10 Ups & 12 Downs For WWE In 2020 (So Far)

Drew McIntyre has shone, but let's calm down with the Charlotte Flair push...

Drew McIntyre Charlotte Flair
WWE

This column will focus only on matters relating directly to WWE's televised product rather than what goes on behind the scenes. 2020 has been a horrendous year in that regard. From needlessly firing dozens of workers during a global health crisis despite forecasting record profits and spitting in said workers' faces with the vulturous Drake Maverick storyline, to the prehistoric handling of said health crisis and ongoing Saudi Arabian dealings, the past six months have been rotten. When awards season hits, the Wrestling Observer's Most Disgusting Promotional Tactic field may be a WWE whitewash.

Situations outwith the promotion's control will be avoided too. It is unfair to drag WWE over hot coals for things they had no say in, though their responses to these issues are fair game.

It's almost impossible to touch on everything Vince McMahon, Bruce Prichard, and co. have produced this year, as they churn out a minimum of nine hours of new in-ring content every week. Notable omissions are a certainty - though most major bases have been covered. This has been an eventful half-year, even through the Empty Arena Era, and there's surely more to come.

Let's dive into it...


Downs...

12. Pure Sterility

WWE Performance Center
WWE

The first, tremendous SmackDown episode aside, WWE's early forays into empty arena wrestling were grim - and could have been avoided had Vince McMahon swallowed his pride and followed the competition's lead sooner.

Rows of empty seats were stark reminders of an escalating global health Criss that made the escapism these shows were supposed to provide impossible. Focusing the hard camera on these areas, not the stage, heightened this. Though safer than AEW's gather masses (does that even matter when people are wrestling in the ring and violating social distancing guidelines by posing for group social media content, anyway?), the lack of noise made for a sterile, library-like atmosphere. Performers unironically playing to non-existent crowds looked laughable. The list goes on.

Things have now moved in the right direction, though reports suggest Vince McMahon was initially reticent to switch the camera angles and bring Performance Center audiences in for fear of looking like he was copying AEW. Who cares, though? A good idea is a good idea, regardless of who did it first, and the previous, lifeless format only made WWE's tired old formulae even more striking.


11. Bizarre Demotions

WWE.com

Confusing demotions are always a fact of life in WWE, where pushes can begin or end in the blink of an eye, though that doesn't make them any less disappointing. 2020 has had more than its fair share.

Zelina Vega's gang of Austin Theory, Andrade, and Angel Garza promised much when they came together, but were soon typecast as losers, couldn't break that impression, and have now shed Theory as tensions rise between Andrade and Garza. Ricochet has been relegated to Main Event after challenging for Brock Lesnar's WWE Championship just four months ago. Brought to the main roster at WrestleMania 36 (following a stellar Royal Rumble run), creative has nothing for megastar-in-waiting Bianca Belair. Remember Shayna Baszler? Riddick Moss?

Paul Heyman, to his credit, at least endeavour to get the likes of Aleister Black, Apollo Crews, and the Street Profits over with wider audiences. His recent deposal suggests these names and more could soon join this listed above.


10. Ninja Stuff

Akira Tozawa
WWE.com

The reductiveness of having Asian wrestler Akira Tozawa playing a ninja clan leader with full garb and choreographed poses on television shouldn't need pointing out, but there you go. We just pointed it out.

That the gimmick debuted in WWE's most so-bad-it's-hilarious match of 2020 makes matters worse, as does the lack of laughs. This is supposed to be funny! You're supposed to pop when you see Tozawa roll up with the gigantic Jordan Omogbehin and "threaten" dudes who invariably kick his ass, and that's a problem: WWE's low comedy remains horrendous.

Let's hope this dies quickly.


9. Spider Stuff

Erick Rowan spider lol imagine liking this
WWE

Was this the lamest WWE reveal in history? In a universe that includes the Gobbledy Gooker and higher power, no, probably not, but it's definitely in the conversation.

WWE spent months building up the mystery of what Rowan was keeping in that veiled cage. They told you it was something important because the former Wyatt Family man was so protective of it, murdershagging anyone who dared glance in its direction. It petrified grown adults, bit its owner one week, and rapidly descended to farce, but still. WWE put effort into this daft little thing.

And then it was a mechanical spider.

And then Drew McIntyre literally killed it the next week.

And the--... oh, what's the point?


8. Jeff Hardy Vs. Sheamus

WWE.com

WWE likely acquired Jeff Hardy's permission before running with the Sheamus feud, which has used his real-life struggles with addiction to generate heat in a fake, scripted world. That's fine, and the storyline would be straight-up ghoulish if the promotion hadn't taken this step, but it's still a questionable, hamfisted narrative from a creative team that has never done sensitive topics well.

Sheamus framed "junkie" Jeff for a hit-and-run on Elias, making it look like an intoxicated Hardy had tried to kill one of his co-workers. Jeff exposed the scam then looked to face the Irishman at Backlash. Sheamus made his opponent do a piss test on the go-home SmackDown, leaving him with a faceful of urine when Jeff doused him in it, before the 'Celtic Warrior' triumphed in a tremendous pay-per-view bout.

Match quality is the only thing this storyline has going for it. While it's cute that Jeff likely gave his permission, the message, from the very beginning, is that people with his afflictions are self-destructive losers who can't help themselves. It's a harmful message hammered home by dumb-as-a-box-of-rocks scripting, with the piss segment so bad it compelled FOX to pull it from SmackDown's west coast broadcast.


7. Gronk

WWE.com

Lifelong wrestling fan Rob Gronkowski could have been a boon to WWE. Had his sporting popularity been parlayed into a big daft SummerSlam match, as was originally pitched, perhaps he would have attracted eyes to a pseudo sport that has been shedding fans for the best part of two decades. Saudi Arabian silliness would likely have followed, with Gronk stopping by for intermittent appearances in between, and both parties would end their agreement satisfied, despite the ex-NFL man's dopy dance moves.

Gronkowski ended up having one of the worst WWE runs in living memory.

His pre-WrestleMania 36 appearances were comically bad and the oversized manchild was a listless 'Show of Shows' host, where a 74-year-old Vince McMahon had to demonstrate his big dive before he was convinced to do it. Gronk became 24/7 Champion. Two weeks later, he was returning to the NFL with the Tampa Bay Buccanneers and released from WWE just a few months after signing.

"Farce," is the word you're looking for - and the actual content sucked too.


6. Stuck In The Middle With Who?

Bayley Sasha Banks Tamina Naomi Lacey Evans
WWE.com

The imbalance in Raw and SmackDown's women's divisions is odd, given this is one of the fantastic NXT scene's greatest strengths. The level of talent has never been in doubt and the likes of Sasha Banks, Asuka, and Charlotte Flair deserve to be mentioned amongst the best in the world. This isn't the problem: the presentation of the midcard wrestlers is.

Lacey Evans, Tamina, Naomi, and 2020's undercooked version of Carmella have all mounted unconvincing, uninvestable challenges for Bayley's SmackDown Women's Title. None looked sufficiently threatening for the spot. Mandy Rose and Sonya Deville offer adjacent hope thanks to their feud's slow, concerted build, but where has this effort been with the rest of them?

Bianca Beliar was forgotten about within weeks of arriving on Raw. Shayna Baszler's on again/off again presentation is equal parts frustrating and bewildering. Natalya, Liv Morgan, and Ruby Riott drift in and out like passing thoughts.

It's rubbish. The people are there, though the promotion looks reticent to push more than a couple at the time, even with the absence of Becky Lynch leaving a gaping hole that needs to be filled.


5. The Continued, Dangerous Push Of Nia Jax

Nia Jax
WWE.com

On recent evidence, the misfiring Nia Jax should not be a candidate for elevation towards the Raw Women's Championship scene.

It's not because the quality isn't there, though 'The Irresistible Force' somehow contrived to drag a peak-form Asuka to two clangers in a row, or the way the promotion has presented her character. No, it's because Nia Jax keeps hurting people.

The first Kairi Sane incident was troubling, particularly as it sounded like the diminutive victim was vocally protesting the buckle bomb before Jax bounced her head off the bottom rung. The second, in which Sane suffered a nasty cut after being lobbed into the ring steps, is easier to pass off as an accident, though the excessive force used suggests extreme clumsiness.

There is now more than enough evidence to state that Jax is an unsafe worker whose lack of finesse is a danger to her fellow wrestlers. Pulled from developmental far too early, she should return to the Performance Center until these things stop happening.


4. The Continued, Misguided Push Of Charlotte Flair

Charlotte Flair
WWE

Charlotte Flair is an outstanding professional wrestler. Let's get that out of the way immediately. She projects stardom, carries herself like the biggest deal in any given building, and has given most active main roster wrestlers their best WWE match - which isn't a coincidence. Flair is as flawed as any other imperfect human being, but she is tremendous.

Her continued, misguided push is not.

It's the old Roman Reigns situation: a fantastic performer drawing genuine, Universe-breaking scorn through overexposure and inconsistent presentation. Charlotte is everywhere. She dominates airtime like nobody else in the promotion to the extent that it doesn't even matter how good her work is, because so many are just sick of the sight of her.

That she flip-flops between face and heel sometimes on the same show doesn't help, either. People have no idea how they're supposed to take to Charlotte, so they don't take to her at all. The Wonder Woman push hasn't worked: we have the viewership figures to show it and while she's currently injured, all parties would benefit from dialling back when she returns.


In this post: 
EDGE
 
Posted On: 
Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.