10 Worst Title Reigns In AEW History

All Elite Wrestling has crowned some of the best champions in modern wrestling history. However...

Private Party Tony Khan
AEW

"Growing pains" has been the phrase most commonly associated with the changes All Elite Wrestling has undergone in the last few years, and that's reasonable to an extent - the quest for money and expansion has resulted in one happening as a result of the other. 

Television rights for Rampage and Collision have made AEW a several-hours-a-week television product with 10-12 pay-per-view offerings as opposed to 2019's starting point of Dynamite on TNT and a quarterly high-stakes supershow. In that respect, a comparison between the two products is somewhat unfair, but it happens anyway because, amongst other things, people miss the quality of the original. 

The limited scope might have been bad for business, but the rules and restrictions put in place by the smaller roster and fewer belts kept the product honest and disciplined in impossible ways the more wrestlers and belts you add. It's why there's not much in here from the earliest days of the organisation when it couldn't have aimed to be more different from the increasingly monolithic WWE. That's not to say mistakes weren't made, but the attempts to maintain the prestige of the wrestlers and the belts were obvious enough that some leeway could be extended.

That's less the case now, as evidenced by several very recent titleholders...

10. The Elite (September 4th 2022 - September 7th 2022)

Kenny Omega The Young Bucks Elite AEW Trios Titles
AEW

More on the other belt that was severely damaged by everything that happened on the night of All Out 2022, but AEW's brand new Trios Championships being won then immediately vacated did little help a division that already felt like it was being formally launched a year or two late.

The Elite were great winners of a great tournament, and would prove that again in a captivating best-of-seven series with Death Triangle when they returned to television from their suspension, but the belts being drenched in controversy from the off left a stain that hasn't really been washed away during the coldest period in AEW history. 

Trios matches required their constant presence and attention to sell the idea that this was where the best wrestled, long before the company forced it through as a catchphrase. They'd been pulled into the whirlwind of chaos stirred up by CM Punk's words in the All Out 2022 press scrum, the belts came with them, and it understandably felt like forever before the performers and the prizes were back to best. 


9. Jack Perry (June 30th, 2024 - November 23th, 2024)

25 4 Jack Perry
AEW

There's nothing wrong in a noble failure of a push in pro wrestling, and that's what Jack Perry's 2024 will ultimately go down as.

He was given major wins, major matches and - for better and worse - one of the major moments of the year. Taking out Tony Khan to reveal the full formation of a new Elite alongside The Young Bucks and Kazuchika Okada was supposed to be a transgression so enormous that it justified showing camera footage of the real Wembley fight with CM Punk weeks earlier and launch the group into the stratosphere with 'The Scapegoat' at the forefront.

He became the TNT Champion as an integral part of the story, but the lack of credibility in the foundation of the group and realistically Perry's matches lowered the status of the division below the numerous other midcard titles at the company's disposal. The former 'Jungle Boy' was a rule-proving exception in his biggest year yet - while there were too many wrestlers getting not enough time, he was getting too much time in place of too many other wrestlers. 


8. Chris Jericho (April 21st 2024 - August 25th 2024

Chris Jericho
WWE

The FTW Championship being brought into All Elite Wrestling as a serious title to fight for was always stretching the gold beyond its original premise, but Chris Jericho getting hold of it in 2024 to allegedly help move Hook up to some mythical next level was a case of the idea completely eating itself.

'The Cold Hearted Handsome Devil' was the latest to get caught in the Jericho Vortex (not the gimmick kind, if the gimmick is even a gimmick because it's a shoot), but the fact that the entire story of Hook being robbed of the gold only to win it back at Wembley was one that had been done with Jack Perry a year prior seemed to have escaped Jericho's attention as he went through loads of the same motions. A series of themed weapons brawls on television did nothing to justify the spot both the Champion and Championship commanded over a miserable few months before he predictably lost it back in a sequence of events he pretended was star-making. 

One only need to look at the retirement of the title in the immediate aftermath to see how ineffective it was - upon reclaiming the belt, Hook handed the strap to Father and originator Taz, and back on the mantlepiece it went.


7. The Young Bucks (April 21st 2024 - October 30th 2024)

16 5 Young Bucks
AEW

Matthew and Nicholas Jackson have since explained that several different pitches didn't make air that might have made their 2024 run with the Tag Team gold more interesting, and it's worth caveating any criticism of this particular period with the reminder that they still had two of the best television matches of the year and delivered an immensely satisfying title change.

But.

But but but.

Expectations for the brothers are permanently set to sky high, and a run going so many days without a defence was bad form, even if it was in service of their new EVPs gimmick. The division felt like it was being disregarded creatively, and with The Bucks atop the pile and only Sting's retirement match justifying finally getting the belts in a pay-per-view main event, the criticisms grew louder.

It at least ended on a high, but that too was somewhat transparent and extremely short-lived. The last couple of years have been ones to forget for The Elite, and few will share treasured memories of this title run to go alongside them. 


6. Sammy Guevara/Scorpio Sky (January 26th 2022 - July 6th 2022)

Scorpio Sky
AEW

Time's been particularly unkind to it, but he feud between Sammy Guevara and Scorpio Sky was a major factor in the decline of the TNT Championship's prestige. 

What started with potential - especially considering both competitors' then-untapped in-ring talent - quickly devolved into a series of forgettable moments and misguided booking decisions that tarnished the once-promising title. Initially, the TNT Championship had a strong reputation, often featuring some of AEW's best performers in high-profile matches. It was a symbol of everything a thriving midcard should be, but once Guevara and Sky entered the scene, the championship's credibility took a hit. Sammy's increasingly self-centered character and reckless booking, such as his inconsistent title defenes and reliance on shocking, over-the-top angles, made the belt feel like a prop rather than a meaningful prize.

Sky's involvement only compounded the issue. His character, which initially had promise as a serious contender, was muddled by unnecessary backstage drama and a lack of proper storytelling. Instead of elevating the title, the feud between the two became more about personal animosities and backstage politics than the actual championship. This shift in focus caused fans to lose interest in what was once AEW's most prestigious secondary title.

In the end, the Guevara-Sky feud didn’t just fail to elevate either competitor; it diminished the very concept of the TNT Championship, leaving it feeling like an afterthought rather than a coveted prize. AEW desperately needs to refocus and rebuild the credibility of the TNT title if it hopes to restore the prestige it once had.


5. Private Party (October 30th, 2024 - January 22nd, 2025)

Private Party
WWE

Private Party's 2024 tag team title reign in AEW is so widely regarded as a dead rubber that it wasn't even a surprise when top heel group The Hurt Syndicate were received like heroes when they effortlessly dethroned them in an extended squash. 

Isiah Kassidy and Marq Quen are talented performers with charisma and in-ring ability, but hopes of a strong reign were quickly dashed due to the total lack of significant title defences and storyline developments while holding the gold. Over three months, they only defended the titles twice; at Full Gear in a chaotic four-way match where their win felt more like luck than skill, and a milquetoast win against Leo Rush and Action Andretti. This period was marked by a noticeable absence of narrative progression for both Private Party and the tag team division as a whole, which fans quickly picked up on and subsequently rejected in kind. 

Ultimately, the championship run did not leverage the potential to elevate the team or enrich the division's storylines. Instead, it became a tragic footnote in AEW's history, remembered more for its shortcomings than any memorable achievements.


4. CM Punk (May 29th, 2022 - August 24th, 2022)

CM Punk FTR
AEW

Few would have predicted it and even fewer could have spotted it, but the eventual explosion of tension between CM Punk and AEW was bubbling under from before he won his first AEW Championship, but things might have gone differently had the 'Second City Saint' not jumped into the crowd on his first Dynamite as Champion and broken his foot.

An immediate injury wrote him off television for the summer months, but the decision was made to keep him Champion in order to do a bout with whoever claimed interim gold in his absence. That man was Jon Moxley - somebody then so deservedly beloved by audiences that the potential dream match between the pair became more of a political war than a kayfabe one.

Moxley's squash win over Punk on television to set up their pay-per-view blowoff weeks later reeked of compromise and lack of communication, and the worst was still yet to come. 


3. The Deathriders (August 24th 2024 - ???)

AEW Collision FTR Wheeler Yuta Claudio Castagnoli
AEW

Furthering the idea that the division and titles are cursed, Claudio Castagnoli, Wheeler Yuta and PAC won the belts as a makeshift Blackpool Combat Club offshoot in the sunshine of Wembley Stadium in 2024, only to plunge them back into darkness when they all became part of sludgy Jon Moxley takeover of All Elite Wrestling.

Yes, they're credible wrestlers, but who isn't in 2025? Good Wrestling is everywhere across every product, televised and otherwise (making a further mockery of the Moxley character shift based on how he supposedly wants to reshape the product) and even with title defences - and there hasn't been many -  the quality hasn't risen to such an extent that the hostage situation/vacuum effect created by their reign has solved the problem of dragging the gold back from irrelevance. 

This isn't the biggest crime (not counting the actual crimes) the group have committed with a title though...


2. Jon Moxley (October 12th 2024 - ???)

Jon Moxley
AEW

A worst case scenario for the AEW Championship and the product writ large, Jon Moxley literally holding the belt hostage in a briefcase has come to symbolise a total loss of connection between the promotion's former conscience and what its core audience desperately wants to see. 

Muddled creative re-introduced Moxley's character as a harbinger of doom for the roster, determined to take out the (supposedly) weak and fix a broken organisation. Acknowledging that the show hadn't been all that good was the first misfire, because Mox - the heel - was ultimately speaking on behalf of a loud portion of the fanbase. Then, when he took to attempting to murder various members of the roster in cartoonish ways, he broke one too many unwritten wrestling rules and flushed away his own credibility in the process.

Ironically, 2025 has seen several encouraging creative signs of life for the distant challenger brand, but the main event picture patrolled by The Deathriders Is almost universally derided as its achilles heel.

Mission accomplished? And if so, let somebody else have (and show off!) the belt to celebrate.


1. CM Punk (September 4th 2022 - September 7th 2022)

CM Punk Tony Khan
AEW

'The Best In The World' was the worst for the World Title picture in 2022 when, mere minutes after winning it, he unleashed a now-infamous verbal tirade on the state of the organisation via brutal digs at the expense of the EVPs and anybody else that had wronged him.

CM Punk's needle-moving ability was and is without compare in All Elite Wrestling, but the All Out press conference explosion was as damaging to business in the short term as it was long. A long-awaited rematch with MJF was as good as dead, dream potential contests against Kenny Omega and The Young Bucks were torched, and a relationship between 'The Second City Saint' and the challenger brand's core base was destroyed forever.

The only natural outcomes were suspensions and title-strippings, and that's what happened as early as the following Wednesday's Dynamite. It made for what's likely to be one of - if not the - shortest reigns ever, whilst plunging the value of the belt and perception of the company's inner workings to an all-time low.  


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.