10 Most Surreal WWE Matches Ever
Horror show in a half-shell.
This Sunday's Men's 5-on-5 Traditional Survivor Series line-up is surreal in the extreme, all things considered.
The bridge was once considered burnt by Shane McMahon, who famously relinquished the WWE throne to sister Stephanie in 2009. Ditto rival captain Kurt Angle - and that's before stringent medical testing was thought to have put paid to the prospect of his in-ring return. Angle can still go in short bursts, but you'd never think it to look at him: the man's posture is caved in, in addition to his compounded neck.
Braun Strowman is a Vince McMahon wet dream fans are actually on board with. Finn Bálor is the one wrestler on the planet able to reconcile the great divide between Kevin Dunn and the hardcore fandom. Samoa Joe and Bobby Roode, just a few short years ago, were TNA guys - and thus considered tumours. Shinsuke Nakamura forged his career in defiance of WWE: he worked a ludicrously stiff style, and is Japanese. Triple H, John Cena and Randy Orton provoked apathy by wrestling in some combination for what felt like aeons just under a decade ago. Ironically, they might even generate "Fight Forever!" chants, if the match lives up to its immense potential.
And yet, all 10 men will do battle in Houston - but they may still have a problem out-WTFing the following dreamlike mind-f*cks...
10. Donald Trump Vs. Rosie O'Donnell - RAW, January 8, 2007
The one time Vince McMahon was alert to the pulse of wider culture, post-Attitude Era, saw him capitalise on the beef between pre-presidential Donald Trump and Rosie O'Donnell - and book two impersonators to settle their differences on the flagship. We often complain, exaggeratedly, that Vince McMahon plays to an audience of one. This is that complaint manifested literally; absolutely everybody in the audience rejected this self-serving bullsh*t.
The match began with Trump and O'Donnell trading barbs. "I'm gonna take everything you have and buy me a large pizza!" said Rosie - as if Trump's historic involvement with WWE and O'Donnell's very being wasn't enough to help you determine whose side Vince was on. Trump constantly tended to his hair, destroying the rule of the running gag. Rosie was in no condition to perform, at first. She needed a prematch meal, and so tucked in to some ringside cake. Rosie took over the early going - because, naturally, she had the weight advantage. Trump, fighting back, roared "Come on fatty - come here and get some barbecue sauce!"
Yes, McMahon made certain to throw in a Jim Ross-sized dig, too.
They riffed on the Hogan Vs. André WrestleMania III finish to finish, and the folly was profundly exposed; never had WWE seemed so small-time.
9. John Cena Vs. Brock Lesnar - Extreme Rules 2012
The very sight of Brock Lesnar in a WWE ring was surreal in 2012. He walked out on the company eight years earlier, made thoroughly miserable by the brutal schedule - and far surpassed his initial celebrity and purse by briefly dominating the UFC Heavyweight division in the interim.
Money talked, and thus Lesnar returned to the fold under unprecedented terms. His debut match saw him beat and bloody the man he perceived to luck out on his throne: John Cena. It was astonishing to witness such a claret-drenched, one-sided thrashing at the height of the SuperCena Era. Blood, to every other performer, was a no-no. Lesnar smeared the blood he scraped from Cena's skull over his chest, and licked it - literally lapping up the singular freedom afforded to him. We were even treated to a ludicrous sight gag in the midst of it all; Lesnar hoisted ref Charles Robinson up by his belt like a suitcase. Lesnar always does have one eye on his private plane, so it was fairly apt.
More surreal still was the finish. After absorbing very little punishment, comparatively, Lesnar - WWE's hideously expensive meal ticket - ate the pin. Over the course of 18 crazed minutes, the status quo was shattered - and depressingly restored, just as quickly.
8. Bret Hart Vs. Vince McMahon - WrestleMania XXVI
Longtime fans of the 'Hitman' were left in a state of sadness and disbelief at WrestleMania XXVI.
In wrestling, real-life separations tend to last as long as those in go-home show pull-apart brawls - but this was Vince McMahon Vs. Bret Hart. The latter accused the former not just of ruining his career, but ruining his life. Hart, McMahon's most loyal ever lieutenant, was taken 'round back and shot when he wasn't even dying.
In 2010, something talked - money, ego, the need for absolution/to let go, respectively - and Bret Hart entered a programme with McMahon culminating at 'Mania. This wasn't the Hart of old; he'd retired following a devastating concussion, shortly following which he suffered a debilitating stroke. He was physically incapable of and legally unable to take any bumps. Consequently, the match manifested as a disturbing, pointless, protracted 11 minute steel chair massacre.
If the visual was surreal in itself, even more so was Hart's betrayal of himself; the in-ring perfectionist, the master of his craft, cared more about settling a prehistoric dispute than preserving his legacy of giving the fans the best possible performance.
7. The Toxic Turtles Vs. Ron Preston & Tommy Stevenson - Wrestling Challenge, March 9, 1993
The Toxic Turtles were Duane 'Gillberg' Gill and Barry Hardy - two jobber journeymen who, after years of searching, finally conceived of their big break: ripping off, wholesale, the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.
This idea wasn't as moronic as it first appeared, insofar as getting the green light. Vince McMahon loves alliteration, and in 1993, he loved the most naff sh*te imaginable. The second he saw Gill breakdancing in the outfit backstage, he booked the Turtles on the spot in a match with two other jobbers. Bear in mind that this was a different time. The reviled Survivor Series semi-main, banana skins and all, actually drew a mildly positive reaction. This did not.
It isn't in the so-bad-it's-good realm; it's just bleak. The Turtles ran to the ring, bumping their fists in the air as if they'd finally made it. One or two kids in the audience - max - popped. One Turtle - "Terry" or "Tommy" - started the match by dancing about and giving the crowd a "Get a load of this!" gesture as his partner encouraged a clap. He then fell on his back, but, being a turtle, could not get up.
The crowd died. Tragically, so too did the enthusiasm of the Turtles; they soon dispensed with the radical body language, and finished their match with shame visibly seeping out of their pores.
6. Goldberg Vs. Brock Lesnar - Survivor Series 2016
Goldberg played a blinder in 2016.
He was never institutionalised by pro wrestling - and thus, when he was ground into dust by WWE's oppressive booking and Triple H's ego trips, he simply blew into the wind. He discussed his run in the years since not with bitterness but a sort of detached disbelief - and in those years since, WWE, short on genuine creative inspiration, opted to play the nostalgia card. Goldberg, moved into a return by the prospect of wrestling in front of his son, belatedly returned to the fold with much in the way of leverage.
On November 20, 2016, that proved to be an understatement.
The sight of Goldberg obliterating Lesnar in just 01:26 - a shove, two Spears and a Jackhammer was all it took - rocked the fandom. Short of any logical answers, we only asked questions in a delirious fugue. Lesnar's two-year dominance was wasted on a 50 year-old? Was that an awesome moment, or a long-term disaster? What the f*ck just happened?
Lesnar lasted less in there than WCW luminaries such as John Nord, Van Hammer and Rocco Rock - the mangled memories of which only numbed the mind yet more.
5. The Undertaker Vs. Mankind - King Of The Ring 1998
The WWF had already implemented a more violent approach prior to June 1998 in their march towards the Attitude Era: Steve Austin popularised the crazed arena-wide brawl; the blood ban had been lifted; the Spanish announce table was now firmly a wrestler-sized crash pad; chairs were as plentiful in the ring as they were in the stands...
This was something else. The Undertaker threw Mankind from the top of the Cell, a fall that incurred several horrendously painful-sounding injuries - and then through it, a fall that almost incurred death, given how close the leg of one such chair was in proximity to Foley's skull. This was suicidal backyard wrestling performed on the grandest and most glamorous stage, essentially. Mankind kept getting back up, and back up, after suffering the sickest bumps ever performed in the mainstream. It was like taking in a blockbuster sequel the very second before you left your cinema seat.
This remains the most harrowing, violent and disturbing match Mick Foley ever wrestled - and this is a man who has dealt with exploding barbed wire boards and timed bombs.
4. The Undertaker Vs. The Dudley Boyz - The Great American Bash 2004
Vince McMahon must have been desperate - the man is famously adverse to treating tag team wrestling seriously - to green light a handicap doubles bout as the main event of a pay-per-view. Knowing that a further stipulation was required, somebody, somewhere devised the 'Concrete Crypt'.
The storyline was nonsense; essentially, if Undertaker didn't do "the right thing," and accept Paul Heyman's advocacy by laying down for the Dudleyz, Paul Bearer would be entombed in cement. "The right thing" was somehow teased as a mystery in the weeks leading up the Bash, which, Christ. 2004 was significantly worse than 1995. Bearer's stuff was clearly pre-filmed, rendering the already ridiculous absolutely preposterous. This match was also rubbish - so you'd think the cuts to Heyman, with his hand on the lever of the cement mixer, would represent a welcome diversion. They didn't, for this was the worst promo work of Heyman's career.
"You're a good dog. And I'm a nice master. So don't you test me again!"
After easily dispatching of the Dudleyz, 'Taker decided to up and murder Bearer anyway - after scaring Heyman off with a lightning bolt. Was this a WWE main event? Did WWE just simulate murder?
How was this not a heel turn?
3. Kurt Angle, Dean Ambrose & Seth Rollins Vs. The Miz, The Bar, Kane And Braun Strowman - TLC 2017
The hysterical Roman Reigns detractors were sort of proved right in the end: the very second he left for a short, enforced spell, WWE turned into this Bizarro Land of Match Of The Year contenders and impossible comebacks that were as sudden as they were glorious.
The sight of Kurt Angle in full Shield regalia, completing the Reigns cosplay act by mimicking his pre-Triple Powerbomb roar, remains beautifully absurd.
Angle wasn't meant to make it back to WWE; the more ghoulish publications out there probably still have an obituary tucked in a shared folder, such was the grim inevitability of his drastic painkiller dependency. But come back he did, having conquered addiction like he'd conquered so much else. He also wasn't meant to wrestle - optimistic whispers were reduced to silence when it became apparent that Angle hadn't yet undergone medical testing.
But wrestle he did, in a match that went full surreal; Angle, beaming stepdad, was power-slammed through a table by Braun Strowman, who was ostensibly killed off in a trash compactor by a demonic mayoral candidate, allowing a reconciled Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose a faint chance of defeating Sheamus, Miz and Cesaro, the latter of whom finally taking his rightful place in a WWE main event.
Angle's triumphant return to the fray was a brilliant wrinkle to what was, literally, a stupidly good match.
2. The Rock & Steve Austin Vs. Hulk Hogan, Scott Hall & Kevin Nash - RAW, March 11, 2002
How many days away were we from WrestleMania X8 when this absolutely ridiculous match took place?
Six. Six days.
We know this because Messrs. Hogan, Nash and Hall repeated this tidbit constantly in their pre-match promo. This minute-long segment could not have acted as a more fitting symbol of their failure; the nWo, who threatened the very existence of WCW, were reduced to shills in the WWF.
The match itself was a real curio, more than it was a classic. The five biggest drivers of the Attitude Era in the driver's seat towards the Road to WrestleMania, this surefire PPV-seller was thrown away on free television by the tag team-allergic Vince McMahon. Austin Vs. Nash - ending in a schmozz with the barest physical exchange between the major players - surely would have sufficed. Given that it was a popcorn break punch-up, there was little to really see in terms of content - but furrow underneath, and it's never anything less than interesting. Hogan's selling for Austin's offence (a crazy sentence to write) was dismal.
Purposefully so: Austin rejected the mooted 'Mania match, and the inner cynic can't help but feel that Hogan loved crumpling to the floor like a sack of sh*t whenever Austin went anywhere near him.
1. Vince McMahon Vs. Stephanie McMahon - No Mercy 2003
"You've become a disrespectful little b*tch!"
"You want me to take Daddy's Little Girl, and crush her in my hand, and throw her on the mat, and leave her a bloody pulp?"
And that is how WWE sold No Mercy 2003, live on pay-per-view: with the promise of a billionaire father half-killing his daughter for all the world to see. This was real only-in-America stuff, the opening salvo of which set the blackly hilarious tone: as Stephanie gently ushered concerned mother Linda out of the ring, Vince smacked Stephanie across with back with a brutal forearm, drawing an involuntary, guilty guffaw from the 254,000 pathomaniacs glued to the telly. McMahon was in imperious form, screaming "You like that?", with all its unsettling connotations, as he threw his daughter around the ring. It was surreal then - and the sight of Stephanie McMahon selling enthusiastically is f*cking surreal now.
"Mr. McMahon cannot call himself a father," winced Michael Cole on commentary. He d*mn sure could call himself a promotor, and a performer, after this: this was advanced drama from the most basic components - and Vince's beg-for-mercy fake-out bit was cinematic stuff for this Big Top circus.