10 Under-Appreciated WWE September PPV Matches

September's not appreciated enough, and neither are these ten great matches.

AJ Styles Dean Ambrose Backlash
WWE

September is a difficult month for WWE. With the start of Monday Night Football, RAW's ratings take a serious hit. Plus, the fanbase at large go through a major post-SummerSlam hangover that slightly subsides during Survivor Series, but doesn't go away entirely until the Royal Rumble. This generally results in a stretch from September to January where WWE seem creatively stagnant and directionless. With none of the major angles heading into WrestleMania building until the Royal Rumble, fans are forced to sit through a lot of filler that feels like an uninspired rerun most of the time.

However, such a stigma can result in quality getting overlooked. While September has never been a banner month for quality PPVs, the fact is, there's still been plenty of great stuff to come from it. That doesn't include the obvious classics such as Shawn Michaels vs. Mankind or Cena vs. Edge in a TLC match. There have been some truly standout matches that have been swept under the rug probably because they took place in September instead of at a bigger PPV.

Not all of these matches were instant classics, but all of them are ones that aren't talked about enough, or feature performers who don't get enough credit.

10. Bret Hart Vs. Jean-Pierre LaFitte (In Your House 3)

Jean Pierre Lafitte bret Hart
WWE.com

Despite taking place in a down period in the company and having an abysmal build, Bret Hart's match with Jean-Pierre LaFitte showed that the most skilled workers could make anyone look credible, and that any match could be a thrilling watch.

LaFitte (played by former Quebecer Pierre, AKA Carl Ouellet) had the absolutely inspired gimmick of an evil pirate who stole things. What's sad is that this gimmick was hardly WWE's most cartoon-y creation in 1995. Also sad about 1995 was that while Kevin Nash was consistently stinking up the main events as WWE Champion, Bret Hart was forced into meaningless feuds with the likes of Jerry Lawler, Issac Yankem, and, of course, LaFitte. Their match at In Your House 3 came about because LaFitte, I kid you not, stole Bret's jacket, and Bret was cross about it.

However, Bret, being the professional he was, shouldered the feud with gusto, and delivered a surprisingly good match with LaFitte. Featuring a variety of high spots and near-falls, the match is a textbook case of Bret making any competent worker appear on his level. Even at a time when crowd attendance and engagement were at all-time lows, the crowd were into this bout in a big way, legitimately believing LaFitte was close to defeating Hart.

All in a day's work for the 'Excellence of Execution'.


9. The Hardy Boyz Vs. Edge & Christian (Unforgiven 2000)

Edge and Christian Hardy Boys Cage Match Unforgiven 2000
WWE.com

The Hardyz and Edge & Christian were known more for their ladder-based encounters, but this cage match from Unforgiven 2000 shows that the two teams had amazing chemistry period.

One month after losing in their home state in the iconic TLC 1 at SummerSlam, the Hardyz went into the match as the underdogs, with Edge and Christian always managing to escape with the tag team titles by the skin of their teeth. Now forced into a steel cage, the two teams had to forego the high-flying mayhem of their ladder matches in favor of a gritty, desperate battle for escape.

This match succeeds in storytelling, as Jeff escapes the cage early, making it a 2-on-1 handicap as Matt tries to dodge Edge and Christian's assault. Jeff, meanwhile, tries whatever he can to get back into the cage to help his brother. And even though it's not a ladder match, Jeff Hardy can't help but use one, as he breaks one out to help himself climb the cage. Edge and Christian even get to break out their signature chairs for con-chair-to spots. And, of course, Jeff gets to do a swanton off the cage because Jeff Hardy laughs at death.

Ultimately, the Hardyz would win the tag titles and continue the white hot streak of quality the tag division in 2000 was on. If all you've seen of this feud are the TLCs, you should definitely check this one out.


8. Sheamus Vs. Cesaro (Night Of Champions 2014)

Sheamus Cesaro Night of Champions
WWE

Stop me if you've heard this one: Sheaus and Cesaro have a match that starts out with a lukewarm reception, but through sheer physicality and in-ring action, have the crowd in the palm of their hands by the end.

Yes, two years before their infamous best-of-seven series that everyone complained about, but nonetheless delivered every match, Sheamus and Cesaro were programmed on-and-off in 2014, culminating in this blisteringly good match at Night of Champions. Sheamus, then the babyface United States Champion who was lacking direction, defended against Cesaro, a heel who was lacking direction. The crowd really had no reason to care about this match, but that didn't matter to these two, as they kicked, punched, and pummeled their way into the fans' hearts. It may be hard to remember, but Sheamus actually was a very effective energized babyface, and Cesaro of course is a natural as a domineering, technically proficient heel.

Some would argue that their outing two years later at Clash of Champions was their better September outing, and that too was a great match. Ultimately, a shoddy no contest finish combined with that horrifying Cesaro botch that could have paralyzed him gives the Night of Champions match the edge.

If you need an example of why Sheamus and Cesaro work so well together as foes as well as friends, fire up this match on the Network.


7. The Usos Vs. Gold And Stardust (Night Of Champions 2014)

usos goldust stardust
wwe.com

Right now, the Usos are probably the best tag team act in WWE. A year into their heel run, the two have found themselves both in the ring and on the mic and are carrying SmackDown's tag team division. However, despite their (well-earned, I might add) praise from fans celebrating their current run, the Usos have been the victim of revisionist history. The assumption is that it was only until recently that they were a good tag team, and otherwise, they were mediocre, meandering babyfaces who were never over.

Looking at their run as tag champions in 2014, however, it's clear as day that the Usos were very much over, even as whitemeat babyfaces. That can be attributed to their energy and chemistry as a team, and the fact that they were having great matches with just about everyone from the Shield, to the Wyatts, and of course, the Rhodes Brothers. This opening match at NOC 2014, where the Usos lost their titles to Goldust and Stardust, was a fun, energetic opening contest that showcased the athleticism and chemistry between the two teams. Even if the fans' enthusiasm had waned for the Usos' act by this point, they still perked up mightily for the contest.

The Usos are great right now, but as this match shows, they've always shown signs of greatness.


6. Curtis Axel Vs. Kofi Kingston (Night Of Champions 2013)

Curtis Axel Kofi Kingston Night of Champions
WWE

It's hard to imagine that Curtis Axel was once given a significant push, to the point of being paired with Paul Heyman, but it happened. While he would ultimately become cannon fodder, Axel did show flashes of greatness in 2013, as evidenced by his Intercontinental title defense against Kofi Kingston at Night of Champions.

This match isn't a particular standout, as it was literally thrown together at the start of the show by Triple H, but even for being a random curtain-jerker, it showcases a lot of things that go underappreciated in WWE. For one thing, the crowd were instantly hot for it, meaning that Axel and Kofi didn't have to pull particularly heavy duty to get them to care, which is something too many competitors have to do.

Speaking of Kofi and Axel, they too are unjustly overlooked as singles competitors as this match showed. Sure, neither are the most dynamic personalities, and nobody would mistake Curtis for his Perfect dad, but the way these two were able to take what they were given and deliver a heated match shows that they were a lot better as singles guys than WWE would want you to think. Kofi especially deserves credit for his exciting blend of acrobatics and sense of the crowd.

Again, not a blowaway match, but since we're talking about an overlooked month, it's important to shine a light on the overlooked wrestlers as well.


5. Daniel Bryan Vs. The Miz (Night Of Champions 2010)

The Miz Daniel Bryan Night Of Champions
WWE.com

Given the semi-feud that was so heated between Daniel Bryan and Miz in 2016, it's interesting to look at their initial feud in 2010 and realize that even then, these two had great chemistry with each other.

At Night of Champions 2010, Daniel Bryan was just a bland babyface who had recently returned to WWE after necktie-related shenanigans got him fired earlier in the year. Now programmed with The Miz, Bryan had to work from the bottom in terms of getting over. He didn't have the Yes chant, the luxurious beard, or Flight of the Valkyries as his theme music. All he had was his supreme technical ability and an obnoxious heel opponent. Would Bryan be able to get over on those alone? Yes he could.

Bryan and Miz's match was the sleeper hit of an otherwise dire PPV, and Bryan, who came out to a lukewarm reception, was supremely over by the end. Credit also goes to Miz, who showed how he could hang with some of the best in a big match. It's not hard to see how even in 2010, the company brass saw something in him.

Fair warning, however, as this match took place during Michael Cole's heel commentator run, so all of the match is set to Cole's incessant burial of Bryan. Needless to say, it's completely obnoxious.


4. AJ Styles Vs. Dean Ambrose (Backlash 2016)

Dean Ambrose AJ Styles Backlash 2016
WWE.com

At some point in Dean Ambrose's WWE Championship reign last year, a portion of fans decided they were tired of him and that he was lazy and boring in the ring. Maybe they were correct, or perhaps wrestling fans hate seeing babyfaces be successful long-term and sour on them quickly, but in any case, fans were ready to move on and see the company's new golden boy AJ Styles be coronated. However, for his final hurrah as WWE Champion, Ambrose more than held his own and helped Styles deliver a sleeper match of the year candidate at Backlash 2016.

Despite not living up to the lofty heights of Styles' encounter with John Cena at SummerSlam the month prior, the match was still an exciting and well-wrestled affair that washed away the memories of Dean's lackluster title defense against Dolph Ziggler, and showed that WWE weren't wrong by putting the title on him.

However, as evidenced by the crowd reaction and the ending, this was Styles' night, as the 'Phenomenal One' delivered a low blow to Ambrose and hit the Styles Clash for the victory (which has actually been a rarity in his WWE run). Obviously, everyone remembers the feel-good moment of Styles holding aloft the WWE title for the first time, but let us not forget the great match that preceded it.


3. Shawn Michaels Vs. Randy Orton (Unforgiven 2003)

Shawn Michaels Randy Orton Unforgiven
WWE Network

So, it's not really talked about a lot, but Shawn Michaels was actually a pretty good professional wrestler. WWE, other wrestlers, and most fans are pretty low-key about it. You may or may not know that he's one of those guys who could have a great match with just about anyone, and when matched with another great worker, they could produce magic. Again, it's a really hidden tidbit about the guy.

And since you're probably choking on sarcasm, I'll stop and say that Shawn Michaels and Randy Orton expectedly had a really good match at Unforgiven 2003.

While Orton was still fairly green and not as smooth in-ring as he would eventually become, it was clear that by this point, WWE knew they had something special with him, and thus, giving him a legend killer gimmick and a match with Shawn was quite the rub. HBK, of course, carried the match with aplomb, delivering smooth sequence after smooth sequence, with Orton more than being able to keep up. It's not exactly the standout classic that Michaels had with Chris Jericho at WrestleMania XIX, but it's still an excellent showcase of how HBK looked like he hadn't missed a beat after his long absence. If you're a fan of both guys and are curious to see how even in 2003, Randy looked like a pro, check this one out.


2. Cena Vs. Orton (Breaking Point 2009)

Cena Orton Breaking Point
WWE

WWE fans can be cross about many things. One is John Cena and Randy Orton's endless on-and-off feuding, which reached a fever pitch in 2009 when the two hot-potatoed the WWE Championship for months. Another is WWE taking previously brutal, violent, hardcore stipulations, and attempting to make them palatable in the PG era. However, despite both of those things being combined at Breaking Point 2009, Cena and Orton's I Quit match managed to be quite the gem.

Framing Orton as the brutal, remorseless heel and Cena as the tenacious, undying face, this match was a supreme example of WWE forgoing an in-ring clinic and opting for story-based spectacle, and such a decision working to their benefit. The entire match saw Orton brutally attack Cena, trying to systematically destroy him and force him to surrender, but Cena, as is cliche, would never give up. It's an incredibly basic story, but Cena and Orton are such great performers, they were able to play their roles to perfection.

Cena of course would end up getting the upper hand on Orton, putting him in handcuffs and forcing the Viper to submit to the STF. It's a simple, elegantly-told story of good triumphing over evil, and is a definite highlight of Breaking Point.


1. Cena Vs. Punk (Night Of Champions 2012)

john cena punk
WWE.com

In terms of personality and in-ring quality, few feuds in the 2010s have matched John Cena and CM Punk's on-and-off rivalry from 2011 to 2013. Starting with Punk's infamous pipebomb, the two polar opposites brought out the best of each other in their matches and promos. However, when thinking back on the feud, most people mainly point to the pipebomb and their 5-star encounter at Money in the Bank 2011. It's not hard to see why, as that match was an instant classic, but it would be a shame to not mention the other spectacular encounters. Most notably: the main event of Night of Champions 2012, in which Punk defended his WWE Championship against Cena in a match that, for my money, exceeds MITB 2011's main event in terms of in-ring quality.

Of course, there are some factors that perhaps sour perceptions of this match in comparison to Money in the Bank. For one thing, instead of a nuclear Chicago crowd 100 percent behind CM Punk, NOC had merely a hot Boston crowd who was split between Punk and Cena. In addition, the double pin finish, while creative, ultimately left the show ending on a flatter note than the jubilation that was Money in the Bank.

Still, if you want to see a smoother, more seasoned performance from Cena and Punk, Night of Champions is an absolute must-watch.


Contributor
Contributor

A mystery wrapped in an enigma wrapped in bacon wrapped in wrestling listicles wrapped in tin foil wrapped in seaweed wrapped in gak.