Supergirl Season 4: 3 Ups & 2 Downs From 'Blood Memory'

Supergirl tackles a very important matter in a strong and mature outing.

Supergirl S4 Ups Downs 11
The CW

Contains spoilers from Supergirl Season 4, Episode 11.

After spending the first half of its fourth season providing us with a social commentary on some of the issues in modern day America through some clever politically-charged subtext, Supergirl returned to The CW last week with a midseason premiere that took things back to basics. Focusing solely on its core characters, the episode saw Alex Danvers' attempts to protect her sister's true identity fail, ultimately resulting in J'onn J'onzz having to wipe Kara's secret from the mind of every D.E.O. agent (Alex included).

Of course, this continued to play a major role in this week's instalment, 'Blood Memory', as Kara struggled with the realisation that her own sister was no longer aware of the truest part of her and, as a result, didn't relate to Supergirl (or any aliens) in the way that she once did. But the Girl of Steel wasn't the only one having family trouble as newcomer Nia Nal faced some revelations about her own heritage.

All in all, 'Blood Memory' is a tale of clarity - one that takes a welcome detour to place the spotlight on the show's newest character, while still managing to effectively tie it to the season's main narrative.

First, the positives...


3. The Little Things

The CW

While sisterhood struggles in the small town of Parthas were very much the focus of this week's encounter, there was a considerably strong amount of storytelling done around it in order to remind us what was actually going on in the world.

While there, Kara noticed that some civilians were wearing Children of Liberty masks and even walked around town with dogs that could spot aliens. Elsewhere, Alex experienced some difficulty with her memory in the aftermath of J'onn's mind-wipe, alerting her to the possibility that something was off. The episode's subplot, which revolved around dealers who were selling rage-inducing pills that turned people into alien-like creatures, brought everything together nicely as the D.E.O. hunted the dealers down just after they were attacked by the Children of Liberty.

This led to an all-out war in Parthas as Supergirl and Alex clashed over their attempts to stop the rage-induced Children of Liberty, with the latter now exhibiting much less compassion towards aliens - another sign of how she has changed without knowing about Kara's life as Supergirl.

Though all of these long-running stories played a reduced role here, their inclusion helped ground the standalone episode, reminding us that Liberty's anti-alien mission is far from over as well as the fact that Kara is losing the best part of her sister. It was a perfect reminder that, although Kara had taken a short-lived holiday, there was no rest for the Girl of Steel in this increasingly flawed world.


2. The Not-So-Distant Dreamer

Supergirl Dreamer Suit Nia
The CW

Since her introduction, Nia Nal has been circling the season's main storylines while never quite at the heart of them. She did get a chance to shine on occasion, but it wasn't until she revealed her abilities to Kara and subsequently helped the team track down Agent Liberty that she was given some real spotlight. Thankfully, that was a sign of things to come.

The primary focus of this week's episode was Nia's return to her hometown - a story device that finally allowed us to get to know more about the character's backstory. The idea of the family reunion sparked some uneasy feelings for her as she revealed to Kara that her mother possessed the Dreamer abilities and that only her daughter was due to inherit the gift. Being transgender, the family overlooked the possibility that Nia could ever become the next Dreamer and, because of this, she was terrified of revealing the truth to them.

While her mother's happiness (and subsequent death) along with her sister's upset ensured that the trip was a rollercoaster of emotions for Nia, it brought her closer to where she is going. All that, plus the fact that she now knows Kara is Supergirl, has finally put her on a collision course with her super-heroic future. Her return to Parthas has set the stage for Dreamer and, it certainly looks like she's going to arrive sooner rather than later.

But the episode accomplished so much more than just that...


1. Highlighting Important Issues

Supergirl Nia Nal
The CW

Nia's introduction into the show was groundbreaking because it officially introduced the world to TV's first ever transgender superhero. However, 'Blood Memory' took that one step further, using the show's platform to highlight some of the issues that transgender people face on a daily basis.

In the past, Supergirl has become too caught up in trying to make statements that the storylines and characters often suffer, but that was not the case here. The writers cleverly used Nia's alien heritage to create conflict in a family that had already accepted her for who she was long ago, as the resulting argument saw her transgender identity brought into it. While the characterization of Maeve wasn't perfect (more on that later), her heat-of-the-moment comment about Nia "not being a real woman" was cold, callous that, quite frankly, made us uncomfortable, and it served as a powerful reminder of the prejudice that transgender people can face at any given time, even in the safety of their own home.

Nia Nal isn't just a superhero in a TV show, she's a hero to countless people going through what she went through and the writers, cast and crew of Supergirl deserve major credit for representing transgender people and the struggles they face.


Downs...

2. Death Takes A Holiday

Supergirl Isabel Nal
The CW

While the episode's main purpose was to give us a crash course in Nia's family history, that doesn't mean that basic human (or in this case, alien) emotions should be overlooked. From the way in which Nia spoke about her family to the warm greeting she received from her parents when she arrived in Parthas, it was clear that she came from an incredibly loving environment and, even though the writers didn't have an awful long time to set it up, we bought it nonetheless.

This, however, made the death of her mother, Isabel Nal, all the more impossible to fathom. Granted, Isabel's death did serve a purpose as it allowed Nia to get that approval from her mother than she had been seeking and ultimately propel her to embrace her gifts, but it all happened far too quickly.

Suddenly, the episode took unexplained time jumps and, as a result, we didn't even get to see either of the Nal sisters truly grieve for their mother. Moreover, Nia's acceptance of her own abilities and the family drama that ensued from Maeve's discovery all took center stage and resulted in Isabel's death taking a backseat.

A little grief goes a long way in helping us relate to the characters and, unfortunately, there wasn't much here. The death of a parent is monumental to any character but, for some reason, after the initial shock, the impact of Isabel's passing on Nia and Maeve didn't come across that well.


1. Maeve's Actions

Supergirl Maeve Nal
The CW

Nia's struggles over the fact she possessed the very gift her sister had spent her whole life waiting for set the stage for some very juicy conflict between herself and Maeve. Unfortunately, the way that things progressed upon Maeve's discovery of the truth was just a little problematic.

Before we carry on, this doesn't have anything to do with the jibe about Nia "not being a real woman", because as hurtful as that was, it was intentionally designed that way to highlight an important message. The problem with Maeve lay in her ridiculously sudden character change as, somewhere along the line, she turned from loving sister into something else entirely.

This woman who wanted to be a hero more than anything wasn't able to put her feelings aside to help those in need. The fact that she stormed off in a strop, completely unperturbed by the fact that her town was under attack and her sister had just saved her life verged on ridiculousness. It ended up portraying the character as a self-centred overgrown child, and this didn't appear to be the writers' initial intentions.

She had every right to be heartbroken by the realisation that Nia lied to her about her Dreamer abilities, but the personality change was just too jarring. Despite her flaws, she was a good person and yet we were suddenly expected to buy that she didn't care what happened to any of those in danger? Needless to say, this didn't exactly portray her in the most positive light, and that was before she made those unforgivable comments.

-

Did you enjoy this week's episode of Supergirl? Tell us in the comment section below.


In this post: 
Supergirl
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.