10 Great Wrestlers (With Terrible WrestleMania Records)
6. Big Show (5-12)
No doubt some people will scoff at the idea of Big Show being a great wrestler, but the furore surrounding his recent defection to AEW shows that Paul Wight is still a valuable commodity in the business. And in the words of the late, great Tracy Smothers "The only place you need to win is going to the bank".
Which is good news for Wight, because his WrestleMania record was abysmal.
WWE never really got behind the Big Show, and his matches at the Granddaddy of Them All reflected that. He lost his first six bouts there, his one and only main event appearance saw him be the first man eliminated in a fatal four way, and he got beaten by not one but two non-wrestlers.
Put it this way - when you have enough embarrassing 'Mania moments in your locker that WWE decide to build a feud around it, it's safe to say you've never been seen as the top man in the company.