10 Wrestlers WWE Protected In The WORST Way Possible
WWE didn't actually do these guys any favours by shielding them from criticism.
WWE doing all they can to creatively protect wrestlers is one thing, but sometimes the company has taken it too far. Way too far. In a bid to make these men and women look like the greatest going, writers have shielded them from criticism that's totally valid - whether that's coming from fans in the stands or the rest of the roster behind the curtain.
Look, jealousy is clearly a factor in all of this. Wrestling locker rooms can be childish, and Bruce Prichard's story about Bob Holly claiming WWE should just stick the top title on him because he's tough springs to mind. Bob thought he was overlooked for the belt and it was unfair. Not quite. Maybe Brock Lesnar, Kurt Angle etc had the big prize because...they deserved it, drew money and fans accepted them as main-event talent. "Maybe".
If management wanted to play along with Holly's delusion, then they'd have bent over backwards to give him a lengthy reign on top. Unfortunately for ol' Hardcore, he was never important enough for WWE to ignore obvious personality flaws or book him like the second coming of Roman Reigns from 2020-present day.
Nepotism, outright favouritism and undeniable talent/box office appeal can skew the promotion's approach though, and there's no denying it. Some folks get away with more than others, but this isn't always a good thing. Often, it leads to egos running completely out of control or someone's glaring issues being exposed in the worst way imaginable.
These wrestlers thought they could play by different rules than everyone else. Sometimes, they did!
10. The Ultimate Warrior’s Archaic Style Is Exposed
Only around 4 years had passed between The Ultimate Warrior being fired in 1992 and his early-1996 return, but it felt like a lifetime. Vince McMahon, who was starting to feel the competitive heat from WCW post-Nitro launch (which would only worsen when the nWo landed), was desperate for big stars and attractions. So, he turned the other cheek on Warrior's glaring deficiencies.
Ultimate returned in time for WrestleMania XII and squashed a young Hunter Hearst Helmsley like he was nothing. Fair enough, Triple H wasn't what he'd become in '96, but there were bigger problems with Warrior than that. He was a one-note act when fans had grown accustomed to seeing more than that on top of cards.
People popped for Warrior and enjoyed the Hunter squash at 'Mania, but it didn't take long for them to grow bored of the same old, same old. Since Warrior's 1992 exit and the end of the Hulkamania boom he benefitted from generally, the WWF fanbase had been reconditioned to enjoy stellar, workrate-heavy matches in the main event slot by the likes of Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels.
Anyone who didn't fit neatly into that category, like Diesel or The Undertaker, proved talented/smart enough to adapt. The Ultimate Warrior was just never going to do that. He neither wanted to nor saw the need to do so. By protecting Warrior and effectively letting him relive the late-80s/early-90s, the federation shot themselves in the foot and woefully exposed how limited he was compared to others.
The returning "saviour" was never going to thrive in a 'New Generation' that required more than muscles and rope-shaking.
9. Baron Corbin’s Finisher Is Bizarrely WWE's Most Lethal
This is unbelievable but true: It took until Drew McIntyre at WrestleMania 38 for someone to kick out of Baron Corbin’s End Of Days finisher. Before that happened, the move was a guaranteed nail in the coffin for countless wrestlers, and it was weirdly one of the most overly-protected finishes in the biz.
That's bizarre, because it’s not like Corbin was pushed to the top relentlessly. He was pushed, but not necessarily as someone who had the most dangerous move in all of WWE. If anything, Baron was largely there to make others look good, or try to. He was the kind of despicable, easy to loathe heel who'd always get his comeuppance in the end.
Unless he was retiring legends like Kurt Angle, of course. Few will ever get over that call.
Come 'Mania 38, the announcers attempted to make a huge deal out of McIntyre's kick out, but it fell pretty much flat. Why? Well, despite WWE's best efforts to make End Of Days look like a surefire death knell for anyone's hopes and dreams, it wasn't really viewed that way by the core audience. To them, it was a flashy finisher with a meaty, impressive thumped landing but nothing more.
In short, what was meant to be a 'WrestleMania moment' for Drew and Baron boiled down a midcard nothing encounter on the first night that reeked of a poor way to use the big Scot. No-one was tricked by Corbin's shocked face when McIntyre powered out, much to the chagrin of Vince McMahon's writers.
8. Chyna Plays By Different Rules
The last year and change of Chyna's otherwise-historic WWF run was miserable. She blatantly didn't want to be part of the women's division at all, and had failed to renegotiate the same kind of money as top names like Steve Austin when sitting down to thrash out terms with Jim Ross and other bosses.
On top of that, and this is important for context, Chyna's personal life was falling apart. Her relationship with Triple H ended, he began dating Stephanie McMahon, and the 'Ninth Wonder Of The World' spiralled before leaving the company in late-2001. Realistically, despite the clear agony of her love life, Chyna had started to show signs of cracking before that.
In 1999, Chris Jericho got scorched by Vince because he caught Chyna with a stray punch during one of their matches. She was mixing it with the guys, but the WWF didn’t want her taking potatoes. Jericho pointed out that everyone else was, which didn't go down well. McMahon bellowed: "She's a woman, damn it!".
Management fostered a pretty precious outlook from Chyna towards other workers, and made her think she was much better than she was inside the ring. That was only ever going to end in trouble. She was shielded from the truth; that she was solid but unspectacular between the ropes, and wasn't going to become a sustainable headliner opposite Austin, Hunter, The Rock, Undertaker and more.
Giving her different rules to play by was risky, and it backfired. She was either willing to wrestle the rugged style expected from the guys or she wasn't. There was no middle ground.
7. Randy Orton Can Get Away With Anything
See above for a handsome young buck who knows he can (reportedly) defecate in someone's bags backstage one minute, then relish in the glory of a World Title push the next. That sentence isn't there to make light of Randy Orton's alleged horrendous backstage behaviour when he was rising up the ranks towards superstardom, but it's fascinating to see it laid out like that.
WWE chiefs were ready, willing and able to turn a blind eye to Randy's sophomoric, sometimes dreadful actions because he was such a fabulous prospect. So, even amidst reports of him bullying certain female talent or generally acting like a high school jock who was somehow still the teacher's pet, Orton was pushed to the moon time and time again regardless.
Even John Cena has gone on record to say that "new Randy" wouldn't have liked the "old Randy". Yep, Orton has matured and changed for the better. Today, he's one of Triple H's most trusted lieutenants, and there's no doubt he'll have a spot backstage if he wants it once he hangs up his boots. Rightly so, by the way, 'cause Randy has vast experience by this point in his life/career.
However, WWE taught him that he could do almost anything he liked then take a quick slap on the wrist before raking it in by working pay-per-view main events. It must've been endlessly frustrating for those who were well-behaved and talented but couldn't match the onscreen hype and riches that Mr. RKO was feasting on.
Protecting a bully makes someone complicit. Thankfully, Randy isn't like that anymore.
6. ‘King’ Mabel Hurts Everyone But…
…a push gotta push.
Some pro wrestlers need to be protected from everyone else because they're injury prone or a prior incident has weakened part of their body. Case in point: Steve Austin after Owen Hart dropped him on his head at SummerSlam 1997. That totally altered how 'Stone Cold' approached his matches.
It's probably just as well Austin was never programmed against Mabel/Viscera/Big Daddy V then. Mabel didn't need to be protected from anyone - everyone needed to be protected from him! He was a walking pain train who hurt numerous WWF stars during his short-lived main event run, and the organisation strangely turned a blind eye to most of it.
Vince McMahon likely just reasoned that 'this ain't ballet' until 'King' Mabel wrecked reigning WWF Champ Diesel at SummerSlam 1995 then broke The Undertaker's orbital bone later that same year. Honestly, the dude was a giant red flag inside the ring, but the office ignored everything that was going on because they needed to create fresh headliners.
Cool, but maybe pick somebody who isn't sitting down with his full weight on your champion's back or caving someone's face in by being utterly reckless. The entire episode between Mabel's '95 king Of The Ring win and his feud with 'Taker should be studied. It was like a masterclass in pushing somebody dangerous who was also out of his depth.
Mabel never once learned his lesson. Nobody's suggesting that he went out of his way to injure others, but he certainly didn't seem intent (or capable) of being more careful.
5. Past-His-Prime Goldberg Must Be Catered To
Being brutally honest, there wasn't much to Bill Goldberg's WWE reprise once he'd done the honours for Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 33. This writer will always maintain that their clash in Orlando is one of the finest powerhouse vs. powerhouse bouts he's ever seen live in person, and he is a mark for WCW nostalgia, but they should've stopped pushing the Goldberg hype train on 2 April 2017.
We all know that wrestling doesn't work that way. If promoters sniff even the slightest chance to make money, they're going to take it. That's all well and good, but other talent on the roster (especially those in prominent World Title positions) shouldn't have suffered because of it. Unfortunately, they did. For example, Kevin Owens before 'Mania 33 even happened.
WWE almost seemed to believe they had a bit of making up to do when it came to Bret Hart's favourite wrestler. That idea only strengthened after Goldberg and The Undertaker had nearly killed one another in Saudi Arabia in June 2019. Yes, over 2 years after he'd stared at the lights for Brock. Remember "they should've stopped" there?
They didn't.
Goldberg returned for squashes over Dolph Ziggler and Bray Wyatt's 'Fiend' offshoot, then dropped the Universal Title to Braun Strowman at 'Mania 36. It was supposed to be Roman Reigns, but COVID halted that plan. Bill and WWE have always erm...enjoyed an uneasy working relationship, but the way the promotion catered to Goldberg right up until his 2025 retirement was often awkward and unwanted by fans.
Goldberg's rise in WCW was unmatched, but it isn't 1998 anymore.
4. Tolerating Those Shawn Michaels Antics
Shawn Michaels is surely glad it isn't 1998 anymore.
He suffered a career-threatening back injury that kept him benched for over 4 years in '98. Before that, HBK was a spoiled brat throughout the 90s, and he set the template for the kind of backstage envelope pushing others like Randy Orton could follow early on in their own careers. At times, Shawn was intolerable to be around for some.
Vince McMahon shielded Michaels from criticism even when he was, by his own admission, an absolute annoyance who was out of control. Being real, this didn’t actually do Shawn many favours, because he ran riot and often went against company policy or refused to drop titles cleanly in-ring. Why should he when he was allowed to get away with whatever he pleased without proper punishment?
That irked fellow top stars like Bret Hart and The Undertaker. They were outraged (particularly Hart) that Michaels was being enabled by McMahon when the boss had full authority to put his foot down. Instead of doing that, Vince backed Shawn over a dependable, more stable workhorse like Bret. Montreal, and all that noise.
It's staggering how creative Michaels got when seeking ways to get out of doing the job for belts. He'd claim injuries and vacate titles, or pass belts off to pals like Triple H so they could drop them instead. It certainly isn't out of line to suggest that NXT chief and developmental talent darling Shawn wouldn't have seen eye to eye with his old self.
There's no way he or anyone else would want to manage a powder-keg like mid-90s HBK.
3. Triple H Is WCW’s Final Boss
Apparently, perhaps because he missed the entire invasion angle due to injury, WWE reckoned Triple H had to become WCW's very own final boss for years afterwards. This was particularly troublesome during Hunter's reign of terror as World Heavyweight Champion in 2002 and 2003. Back then, they easily could've changed his name to 'WCW Killer', because that's how 'The Game' was presented.
He beat Booker T, Goldberg, Scott Steiner, Kevin Nash, Ric Flair and more during a tyrannical run that included race baiting, ridicule and some of the shoddiest matches WWE fans had seen on top of company cards for many a year. Ravaged by injuries and packing on more muscle than necessary, the once-lithe (but still physically impressive before becoming an actual tank) Trips could barely move.
Then, WWE finally got Sting. Backstage, people were jumping for joy, because now they could nonsensically feed him to Triple H and put one more nail in World Championship Wrestling's coffin. That became the story of the pair's WrestleMania 31 match more than the Stinger looking to tear down a despotic Authority stronghold on the product.
Worse, by portraying Hunter as some defender of the WWE name, creative ignored the fact that Sting was the babyface of the piece. They even spat all over his WCW legacy by having him buddy up with nWo enemies like Hulk Hogan, Kevin Nash and Scott Hall. It didn't make a lick of sense, but WWE didn't care.
Trips got to look strong and avenge his run as Terra Ryzing in WCW, and that's all they cared about.
2. Triple H Can’t Look Weak In Video Games!
So, this was absolutely ludicrous and a classic example of ego gone wild.
The gaming press of 2008 couldn't wait to get their mitts on preview copies of WWE SmackDown vs. Raw 2009 for PS3, Xbox 360 etc. THQ's latest game allowed outlets to play test it and snag some handy screenshots for use in their preview articles, but there were restrictions. The subheading above gives it away.
As reported by Bleacher Report at the time, anyone lucky enough to sit down and fiddle around with the game had to avoid screens of wrestlers all bloodied up, and they definitely weren't allowed to show Triple H "losing or in a defenceless or vulnerable position". You're reading that correctly. This is not a drill.
It wasn't long before word spread that this was the edict, and that led to mass ridicule from wrestling fans and the gaming media alike. Nobody was quite sure who this directive had come from. Was it Vince McMahon? Hunter himself? Someone from THQ? It's most likely that Trips was in Vince's ear, and that things grew arms and legs from there.
How ridiculous is that?! 'The Game' didn't want anybody seeing him being pinned or even taking a move in promotional materials for the new video game hitting stores. Gamers couldn't quite believe what they were reading/hearing. It seemed like a rib, because surely no-one would be so protective of any wrestler to the extent they couldn't be hammered in digital form.
Well, it happened back in '08. What a time to be alive.
1. Shane McMahon Is The Hardest Man Alive
Did you know? Shane McMahon hits harder than Mike Tyson in his prime, and everyone's lucky the MMA/UFC boom didn't come along when he was in his 20s or there wouldn't have been any fighters left to grace the octagon. Our Shane-O would've slapped them all silly, then called them dafties like his name's Noam Dar.
At some point in 2003, WWE suddenly decided that Shane should go from being a daredevil who could take a kicking and keep on ticking better than most to one of the toughest men walking the face of the earth. That's the only explanation for why he went toe to toe with Kane or stuck Randy Orton with some of the worst looking rabbit punches ever in 2009.
Randy was instructed to run away from McMahon's fury like he was faced with some unstoppable boxing machine. It was laughable. This sort of booking persisted all the way through until Shane's egotistical performance (both in-ring and behind the curtain) at the 2022 Royal Rumble.
There, he somehow thought he should be the star of the show and made to look harder than full-timers, including Brock Lesnar. Even his father had to pull McMahon to one side and put him back in his lane. If WWE's 'tough guy' creative had successfully tricked Shane into thinking he was The Terminator, then more fool him.
Nepotism definitely played a part in this silliness.
For more wrestling content like this, check out 10 Superstars Who Could Debut (Or Return) On WWE Raw After WrestleMania 42 and 20 Dumbest Wrestler Names EVER (...That We Absolutely LOVE)!