10 Times WWE Got "The Guy" Wrong

You are not 'The Guy'.

Diesel WWE Champion
WWE.com

Making genuine, world-beating stars is one of the biggest challenges WWE faces these days.

Anyone the company does try to elevate to the position of 'The Guy' is inevitably held up to the standards of generations past, a comparison from which they almost always come off second best. He's good, the fans say, but is he really Stone Cold Steve Austin-level good?

Speaking of the fans, it is they who decide whether to accept a potential heir to the main event throne as a credible top-level star. And when they decide that they aren't up to the task, things can turn very ugly, very fast.

All of this is to say that it's a tough job choosing who should be given this chance of a lifetime. The company can leave it completely down to crowd reaction, of course, but the crowd have a tendency to lionise some of its more unreliable employees.

Should they then bow to the pressure of audience demand? Or stick to their guns and continue to push the musclebound guy with the chiseled jaw who will work 300 nights a year and look good on the side of the tour bus?

Whatever they do, there's a good chance they'll get it wrong.

10. Jinder Mahal

Jinder Mahal
WWE

The received wisdom that putting the WWE Championship on Jinder Mahal's shoulder would drive new commercial opportunities in India seemed like a sound one, on paper.

Until now, though, we're yet to see any evidence that it has worked, and since the company felt the need to enlist the help of The Great Khali - for one night only - to help him get over at Battleground, there's reason to believe it hasn't (at least not to the extent they'd hoped).

As for the wrestling side of things, Jinder has shown tremendous improvement since taking the mantle of SmackDown's leading man - there are few who can match him when it comes to an intense promo, for example - but he continues to disappoint in the ring.


9. Rey Mysterio

Rey Mysterio World Heavyweight Title 2006 WrestleMania 22
WWE.com

In the minds of WWE writers, Rey Mysterio's 2006 title run was probably supposed to go something like this...

He receives a hero's ovation after lifting the belt at WrestleMania 22, is instantly taken to as a credible heavyweight champion and the resulting David vs Goliath feuds become the stuff of wrestling legend.

Reality was a little different. The "Bizarro Land" Chicago crowd didn't get behind Rey's coronation, and in the months that followed he simply wasn't presented or viewed as a legitimate main event wrestler.

Rey had plenty of talent - perhaps more than almost anyone else on the WWE roster, in fact - but the writers tried too hard to shoe-horn him into a position for which he wasn't suited, and his career paid the price thereafter.


8. Rob Van Dam

Rob Van Dam WWE Champion
WWE.com

It's hard to argue that Rob Van Dam's peerless talent wasn't deserving of a place at the top of the card.

Then again, it's also hard to argue that the experiment which saw him become WWE and ECW Champion in mid-2006 wasn't a failure, given that the company was forced into stripping him both belts not a month after he won them when he found himself in trouble with the law.

To be fair, that touchstone moment in New York's Hammerstein Ballroom was - and still is - enough to convince most of us that RVD's brush with the main event was worthwhile.

It's just, when you look at the damp squib of a reign that followed, you can't really escape the conclusion that he wasn't up to the task of filling John Cena's considerable (and uber-professional) shoes.


7. Ryback

Ryback WWE Title 2013
WWE

Unlike many others on this list, Ryback never did manage to get his hands on WWE world title gold (although, as he'll never tire in telling you, he definitely should have).

It was clear from the outset that the company had big plans for him (well, nearly from the outset - his stint as Skip Sheffield didn't exactly scream money).

But he never felt entirely convincing as the next Goldberg, and despite being in and around the main event for much of the early 2010s, his appearances in headline matches - with wrestlers we'd sooner see competing with more worthy adversaries - were usually greeted with collective groans.

Also: he seemed to have one or two issues with CM Punk, which didn't help the campaign to get the Straight Edge Superstar - a real 'The Guy' candidate - to stay when things turned sour in 2014.


6. Jack Swagger

Jack Swagger World Heavyweight Champion
WWE.com

Jack Swagger drew tentative comparisons to Brock Lesnar when he first came onto our screens in 2008 - in the sense that he was blonde, physically imposing, and had an impressive background in amateur wrestling.

Unfortunately, that's where the similarities ended. Swagger always seemed a bit half-formed, as though he could have done with a couple more years in the developmental ranks to really flesh out his ring and mic work before stepping up to the main roster.

Yet no sooner had he debuted was he being pushed as one of the company's next big stars, sealing his first World Heavyweight Championship win abruptly just a couple of days after winning Money in the Bank at WrestleMania XXVI.

It felt wrong - too rushed - and he never really did anything to change that perception.


5. Alberto Del Rio

Alberto Del Rio World Champion
WWE

Like Jinder, many believe Alberto Del Rio was pushed to the top of the company early in his run in order to curry favour with a particular demographic. This time, it was Latino fans, who had supposedly been starved of a genuine WWE star since Rey Mysterio burst onto the scene a decade prior.

Del Rio was a surprise choice to win the Royal Rumble in 2011, not least because he had only made his debut a mere six months prior. It was a classic example of too much, too soon, and in the end his subsequent WrestleMania encounter with Edge felt somewhat low-key.

You can put that down to poor booking as much as the man himself (who is, plainly, a competent and charismatic performer), but given that he never grew into one of the company's biggest stars, there is a nagging sense they simply gave the ball to the wrong guy.


4. Jeff Hardy

Jeff Hardy World Heavyweight Champion
WWE.com

Nobody can deny that Jeff Hardy was eliciting the sort of crowd response you would associate with 'The Guy', but it was arguably a mistake to put him in the role of leading baby-face in 2008 and 2009, given how close he was to the end of his contract.

Instead of erecting one of the WWE building blocks for the next decade, they ended up inadvertently putting eyes on TNA when he jumped ship at the beginning of 2010 (and on the eve of the hugely competitive Monday Night War II, as well).

Of course, it would have been foolish not to capitalise on Hardy's unrivaled popularity at the time. However, in hindsight, his spot at the top of the SmackDown card may have been better given to someone more likely to stick around for the long haul.


3. Diesel

Diesel Champ
wwe.com

Any half-decent wrestling historian will be able to tell you that WWE was going through a rough patch in the mid-1990s. Big-spending WCW was beginning to emerge across town, and Vince McMahon had yet to figure out that sex and violence sells. It was the calm before the storm, basically.

So pickings were slim, world champion-wise, and with Shawn Michaels still to begin his ascent towards the main event, it was left to his one-time bodyguard Diesel to lead the company instead.

And lead the company he did. For more than a year, in fact, 'Big Sexy' was the WWE Champion, yet his matches were nearly always forgettable, outside of his WrestleMania encounter with HBK.

Nobody can deny Nash's star-power, but there's a reason he mostly played second fiddle to Hogan after he jumped ship.


2. Roman Reigns

Roman Reigns
WWE.com

From being jeered out of the building at the last three WrestleManias to - somehow - ending up as the heel in a feud with Braun Strowman, there's a litany of evidence to support the notion that Roman isn't quite 'The Guy' yet.

Few can really doubt the quality of his ring work - of which SummerSlam was another timely illustraiton - but it's the poor booking, the repeated fighting against (and usually overcoming) the odds, that has led to fans resoundingly rejecting him as their next hero.

At the same time, his inexorable push shows no signs of abating, and with John Cena set to be his latest opponent at No Mercy next month, there's a decent chance WWE could officially pass him the torch as it prepares for another coronation for 'The Big Dog' at next year's WrestleMania.


1. JBL

JBL WWE champion
WWE.com

JBL's 2004 transformation from one-half of a tired tag team to the single biggest heat magnet in WWE was pretty impressive, and perhaps - with a little more build-up - you could argue it deserved to be capped with a short world title run.

But dominating SmackDown for nearly a year? Cutting short Eddie Guerrero's long-awaited main event push? One of the headline spots of WrestleMania 21?

This was all a little bit too much, especially since 'The Wrestling God' - a stiff and meticulous worker - was seldom able to put in genuinely high-quality performances between the ropes.

In the end, WWE got out of the JBL experiment a set of fans fully behind John Cena's WWE Championship challenge in early-2005 - but the year or so that preceded it was a little rough, if we're honest.


In this post: 
Kevin Nash
 
Posted On: 
Contributor