Game Of Thrones: 7 Big Problems With Season 5

No hope, no resolution, no important scenes in Dorne.

Brienne And Pod Game of Thrones
HBO

Game of Thrones' fifth season had some pretty glaring problems, but the biggest ones can't even be blamed on the underwhelming source material. No, there were plenty of issues these showrunners created all on their own.

Some disappointments with the season were inevitable, as books four and five were easily the weakest in the series. After the extreme highs of the Battle of the Wall and Tywin's death, it suddenly felt like George R.R. Martin had run out of steam. In these novels, a bunch of storylines go absolutely nowhere, and many of Martin's new characters are just flat out boring. Then things end just as the action is getting started. The books were truly a slog, a massive step down from the original three.

So the showrunners had their work cut out for them this year, and some of these same disappointments carried over into Season 5. There were once again plenty of boring plot threads, characters doing nothing, and a massively unsatisfying ending. But in addition, some storylines which were excellent in the book were completely botched on screen, with flat characters and boring plotting every week. The tone was also completely off compared to the book, and everything with Ramsay and Sansa that was invented for the series was just flat out horrible.

Now that the show has passed the books and the showrunners will be writing mostly on their own, these problems really need to be addressed. Here are the 7 biggest issues with Season 5.

7. Dorne

Sand Snakes Game Of Thrones
HBO

Oberyn Martell was one of last season's greatest achievements, and Pedro Pascal delivered an unbelievable performance as a guy who doesn't wear a helmet at the most vital of moments.

So fans were ecstatic about the show moving to Dorne this year, a new part of the world where Oberyn is from. But although Dorne had its moments, this whole thing was pretty disappointing. 

The Sand Snakes should have been badass on the level of Oberyn, but instead they blended together into a trio of cliche characters, constantly spouting out revenge monologues and spending most of the season not accomplishing anything. It seemed like the writers just assumed everyone would love the Sand Snakes, so they didn't even bother fleshing them out.

There were also some scenes in Dorne that were just a waste, like when one of the Sand Snakes poisons Bronn, messes with him for a bit, and then just gives him the antidote. What was the point of that? Luckily, the season ended with something actually happening when Myrcella was assassinated, which should lead to an interesting conflict between Dorne and King's Landing next year. But overall, this wasn’t a great introduction to Dorne, and a lot of time spent there now kind of feels like a waste.


6. The Battle Of Winterfell

Stannis Baratheon Game Of Thrones
HBO

For the last half of the season, the show was getting viewers ready for the Battle of Winterfell, an epic confrontation between Stannis and the Boltons. This was going to be a defining moment for both sides of the war, and given how great Stannis’ siege on King’s Landing was back in Season 2, this would surely be an awesome battle.

And then just as the two sides are about to start fighting, the show immediately cuts to the aftermath, with Stannis' entire army wiped out. That's it?

This is somewhat understandable considering the show only has so much money in the budget, and the showrunners decided to spend most of that on Hardhome. But this still felt really anticlimactic, and in fact the editing almost seemed like it was intended to be comedic, cutting from the excitement of the battle starting right to the brutal aftermath. It was like when a sitcom cuts from a character saying “I’ll never do that” to a scene of them doing it. Not exactly a great way for Stannis to go out.

The show didn’t need to provide another full battle episode, but to cut around this massive conflict which had been building for several episodes was a big disappointment. 


5. Sansa's Storyline

Sansa Ramsay Game of Thrones
HBO

A lot of controversy arose when a Season 5 episode ended with Ramsay Bolton raping Sansa Stark. It was a truly horrifying moment, but at least it seemed like this was setting the stage for Sansa to get her revenge. She has to be beaten down so that when she strikes back, it’s that much more satisfying. That sort of makes sense. 

Viewers had been promised that this would be the season Sansa really comes into her own and steps up. And then what was the climax of all that? Sansa stumbles out of her room and Theon rescues her. That’s it. 

When she picked up that corkscrew, and a lot of people thought she’d use that to kill Ramsay or do something, that was actually just to open a door. And then she immediately drops it. So in retrospect, Sansa’s storyline this season has essentially boiled down to her being beaten down and tortured week after week only to be saved by someone else.

Let’s just hope the show is still headed towards some Sansa revenge, or if not, it'll at least allow her to do anything on her own. Not ending her Season 5 arc with any sort of victory that she accomplishes herself was a big let down.


4. Ramsay Is Way Too Overpowered

Ramsay Snow Game Of Thrones
HBO

Speaking of Sansa, let’s talk about Ramsay. While Game of Thrones is full of people that viewers dislike, it’s clear that the show always wants to have one really despicable, psychopathic villain that stands above the rest. For the first few seasons there was Joffrey, and since his death, Ramsay has taken his place.

But here’s the problem: it’s getting really tiring how ridiculously overpowered Ramsay and the Boltons are. A lot of the reason people love Game of Thrones is the idea that anything can happen, but this idea that bad things can happen at any time now only applies to the good guys. When it comes to Ramsay, he can fight off a whole team of Greyjoys by himself completely shirtless. He can completely sabotage the most skilled fighter in Westeros with 20 men all while totally undetected. 

There is no Bolton opposition at all? They never face any sort of setbacks whatsoever? It’s getting so old going through the motions of having the Boltons take down everyone and torture whoever the audience loves while facing no challenges. For a series that loves to deal with the realism of war and show that anyone can be killed, the Boltons have become far too unstoppable.


3. Brienne’s Storyline

Brienne And Pod Game of Thrones
HBO

In the books, the Brienne storyline was kind of disappointing at this point, as she spends an insufferable amount of time wandering around looking for Sansa and never getting anywhere. But with Season 5, the character's journey started off strong and she actually ran into Sansa, which was a huge improvement. Finally she'd have something to do!

And then that really didn’t go anywhere. Brienne spent about half the season staring at the tower in Winterfell, but presumably she was placed there for some sort of great payoff at the end. What happened? She looks away from the tower at the literal exact moment that Sansa gets there, wanders into the forest, and maybe kills Stannis but maybe not. The end.

If Season 6 opens with Brienne and Sansa running into each other, this will all be somewhat redeemed. But having her spend the entire season in one place waiting for a thing to happen, and then looking away at the exact moment it happens, is just such frustrating storytelling. It was a buildup to absolutely nothing. Maybe if she unambiguously killed Stannis it would at least feel like she abandoned her watch for some purpose, but at this point, it’s not even clear if she really did kill him. If not, she missed Sansa for no reason at all.


2. Way Too Many Cliffhangers

Sansa Theon Reek Game Of Thrones
HBO

This was a problem with A Dance With Dragons that unfortunately carried over into the show as well. George R.R. Martin has generally never been a writer who relies on too many lame cliffhangers to keep you reading, and the show has been the same way. You get the Red Wedding, but that’s not actually how the season ends: viewers get a sense of resolution in the following episode, and generally every finale has left you with a good sense of closure.

Then this one comes along and it seems practically designed to be as frustrating as possible, resolving absolutely nothing. One major cliffhanger is fine, but looking back on this finale, just about every single plot thread is left completely unresolved in a way that Game of Thrones has never resorted to before. Did Sansa and Theon survive the fall? Did Brienne kill Stannis? Is Arya permanently blind? Is Myrcella dead? What’s going to happen to Dany? Is Jon gone for good?

Past finales have always ended with some sense of certainty, but this one just cuts you off over and over to get people talking for the next few months. Viewers are left with almost nothing that feels remotely wrapped up, and that leads to a pretty unsatisfying final episode.


1. Not Even One Glimmer Of Hope?

Game Of Thrones Reek
HBO

Contrary to popular belief, the Song of Ice and Fire book series was never just about pure misery. In the most recent book, there’s the terrible events with the Boltons and with Jon’s potential demise, but there’s also a whole lot of moments that suggest there’s still hope left in this universe.

The showrunners decided to cut out virtually all of those hopeful moments, crafting a season where nothing ever goes right for anyone, everything is miserable, and there is no satisfaction to be had. See this woman who is supporting Sansa and the North? Maybe something satisfying will happen there? Nope. Watch her get horribly murdered. Everything sucks.

In a post-Red Wedding world, it seems like these showrunners think audiences like the series because terrible things happen. But what was great about the books (and previous seasons) wasn't that bad things happen, but that good and bad things happen. By cutting out any potential moment of retribution or catharsis, this was a season of television which made sure viewers never experienced one single moment of happiness. 

It’s not that there’s anything inherently wrong with being dark, but at this point, the show’s bleakness is becoming predictable. Instead of this being a series where anything can happen, it’s become a series where only bad things can happen. And that’s just another kind of predictable.


Contributor
Contributor

Lover of horror movies, liker of other things. Your favorite Friday the 13th says a lot about you as a person, and mine is Part IV: The Final Chapter.