10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2008
WWE nuked ECW, screwed CM Punk and tried to kill off Vince McMahon AGAIN in 2008.
"I'm sorry, I love you". Those immortal words from Shawn Michaels towards Ric Flair at WrestleMania XXIV closed the book on an iconic 'Nature Boy' career, or so everybody thought. Flair ignoring WWE's grand scale retirement treatment and returning to the ring technically happened in 2009 though, and it occurred outside company walls, so any deep dive on '08 is free to bask in the glory of his emotional send off.
Other top moments from the year include CM Punk cashing in Money In The Bank to become new World Heavyweight Champion, John Cena's phenomenal Royal Rumble return, some outstanding work between The Undertaker and Edge, and a year-best feud pitting Chris Jericho against HBK. All of that was great, but...what about the other end of the scale?
WWE went PG midway through 2008. Blood, swearing, scantily clad Diva behaviour and pretty much anything that had defined 'Attitude' or 'Ruthless Aggression' was out. It took a while for the promotion to settle into a new style though - nobody knew just how far they could push the envelope, and that'd quickly sanitise the product come 2009/2010-ish. Mercifully, '08 was spared the worst of it, but there were still some horrors lurking for fans when readjusting to Raw becoming more like 'medium rare' every week.
PR stunts overshadowed another bold attempt to write Vince McMahon off TV, they picked literally the worst person ever for ECW, a lifeless main event push stalled, women were handed a brand new belt then ignored, and poor Punk became a babyface afterthought on Monday nights. 'We're sorry, we hate you' came the cry from writers towards Punk by September. Probably.
Here's the worst from a year when everything changed.
10. The HOF Run Of Braden Walker
TNA fans would've called Chris Harris one of the most dynamic tag wrestlers on the planet by the end of 2007. His America's Most Wanted unit with James Storm was one of the company's finest, so there was a mini-buzz rippling when Harris inked a WWE deal in January. Would he bring tag excellence to the E, or would he find his footing as a breakout singles star?
Neither. Harris didn't work his first dark match in his new home until March, then he wouldn't show up on TV until 8 July's ECW. The re-dubbed Braden Walker (a name that had money written all over it...) debuted opposite Armando Estrada in a short backstage segment, and it was infamously bad. Walker's gimmick? He told basic 'knock knock' jokes, or one of them at least.
When he said "knock knock" and Armando asked, "Who's there?', Braden replied: "Braden Walker, and I'm gonna knock your brains out". OK then. Not really a punchline, but maybe the one time 'Wildcat' was going literal with the punch part of that word. A catchy tagline wouldn't have mattered anyway, because Walker looked like the most boring singlet and boots wrestler going.
He beat Armando on ECW, then won an even more pointless bout vs. James Curtis on the 5 August edition. Initially, announcers called Braden a key figure in the ongoing ECW recruitment drive, but he was released a mere 2 days after the match with Curtis. So much for that then, eh?
WWE's writers blatantly didn't put more than 20 seconds of thought into Braden's debut or presentation. He was more 1995 Superstars jobber than must-see new name. What a 'Best Of' DVD boxset he had though. Literally 15 minutes of fun.
9. Hornswoggle & Finlay’s Baffling Royal Rumble
Most people get a big grin on their faces when reminiscing about the 2008 Royal Rumble. That classic Madison Square Garden set up, the fact that WWE opened their 30-man special with The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels, John Cena's iconic surprise return - oh yes, it was glorious. Mostly. There's something else about the match you've maybe forgotten since it happened.
Perpetual 2007 nuisance Hornswoggle entered as #9 in the Rumble. Knowing he was outgunned, he immediately hid under the ring, and only really resurfaced to pull The Miz’s arm and score an elimination. Then, wee Horny went back underneath until being attacked by Mark Henry and Big Daddy V. That prompted Finlay to come out earlier than his planned #27 number so he could save Swoggle from a kicking.
The end result? Finlay and Hornswoggle left. No joke, they just walked out of there. The announcers seemed confused, at least until they clearly got word from the back that Finlay had been disqualified for using his shillelagh/jumping the gun on his entrance into the match. He was DQ’d for using a weapon in a Rumble? Hmm, that didn’t add up considering everything that had happened in prior years. Worse, Swoggle was never actually eliminated at all. He simply strolled off.
Also, Hornswoggle technically went 26:17 in the match, which meant he’d lasted the 5th longest in the Rumble behind Batista, Michaels, Undertaker and John Morrison. Yep, Swoggle outlasted workers like CM Punk, Cody Rhodes and Umaga who entered around the same sort of time as him.
Shelton Benjamin got 18 seconds out there, by the way. Let that sink in for a second. Or 18 of them.
8. Lil’ “Hornswoggle McMahon” Gets Whipped
If you read the worst WWE moments of 2007 piece, then you already know the nightmares caused by Hornswoggle being outed as Vince McMahon's illegitimate son. That spot had originally been ring fenced for Mr. Kennedy, but his toxic mix of injuries and suspensions meant Swoggle got the nod instead. A natural replacement if there ever was one.
Ahem.
McMahon was incensed and embarrassed by the bombshell that Finlay's leprechaun was his boy, so he decided to punish Hornswoggle in a steel cage match on the 18 February 2008 Raw. This was designed to start moving towards a match between Finlay and JBL come WrestleMania XXIV, but it was flagship torture for fan eyeballs. The "Hornswoggle McMahon" storyline felt interminable, and things got proper silly here.
The one-sided cage bout saw Vince literally whip Swoggle with his belt as Finlay (who was handcuffed to the ropes) promised to make the boss and JBL pay for their crimes. When McMahon had his fill, Layfield destroyed his mini peer with a brutish display that near enough made Finlay foam at the mouth. Then, Vince seemed remorseful afterwards.
This ate up far too much TV time for what it was. It also doesn't appear that WWE acknowledges it as a proper match. Nor, mind you, does aggregate fan site Cagematch. There's next to no mention of it anywhere. Wait, did this writer imagine the whole thing? Nobody wants to come to terms with the idea that they might've been sleep-Swoggling. That's like bullying yourself!
Watching wee Swogs getting whipped in the butt by his kayfabe daddy was not a fab way to spend a Monday evening in Feb '08.
7. The Divas Title Is Born
Wrestling is a subjective business, so somebody out there might regard Michelle McCool as their favourite wrestler ever. Fair enough, but WWE's pretence that she was some tremendous in-ringer who made waves in the women's division and is equal to stars like Trish Stratus or Lita is objectively wide of the mark. Can anybody name even one memorable McCool match?
That sounds harsh for a Hall Of Famer, but can they?! Her time riding high as a babyface singles name in the division peaked when WWE introduced a second belt for the women at the Great American Bash '08 pay-per-view on 20 July. There, Michelle beat Natalya in a match that ran less than 5 minutes, and she became the first ever Divas Champ as a result.
Vince McMahon was so excited about his new creation that he forgot all about it, and McCool didn't defend the thing until Unforgiven in September. That should've told fans tuning in just how important the belt was. Somehow, it lasted until 2016 when the superior trio of Charlotte Flair, Becky Lynch and Sasha Banks reinvented the wheel at WrestleMania 32 - they strived to become Women's Champion, not Divas.
Admittedly, McCool and Layla's tag-team did pin down the division for a while a few years later, but many of Michelle's solo matches were bang average. Being fair to her, WWE didn't do nearly enough to make anyone care about the Divas gold. Or pink. It was a trinket, one to be downplayed whilst the women struggled to adjust to life without titillation to fall back on.
They'd been creatively institutionalised, and so had fans, so it was difficult to take the Divas belt seriously.
6. McMahon Million Dollar Mania Ends In Disaster
Vince McMahon once declared (probably with a trademark grin and laugh combo) that he 'couldn't be on TV if he was dead'. That led to the limo explosion angle from 2007, but McMahon quickly had to reappear and talk about scripted entertainment/kayfabe deaths once agonising details about the brutal Chris Benoit double murder and suicide tragedy came out.
Approx 12 months later, Vinnie Mac was back at it again. He introduced 'Million Dollar Mania', a PR stunt that saw McMahon giving away oodles of his own cash in a sweepstakes competition if fans who entered answered the phone live on air. This lasted for around 3 weeks or so, and it chewed up an insane amount of television time in the process.
Seeking a shocking end, Vince booked some staging to collapse on the 23 June Raw. He was crushed during the segment, and memorably cried out to Triple H by calling him Paul and revealing that he couldn't feel his own legs. It was the 2005 Royal Rumble all over again! Not really.
Fans were less than convinced by all of this. It was the second time in a year that WWE had tried to kill off Vince's onscreen character with a big set piece explosion, after all, but the 'Million Dollar Mania' stunt lacked the impact of the limousine moment. On top of all that (or buried underneath the wreckage with Vince), those ‘Million Dollar Mania’ skits were dry and a total waste of airtime when it could've gone on building towards PPV matches at Night Of Champions.
Nah, why concentrate on Edge vs. Batista or John Cena vs. Triple H when McMahon can brag about being rich instead?
5. Vladimir Kozlov’s Boring Main Event Push
WWE actually has a fairly solid record when it comes to picking workers deserving of a main event push in the modern era, but they got it spectacularly wrong with Vladimir Kozlov. He was an old school anti-USA heel who felt passé, but that wasn't the biggest problem. Rusev came along and did that with aplomb years later. No, the real issue was that Vlad was straight up boring.
His squashes were dull, and no-one was fooled by commentary claims that he'd be a force to be reckoned with by the biggest stars on the roster. Regardless, WWE shoved Kozlov awkwardly up the ladder and booked him in a Triple Threat match vs. Triple H and Jeff Hardy for Survivor Series '08. Come crunch time, Jeff was posted missing the bout due to an attack angle staged before the match.
That, rather unfortunately, meant that Trips had 10-12 minutes to try squeeze a passable match out of Vladimir. It was an uphill task, to say the least. Vickie Guerrero didn't show up until late on to announce that Edge was taking Jeff's place, which meant a bored live crowd had to sit through Hunter struggling to get anything out of Kozlov. That 10 mins or so felt like a lifetime.
Indeed, everything about 'Vladimir Kozlov - Vince McMahon Pet Project #8,263' was crummy. Exposing him in a singles bout like this (even against one of the most established names in the company) on a major pay-per-view was a terrible decision. McMahon and his lieutenants surely regretted this one straight away.
Big Koz should've had a few extra z's behind his name. "Kozzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz". He put people to sleep.
4. “JBL Is Poopy”
File John Cena and Cryme Tyme aligning as CTC (Cryme Time Cenation) under factions you've almost certainly forgotten about. All in all, the trio were only together for a few weeks in mid-2008. That was a shame, because it might've given JTG and Shad Gaspard a leg up on the roster again due to the fact they were rubbing shoulders with the poster boy. WWE didn't give this one nearly enough time to breathe or resonate with fans.
Perhaps one angle turned them off. It sure turned some stomachs in the audience.
On the 7 July 2008 edition of Raw, Cena and his pals vandalised JBL's trademark bull-horned limousine by sketching some graffiti all over it. One of the phrases JC used would go down in history as a worst ever moment in his career. He spray painted, "JBL Is Poopy" on the car in bright red, and the announcers tried to present that as one of the edgiest things they'd ever seen.
Back home, countless people watching Raw screwed up their faces. WWE were preparing to go PG on 22 July, so they didn't want to do anything that'd jeopardise that or get them into trouble with potential sponsors. Thus, Cena couldn't say or scribble anything that'd be considered too offensive or over the tope, but..."poopy"? It was lame.
"JBL Sucks", or something to that effect, would've worked way better. This was in line with the "fudge, baloney, mustard" nonsense that sanitised Cena came away with during this time period. He'd gone from rapping badass with an edge to a walking cartoon character adults were still supposed to take seriously. It was a lot to take in.
3. Mike Adamle Replaces Joey Styles On ECW
By 2008, the revived ECW brand was a glorified retread of Sunday Night Heat, Superstars, Metal/Jakked or any other number of 'C' or 'D' tier weekly shows. It had nothing in common with the brand Paul Heyman had promoted throughout the 1990s, and the program even lacked some of the hardcore sensibilities WWE's own One Night Stand events had boasted in 2005 and 2006.
Regardless, it still had Joey Styles. He was the voice of extreme, and both he and Tazz made for a credible announce duo that old school fans of Heyman's cult-like product could get behind. On 15 April, WWE changed all of that. Bumbling backstage interviewer Mike Adamle replaced Styles as Tazz's new commentary partner, and he instantly struggled in the role.
Mike was trying his best, sure, but he was rotten and never seemed to get WWE or pro wrestling in general. The dude was no Joe Tessitore. What of Joey then? Well, Styles was posted to WWE.com for no particular reason, and ECW continued to dwindle as Adamle dropped clangers like referring to Little Guido/Nunzio as a former ECW World Champion.
It was almost as though bosses were actively looking for ways to shut down the land of extreme. Their glitzy version of ECW lagged behind Raw and SmackDown, didn't conjure up memories of yesteryear, and now it had some guy who barely even knew Jeff Hardy was called that ("Jeff Harvey") manning the desk.
Unthinkably, the Adamle pain continued on a much bigger platform than WWE-ECW too. What on earth were they thinking when management...
2. Adamle Becomes Raw GM
...made Mike the new Raw GM on the 28 July '08 flagship?!
WWE took an announcer who had limited product knowledge and was woefully out of place on ECW, and they (in their infinite wisdom) decided to turn him into a recurring authority figure on their biggest brand. Adamle was a fish out of water as the General Manager of Raw. The promotion would have been as well drafting in some celeb who knew nothing about wrestling to fill that spot.
Mike's 3 month reign of terror included plenty of boring promos and announcements, and he never really seemed to have a clue what was going on. Shane McMahon was the one who announced he was new GM, and it wasn't lost on anybody that he would've been a preferable choice to Adamle. Hell, anybody would've been. You could've given the gig to future Raw guest host Bob Barker and he'd have made a better fist of things than our Mikey.
Raw was, is and probably always will be WWE's television focal point. So, to pluck an out of his depth 'C' string announcer from ECW (where he was tanking) and think he was going to thrill fans tuning in on Monday nights was frankly crazy. It was a bonafide 'chuck at wall, see what sticks' moment in time. There was no reasonable justification for giving a role this important to Mike f'n Adamle!
He'll go down as one of the worst Raw GMs of all time, guaranteed, but what did WWE think was going to happen here? Did they honestly believe he'd suddenly develop charisma and become the latest version of Teddy Long?
1. CM Punk Doesn’t Even Get To Drop His Title
2008 was an up and down year for aspiring headline attraction CM Punk. The ups were outstanding - WWE had Punk win the Money In The Bank ladder match at WrestleMania XXIV, then they had him cash in on Edge to win the World Title on the 30 June Raw. How about the downs? The writers clearly didn't see CM as a long term solution with Raw's top belt, and a feud with JBL over the summer proved it.
Layfield lambasted Punk as a pretender throughout, and he was speaking for Vince McMahon/Triple H there. A solid reign with a satisfying conclusion could, in theory, cement the breakout star as a true main eventer though. Sadly, WWE didn’t deem Punk important enough to even be involved in dropping his own title. Yikes! That's when you know you're not welcome to dine at the top table.
He was attacked by Randy Orton in a short backstage skit and removed from the scramble match booked for Unforgiven in September. Chris Jericho took his place, and it was he who ended the night as champ. Punk did receive a cage match vs. Jericho on TV after that, but he lost and was placed in a tag-team with Kofi Kingston towards the end of the year.
WWE outright failed to get behind him as a babyface champ. They clearly didn't want to, or had buyer's remorse as soon as he cashed in on Edge as a smiling Batista looked on. Imagine being written out of your own title loss, and barely getting the chance to kick and scream about it following that. Punk doesn't need to imagine it.
He lived that humbling experience.
What other moments from WWE's 2008 could be considered some of the worst? For more like this, check out 10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2007 and 10 Wrestlers That Got BANNED From AEW!