10 Original Failed WWE Pushes You Completely Forgot About

Getting a second chance to make a first impression.

Honky Tonk Man Hulk Hogan
WWE

When WWE get it right first time, it's magic. One only need to look to NXT in recent years for the sort of debuts that were truly out-of-the-box awesome to know and feel an emotion sadly currently lacking in the Empty Arena Era.

To the strains of a "Glorious" theme, Bobby Roode had an It Factor TNA had worked to fabricate for years. In 2017, "ADAM COLE BAY BAY" echoed throughout the Barclays Center from a Brooklyn crowd barely removed the former ROH star's debut and formation of The Undisputed Era alongside Kyle O'Reilly and Bobby Fish. Shinsuke Nakamura's TakeOver: Dallas maiden entrance and match was perhaps the WWE debut perfected - it's since come to represent the peak of a run perpetually perforated by just how spectacular his arrival was.

There are sadly more catastrophes to oppose these rampant success stories, but there's something to be said for a first draft going so poorly that fans simply erase it from their memories. WWE's cockeyed creative machine has made a lie of yet another adage - you can get a second chance to make a first impression, as long as the majority of fans have forgotten your initial effort...

10. The Headbangers - The Flying Nuns

flying nuns
WWE.com

Shotgun Saturday Night was much of what its title suggested - a blast by WWE right into its own face, paying no heed to the ramifications of pulling the trigger when such extreme measures were deemed necessary.

Vince McMahon was already in the process of borrowing liberally from ECW in the shifting tones and styles of promos and brawls brought forth by Stone Cold Steve Austin et al, but the New York nightclub locale was an added quirk never attempted before or since by a company typically fastidious in their production standards and output. The shows, lovingly, looked like sh*t. But the sort of sh*t you couldn't stop staring at.

Yellow ropes, before they were the preserve of NXT, were there as police tape to go with an aesthetic that looked like it was breaking laws, even if they were just around fire hazards and maximum occupancy. The Flying Nuns visiting a church before hitting the Mirage Nightclub for a bout with The Godwinns were an act so toothless they should have been illegal, even if really it was just an ecumenical matter.

They were one-and-done as the company did the opposite of the late night broadcast and erred on the side of caution.


9. Rosey - Samoan Gangsta Party

Rosey Jamal
WWE

A bland idea spinning off from another one, the Samoan Gangsta Party were barely given their own name let alone screen time during their brief appearances on WWE television in 1995 as former Headshrinker Fatu suddenly abandoned the cartoonish savage he'd been playing on television for years in pursuit of "Makin' a difference".

Hard to hate but just as tricky to love, the gimmick was what it was. Fatu spoke earnestly of his hope for a brighter future for the tough neighbourhoods he frequented in vignettes and during his real life, but it did little to reconnect WWE's broader audience with a man toe-tagged by a doubles run that had no right to end as flatly as it did.

Stood shoulder to shoulder with the future Rosey was Samu, another former Headshrinker that had left a year prior right as the act found itself on the wrong side of its peak. This slab of history and the linked gimmicks offered more than just a generic Samoan turf war, but the duo were gone without trace just weeks after trying to stare out the future Rikishi.


8. The Honky Tonk Man - Hulk Hogan's Friend

Honky Tonk Man Hulk Hogan
WWE

A character so detached from how fans felt about it that WWE rapidly turned it into an opportunity to add loads of addresses to their mailing list, The Honky Tonk Man being a buddy of the WWE Champion was the only likeable thing about this Elvis-wannabe d*ckhead that sailed into town with none of 'The King's talent and some hideous suspenders keeping his tights up.

That was the whole pitch. Honky was here, Hogan said he was great in spite of a working style that undermined his cheerleading, but get in the Pink Cadillac or get kicked to the kerb, brother.

Rarely had this relatively new mass audience made a decision so easy for the company to make when time came for his heel turn. Clocking the boos (and, just as importantly, the lack of cheers) the organisation trotted an indignant Honky out in front of the cameras to ask for a "Vote Of Confidence" he knew he wasn't going to get.

It was inspired, and actually increased the heat he garnered upon embracing the dark side - he drew a fortune as the sh*t-scared Intercontinental Champion a year later.


7. Barry Windham - The Widowmaker

Barry Windham
WWE

Vince McMahon's failure to bring Ric Flair into the fold in 1988 ultimately robbed the company of a dream match with Hulk Hogan years before The Chairman simply didn't see the appeal for WrestleMania several years later. More's the pity too - he had every other Horseman on the books a year later.

Just months removed from Arn Anderson and Tully Blanchard's arrival, JJ Dillon took a front office job with the company, and just a short time after that, Barry Windham was also on board.

A beloved babyface and hated heel for years in the NWA, Windham's character was watered down to being neither one nor the other as the barely villainous Widowmaker in mid-1989. His aesthetic shared that of his most recent run with the opposition, but a series of televised squash didn't come with any of the heat big Baz should have brought along with him.

A heel by default, the closest he came to an actual angle was working that year's Survivor Series before he left the company ahead of the show. His latter spells as The Stalker and member of The New Blackjacks didn't move many needles, but at least left a deeper footprint in company history than the flawed first attempt.


6. Lex Luger - WBF Bodystar

Lex Luger WBF
WWE

In a move that ultimately diffused his eventual arrival a year later but found a way around getting him on television in the meantime, Lex Luger's trip North from WCW in 1992 brought him in as a member of Vince McMahon's fledging World Bodybuilding Federation.

This got around a no-compete clause, and also positioned the 'Total Package' in a role relatively familiar-feeling, but several huge setbacks came between Luger and Bodybuilding supremacy.

The idea was already on its a*se around the time Lex informally debuted via link-up promo at WrestleMania VIII, but had folded entirely by the time he was medically cleared to appear again. In downtime between his WCW departure and...whatever it was exactly his WBF run would have entailed, he suffered significant injuries from a motorcycle accident.

At full fitness by January 1993, he was reborn as 'The Narcissist' with the metal plate used to repair his arm as big a weapon as the bulging biceps he clung onto from his brief WBF pomp.


5. Damien Sandow - Idol Stevens

Idol Stevens KC James
WWE.com

The picture above finds the future Damien Sandow flashing an eerily similar grin to the face he pulled on his Impact Wrestling debut. Could this be a tell - a "this ain't it, chief" -from a steadfast professional that knows the the difference between sinking under and getting over?

Idol Stevens categorically wasn't the moneymaker for the future 'Intellectual Saviour Of The Masses'. Alongside fellow developmental prospect KC James and manager Michelle McCool, Sandow made up the numbers in a rudderless mid-200s SmackDown tag team division anchored by the excellent Brian Kendrick and Paul London.

The pair of disillusioned cruiserweights were en route to setting records as blue brand doubles stewards, but referring to the run as a push would be overstating the ordinary - they held the belts because they could be relied upon to have excellent matches without the creative team needing to work hard for them. Stevens and James were - like several others - just losers waiting in line to lose.


4. Essa Rios - Papi Chulo

Papi Chulo
WWE

Long before Essa Rios was a dynamic C-show light heavyweight, Papi Chulo was a...dynamic C-show light heavyweight.

Something of a wasted talent on a bigger stage, Rios' repackaging as firebrand babyface alongside Lita in early 2000 ultimately did more for the latter than the former, but it appeared to be a noble effort to repackage a weekend show favourite into something more palatable.

As a bit of a sleaze in fur coat, coloured shades and ostentatious leather...everything, his aesthetic was Attitude Era bargain bin by mistake. Looking more like a Tiger King talking head than a pro wrestler, Chulo then kicked all that into his own cocked hat with jaw-dropping high spots rather similar to those done by the masked Mexican star Aguila that had suspiciously disappeared just before his debut.

Like virtually every character trapped on Metal/Jakked at the time, he did nothing but work and worked for nothing. Only as Rios did he claim the Cruiserweight Title and a feud with Eddie Guerrero that snuck him on to PPV in the company's glorious and all-things-to-everybody year 2000.


3. The Battle For Bam Bam

Bam Bam Bigelow Andre The Giant
WWE.com

A war was waged in 1987 between some of WWE's most devious minds, all for the services of a flame-headed hybrid star.

Bam Bam Bigelow brought size, strength, athleticism and f*cking fire tattooed on his skull to the company with murmurings that this unique collection of attributes would be enough to unseat Hulk Hogan as the organisation's top star. To this end, they sent out Jimmy Hart, Slick, Bobby Heenan and others to campaign for his signature.

In the end, the monstrous-looking star was a good egg after all. He chose fellow new arrival Oliver Humperdink over last manager standing Slick as a way to set up an early angle with Nikolai Volkoff, and he was off and running in a career that bizarrely went nowhere fast.

Booked to last longest in Hulk Hogan's 1987 Survivor Series team before linking arms with 'The Hulkster' himself in taped tag matches ahead of WrestleMania IV, Bigelow was gone from the company just two months after the 'Show Of Shows amidst creative and contractual disinterest on both sides.

None of the above was mentioned when he was reinstalled as a killer heel after finally returning to the company four years later.


2. Bret Hart - Brett Hart

Bret Hart
WWE

The future 'Best There Is, Best There Was, Best There Ever Will Be' managed to avoid a miscasted role as a cowboy upon first signing with Vince McMahon in 1984, but an extra letter on the end of his first name was just about the only thing added to his presentation before he eventually found The Hart Foundation a year later.

As a straight up great wrestler, Hart's typically tight work didn't land all that well with an audience growing ever fonder of the big and boisterous style being popularised by the company's hugely successful promotion of Hulk Hogan.

It's ironic - this version of Hart was so flavourless that he never stood a chance of getting over on his own terms, regardless of how good the worked punches looked. He upped every single other aspect of his game in the following years to become the perfect all-rounder, but it was as though McMahon only remembered the relatively underwhelming Brett when he should have embraced 'The Hitman' he'd had along.


1. Rocky Maivia - It's Yer Da

Rocky Johnson The Sultan
WWE

Much gets made of The Rock's early days, with WWE having a grand old time laughing at how ruddy bloody stupid everybody was to label a future global megastar Rocky Maivia in tribute to two generations of his family rather than something all of his own.

It's often coupled with footage of his wide-eyed company debut at Madison Square Garden, with the heavy-handed implication that the 'Blue-Chipper' was the only aspect of his original persona they got bang wrong before a magic wand fix following a heel turn. Those early days, sadly, stretched way beyond his fairly well received arrival.

When an Intercontinental Title victory in February didn't turn low level jeers into rapturous cheers, the company doubled down on the full impact of his heritage by bringing his once-famous father Rocky Johnson to ringside at Raw. The company had only just rendered his era relics thanks to their New Generation campaign, yet there he was literally fighting his son's battles following a WrestleMania 13 victory over The Sultan. 'Die Rocky Die' was an emerging shared take, but at least it allowed The Rock to eventually live.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.