10 Times WWE Actually Admitted It Sucked

WWE is actually *about* how much WWE sucks...

Kevin Owens Shane McMahon
WWE

Your writer is often tarred with accusations of "bias", or as it is sometimes more colourfully known, "being a c*nt".

But consider this:

WWE has buried itself for far, far longer than June of 2016. Months prior to that WC employment start date, Shane McMahon, having won the right to govern Monday Night RAW after losing to the Undertaker (!), outright told his predecessor and blood sibling, whose breasts he once described as cute (!), that Monday Night RAW sucked.

You didn't spit your little dummy in the WWE dot com comments section then, did you? Never accused Vince McMahon of kissing Dave Meltzer's aerobicised ass then, did you?

WWE has acknowledged its quite frequent awfulness longer than your writer has, and it hasn't just manifested as the odd, hasty reset. In fact, delve deep into WWE's modern history, and you will find that this sort of practice is closer to the norm; it is the strange, merry go-round way in which the main roster has functioned, or not functioned, for a very sobering amount of time.

WWE is its own biggest, snarkiest, smarkiest, toxic, biased, negative, neck-bearded critic...

10. Shane McMahon Tells It Like It Is

Shane Return
WWE

As mentioned, Shane McMahon returned to WWE after a long exile on February 22, 2016.

He interrupted a ceremony - in which his sister was to be awarded the 'Vincent J. McMahon Legacy of Excellence' award - with a stark and ominous message: WWE sucks!

Those weren't too dissimilar to his own words: "You and your husband, Triple H, have really been running this company into the ground."

Ratings may have plummeted because the audience didn't need it specified that Triple H was married to Stephanie, and were "quite frankly tired of having their intelligence insulted". Incidentally, that is another occasion on which WWE admitted that they sucked sh*t, only that moment actually held some weight to it. None of this or what followed did.

Shane went on, referencing the falling stock price and ratings. The theme here was that WWE sucks, the Authority stuff was played out, and that he was here to save it - the sweeping, transformative idea behind which was to...to change the passé authority figure from heel to babyface.

But first, Shane had to defeat the Undertaker, at WrestleMania, inside Hell In A Cell, to commence his so-called 'New Era'. He lost, but his dad was suitably impressed at his willingness to die in a pseudo-sport, and he took control of RAW regardless.

Basically, everything stayed the same, except the obsequious babyfaces wrestled a bit more and there were a few less f*ck finishes.


9. Kevin Owens Tells Shane McMahon How It Is

Kevin Owens Shane McMahon
WWE.com

To illustrate the central theme of WWE programming - that it sucks - let's fast-forward to 2019 for a cyclical example of it.

Shane McMahon had told Stephanie McMahon that RAW sucked. He couldn't make it not suck, because it sucks systemically, and so it was his time to be at the forefront of programming when it sucked, and it was the turn of Kevin Owens to tell us all that it sucked.

This is a thing, honestly. Shane McMahon turned heel, and dominated programming. The obnoxious and total insistence on heat segments led many fans to voice their displeasure, and the mood surrounding the programme was fictionalised into yet another overbearing authority figure versus voice of the voiceless babyface narrative.

On the July 9, 2019 SmackDown, Owens raged against Shane, and even referenced the infamous "You are the Authority now" deal that yes, we'll get to. He accused Shane of gobbling TV time up for himself and refusing to grant "opportunities" to the actual talent. SmackDown sucked, and they once more told you it sucked, and what's more, they held a Town Hall meeting so that the roster could also confirm that the show sucked.

"The show sucks" is WWE's central conceit, in much the same way as "the infrastructure of America is fundamentally broken" is the theme of The Wire.


8. Edge Campaigns Against Stupidity

Edge General Manager Computer
WWE.com

At the tail-end of the godforsaken 2000s, WWE unveiled a new General Manager to oversee the developments of flagship programming: The Anonymous RAW General Manager, who would issue their decrees via laptop computer, and a really, really annoying noise. And before Michael Cole read out the emails, the laptop made a beeping sound.

It was so, so unbelievably stupid.

These men and women were literally under the orders of a machine, reducing their already not-ideal perception as worker bees, toiling under the weight of autocracy, to robots not programmed with the function of agency. The contrived blocking that facilitated this was just awful - and it got even worse!

Edge agreed with this assessment, and since he was programmed to speak the words of his creator, his creator agreed, too.

By 2010, the laptop had developed sentience and could speak. To wit: they could cut an unscripted promo, and the human beings could not. After Edge defeated John Cena, the GM spoke up in a Johnny 5 voice, f*ck this, f*ck all of this. "You need to play by the rules," the GM said, on one of several dumb and inconsistent occasions on which action replay was a thing.

Edge, who had campaigned against the "stupidity" of the Anonymous GM, promptly destroyed the laptop.

He, under the narrative framework of the show, outright told us that the show was stupid.


7. Literally Every Superstar Shake-Up

Superstar Shake Up Raw
WWE

The Superstar Shake-Up was a more tacit admission of main roster awfulness.

This wasn't held under the framework of a draft. The faintest allusion to "negotiations" were made, but that was the extent of the effort. Not one General Manager or Commissioner or whatever f*cking way 'round it was agonised over a trade decision, nor did any of the talents feel particularly aggrieved over being perceived as expendable. This did not inform the narrative.

It was all, 'Hey, I'm on RAW now! I'm coming to RAW - and I'm bringing my brand of craziness with me!"

They were coming to RAW for no good reason. Dean Ambrose was shaken over to RAW in 2017, and it was presented as nothing. Simply, he was on RAW now. "Wow!" this compelled Michael Cole to say, as if it was an earth-shattering announcement that had happened for a specific purpose.

"It's Dean Ambrose, and he's next to red ropes now!"

In announcing the Superstar Shake-Up, Vince McMahon himself actually just said "It's time to shake things up around here!", the subtext of which was "We can't possibly tell stories with one fixed roster for less than a calendar year!"


6. Whenever They Build A New Star (!)

Drew McIntyre 3MB
WWE.com

Kofi Kingston overcame an 11-year journey to finally become WWE Heavyweight Champion at WrestleMania 35.

This was framed as the ultimate, arduous babyface journey, but that wasn't quite accurate. WWE had to suck for the wait to last as long as it did. WWE had to bury him after he botched - once - in his 2009 feud with Randy Orton. WWE had to be apathetic and directionless to explain his years and years and years in meaningless midcard title wilderness. WWE had to remove the agency of its stars to account for the New Day's hopeless start as a stable. WWE had to suck, for this arc to resonate.

The very same thing is happening, right now, with Drew McIntyre.

He had to endure years of nothingness after WWE made the dumb decision to go all in on a talent they weren't savvy enough to recognise wasn't ready. His embarrassing run in 3MB was framed in a recent candid sit-down as a reality check. He had to escape the WWE system, that sucked, to get over in a series of companies that did not suck, in order to return to WWE in a better position.

Literally, to become a top star in WWE, WWE must suck, institutionally, for these men and women to overcome and get over in spite of it. It is a wild development, when you really think about it.

WWE is celebrating its awfulness, because after a decade, a star just might be created in spite of it!


5. The Original Version Of NXT

Daniel Bryan Boot Michael Tarver
WWE.com

NXT was absolutely wild. That sh*tty theme song was at least half-accurate.

It was so fatally inept, and revealed so much of what WWE is, systemically, that this was essentially WWE putting itself on trial and acting as the snarky, witless prosecution, telling the judge it was tired and needed to make a phone call to its mother - which couldn't wait, because what was more pressing? Those women embarrassing themselves in the ring on live television? Hey guy, do me a favour: wake me up when the bimbos turn into wrestlers and I'm paid to give a sh*t, all right?

NXT ridiculed its contestants in anti-fertile conditions in which to create a star. Great technical wrestler? Nerd, don't care so much! Everybody else? Boring! Female? LOL!

These people were buried for being pathetic and green and terrified on a show that actually happened on national television for a while. It was insane. "Riveting!" became a catchphrase among the bored broadcast team, who treated the whole thing - lives, careers - like 4-5PM on.a Friday.

In a previous era, Randy Orton might have started life under the tutelage of Mideon, and not Ric Flair.

In a future one, Velveteen Dream might get snorted at by Michael Cole. "Someone should tell this goof that we already had a Rick Rude, on a show that wasn't god-awful!"


4. Why Did Ruthless Aggression Happen?

ruthless aggression originals
WWE.com

The function of a pro wrestling promotion is to effectively promote stars.

A pro wrestling promotion must be a failure - it must suck - if it fails to achieve this base remit.

In June of 2002, Vince McMahon, with Steve Austin pissed off and the Rock bound for Hollywood, strutted to the ring and admitted he didn't have any stars on the books. This was a strange admission of a promo that doubled as a b*llocking. He asked an entire ring of talent to show him "ruthless aggression" - "Who among you has that quality?" he pined - and their very positioning in the scene provided him the answer. They were, monopolised and marginalised, now part of a new system that punished them for showing ruthless aggression at 7:45PM, when Vince asked for it at 7:10 and had since changed his mind.

Vince was compelled to script this segment, and re-label a misfit generation of greenhorns and journeymen, because he'd monumentally botched the WCW Invasion angle.

This scene was the byproduct and tacit acknowledgement of it: This is a company with no true main event-level players, Vince effectively said, in a year in which he got even got Hulk Hogan wrong.

Perhaps I shouldn't have had 'Taker teabag DDP, he ruminated.


3. Every Time They Glorify The Attitude Era...

Mantaur WWE
WWE.com

...they tell you that the New Generation Era sucked.

If it didn't suck, they wouldn't have had to put an end to it. Vince McMahon in his famous December 1997 speech even acknowledged that fans were bored of the old archetypes, which he permanently reintroduced five years later, but that's another matter.

If you take WWE's word for it, the New Generation sucked. It didn't draw, but it didn't suck. They will point towards the unfunny, patently bullsh*t occupational gimmicks, as if the majority of them lasted more than a month, as evidence that Vince, the absolute picture of machismo and bravado, just needed a challenge from a competing alpha male to summon that gigantic c*ck of his out of his suit trousers and piss, once more, on the territory of others.

It's a tall tale of dogged determination spun in order to get him over as the grapefruit-balled genius, but to arrive at the third act of his story, WWE has to rubbish years of its own existence. Those years are held very dearly to the same demo that props this operation up, and they are buried because it's easier to get Road Dogg to say "Mantaur? What was that all about?" on a talking head than discuss the complexities of art versus commerce.

Basically, they're d*cks to Bret Hart when they do this and they didn't deserve him.


2. Baron Corbin Is Scapegoated

Seth Rollins Baron Corbin
WWE.com

On the December 17, 2018 RAW, WWE responded to a deluge of criticism.

2019 was somehow worse - so emphatically sh*t that Vince actually relinquished a degree of creative control - but 2018 was hardly 1998 WCW. No cliff was driven over; Vince McMahon had lost his grip on the edge for a long time, no-selling the blood on his new bone-fingers as a sign of weakness. It was the fault of the cliff. The cliff did not know what the cliff wanted.

Corbin was a witless and overexposed RAW GM, a beyond tired role; Crown Jewel was pathetically bad, and its Shane McMahon heel turn exacerbated the ceaseless heat; Dean Ambrose's heel turn, meanwhile, reduced a promising and overdue development to an over-gimmicked joke scarcely believable in how crass and unconvincing it was. They ruined Daniel Bryan's comeback.

All of this was clearly Corbin's fault!

But in a rare show of humility on the part of Stephanie McMahon, she herself said "We haven't been doing a very good job for you lately".

Lately?

The Anonymous GM outdrew Corbin by several million viewers, and they told us it sucked!


1. And It's Not Just Baron Corbin

stephanie mcmahon mick foley
WWE.com

Modern-day WWE is a relentless onscreen cat-kicking exercise in which the talent tasked with performing in accordance with the script are blamed - often cruelly - for its unpopular product.

Vickie Guerrero was bad for business in July 2013 because she drew the "not good kind" of booing, which doesn't explain Baron Corbin. Nothing explains Baron Corbin. Brad Maddox followed her out of the RAW GM door in May 2014. Notice how we are firmly in the post-WrestleMania doldrums? Notice how WWE needed a scapegoat to blame the suck on? Stephanie McMahon talked to Mick Foley like he was a piece of sh*t on her shoe for about a year, and they never even paid it off.

WWE is telling you, always, that the product "overseen" by these "authority figures" sucks, and when they are fired, it's meant to act as a sort of cleansing.

"Get with the programme, Foley, you f*cking idiot! These people don't want 20 minute opening promos!"

The McMahon family operate as heels, primarily, except when it comes time to sh*t-can a subordinate, and we are to enjoy their schtick. This strange, ongoing practise isn't too dissimilar to the excuses Vince McMahon makes on investor conference calls.

Vince McMahon is basically Shaggy. It's never him.

All roads lead to Vince. He is essentially firing himself over and over and over again. Maybe, all along, he despised pronouns because he doesn't understand which one is which.

"I'm fired!"

There you go!

Once again for those in the back: "WWE sucks" is the theme of WWE, and I'm negative or biased for simply understanding the message I'm being told?


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!