10 Wrestlers Who Broke Typecasting In The Most Epic Way

First the worst, second the best...

Trish Stratus Then And Now
Instagram/@trishstratuscom/WWE

Professional wrestling, for all its comparisons to film and television, should actually be easier on those that maybe take longer to find their best personas either side of the bell-to-bell bit.

Few performers are genuinely great actors - the nuts and bolts of the in-ring craft can be practiced and perfected, but it takes an altogether different head to master the microphone in a believable manner that connects emotionally and financially with live and television audiences alike.

Typecasting shouldn't be as common as it is in the industry, but promoters and performers often take the path of least resistance in the interest of making the quickest buck. Why ask a musclehead to talk, a wrestler to Sports Entertain or - once upon a time - a woman to actually work?

When it's hard enough to get potential stars to be themselves (but turned up to 11, etc etc), it can be more effort than it's worth to go looking for something entirely different to make somebody a somebody.

Shame, too. As the following examples show, there's a lot to be said for unlocking somebody's surprising second self...

10. Raven

Raven Pose
WWE.com

Starting life as Scotty The Body, Scotty Flamingo and Johnny Polo, Scott Levy seemed destined to play braggarts and bolshie body guys for the rest of his career until Extreme Championship Wrestling mastermind Paul Heyman unlocked something entirely different in the WWE want-away.

Levy developed the character at the very end of 1994 following his exit from the organisation, altering his entire look to include grunge attire and piercings whilst taking a misanthropic swing at the wider world in his promos.

Jim Cornette allegedly passed on the persona for Smokey Mountain Wrestling, but Heyman fell in love with the gimmick and tweaked it further to position Raven as a cult leader and childhood scourge of existing babyface Tommy Dreamer.

Their angle in particular brought him in red hot, and multiple reigns as ECW World Champion were underpinned by Dreamer's inability to beat Raven in multiple brawls over two absorbing years.

The gimmick had enough legs to last out the remainder of Levy's career, though the night-and-day switch upon his 1995-1997 run (and callous acts he engaged in to further distance himself from the bombastic buffoonery of old) remained the most impactful period in his career.


9. Hulk Hogan

Hulk Hogan Tearing His Shirt Off
WWE.com

Hulk Hogan's size and natural charisma made him an obvious choice for Vince McMahon when he surveyed the industry looking for somebody to lead his kind of national expansion, but Hogan himself ran most of the hard yards refining the character in the American Wrestling Association after McMahon's father Vince Sr booked him as a bully heel during his original run.

Arriving in 1979 as something of a giant compared to the bulk of the New York territory's roster, Hogan was given heel manager Freddie Blassie as a mouthpiece and two jobbers at a time in his squash matches. Big enough to pose a believable threat, he even feuded with Andre The Giant in a ticket-shifting reversal of their era-defining 1987 angle.

It was this villainous charisma that got him cast as 'Thunderlips' in Rocky III, but the decision to take the role that cost him a spot with Vince Sr. A made man from Hollywood upon his return to wrestling, Verne Gagne's saw babyface dollars in Hogan for the AWA, but McMahon saw millions.

The flag-waving, demandment-spewing icon that returned in 1983 was a far cry from the monster that had departed two years earlier. It'd be a wrestling lifetime before he switched again...


8. Hollywood Hogan

Hollywood Hogan
WWE.com

...but the industry was again irreversibly transformed by Hulk Hogan's return to the dark side.

A two-year stint in WCW had yielded reasonable pay-per-view returns in 1994 and passable brand recognition in 1995, but pre-existing fans of the product had violently turned on the dated red-and-yellow hero Hulk by the time he took a sabbatical in mid-1996.

Hogan's 1980s dominance wasn't something well-replicated on WCW's red hot weekly product by then - squashing Dungeon Of Doom duds and outwrestling the likes of Ric Flair, Arn Anderson and others was the sort of stuff getting him heckled out of arenas for the first time in nearly two decades.

It spoke to how loyal he was to everything that had worked in his life up to that point how big a decision it was to ditch the red and yellow for the black and white, but the power of the turn rocket-strapped WCW beyond any reasonable expectations. Which, in turn drove WWE to fight back in a "Monday Night War" many fans pine for nearly two decades after its conclusion.


7. Braun Strowman

braun strowman
WWE.com

Braun Strowman's Wyatt Family debut was completely in keeping with the company's historic treatment of men his size and stature.

Strowman was mean but green as Bray's latest big mate, and looked to be the next foil for an Undertaker or Brock Lesnar strictly to kill time in between them wrestling bigger stars he could be barriers to. All until a 2016 gamble on his...ahem...raw materials made him the flagship show's biggest breakout star.

One of that year's brand extension's biggest beneficiaries, Braun went on squash duties like many others before him, but brought incredible physical charisma to the same old stories. His short sharp shocks on the microphone got his own name over as a catchphrase and entrance theme sting, and longer promos highlighted the wit and timing of the man behind the 'Monster Among Men'.

A failure to win the big one despite a good record against Roman Reigns over the past few years has perhaps reduced his role in the eyes of Vince McMahon, but at just 35, he's got years left to make good on the incredible promise few could have predicted on his debut.


6. Kofi Kingston

Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

Kofi Kingston's recent WrestleMania push hasn't been without merit. It's merit in fact that's underpinned everything about the push - fans and New Day friends Xavier Woods and Big E alike have espoused hard truths about his graft and survival instincts in the organisation since his 2008 debut. It's the pro wrestler getting the spot, not the entertainer, clown or fool that may have once upon a time.

WWE's booking of non-white performers has been historically problematic even during their attempts to earnestly improve. Stereotypes are too often dug deep into - whilst characteristics such as intellectualism, fighting spirit or technical excellence have always been reserved for the various great white hopes Vince McMahon's hitched his wagon to over the decades.

Kofi Kingston is - at long last - all business, and his business is pro wrestling. This push has emerged not just from his ability to get over as a grinning babyface singles star or pancake-chucking New Day boypopper, but his dynamism and dedication to the craft.

All of it was hiding in plain sight all along of course, but deep-rooted and dormant prejudices take a long time to overcome.


5. AJ Styles

AJ Styles
WWE.com

AJ Styles has been with WWE long enough now that the novelty has almost worn off, but it can't be understated how much it appeared as though he'd be a modern era Sting as the one Vince McMahon hold-out during his generation's boom period.

Beloved in TNA before a total NJPW rebirth, Styles wasn't a WWE guy under any old definition, and wore the description well as the super-technical superstar that hadn't ever needed McMahon's promotional empire to get across just how 'Phenomenal' he truly was.

Even upon signing in 2016, he did so during a time others had the potential to surpass him. Styles has gone on record to say McMahon wasn't after him just for his in-ring skill, but to challenge what else he could bring to the organisation.

It was all asked and answered within months - Styles assembled an astonishing series with Roman Reigns to get 'The Big Dog's post-WrestleMania WWE Title tenure off to the best possible start and elevated himself in the process.

A made man by the time he claimed the gold that Autumn, Styles second 2017-2018 run was an acknowledgement that he'd become the company's safest pair of hands. Not since Bret Hart's 1994 tenure and McMahon showed faith in someone so unexpectedly.


4. Chyna

Chyna WWE
WWE.com

Spotted by Triple H and Shawn Michaels (and used by her then-boyfriend Hunter to get over altogether) Chyna's initial appeal was undeniably because she looked as if she could deck any man on the roster with ease.

Positioned against the tiny Marlena was a masterstroke in its own right at that point, but only when she moved into fighting males full time did WWE's faith in the 'Ninth Wonder Of The World' pay off.

The nickname itself was of some prestige - Andre The Giant claims the eighth wonder in wrestling circles - but Chyna's own pedigree was briefly more powerful than Triple H's untouchable finisher. The silence behind the violence of DX broke out proper in late-1999 and became the first female Intercontinental Champion.

The normalisation process was such that her brief shift to the Women's division shortly before her acrimonious 2001 exit was harder to parse than the wars she'd waged against Chris Jericho, Jeff Jarrett et al.


3. Trish Stratus

Trish Stratus Women's Champion
WWE.com

Before the Four Horsewomen and the Women's Revolution in general reimagined what it meant to be a female wrestler in WWE, Trish Stratus was considered the greatest to ever compete in the company. The compliments weren't without merit, but the journey from 2000 fitness model to 2006 finesse performer was truly remarkable.

It wasn't just how good Stratus got - because she was objectively excellent - but how little she probably needed to considering the trends of the time.

As manager of T&A, the implication was on-the-nose by design - highlighted in gross fashion by her angle with Vince McMahon a year after her debut. Hired for her looks first like every other "athletic 10" the jaded old men were told to chase at the time, Trish instead worked relentlessly to reach the level of Molly Holly, Jazz and other contemporaries that had finer grasps of the fundamentals.

She gradually became considered a wrestler first and eye candy second - creative death for most women of the era before Stratus showed the idiots in Stamford that they'd got themself a girl that could do both.


2. The Miz

The Miz Custom Title
WWE.com

During his first stint as United States Champion in 2010, The Miz cut a memorable promo that involved him talking his way from the locker room to the ring - it painted the picture of the man he'd become in spite of the start he'd faced as a WWE Superstar.

A figure of loathing and hatred amongst some of the worst business-protecting b*stards of the day, Miz was prohibited from even changing with the other wrestlers after breaking various unwritten rule and daring to be a slightly irritating fan that had broke in via reality TV rather than a bruising past on the independent scene.

Work - hard, hard work - got him through the dark days and to the promised land as WWE Champion at the tail-end of the year. Though that run was destroyed by the highly corrosive John Cena character at the time, he's since carved out a different legacy as the company's best all-round Sports Entertainer. Few ever saw him getting near the top title, let alone earning actual - gasp - respect from most and many as such a vital cog in the WWE machine.


1. Charlotte Flair

Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

Charlotte Flair signed with WWE in 2012, after careers as a professional volleyball player and personal trainer took a backstep in order for her to follow in her Father's footsteps. When her brother Reid passed away a year later, she dug even deeper to ensure his dreams were realised through her - a lofty challenge considering her older sibling David's woeful attempt to do the same a decade earlier.

For somebody carrying such a huge weight of familial expectation without having wrestling as a first love, 'The Queen' has - in less than six years - become one of the era's best all-rounders and one of the best second generation stars in company history.

No more will those from outside wrestling entering from another field be bullied or bantered off for not having it "in their blood" or whatever absurd qualification used to supposedly be needed. Charlotte did, still didn't pick it, and still became one of the best to "walk that aisle" in her own time.

Every female wrestler over the past few years has been forced to smash at least one stereotype - Charlotte shattered all of them.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Trish Stratus
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.