Marvel's The Punisher Season 2: What Does The Ending Really Mean?

Is this the end of Frank Castle on Netflix?

The Punisher Season 2
Netflix

Season 2 of Marvel's The Punisher has now landed on Netflix, with enough time passing since its drop for most willing fans to have binge-watched their way through all 13 episodes of Frank Castle's latest MCU outing.

Following on from the events of Season 1, the second season begins with Frank (Jon Bernthal) trying to love the quiet life, drifting his way across the USA and once again going under the name of Pete Castiglione. Before long, he's saving a young girl, Amy (Giorgia Whigham) in a barroom brawl, and is forced to return to New York.

From there, he's left fighting battles on two fronts: one sees him going up against the mysterious Christian fundamentalist John Pilgrim (Josh Stewart), and the other is a rematch of last year's battle with Billy Russo (Ben Barnes), only with the script flipped, as the scarred Russo is now the one without knowledge of what happened.

It's another Netflix Marvel series with pacing issues, but works largely thanks to Bernthal's incredible performance. It all builds to an ending that, while not quite as explosive as Season 1's, should serve as a fitting finale if the show is indeed the next to be cancelled. Spoilers follow.


8. The Ending

Punisher Jon Bernthal
Netflix

While The Punisher doesn't quite manage to juggle its twin storylines, it does succeed in wrapping them both up in the finale.

Billy Russo is severely wounded by Dinah Midani (Amber Revah Rose), and finds refuge in the basement of Curtis' apartment building. That's where Frank turns up and, cold as anything, executes his former friend. The body is then found by Madani, Curtis, and Mahoney, with neither of the former prepared to give Frank up.

Along with that, Frank has to deal with Pilgrim and co, with the reveal that he was just a puppet for the Schultz family. After a brutal fight between Frank and Pilgrim, the former gets their address and kills Eliza, with Anderson then committing suicide. Pilgrim goes his own way, before Frank arranges for Amy to leave New York and head down to Florida, where she can fulfil her dream of diving and, more importantly, be safe.

It then cuts to three months later, where Madani is working for the CIA and looking to recruit Frank. He turns her down, though, because he has his own job going on. He then walks in on a pair of rival gangs meeting, killing everyone in sight. In loving memory of Stan Lee indeed.


7. The Jigsaw Is Complete

The Punisher Season 2 Jigsaw First Look Official 1152265
Netflix

After two seasons as a thorn in Frank Castle's side, Billy Russo's story is finally done.

Admittedly you could make the argument that it was mostly done after Season 1, because the conflict here doesn't do too much different to what we saw in the first season, save for the fact it's Russo who doesn't know what happened this time out. Still, the performances of Ben Barnes and Jon Bernthal help to make it work, and it's fitting that it does come down to those two (with some assistance from Madani).

It's also important to note the difference in how their rivalry ends here, compared to Season 1. Then, with everything so raw, Frank chooses not to kill Billy, but instead completely decimates him, consumed by rage and the feeling of betrayal. This time, he just shoots him a couple of times. It's cold, efficient, ruthless, and suggests that Frank is now completely done with his old pal Billy. Not all of his demons are behind him, but this big one is.


6. Pilgrim's Redemption

The Punisher John Pilgrim
Netflix

It's hard to say that John Pilgrim finds complete absolution by the end of his arc. This is still a man who did heinous things, first as a white supremacist when he was younger, and then in the name of religion while being used by the Schultz family. But The Punisher deals with the grey areas of life, and Pilgrim's story comes to an interesting conclusion.

It would've been easy to have him dispatched in a similar way to Russo, but after he and Frank beat the hell out of each other, Pilgrim decides to give up the Schultz address, with Frank going to kill them instead of him - something that Pilgrim simply lets happen.

There's then a parting of the ways between them, which suggests that he has found some semblance of redemption, which comes from how he mirrors Frank. Frank serves as the Punisher because he lost his family and fights for revenge; Pilgrim kills in order to give his wife and children safe. A lot of the season is about Frank questioning whether or not he can do what he does and still be good, but that's explored in this ending with Pilgrim as much as it is the Punisher.


5. Amy Has Her Life Back

The Punisher Season 2
Netflix

Life back perhaps isn't the right time. It might be more straightforward to simply say that, thanks to Frank, Amy now has her life. She's been living without freedom for too long, but is sent on her way (with a wad of cash to boot) in the finale.

It's a touching end to the sweet relationship that develops between Frank and Amy, which gives the former a chance to once again act as a father figure, with Amy roughly the same age his own daughter would've been. Like with Micro in the first season, we get to see how she has changed Frank, and how his actions can impact others too, and how he can be a positive force for change as much as a destructive one.

The door is very much left open for reconciliation later down the line - much as it is with Micro - although the fact the show will probably be cancelled means it's unlikely to ever happen on screen. Nonetheless, Amy has the freedom to start anew and live her life properly, which means a great deal to her, but is also a huge gift for Frank, who has lost so much and killed so many, to be able to give.


4. What Happens With Karen?

The Punisher Karen Lightened
Netflix

Karen Page was an important part of The Punisher's first season, building upon their relationship in Daredevil Season 2 where they were able to truly understand one another when no one else could.

This time around, though, she only works a one-off appearance, visiting Frank in the hospital. It's still great to see Karen turn up, although it does feel slightly random, and doesn't exactly give any closure considering this is probably the last time we're going to see Deborah Ann Woll in the MCU.

It certainly hints at the romance that many fans have been wishing for since Daredevil Season 2, but never goes any further with it than a few furtive glances, and then she creates the distraction that allows Frank to escape the hospital. After that, she presumably simply goes back to Hell's Kitchen and Murdock, Nelson & Page. The pair obviously care deeply for each other, but for now, with Daredevil scrapped and The Punisher likely to be, it won't go beyond that.


3. Madani Has Learned A Lot From Frank

The Punisher Dinah Madani
Netflix

Joined CIA, morally questionable, sees Frank's reasoning

Season 1 had Agent Madani frequently butting heads with Frank Castle, with her belief firmly placed in the system going up against his 'f**k the system' approach.

In Season 2, we have Brett Mahoney filling that role, with Madani now much more sympathetic to Frank's approach, and that's something the ending in particular rams home. After refusing to turn Frank in to Mahoney, we pick up three months later, and find that Madani is now working for the CIA, It's a job where she can get her hands dirtier, and is definitely a little more morally questionable.

For as much as it's about questioning whether Frank can be good, he also makes others see the world differently, and it's clear that she has learned a lot from Frank, even going so far as to not just accepting his methods, but wanting to put them to use for the government.


2. Frank Fully Embraces Being The Punisher

Punisher Season 2 Jon Bernthal
Netflix

One of the highlights of the season is the way we see Frank struggle with, question, and then finally embrace being the Punisher. Season 1 was about him reclaiming his identity as Frank Castle and being able to live as that person, past and all, and this year then becomes a true Punisher story.

It's fascinating to watch Frank as he questions whether he can be the killer the Punisher has to be and still be good, and even more fascinating to see him realise that this isn't just some revenge mission. This is simply who he is, and he loves it.

It never just makes him an amoral killer, but makes it clear that he is the man prepared to cross the line and pull the trigger. Not just because he has to, but because he wants to. It results in that final sequence where he blows away a bunch of criminals, after turning down Madani's offer to work on a CIA mission. Rawlins, Russo, Pilgrim - all his enemies are gone. He could've chosen to live the quiet life. But THIS is who he is at his very core.


1. It Doesn't Need A Third Season

The Punisher Season 2 Jon Bernthal
Netflix

Is this the end of The Punisher? We likely won't find out for another month or so, which is the typical window after airing before Netflix renew or cancel a series, but it seems likely. With Iron Fist, Luke Cage, and Daredevil all canned, it'd be a major surprise if they didn't cancel The Punisher too.

It's something of a relief, then, that The Punisher doesn't *need* a third season. Unlike the endings to those other three series, which had some major setup for future instalments, all of the stories here are quite neatly wrapped up. All of the key players have a sense of closure, which should prove a satisfying end if the series is scrapped.

That's not to say it should be cancelled, if for nothing else than it'd be great to have more of Jon Bernthal's take on The Punisher. A miniseries, a movie, a recurring role in another show - Bernthal gives the definitive take on the character, and it'd be a shame to lose him from the MCU. But for the show itself, it can go out if not on a high, then at least on a proper endnote.

What did you think of The Punisher Season 2? Let us know down in the comments.

Read Next: Marvel's The Punisher Season 2 Review: 6 Ups & 4 Downs


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.