10 Terrible WWE Reinventions

Don't be the change Vince McMahon wishes to see.

Emma Emmalina
WWE

When reflecting upon his largely successful career, the late, great Leon 'Vader' White nevertheless tended to dwell on his biggest professional regret: that he didn't allow Vince McMahon to completely repackage him in his own vision.

On the one hand, you can't really blame him. Carved by the chairman's chisel, the likes of Mick Foley, Mark Calaway and Steve Austin all emerged as prosperous Pygmalions, the industry's most cherished ornaments as it hit its boom period. Vader - or rather, 'The Mastodon', could have been one of them.

D'autre part, his trepidation is likewise understandable. Here he entered the promotion with a glittering résumé as 'Big Van Vader', a significant body of work which should have established him as a star immediately. Giving that up was surely bonkers.

That, basically, was the problem. Pushing Vader as Vader meant accepting wrestling's Mensa expanded beyond a solitary office in Titan Towers. White, then, gradually declined into a "fat piece of s**t", proving - even if the evidence was penned by the researcher - that only one man's ideas were worthy.

Vader's career was more than respectable, but his lament lasted until his death. If he'd peered a little closer, he may have had a different opinion. Studying any of the following makeovers at the hands of Stamford's superstar surgeon would have revealed that, you know what, maybe he made the right decision all along.

10. Barry Windham > The Stalker

Barry Windham Stalker 2
WWE

When Barry Windham returned to the WWF in 1996, he did so on increasingly wobbly knees. Years on the road and multiple surgeries had left his body somewhat worse for wear, so a killer new gimmick to help mask his ailing mobility was just what the doctor ordered (though not any medical ones, who probably would have advised packing it in).

Well, he got that 'killer' gimmick. Kind of. As The Stalker, Windham was disguised in camouflage facepaint and a jaunty beret to help him blend into the environment (from which he was billed), as he hunted WWF superstars. In particular, the former 'Widowmaker' was to make a widower out of Marco Mero by kidnapping Sable and then, presumably, murdering her a bit.

As you might imagine, Mero wasn't massively keen on the idea of his wife being slaughtered, and rejected the angle. The Stalker debuted as a babyface instead. A do-gooding stalker, hiding in plain sight. Or standing in plain sight, since he was patently obvious.

Mankind debuted around the same time; Foley told how McMahon seriously believed Windham's new persona was going to be a merchandising moneyspinner.

It wasn't.


9. Terry Gordy > The Executioner

Terry Gordy Executioner 2
WWE

Apocryphally (ie from the mouth of Bruce Prichard, so likely to be hot b*llocks), The Executioner gimmick was conceived as a rare act of mercy from WWF's legendarily spiteful chairman.

Terry Gordy was no favourite of Vince McMahon, only begrudgingly hired as a favour to Michael Hayes. The boss had several legitimate doubts over the battered and bruised veteran's physical capability, but instead of gleefully hanging the former Freebird out to dry as he would rival talent time and time again, he instead offered Bam Bam a reprieve. Under a cowl as The Executioner, Vince gave Gordy the chance to prove he still had it; if he didn't, his reputation would be spared.

Long story short: he didn't. And what's worse, we all know it was him, thanks to articles such as this. Talk about a hatchet job.


8. Ron Simmons > Farooq Asad

Ron Simmons Farooq Asad
WWE

Back in 1991, Ric Flair was effectively given two options by WCW's president Jim Herd: become a Roman gladiator, or pack your bags, sunshine. Flair, who apparently hadn't seen Kirk Douglas' 1960 epic, flatly refused to be Spartacus. WCW's, um, maverick new brain trust promptly fired The Nature Boy, and we was free to turn up in WWF doing what he did best.

Four years later, former World Heavyweight Champion Ron Simmons' own WCW career had wound down, and after briefly popping his head in ECW's door, he too sought the fresh pastures of Titan Towers. He must have missed the returning Flair's memo: WWF wasn't quite all it was cracked up to be.

Simmons promptly found himself in The Nature Boy's shoes - or rather, caligae - shoved into an unused gladiatorial outfit presumably found at a Herd yardsale and handed the incongruous moniker 'Farooq Asad'. It lasted less than a year.


7. Sgt. Slaughter > 'Iraqi Sympathiser' Slaughter

Slaughter Evil
WWE

After seven years playing the patriotic defender of all things starry and stripey, perhaps giving Sergeant Slaughter a new lease of life as a heel wasn't the worst idea.

That is, had he not been turned into an Iraqi sympathiser during the middle of the Gulf War.

In 1990, WWE's business was in decline, and in a bid to boost interest - and more pressingly, sell-out the ludicrously ambitious 100,000 seater Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum for WrestleMania VII - Vince McMahon reverted to first principles: xenophobia.

Having Slaughter turn on his country out of admiration for Saddam Hussein's brutal, Ba'aathist Iraq certainly got lips flapping - or more specifically, journalists' pens scribbling - but not much of it was positive. Rather, the stunt was seen for the transparently sensationalist publicity grab it was, whilst being denigrated for demonstrating precisely zero tact in the context of actual soldiers losing their lives in the desert conflict.

Slaughter himself was uncomfortable with his new character, this discomfort no doubt worsened by the company's decision to move WrestleMania to the (considerable smaller) Los Angeles Memorial Sports Arena, due to "security concerns".

There was a simpler explanation for the switch: the whole thing was a bit crap.


6. Too Cold Scorpio > Flash Funk

2 Cold Scorpio Flash Funk
WWE

After a brief but successful stint in WCW, during which time he raised tag gold alongside Marcus Bagwell, dynamic aerialist Charles '2 Cold Scorpio' Scaggs headed for Philadelphia upstarts ECW where he quickly established himself as one of the organisation's finest workers amidst a sea of extremity.

It wasn't for nothing Paul Heyman entrusted Scorpio with the promotion's Television Title, knowing full well he could depend on his weekly work rate as the group began to find its feet on a larger landscape. Meanwhile in the north-east, the industry's flagship promotion was floundering, and its chairman needed fresh ideas. ECW talent was on his radar, notably Scaggs, who he convinced to jump ship in 1996.

Scorpio would soon find there was a sting in the tail.

Whereas Heyman saw an extraordinarily gifted wrestler, McMahon, regrettably, seemingly only noticed one thing about Scaggs, and overnight he went from a high-flying maverick to a zoot-suited funk aficionado. In not quite so many words, he was effectively portrayed as something rhyming with 'blimp'. (No, not that - Dustin Runnels would have that privielege a year later.) It was as bad, and borderline offensive, as it sounds.


5. Shane Douglas > Dean Douglas

Shane Douglas Dean Douglas
WWE

There's something of a developing theme, here (See also: Funk, Flash - Scorpio transformation into). In denouncing the NWA World Title in August 1994 and laying the foundations for the 'extreme' ECW, Shane Douglas entered the annals of wrestling folklore. As the Philadelphia promotion's inaugural champ, the self-proclaimed franchise was much more than an historical pivot point, commandeering the revolution as the landscape of North American wrestling was brutally cleaved.

Vince McMahon was intrigued by the progress made by a greenhorn once under his employ. Perhaps his bellicose, degenerate attitude was just right for his 'New Generation'?

It would be - but not for another two years. Old habits died hard. During their initial meeting, Douglas let slip that he worked as a teacher on the side. That was that for him. Couldn't he just be a wrestler? No, said Vince: wrestling is crap. you're a college dean now. Let us measure your head.

Anyway, the gimmick, which saw 'Dean' Douglas issue report cards to downed opponents between classroom lectures, was f*cking awful. But the robe was nice. And he did become the IC title. For all of twenty minutes.


4. DDP > 'Stalker' DDP

Ddp Wcw Wwe
WWE

Unlike Barry Windham, who sneaked into the WWF as a sort of benevolent Predator, Diamond Dallas Page creeped into the company in the role of a much more traditional L.B. Jefferies stalker.

After several weeks of The Undertaker's wife (literally referred to as 'Sara Undertaker') being preyed upon, the mystery perv ditched the telescopes and veiled threats to reveal himself as the ex-WCW champ. Supposedly, his intentions were not as nefarious as they appeared; DDP simply wanted to make a scene in his new surroundings, and what better way than goading The Deadman?

It certainly sprung him into the spotlight. Sadly for DDP, he spent much of his fifteen minutes there being ritually tarred and feathered by the furious Phenom. He was taught some lesson - though, between the lines, it was mostly about what happens to the product of a rival.

And to think Page bought himself out of his fat Time Warner contracted for this opportunity. If there's one lesson to be learned, it's: "don't be a stalker." In case you didn't already know that.


3. Emma > Emmalina

Emma Emmalina
WWE

Emmalina may well have been the greatest ever transformation in the history of WWE. Sadly, we only saw her Stars in their Eyes cameo for all of fifteen seconds before she vanished again, to return as her pre-evolved form down the line.

Safe bet is that it wouldn't have been, though. The company, unlike your average Dixon's employee, simply doesn't know the meaning of the phrase lingua in maxillam, and it's more than probable Emma's supermodel makeover was to be taken entirely at face value - ridiculous, gibberish name and all.

That's assuming it wasn't just an elaborate rib at the Australian's expense, owing to her unpopularity amongst the hierarchy. In any event, a shelf life of less than a minute has to go down as a massive failure. Emma, not surprisingly, was let go by the company later that year.


2. Tito Santana > El Matador

Tito Santana El Matador
WWE

Around about the time Hulk Hogan was rapidly deflating as he prepared for his day in wrestler's court, Vince McMahon rather urgently needed a new WWF Champion - and preferably, one sans worryingly pulsating veins. The gig eventually passed to the super-safe (eh Seth? *snark*) hands of Bret Hart, but for a while Tito Santana was within the frame of consideration.

There was just one problem: he had been turned into a f*cking matador.

Yes, Santana may have been one of the company's most popular babyfaces amongst Hispanic audiences, but that wasn't enough for McMahon, whose thought process seemingly went, "hang on a minute! I know what these lads like... " Quite literally taking the bull by the horns, the former IC champ traded trunks for traje, rediscovering the one-dimensional Mexican stereotype within him - the one he'd forgot during his years acting as a proper, fully-fleshed person.

Tito Santana was over enough and talented enough to slot into the top role. El Matador, on the other hand, was w*nk. At least the company never tried it aga... oh.


1. Cody Rhodes > Stardust

Cody Rhodes Stardust
WWE

Was it a good idea for WWE to transform Cody Rhodes into Stardust? Let's consider:

Since escaping the company's auspices, Cody has reinvented the life of an independent wrestler, dramatically raising the limits of what hitherto journeymen can achieve. He's not just cracked the east, but helped bring New Japan's global ambitions one step closer to realistic fruition. To cap it all off, he, alongside marketing genii The Young Bucks, sold out a 10,000 seater venue for a show - with just a single match announced - in under an hour.

Stardust pranced around in a bin bag and made peculiar hissing noises as a Fool's Goldust.

It's almost as if WWE want him to leave. Smart move, lads.


Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.