10 Mae Young Classic Wrestlers WWE Must Sign

Cherry-picking the best WWE's women's tournament has to offer.

toni storm
WWE.com

It's hard to believe the Mae Young Classic is already nearing completion. The tournament debuted on 28 August, but WWE's decision to release the episodes four at a time means that only 12 September's live finale remains, with Shayna Baszler and Kairi Sane set to fight for the crown.

While the MYC's talent pool isn't as deep as last year's Cruiserweight Classic, WWE still did a great job in assembling a diverse, multi-talented group of performers. They've produced a number of good bouts together, particularly outwith the first round, and Sane vs. Baszler should be excellent. Both are among the tournament's biggest standouts, and they'll tear the house down if given enough time.

A number of MYC participants already call WWE their home promotion, but at least a dozen others would be great fits for NXT at the moment, and a handful look ready for the main roster. A swathe of signings would keep the company's women's division stocked for the foreseeable future, and if WWE follow the CWC's blueprint, there's a strong chance they've already prepared contracts for the top performers.

They won't all get deals, but each of the following would be an immediate boon to the company...

10. Tessa Blanchard

Tessa Blanchard
WCPW/Oli Sandler @The Ringside Perspective

Just like Kay Lee Ray, Tessa Blanchard was eliminated from the Mae Young Classic entirely too early. Sure, tournament favourite Kairi Sane had to advance, but the company could have just booked her and Blanchard against different opponents to avoid this problem.

Their bout was one of the first round's biggest highlights, and while Sane stole the show, Tessa looked as good as she ever has. She worked heel throughout, generating a great deal of sympathy for her superstar opponent, but had plenty of time to shine throughout the back-and-forth affair, particularly during the fast-paced closing stretch.

She's only 22 years old, but Blanchard has been used by WWE multiple times in the past. She played squash match fodder for Carmella, Nia Jax, and Alexa Bliss in 2016, and her participation in the MYC shows that she hasn't left WWE's radar, despite her lack of recent usage. Sure, she's still a work in progress, but her youth, well-rounded skills, and flashy moveset mean she's a white-hot prospect, and the fact that she's WWE Hall of Famer Tully Banchard's daughter probably doesn't hurt either, given the company's love of 2nd and 3rd generation athletes.


9. Kay Lee Ray

Kay Lee Ray Princess Sugehit
WWE.com

Booking Scotland's Kay Lee Ray to lose to Princesa Sugehit in the Mae Young Classic's first round was a blunder on WWE's behalf. It's not that her opponent didn't deserve to advance, but KLR is one of Europe's finest women's wrestlers, and someone whose skill should've guaranteed a deep run in the tournament. Sadly, the writing was on the wall as soon as she was paired with the tourney's only Mexican participant.

Regardless, she's somebody that WWE should think about picking up soon. She's often labelled a 'daredevil', but while she definitely fits this tag, there's a lot more to Ray's game than such a title suggests. She can be a smooth, crisp technical wrestler when she needs to be, and her work in indie promotions like ATTACK! and Fight Club Pro shows she's no slouch when it comes to the entertainment side of the game either.

WWE used KLR as a squash opponent for Nia Jax on an October 2015 episode of NXT. She's clearly on their radar, and while her young age (25) means there's no hurry to sign her, she'd be an immediate developmental standout if she showed up at the next set of tapings.


8. Candice LeRae

Candice LeRae, Shayna Baszler
WWE.com

Signing Candice LeRae should really be a no-brainer. She came in with one of the tournament's biggest reputations, and justified the hype with a strong showing against the inexperienced Renee Michelle in round one, then again with Nicole Savoy in the second, before falling to Shayna Baszler in the quarter finals.

Candice is one of America's most popular independent wrestlers. She's primarily known for intergender wrestling and her work as one half of the World's Cutest Tag Team with Joey Ryan, which may explain the company's decision to hold off on signing her thus far. Regardless, LeRae is just as adapt at competing within the confines of a women's division, and has put on a number of great matches on both sides of the Atlantic this year.

She's also married to Johnny Gargano, which means there's a ready-made storyline for WWE to take advantage of should they agree a deal.

LeRae's appearance in an NXT battle royal led to speculation that she'd been signed back in April, though this hasn't happened yet. Either way, she's one of the most notable names that WWE haven't signed yet. Surely it's only a matter of time?


7. Kavita Devi

Kavita Devi, Dakota Kai
WWE.com

WWE currently have a number of Indian wrestlers on their books. Jinder Mahal obviously takes top billing, but there are also guys like Jeet Rama and Kishan Raftar, who have been doing the rounds on NXT's house show circuit for months, but are yet to debut on television.

The company are clearly serious about expanding into what they feel is an untapped wrestling market, but it's surprising that they haven't scooped a women's wrestler from the region yet. Fortunately, the answer is right under their noses.

Kavita Devi put forth a strong effort against Dakota Kai in the MYC's first round. The match lasted less than four minutes, but she was put over as a strong, dominant competitor in defeat. Much of this was down to her opponent's expert selling, but she caused quite the stir on social media, and attracted huge interest online, particularly in India.

Devi attended WWE's Dubai tryout in April, but hasn't actually signed with the company yet, despite working at the Performance Center prior to the tourney. Now would be an excellent time to sign the Great Khali-trained athlete, though she'd likely need some more experience before making it to TV.


6. Mia Yim

Mia Yim, Shayna Baszler
WWE.com

Otherwise known as former TNA Knockouts Champion Jade, Mia Yim defeated Sarah Logan in the Mae Young Classic's first round, before falling to Shayna Baszler at the next stage. Both sit among the tournament's better bouts thus far, with her technical ability, athleticism, and in-ring versatility shining throughout.

Yim is an excellent all-rounder. She's just as comfortable throwing nasty strikes as she is applying snug submission holds, and she's a great seller too. Furthermore, she was with TNA for close to four years, so she already knows how to work a sports entertainment-friendly style, and shouldn't need to be taught how to play to a hard TV camera - a common problem among new WWE signees.

WWE could probably throw Yim on Raw or SmackDown tomorrow and she wouldn't look out of place. In fact, given the sheer volume of fresh talent in the Performance Center at the moment, this may just be the best option. She'd be one of NXT's strongest wrestlers, but the likes of Kairi Sane, Lacey Evans, and Sarah Logan are on the cusp of breaking out in developmental, and her presence would only detract from her fellow newcomers.


5. Piper Niven

Piper Niven, Toni Storm
WWE.com

Piper Niven has emerged as one of the Mae Young Classic's biggest breakout stars. While everybody knew the likes of Kairi Sane and Mia Yim were potential megastars ahead of the tournament, Niven's name was rarely mentioned as a standout. She has since charged out of the gates to impress anyone who's been paying attention, outshining some of the tourney's bigger names in the process.

It's easy to draw comparisons with current main roster wrestlers Tamina and Nia Jax, but Niven is a far more compelling performer. Yes, power moves are her bread and butter, but she's far from one dimensional and projects a stronger sense of character than most in the tournament. Throw her natural charisma and inherent likeability into the mix, and you're left with a wrestler whose talents demand a bigger spotlight.

She's still only 26 years old, but Niven has been wrestling since 2008, acquiring a wealth of experience around Europe and beyond. Currently on tour with Japan's celebrated Stardom promotion, Piper will be back in America for the MYC's live final show on 12 September, and there's a great chance we'll see her in a WWE ring again after that.


4. Serena Deeb

Serena Deeb Vanessa Borne
WWE.com

Serena Deeb is this year's Brian Kendrick.

The former WWE Tag Team Champion shone in last year's Cruiserweight Classic, not only for his crafty veteran performances in the ring, but because of his narrative. The company built Kendrick's tournament run around a compelling redemption story focused on him hitting rock bottom after his last WWE release, before finally turning his life around. It made him extremely easy to root for, and Deeb falls into the same category.

While Serena's own story hasn't been as life-or-death as Kendrick's, playing on her struggles with addiction and rebirth as a yogi was a smart move, and made her one of the tournament's more interesting participants.

She looked good in carrying the extremely green Vanessa Borne in their first round match, and also put forth a strong performance against Piper Niven at the next stage, though eventually defeated. Still, she'd be an excellent veteran presence in NXT, fulfilling the midcard gatekeeper's role that Mickie James should probably be playing on Raw at the moment, using her wealth of experience to put the next wave of young talent over.


3. Jazzy Gabert

Jazzy Gabert
WWE.com

Kairi Sane aside, no Mae Young Classic competitor caught the crowd's attention like Jazzy Gabert during the first round. A towering, musclebound performer, her clash with Abbey Laith had Full Sail University in raptures, and though she lost, the 'Alpha Female' shone through with her unique look, imposing aura, and brutish MMA-inspired offence.

Gabert is a superstar in the making. She's exactly what WWE want Nia Jax to be, but is far more adept at projecting her character, and has a stronger grasp of how to utilise her power. She's not on the same level of a Bull Nakano or Aja Kong, but Jazzy would make a tremendous monster character in NXT or on the main roster, and the MYC proves that she can connect with WWE audiences.

None of this should come as a huge surprise. Gabert has been active in the sport since 2001, and though she's spent most of her time in Europe and Japan, she stopped by TNA for a brief run in 2014. Now 35 years old, time is running out for her to make an impact on the American wrestling scene, which means signing her should be a matter of priority.


2. Shayna Baszler

Shayna Baszler
WWE.com

It looks like WWE are on the verge of booking MMA's Four Horsewomen against their former NXT counterparts. Ronda Rousey, Marina Shafir, and Jessamyn Duke squared up to Charlotte Flair, Becky Lynch, and Bayley in a backstage segment released after this week's set of Mae Young Classic shows, and while nothing is confirmed yet, it'd be a big surprise if it didn't go ahead.

When/if it does, Shayna Baszler will be tasked with doing much of the heavy lifting. Her MMA compatriots have all seemingly started training, but she's the only one with significant in-ring experience, having competed on the independent circuit since her UFC release in 2015.

A genuine pioneer of women's MMA, the wrestling style of 'the Queen of Spades' draws heavily on her previous career. She has made a seamless transition to her new profession, and while there are still a few rough edges in her work, she looks extremely convincing whether working limbs and peppering opponents with strikes. More importantly, Baszler comes off like a legitimate badass whenever she's onscreen, and although she's a totally different wrestler to Asuka, this aura makes her well-suited to taking the 'Empress Of Tomorrow's spot in NXT.


1. Toni Storm

Kairi Sane, Toni Storm
WWE.com

No Mae Young Participant has come off like a bigger star than Toni Storm. The reigning PROGRESS Women's Champion carries herself with supreme confidence, dominating the screen with the presence of a wrestler who's been doing this decades. That's something that even performers with thrice her experience struggle to pull off, but Storm has mastered the art, and she's still only 21.

Aside from star power, Toni's supreme in-ring ability is her next biggest selling point. She's extremely athletic, and while her style isn't entirely based on speed and agility, this helps her set and maintain a breathless pace when required. As adept at handling herself in technical grappling exchanges as she is throwing opponents around with suplexes, Storm is one of the most complete women's wrestlers on the planet, and she already has bundles of great matches on her résumé.

Microphone ability might by Toni's only real downside. She's largely untested in that department, but there's little doubt a stint at the Performance Center would help ease any deficiencies in her work. Don't get it twisted, though: Toni Storm is already among the best in the world, and it's only a matter of time before WWE send an offer her way.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.