly given deeper meaning to Tywin's hatred for Tyrion, and made us look entirely differently at the former stating that the latter was no son of his.
Everyone wanted justice for Tyrion, for how he had been treated by his family all his life, but unfortunately he was, is, and always will be a Lannister.
2. Cersei's Death
Throughout the series, fans of Game of Thrones learned to expect the unexpected. From Ned Stark's untimely death to the Red Wedding and Ramsay's horrible treatment of Theon, audiences found that absolutely anything could happen in George R. R. Martin's Song of Ice and Fire.
However, there were a few things that were inevitable, including the eventual death of Cersei Lannister. The Queen was one of the greatest antagonists the show had ever seen, but no one truly believed that she would survive to sit the Iron Throne and rule Westeros.
But how would it happen? How could the writers give Cersei Lannister a death fit for one of the greatest characters in the show's history? Would Jaime kill her? Or possibly Tyrion? Either would fulfil the Valonqar prophecy as told by Maggy the Frog.
Perhaps the greatest of these theories however, suggested that Arya would personally cross Cersei off her list, closing off the character arc she began way back in season two. She travelled all the way from Winterfell to King's Landing after the battle with the dead, specifically to kill Cersei, and with her very specific skills, she had the means of taking Jaime's face to get close enough to her.
This would have given Arya, Cersei, and even Jaime an end to the saga worthy of their incredible characters.
1. The Night King's Victory At Winterfell
This was what we had been waiting for for seven seasons. The battle between the living and the dead. As Jon Snow said time and time again, it didn't matter one bit who sat the Iron Throne if the Night King came and killed everyone.
He spent years of his life preparing for the battle, lobbying for help from his countrymen, and risking his life traveling to Dragonstone and North of Wall to make allies out of Daenerys and Cersei. The way the narrative was presented until the latter half of season eight, this was the real battle, not the scrap for who got to sit the Iron Throne.
But how would this battle play out? How would the Night King overtake Cersei as the main antagonist of the entire saga? Before it was revealed that he achieved no such feat, the theory was that he would actually prevail victorious from the Battle of Winterfell, and continue his march further into Westeros.
Cersei had been far too dismissive of the threat from beyond the wall, genuinely believing that the Night's Watch was concerned about nothing more than grumkins and snarks. Not only would the Night King's victory at Winterfell and subsequent march toward King's Landing have made for the type of huge twist we've come to expect, it would have made for an incredibly tense, surprising end to the saga.
Forcing Cersei to face an army of the dead thanks to her own selfishness and error in judgement? That's a far better "story".