10 Forgotten WWE Experiments That Didn't Last

Experimentation is key, but WWE didn't stick to these forgotten ideas.

Cesaro Ricochet WWE Raw 2019
WWE.com

WWE's product can be fairly formulaic, so it's no wonder the company has sought/continues to seek ways to shake things up. Obviously, not everything they've tried over the years has worked though. For example, concepts like the dreaded 'Brawl For All', the SmackDown 'Junior's Division', Raw Underground and the Greatest Royal Rumble didn't manage to stick.

All of those were flops, but they're well known ones. How about some lesser-remembered schemes that just didn't catch fire or get over with fans? It's those that go under the microscopic lens here, because they're fascinating to unpick and pore over. A lot of them speak volumes about the erm...curious psyche of latter day Vince McMahon too.

Get this: The old boss was trying to think of ways to rejig Raw when the flagship was only a few short years old. Monday's biggest revamps didn't wait until the 'Attitude Era', and there was a not-so-subtle bid to return to the 'War Zone' years after that glorious period too. That came amidst clumsily handled repeats that smacked of uninspiring creative meetings crammed with overworked and frankly shattered writers.

Individual stars as well as TV shows have seen some experimentation too. The Undertaker has mucked about with his presentation/move set here or there, and it almost landed him into trouble. Not to worry though, because he could've just given Sheamus a call to sort everything out in the end.

Also, WWE nearly changed the WWF's logo before 'Getting The F Out'. Long before 'Getting The F Out'.

Enjoy.

10. Braun Strowman Literally Becomes A Train

Braun Strowman Elias
WWE.com

Even A-Train only had literal train sounds in his entrance music.

In 2021, WWE (during the last vestiges of Vince McMahon's loosening grip on company creative) decided that Braun Strowman's gimmicky "Strowman Express" should be more than just a t-shirt. It needed to present the big powerhouse as an actual locomotive who was steamrolling over opponents like helpless birds on the tracks about to become carrion.

For a spell, Braun's run around the ring and big bumping spot was accompanied by train sounds like horns and a carriage gathering speed. It was oddly comedic for someone who was supposed to be one of the roster's most serious threats, and it was never going to last. If anything, creative struck lucky that they didn't try this when live crowds were in after doors opened up again post-pandemic.

Obviously, those in attendance around ringside wouldn't have necessarily heard the train noises (unless they were pumped over the arena PA), but they'd witness them on television. Then, had that become a recurring spot, they would've surely laughed and mocked Strowman's one way ticket to being a jogging punchline rather than a burly badass.

Compare what McMahon tried here to Bron Breakker's deadly spear move today. It's night and day. Apples and oranges. One was born from an out of touch old man's brain as he clutched at straws, whereas the other is accompanied by a satisfying thump sans cartoonish nonsense.

This might've been fine had Braun been a cartoony/comedy character, but he wasn't. So, it didn't fly with the audience. At least WWE had the sense to scrap it pronto.


9. Raw’s ‘Grittier’ Third Hour

WWE Raw Darker Grittier 2019
WWE

May 2019 was a trip, man. Brock Lesnar won a Money In The Bank briefcase nobody wanted him to have (especially Mustafa Ali), and the company debuted a weaker version of the old Hardcore Title via the unwanted 24/7 Title. During that same segment on Raw, Mick Foley also confirmed that the flagship's third hour would be "downright mean and nasty".

This lasted a few weeks before WWE management lost interest and abandoned the idea completely. In truth, nothing of note actually happened anyway. "Mean and nasty" proved to be a glorified lighting switch more than anything. Lighting techs darkened part of the arena, thus making it look more like WCW Nitro in 2000 than some super-cool new direction for WWE's main weekly.

Graphical assets had a new black background for hour 3, and we were all told that this was akin to Raw Is War entering the 'War Zone' back in the late-90s. Not quite. Still PG, the product couldn't live up to the billing or offer anything drastically different to what people were seeing during the first 2 hours of the broadcast, which rendered the whole experiment pretty much pointless.

Put it this way: If the third hour isn't any different beyond some darker lighting and claims that everything's about to get nastier than Sags and Knobbs, then what's the bloomin' point in caring about it? Nobody has ever tuned into a wrestling show and said, 'Ooooh, they changed the lighting a little - I'm hooked'. What was the long term aim here?!

"Mean and nasty" sounded lame too.


8. Raw’s ‘Blue Era’

WWF Raw 1995 Blue
WWE

Raw is red. The end.

Or, at least, that should be the case until the end of time. There are some things people shouldn't tamper with in the biz, and WWE's flagship being the same colour as blood/danger is certainly one of them. For example, can you imagine Monday nights being yellow? How about lime green? Well, back in 1995, the then-WWF decided to play around with a new colour scheme: Blue.

Someone let The Blue Meanie loose with a pot of paint around the place during one of the fed's most derided eras. Those who lived through the mid-90s 'New Generation' period have a bespoke fondness for everything it had to offer, but it was also undeniably crap at times. Sometimes, Raw was very visibly beaming to you from a high school gymnasium, and no amount of ICO PRO banners could hide it.

'The Blue Era' just didn't look right though, so it's no surprise that this only lasted a short time before the McMahon family went back to red. Vince must’ve liked the new paint job, right enough, because blue became SmackDown’s colour scheme in 1999. They'd park that for a while, to be fair. Hell, Superstars and Wrestling Challenge were 'B' and 'C' respectively behind Raw in '95, not Smackers.

Being honest, 'Blue Raw' was half-hearted anyway. The actual set, ring and everything else remained the same. It was only really some wrestle nameplates and a few flashing logos that changed. Some might even believe this was wrestling's very own Mandela Effect, but nope - it happened.


7. Sheamus Debuts “1-800-FELLA”

Sheamus 1-800-FELLA
WWE

Sheamus has put this idea on blast during interviews since, and there could be a touch more criticism coming for it now he's on the outs with WWE. Finally, the world may hear everything there is to learn about the Irishman's fictional phone helpline, and they won't even need to call 1-800-FELLA to find out about it.

In mid-2013, various vignettes began airing that showed Sheamus saving the day...by Brogue Kicking the yellow off everyone's teeth like some sort of well-meaning-but-totally-errant superhero. Marvel quickly got in touch and wanted the 'Celtic Warrior' to play a role in The Avengers. OK, that didn't actually happen. Obviously.

This was another low point for Sheamus. It wasn't quite on par with his King Of The Ring victory and duff royal gimmick, but it was close. 1-800-FELLA was more in tune with the sort of thing you'd see for a comedic lower card gimmick than a refresh for someone who’d been WWE Champion.

Sheamus got injured shortly after the promos began airing, so they were scrapped and everyone promptly forgot they'd ever been a thing. Big ol' S. Farrelly didn't, but he was probably (and secretly) glad that he didn't have to persist with such noise any longer. Main event character, this definitely wasn't.

Fans didn't have zest for more hijinks such as Sheamus rescuing cats from trees or saving someone from choking to death. They wanted to see him work bangers inside the ring. Simple as that. Unfortunately, in Vinnie Mac's non-stop need to 'show personality', this is what 2013 drummed up instead.

Bejesus.


6. Muffy “The Fat Slayer”

Muffy WWE
WWE

Every now and then, WWE likes to remind the paying public that they're not as fit, healthy or motivated as the superstars plying their trade between the ropes. Heel gimmicks such as Simon Dean playing a fitness instructor got on everyone's nerves to an extent, but this generally has a limited shelf life. Here's the deal.

Many wrestling fans know they don't look like Finn Bálor, and they're perfectly fine with that.

So, short-lived skits that saw Stephanie McMahon's kayfabe personal trainer tell people in the cheap seats that they'd reach them less out of puff if they'd just get on the treadmill 3x per week fell on deaf ears. Muffy, played by Caryn Mower, was the one who delivered this news through interludes between matches.

Speaking of Simon Dean, it was that before Nova was repackaged and played the gimmick. Muffy strutted out on stage to berate fans for “being fat” for a few minutes, then she went away again. Afterwards, the dude in Row Q ambled his way down to concessions to check out some 'Stone Cold' merch and maybe get some popcorn. He didn't immediately join the gym and vow to become The Ultimate Warrior.

Clearly, this was an attempt at cheap heel heat and wasn't to be taken super-seriously, but it was too half-baked to really feel important. Muffy had next to no connection to the audience, and it wasn't like Steph was known for being Shawn Michaels circa 1996 back in the year 2000. She barely wrestled at all despite being Women's Champion.

Swing and a miss. No wonder it didn't have staying power.


5. No Action During Ad Breaks

Sami Zayn Seth Rollins 2019
WWE.com

Back to we go to the merry old land of 2019.

Vince McMahon rolled out a puzzling edict that prevented wrestlers from wrestling during wrestling matches that had ad breaks laced throughout a wrestling show. Basically, in his infinite wisdom, he thought it’d reflect real-life sports that stopped gameplay mid-commercial, but it didn’t really work for the medium at all.

WWE booked a ton of '2-Out-Of-3 Falls' matches to make slotting in natural breaks easier. Those quickly became tedious, because they were far too samey, and it was easy for fans watching inside the arenas and at home to spot when workers were readying for those pesky ads. In a way, this only made the bouts seem less like a genuine athletic competition, if you can believe that.

This blew up in McMahon's face in a hurry. Typically, he was never going to stick to this new trope anyway. Restricting his roster to rest holds, double downs or outright pauses without any action bored the pants off those who had stumped up cash for tickets too. Why should they suffer just because they'd elected to actually leave the house and attend the event?! It made no logical sense to punish customers like that.

Thumbs were twiddled, awkward glances were exchanged and more and more people left their chairs to go visit the toilets or buy some snacks. Rumours that Muffy was waiting for them with a slap rather than a freshly poured coke are unsubstantiated.

Stopping the flow of a match completely to serve advertisers just didn't work. Trust wrestlers to work around it!


4. Promo Graphics/Sounds

The Usos Locked Down WWE Graphics
WWE

"Welcome to The Uso penitentiary" was a common refrain before YEET'ing was invented. That was how Jimmy and Jey closed most of their tag-team promos. It didn't quite catch on as much as everyone behind the scenes pretended it did, but it was an identifiable gimmick the brothers could use when closing out their fiery speeches backstage or in-ring.

Then, "Day One-ish" came along and the rest is history.

Before that, WWE put their might behind the penitentiary idea. In January 2018, The Usos talked about all of the other tags they'd beaten as champs. Every single time Jimmy mentioned one, Jey would shout "LOCKED DOWN" as a jail cell graphic popped up on screen to accompany it. This was clear experimentation with overlays and other such assets.

Fair enough, but that sort of thing just kinda got in the way. Remember those big, dumb entrance graphics for Becky Lynch, Roman Reigns and others? Yeah, they were reminiscent of that. Maybe not as egregious or outright terrible looking (Roman's 'Big Dog', in particular, looked like something from the PS2/PS3 era), but still unwanted and a bit flimsy.

Years later, Matt Riddle kicked off his flip flops and a bunch of CGI'd birds rocketed towards the viewer. That was bad (not to everyone, of course), but it lasted longer than The Usos getting "LOCKED DOWN" (all caps for Jey's bellowing voice!) did. This was evidently something WWE higher-ups thought would go over well with those watching at home, but it never really fit and actually served to suck you out of the in-arena experience.


3. The Undertaker’s ‘Deadman Biker’ Gear

The Undertaker No Way Out 2001
WWE Network

What in the name of time machine awkwardness is this?!

At No Way Out 2001, The Undertaker teamed with his storyline brother Kane vs. The Dudley Boyz and Edge & Christian in a Triple Threat Tables bout. It's one of the pay-per-view's lesser-remembered matches, probably because The Rock vs. Kurt Angle, a '3 Stages Of Hell' war between Triple H and Steve Austin, and even Trish Stratus vs. Stephanie McMahon stick out in fan memories more vividly.

Here's something you might've forgotten about: 'Taker wore some old school 'Deadman' ring attire for the show, and he did that smack bang in the middle of his 'American Bad Ass' biker days. Huh? Why?! The world may never know, but it definitely happened. 'The Phenom' looked way more like a mix between his mid-90s look and the late-90s 'Ministry Of Darkness' era than anything Kid Rock or Limp Bizkit.

This was so strange. Perhaps he lost some of his 'Bad Ass' gear en route to Las Vegas, or maybe Undertaker simply fancied mixing things up a bit and seeing if anyone would notice. He even rocked the classic 'Taker symbol on his chest, but had "Deadman Inc" on his tights. Again, very odd.

Someone needs to ask the man himself what was going on here. That might've been done on one of the countless shoot-style interviews or podcasts he's done since hanging up his boots, to be fair. There are so many out there that some stories were always bound to slip through the cracks.


2. ‘Taker’s Elbow Drop

The Undertaker Old School Elbow Drop
WWE

Slipping off the top rope must've been an ongoing worry for 'The Deadman' early on in his federation career when he was trying out this forgotten finisher. You almost definitely don't recall it at all, but here's how it went: 'Taker would scale the ropes, walk along them like he would for decades when going 'Old School', then drop an elbow.

The fact someone so physically large could stroll along the top strand for a few steps unaided (nobody was holding onto his hand to help maintain balance) was very impressive, and it shows how grateful and athletic a worker he was even when playing the original, slow-moving zombie. Falling flat on his face would've been embarrassing.

Maybe that's why Undertaker dropped this from his arsenal.

This 'Old School' elbow scored the newcomer a few wins before both the chokeslam then the Tombstone Piledriver became his go to signatures. Admittedly, it looked bloody rubbish, because he'd land CM Punk style rather than flush like Randy Savage. That might've been done to protect those he was working with, because earning an early reputation for hurting others wouldn't have done 'Taker any good in the WWF.

Even so, the image of him pretty much landing on his feet anyway before dropping the elbow rendered coming off the top fairly pointless. This was never going to be workable long-term. It would've been quite the thump had he tweaked it, but that would've put his peers at risk. Bizarrely, the Tombstone was much safer and didn't result in pointy bits to the ribs/chest.


1. A Split WWF Logo

Ken Shamrock WWF No Mercy 1999 UK Split WWF WWE Logo
WWE

The above is a still screenshot taken from Sky Box Office hype for the then-upcoming No Mercy 1999 pay-per-view. Not the one in the US later that same year, but the UK exclusive one that fans elsewhere would only be able to get on VHS or DVD in the future. Arguably the only match worth seeing on it was the main event pitting Steve Austin vs. Triple H vs. Undertaker in an 'Anything Goes' Triple Threat.

They opened with a 60 second clash between Tiger Ali Singh and Gillberg. Yeah.

What do you notice first when scanning that promotional graphic above? Ken Shamrock's shadowy face even though he wasn't actually on the card? Or, is it that curious looking split WWF ('WW-F') logo which was only used this once? That sticks out as odd, because it'd never be seen anywhere else again.

Thinking about it, this could’ve been something to do with the World Wildlife Fund and the company's inability to openly promote the WWF acronym in the United Kingdom. Nonetheless, it’s fascinating to effectively see that WWE logo 3 years before it was a thing. There was an 'F' crudely sitting close by, but still.

Move the little red underline slightly to the left there, and you've pretty much got the logo they'd use from May 2002 until 2014 and a fresh, 'scratch-less' redesign. That was surely accidental, 'cause Vince McMahon didn't know for sure he'd have to rebrand completely in May '99.

What a bizarre bit of advertising all round - it showed a wrestler who wasn't on the show promoted, and it couldn't even use the WWF's proper symbolism.

What other forgotten experiments from WWE history can you think of? For more wrestling, check out 10 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: Necro Butcher vs. Samoa Joe and 101 Shocking Wrestling Plans You Won't Believe Almost Happened!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.