Westworld: 8 Flaws That Could Totally Ruin It
Host, analyse: What the hell is going on?
Despite being about to wrap its first season, Westworld has the potential to be HBOs next big sensation. Thanks to being written by Jonathan Nolan and Lisa Joy, it's got suspense, mystery, thrilling action - and Anthony Hopkins chewing the scenery.
What more does a good show need?
On top of that, Westworld is extremely ambitious, refusing to water down its sci-fi concepts or grandiose musings for the casual viewer (Jonathan Nolan is the brother of film-maker and professional mind-bender Christopher Nolan, what do you expect?), but the show isn't without its issues.
In fact, it could be argued that so early on, the show is actually too ambitious, and risks collapsing under the weight of its own aspirations.
Westworld has a lot of positives, but its flaws are substantial enough that they could soon become a major problem.
Here are the eight biggest offenders, and how the show can deal with them.
8. The Timeline Of Events Is Convoluted
Throwing the chronology of events into question has long been a staple of effective writing. Lost was one of the first major shows to popularise this technique, utilising flashbacks, then turning them on their head and revealing flash forwards. With that said, Lost went three whole seasons using flashbacks before this stunning reversal, and that's important.
For three seasons, fans knew where and when they were chronologically, allowing for coherent, compelling storytelling.
Westworld, on the other hand, is potentially rocking three whole timelines within the first season (the Man in Black meeting and recognising the woman who greeted William on his entrance to Westworld at the beginning of the season practically confirms there are at least two). The problem is, because the show is doing very little to delineate time periods, it's confusing as hell.
Lost used audio cues to signal there was a shift in chronology, whereas Westworld chucks these scenes together in an attempt to deliberately confuse the viewer. The solution to this is simple, and it needs to come soon. Concretely establish the various time periods.
Perhaps they're being saved for a season finale twist, but are viewers really expected to readjust the chronology of an entire season in their minds retrospectively?
7. Maeve Is Great, But The Writing Of Her Story Arc Isn't
Maeve is terrific, and Thandie Newton's performance is passionate and compelling. Watching Maeve slowly realise the nature of her reality and attempt to utilise it for her own gain is great, the problem, is that the writing surrounding it is wonky as hell. Specifically, the two technicians helping her.
At this point, Maeve's entire story arc is propped up on an incredibly flimsy foundation, requiring a huge extension of disbelief. Watching the two techs each week, it's practically impossible to understand their motivation. Sure, one of them is perhaps sympathetic to the android who has realised they're not really alive, but the other is apparently afraid he'll be exposed for having sex with some of the Hosts.
How is that worse than the trouble he'll get into for helping an android literally escape the facility? If he really wanted to get out of the situation, he could just tell any number of higher ups that Maeve keeps coming alive on the operating table and threatening to kill him. Boom! Decommissioned. That's not to mention how nonsensical it is that nobody has spotted the two techs running Maeve around the facility. It's already been established there is CCTV absolutely everywhere, and then there are the glass windows...
So what can be done to salvage it? Put simply, the two technicians need to be retired. They're dragging down a fantastic character, and the sooner their ploy to help Maeve is foiled, the sooner we can forget all about it.
6. The Little Inconsistencies Are Beginning To Pile Up
Look, nobody is expecting Westworld, a sci-fi show, to provide every detail and answer every tiny, niggling question about its world. But when the show establishes laws and then begins to break them - or bend them to the point of distraction - then there's a problem.
What do I mean? Well, we were told that Hosts supposedly can't harm guests. We saw them punch, push and tackle at the start of the season. Yet, now this has escalated dramatically, with Hosts pistol whipping guests to knock them unconscious, or Maeve slicing open the Man in Black's throat, among other things. How is this safe or approved?
Another thing: we've seen bodies being retrieved from the main town a few times, but what about the bodies that are literally hundreds of miles away? Those in the wilderness that have visible flesh decay?
Why haven't they been collected? Who collects them, and how?
And then there's the premise of loops, upon which the Hosts are supposedly founded. Many Hosts have now been out of their loops for seemingly days on end, like Dolores and Teddy. Why don't the people running the park care? Especially when such a big deal was made about ensuring their consistency at the start (replacing Dolores' father with a new model).
At present, these things pale in comparison to the storytelling, but the more questions that crop up, the harder it is to focus one-hundred percent on the main story.
The show needs to slow down for a minute and allow room for explanation, lest the world's believability be ruined.
5. We Still Have No Idea What The Maze Is
It's safe to say that one of the shows central, overarching mysteries is that of "the maze", an enigmatic concept that has been referenced by multiple characters and is actively being sought out by the Man in Black. The issue is that eight episodes in, we're still no closer to knowing what it actually is - and that means it's not all that compelling.
Seriously, we have no idea. Is the maze a person? A place? Or nothing more than a vague, philosophical concept? The most we've got to go on is the map found across the park, from being carved on tables to printed on people's scalps. We know it was created by Arnold, but that's it. Nothing more.
Why this is an issue, is because it's hard to really care about the Man in Black's search when we literally don't know what he's searching for. The longer the build up with absolutely no details, the harder it's going to be satisfying audiences with answers.
What would alleviate this issue somewhat would be if the show established the maze's parameters. Fine, keep it as Westworld's ultimate mystery, but start to give viewers something - anything - to up their desire to find out more.
4. The Scenes Between Dolores And William Are Bordering Melodrama
At the beginning of Westworld, Dolores was one of the most interesting and likeable characters. In the first episode specifically, her relationship with Teddy - though animated and exaggerated - was sweet and affecting, built on the sorts of sweeping gestures found in old Western movies.
Her relationship with William, however, is somewhat different. It's tough to get a sense for why Dolores has fallen in love with William, but that's not the main problem. The issue is that, knowing Dolores is a Host, it's impossible to believe she has any genuine feeling for him. After all, we've seen countless Hosts feign emotion over humans. Westworld's central location (the brother) is literally built on this.
What this means is that certain scenes come across as like something from a soap opera. The worst offender is the scene when William rejects Dolores on the train, claiming he has a woman on the outside, only to storm back into her carriage and profess his true feelings. The tone of the entire scene is completely sincere, but knowing what we know about the world and how it works, it's hard to take seriously.
The solution would be to play up to these doubts, revealing in a cunning twist that Dolores doesn't care for William at all, and that she was just manipulating his human emotions for her own gain.
Sadly, there's been no evidence for this twist so far, so it's unlikely to happen.
3. Intricate Puzzles Obscure What The Show Is Really About
At its heart, Westworld appears to be a show about what makes humans human. After all, if the Hosts think that what they see and feel is real, what makes those experiences illegitimate? it's also concerned with the reality of human nature, what humans want and desire when freed from the constraints of societal expectation.
These deliberations are what drive the show and make it interesting, but they're beginning to become obscured by intricacy. At the beginning, the show seemed fascinated by these questions, but now it's moving towards an obsession with puzzles.
Teasing viewers every week with a host of new questions shifts the focus away from how any of it actually relates to its viewers as humans, cutting out the heart of what makes it all compelling.
That's not to say the show should drop its mysteries - definitely not. But using confusion as a way to propel the plot forward and to keep audiences coming back, rather than viewers wanting to return to find out how all of this stuff effects the show's characters is a sure fire way to quickly turn it stale.
As mentioned, the answer is not allowing mystery to become the primary focus, keeping the characters and human aspects of the show at the forefront.
2. Character Motivations Are Loosely Defined
Every week Westworld's story gets larger and more grandiose. At the same time, some of its characters are becoming more difficult to fully understand.
The main offender is Dolores, who appears to be leading William on a quest fuelled purely by random, inconsistent memories (or fragments of memories, or flashbacks, or glitches...it's hard to completely make sense of it all unless you've checked out some of the fan theories online). What, exactly, is her motivation?
The same goes for the bumbling techs helping Maeve. Concretely establishing their motivation at this point would provide some much-needed coherence to their story. But there are other characters with limited motivation, too.
Is William's only motivation that he loves Dolores and wants to help her? What about Teddy? Is his current motivation to get back to Dolores? How about Logan? At this point his vendetta against work colleague William is practically sadistic.
Again, this comes down to the show's interest in vagary at the cost of establishing what makes the characters tick. Providing us with some of these details (and making sure subsequent new characters have their motivations clearly defined) would really help strengthen the show's overall feel.
1. When You Think About It, We Have Absolutely No Idea What's Going On
Here is a small list of the things we don't know so far:
We don't know what the maze is. We don't know who Arnold really was. We don't know who Wyatt is. We don't know what Ford's new story line is, or why he's so insistent on completing it. We don't know with any certainty how many time periods there are. We don't know why Dolores keeps seeing herself everywhere. We don't know who the board overseeing Westworld are or what they want or why they're interfering.
These aren't just small, niggling questions. These questions make up the foundation of the show, of the mystery that drives it. And it's beginning to feel a bit like Lost, using massive, significant enigmas to drive the plot forward at the cost of actually being satisfying to watch. At this point, each subsequent episode of Westworld is exciting based on the premise of what it might actually answer next, rather than what its characters are going to do, feel or experience.
Westworld needs to decide where its central mystery lies and what it's really worth withholding from viewers, because if the show continues to pile on question after question without giving anything back, it's going to collapse under the weight of its own self-imposed ambiguity. Round out season one with a string of big answers and streamline the important mysteries during season two.
--
How are you finding Westworld? Let us know in the comments!