Star Trek: Discovery 3.2 Review - Ups And Downs From Far From Home
No, it's not the latest Spiderman sequel. There isn't even any webslinging!
The third season of Star Trek: Discovery has delivered another cracker of an episode, with plenty to discuss. The ship has finally arrived in the future, filling the void she left behind in the first episode last week. Everyone gets their moments to shine here, though the episode is not without issues.
The imagery and the music are both stunning again here this week - it's clear that, in the words of John Hammond, they spared no expense here. From the opening to closing, the episode is full of tension, humour, soft character moments and some of the typical violence that we have now come to expect from Discovery.
There are some problems, addressed below, but overall there is another strong offering this week from Star Trek's far future, one that is sure to divide fans regardless of whether it was brilliant or not!
With that in mind, follow on with this article as we delve into the various ups and downs from this week's episode of Star Trek: Discovery, Far From Home - and don't forget to check out the video list over on YouTube as well!
9. Discovery Crashlands (Up)
The opening to the episode is a stunning feast for the eyes as Discovery comes through the wormhole and emerges on the other side. Unfortunately for them, the other side just happens to have a tonne of asteroids directly in their path.
Kayla Detmer is the true hero of the moment as she snaps to action and begins to pilot the ship as best she can around and, yes, through some of these giant rocks. However, internal systems are buggered and that ship is going down to the planet below. She rolls the ship to let the dorsal side take most of the heat from the atmosphere, and expertly guides the ship during the crash that follows.
The scene is tense, there is a genuine sense of threat and, early in the season or no, there is no certainty that everyone will make it out alive. It is a fantastic first scene of the Discovery in this episode and a wonderful use of imagery.
8. Characters Get A Bit Of Rapid Development (Up)
One very fair criticism of Star Trek: Discovery's first two seasons has been its lack of true character development for the supporting cast. One character more than any other has suffered from this, though we will get to that shortly.
In this opening scene however, after the ship has successfully landed on the planet, the bridge crew, after regaining their composure, breaks into applause for Detmer for getting them down safely. Around the bridge, people are able to express themselves a little, freed from the usual confines of 'do whatever your character needs to do'.
Saru snaps into Captain mode, while Owosekun, Rhys, Bryce and Reno all show a bit of relief at their situation. Both Detmer and Tilly appear badly shaken by what has just happened (fair) and, between this scene and the few that follow, the audience is treated to a few moments of development where the crew actually get to say something.
Star Trek has always survived on the banter between the crew and if this episode is anything to go by, the audience may finally be getting that in Discovery's third season.
7. Dr. Culber And Wilson Cruz (Up)
One of the true gifts to the franchise has been Wilson Cruz. In any interview or panel discussion on the show, he is clearly passionate about the series and the franchise, bringing an energy that is infectious to every moment that he is in.
Therefore, his untimely death in the first season was brutal. Although he of course returned in the second season, it was a questionnable decision at best.
His scenes in this episode are the exact proof as to why removing Dr. Culber from the show is a terrible, terrible idea. He is wonderful here, with his interactions with both Stamets and Reno being among the highlights of the episode. His relationship with Stamets is so believable in these moments together, it is hard not to accept that they really are a married couple, bickering and loving as they do.
In another case of great character work on show, Culber gets to truly shine in this episode. More Culber please!
6. Why Didn't They Ask The Miners What Year It Was? (Down)
The saloon setting was a great location for the episode and there are more than a few nods to the old Western movies that DeForest Kelley starred in as Saru and Tilly enter the bar. The only missing is a piano player closing the lid and scurrying away. The surroundings are a great treat for the eyes here - especially with the half double swing doors opening into space.
However.
This leads to the first down in the episode. While Saru had made a point on board the Discovery not to give away too much about their identities and when the ship is from, why didn't he and Tilly, after ascertaining that the miners in the bar were friendly, simply ask them what year it was? Or the location of the planet they are on? Granted, Cal says that the planet doesn't have a name - but is that all of the information he has?
It seems like the plot demanded Saru not know what year it was, so therefore he didn't ask.
5. Georgiou's 2-D Character Writing (Down)
I, the writer, quite possibly stand alone in this one (hence the change in voice for this entry!). I mentioned earlier that there was one character who had suffered the most from poor character development and that character is Phillipa Georgiou.
Michelle Yeoh is fantastic in Star Trek: Discovery, a true success for the casting department. However, her writing has been far less successful. Her first appearance in the episode sees her rock up, covered in Leland's entrails.
Yes, Georgiou is eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeevil. The only thing she is missing is a moustache to twirl. The problem is that the audience is offered a reminder of this in every...single...scene with her. When one thinks back to the mirror universe episodes of The Original Series, Deep Space Nine and Enterprise, the scenery chewing is absolutely forgiven in those episodes because they are somewhat stand-alone. We're now pushing a season and a half with this version of Georgiou and it is getting very old.
There is plenty of potential here. Her relationship with Michael seems to be the one thing that is melting her hard exterior but this seriously needs to speed up a little!
Also, while not wishing to have her killed off - why on Earth didn't Zara (played by the great Jake Weber) kill her when she started causing trouble? Plot armour. That's why.
4. Reno And Stamets (Up)
While there was a moment on the bridge when Reno may have broken a moment of tension with one of her jokes (stay with us), there is no arguing as to how wonderful an addition to Star Trek: Discovery she has been. Her interactions with Stamets in this episode alone prove that hiring Tig Notaro was one of the best decisions the producers have made.
She is a great foil for the always-so-serious Stamets as she seems to be incapable of taking anything seriously, even in the face of doom. Sometimes, a voice like that is needed, simply to keep the others grounded. She helps Stamets overcome the pain he is feeling by guiding him along with her snark, something that truly gives the episode a bit of extra life.
Stamets, for his part, has been quite up and down in terms of how he has been written. Based on this episode and based on the acting of Anthony Rapp, there is a good double-team in the offing here. Now that the universe ending threat of Control is gone, perhaps its time that the audience will get to see this man lighten up a little!
3. Sonic Screwdriver (Up)
This is speaking directly to the Whovian in all of our hearts, but is this not a sonic screwdriver? The multi tool (not to be confused with the super magical tool from Star Trek: Picard), bears more than a passing resemblance to The Doctor's most famous tool...and that is just fine with us!
We're more than ready for a Star Trek and Doctor Who crossover - if this is the beginning of it, then count us ready!
2. Jeff Russo And The Music (Up)
While the title sequence above, the music at least, has of course been with the show since its first episode, Jeff Russo and the team behind the music deserve a special mention in both this episode, and in the season as a whole. Star Trek: Discovery is one of the first shows this year to have had their post-production done after lockdown went into effect, meaning that the score was recorded by separate musicians, then compiled by Russo.
Listening to the episode's score, it's almost impossible to tell that these players were not in the same room together!
The level of professionalism and the challenge of putting it all together is astounding. The music for Discovery has been one of its high points since the show began, but here it deserves another look and listen. Fantastic job all around.
1. Happy Ending (Up)
The Discovery crew work hard to start digging the ship out of parasitic ice, a growth that is covering the entire exterior hull. As the sun goes down, it grows faster and faster, threatening to destroy the structural integrity of the vessel and crush everyone inside.
Standard November morning in your car, really.
They are saved at the last moment when a tractor beam comes down around them, rocking the ship and lifting it up out of trouble. Of course, on board the ship which is the origin of the beam, is Michael Burnham.
There is a genuinely heartfelt reunion scene, via viewscreen, between the crew and her - leaving the episode on a very upbeat note. This, if nothing else in this episode, was a true scene of a family coming together.
A very solid second episode to the season and another example of season three hopefully relaunching the show in a positive direction.